Estimation of high-resolution dust column density maps. Comparison of modified black-body fits and radiative transfer modelling
arXiv:1305.2129 · doi:10.1051/0004-6361/201321254
Abstract
Sub-millimetre dust emission is often used to derive the column density N of dense interstellar clouds. The observations consist of data at several wavelengths but of variable resolution. We examine two procedures that been proposed for the estimation of high resolution N maps. Method A uses a low-resolution temperature map combined with higher resolution intensity data while Method B combines N estimates from different wavelength ranges. Our aim is to determine the accuracy of the methods relative to the true column densities and the estimates obtainable with radiative transfer modelling. We use magnetohydrodynamical (MHD) simulations and radiative transfer calculations to simulate sub-millimetre observations at the wavelengths of the Herschel Space Observatory. The observations are analysed with the methods and the results compared to the true values and to the results from radiative transfer modelling of observations. Both methods A and B give relatively reliable column density estimates at the resolution of 250um data while also making use of the longer wavelengths. For high signal-to-noise data, the results of Method B are better correlated with the true column density, while Method A is less sensitive to noise. When the cloud has internal heating, results of Method B are consistent with those that would be obtained with high-resolution data. Because of line-of-sight temperature variations, these underestimate the true column density and, because of a favourable cancellation of errors, Method A can sometimes give more correct values. Radiative transfer modelling, even with very simple 3D cloud models, can provide better results. However, the complexity of the models required for improvements increases rapidly with the complexity and opacity of the clouds.
arXiv comment14 pages, Accepted to A&A
References in corpus (37)
- Herschel Space Observatory - An ESA facility for far-infrared and submillimetre astronomy
- The Photodetector Array Camera and Spectrometer (PACS) on the Herschel Space Observatory
- The Herschel-SPIRE instrument and its in-flight performance
- From filamentary clouds to prestellar cores to the stellar IMF: Initial highlights from the Herschel Gould Belt survey
- Clouds, filaments and protostars: the Herschel Hi-GAL Milky Way
- Scattering by Interstellar Dust Grains: Optical and Ultraviolet
- Herschel view of the Taurus B211/3 filament and striations: Evidence of filamentary growth?
- The Star Formation Rate of Supersonic MHD Turbulence
- Tracing the Mass during Low-Mass Star Formation. II. Modelling the Submillimeter Emission from Pre-Protostellar Cores
- The global dust SED: Tracing the nature and evolution of dust with DustEM
- 2MASS wide field extinction maps - I. The Pipe nebula
- The Effect of Line of Sight Temperature Variation and Noise on Dust Continuum Observations
- The "True" Column Density Distribution in Star-Forming Molecular Clouds
- The Ubiquity of Micrometer-Sized Dust Grains in the Dense Interstellar Medium
- Far-infrared to millimeter astrophysical dust emission I: A model based on physical properties of amorphous solids
- Galactic cold cores III. General cloud properties
- The Effect of Noise on the Dust Temperature - Spectral Index Correlation
- The link between molecular cloud structure and turbulence
- Direct evidence of dust growth in L183 from MIR light scattering
- Efficient Monte Carlo methods for continuum radiative transfer
- The Earliest Phases of Star formation observed with Herschel (EPoS): The dust temperature and density distributions of B68
- Cosmological AMR MHD with Enzo
- Accuracy of core mass estimates in simulated observations of dust emission
- Cloudshine: New Light on Dark Clouds
- Dust emission from inhomogeneous interstellar clouds: radiative transfer in 3D with transiently heated particles
- Profiling filaments: comparing near-infrared extinction and submillimetre data in TMC-1
- Monte Carlo Radiative Transfer in Embedded Prestellar Cores
- Modelling the dust emission from dense interstellar clouds: disentangling the effects of radiative transfer and dust properties
- The degeneracy between the dust colour temperature and the spectral index. The problem of multiple chi^2 minima
- Mass and Magnetic distributions in Self Gravitating Super Alfvenic Turbulence with AMR
- Profiles of interstellar cloud filaments. Observational effects in synthetic sub-millimetre observations
- The effect of temperature mixing on the observable (T,beta)-relation of interstellar dust clouds
- A Corona Australis cloud filament seen in NIR scattered light I. Comparison with extinction of background stars
- Radiative transfer on hierarchial grids
- A Corona Australis cloud filament seen in NIR scattered light. III. Modelling and comparison with Herschel sub-millimetre data
- Isolated starless cores in IRDCs in the Hi-GAL survey
- Mapping dust column density in dark clouds by using NIR scattered light : Case of the Lupus 3 dark cloud
Cited by in corpus (10)
- Herschel-Planck dust optical-depth and column-density maps: I. Method description and results for Orion
- Galactic cold cores V. Dust opacity
- Dust spectrum and polarisation at 850 um in the massive IRDC G035.39-00.33
- Galactic cold cores IX. Column density structures and radiative transfer modelling
- Squeezed between shells? On the origin of the Lupus I molecular cloud. APEX/LABOCA, Herschel, and Planck observations
- The location, clustering, and propagation of massive star formation in giant molecular clouds
- The physical state of selected cold clumps
- A CO survey on a sample of Herschel cold clumps
- Comparison of modified black-body fits for the estimation of dust optical depths in interstellar clouds
- Estimation of high-resolution dust column density maps: Empirical model fits