The "True" Column Density Distribution in Star-Forming Molecular Clouds

Abstract

We use the COMPLETE Survey's observations of the Perseus star-forming region to assess and intercompare three methods for measuring column density in molecular clouds: extinction mapping (NIR); thermal emission mapping (FIR); and mapping the intensity of CO isotopologues. The structures shown by all three tracers are morphologically similar, but important differences exist. Dust-based measures give similar, log-normal, distributions for the full Perseus region, once careful calibration corrections are made. We also compare dust- and gas-based column density distributions for physically-meaningful sub-regions of Perseus, and we find significant variations in the distributions for those regions. Even though we have used 12CO data to estimate excitation temperatures, and we have corrected for opacity, the 13CO maps seem unable to give column distributions that consistently resemble those from dust measures. We have edited out the effects of the shell around the B-star HD 278942. In that shell's interior and in the parts where it overlaps the molecular cloud, there appears to be a dearth of 13CO, likely due either to 13CO not yet having had time to form in this young structure, and/or destruction of 13CO in the molecular cloud. We conclude that the use of either dust or gas measures of column density without extreme attention to calibration and artifacts is more perilous than even experts might normally admit. And, the use of 13CO to trace total column density in detail, even after proper calibration, is unavoidably limited in utility due to threshold, depletion, and opacity effects. If one's main aim is to map column density, then dust extinction seems the best probe. Linear fits amongst column density tracers are given, quantifying the inherent uncertainties in using one tracer (when compared with others). [abridged]

Accepted in ApJ. 13 pages, 6 color figures. It includes small changes to improve clarity. For a version with high-resolution figures see http://www.cfa.harvard.edu/COMPLETE/papers/Goodman_ColumnDensity.pdf

References in corpus (14)

• Structural Analysis of Molecular Clouds: Dendrograms
• CO Isotopologues in the Perseus Molecular Cloud Complex: the X-Factor and Regional Variations
• The COMPLETE Survey of Star-Forming Regions: Phase I Data
• Astrometry of Water Maser Sources in Nearby Molecular Clouds with VERA - II. SVS 13 in NGC 1333
• 2MASS wide field extinction maps - I. The Pipe nebula
• The Large and Small Scale Structures of Dust in the Star-Forming Perseus Molecular Cloud
• TMC-1C: an accreting starless core
• The nature of the dense core population in the pipe nebula: core and cloud kinematics from C18O observations
• Dust Emission from the Perseus Molecular Cloud
• The COMPLETE Nature of the Warm Dust Ring in Perseus
• Can We Trust the Dust? Evidence of Dust Segregation in Molecular Clouds
• The Effect of Noise in Dust Emission Maps on the Derivation of Column Density, Temperature and Emissivity Spectral Index
• Estimating Column Density in Molecular Clouds with FIR and Sub-mm Emission Maps
• Hunting Galaxies to (and for) Extinction

Cited by in corpus (157)

• Comparing the statistics of interstellar turbulence in simulations and observations: Solenoidal versus compressive turbulence forcing
• Planck 2013 results. XI. All-sky model of thermal dust emission
• The Dark Molecular Gas
• Self-Regulated Star Formation in Galaxies via Momentum Input from Massive Stars
• The Disruption of Giant Molecular Clouds by Radiation Pressure and the Efficiency of Star Formation in Galaxies
• Probing the evolution of molecular cloud structure: From quiescence to birth
• Modeling Collapse and Accretion in Turbulent Gas Clouds: Implementation and Comparison of Sink Particles in AMR and SPH
• The Structure of the Interstellar Medium of Star Forming Galaxies
• The relation between gas and dust in the Taurus Molecular Cloud
• Direct observation of a sharp transition to coherence in Dense Cores
• Herschel-Planck dust optical-depth and column-density maps: I. Method description and results for Orion
• Modeling CO Emission: I. CO as a Column Density Tracer and the X-Factor in Molecular Clouds
• Gravity or turbulence? II. Evolving column density PDFs in molecular clouds
• On the evolution of the density pdf in strongly self-gravitating systems
• High-dynamic-range extinction mapping of infrared dark clouds: Dependence of density variance with sonic Mach number in molecular clouds
• The Mass-Size Relation from Clouds to Cores. II. Solar Neighborhood Clouds
• NuSTAR Spectroscopy of Multi-Component X-ray Reflection from NGC 1068
• The Bones of the Milky Way
• The Link between Magnetic Fields and Filamentary Clouds: Bimodal Cloud Orientations in the Gould Belt
• Molecular clouds have power-law probability distribution functions
• Understanding star formation in molecular clouds I. Effects of line-of-sight contamination on the column density structure
• Turbulence sets the initial conditions for star formation in high-pressure environments
• Quantifying Observational Projection Effects Using Molecular Cloud Simulations
• An Excursion-Set Model for the Structure of GMCs and the ISM
• The Structure of Molecular Clouds: I - All Sky Near Infrared Extinction Maps
• A method for reconstructing the variance of a 3D physical field from 2D observations: Application to turbulence in the ISM
• The Column Density Variance-Sonic Mach Number Relationship
• The Panchromatic Hubble Andromeda Treasury VIII: A Wide-Area, High-Resolution Map of Dust Extinction in M31
• Numerical Simulations of Turbulent, Molecular Clouds Regulated by Radiation Feedback Forces I: Star Formation Rate and Efficiency
• Probing the evolution of molecular cloud structure II: From chaos to confinement
• Modelling [CI] emission from turbulent molecular clouds
• The Mass-Size Relation from Clouds to Cores. I. A new Probe of Structure in Molecular Clouds
• On the Three-Dimensional Structure of Local Molecular Clouds
• Using Herschel and Planck observations to delineate the role of magnetic fields in molecular cloud structure
• Dense Cores in Perseus: The Influence of Stellar Content and Cluster Environment
• A High Resolution Study of the HI-H2 Transition across the Perseus Molecular Cloud
• Gas emissions in Planck cold dust clumps---A Survey of the J=1-0 Transitions of ${}^{12}$CO, ${}^{13}$CO, and C${}^{18}$O
• The Density Variance Mach Number Relation in the Taurus Molecular Cloud
• The structure of the thermally bistable and turbulent atomic gas in the local interstellar medium
• Cold and Warm Atomic Gas around the Perseus Molecular Cloud. II. The Impact of High Optical Depth on the HI Column Density Distribution and Its Implication for the HI-to-H2 Transition
• Profiling filaments: comparing near-infrared extinction and submillimetre data in TMC-1
• VISION - Vienna survey in Orion I. VISTA Orion A Survey
• CO line emission from galaxies in the Epoch of Reionization
• Star formation in the Taurus filament L1495: From Dense Cores to Stars
• Detection of Structure in Infrared-Dark Clouds with Spitzer: Characterizing Star Formation in the Molecular Ring
• Understanding star formation in molecular clouds III. Probability distribution functions of molecular lines in Cygnus X
• The shapes of column density PDFs - The importance of the last closed contour
• The Structure of Molecular Clouds: II - Column Density and Mass Distributions
• The degeneracy between dust colour temperature and spectral index. Comparison of methods for estimating the beta(T) relation
• A large catalogue of molecular clouds with accurate distances within 4 kpc of the Galactic disk
• Connection between dense gas mass fraction, turbulence driving, and star formation efficiency of molecular clouds
• 3D dynamics of the Orion cloud complex -- Discovery of coherent radial gas motions at the 100-pc scale
• Star-forming content of the giant molecular filaments in the Milky Way
• Large scale IRAM 30m CO-observations in the giant molecular cloud complex W43
• New Constraints From Dust Lines On The Surface Densities Of Protoplanetary Disks
• The degeneracy between the dust colour temperature and the spectral index. The problem of multiple chi^2 minima
• The Lognormal Probability Distribution Function of the Perseus Molecular Cloud: A Comparison of HI and Dust
• Measuring the Alfvenic Nature of the Interstellar Medium: Velocity Anisotropy Revisited
• A $Herschel-SPIRE$ Survey of the Mon R2 Giant Molecular Cloud: Analysis of the Gas Column Density Probability Density Function
• Hierarchical Structure of Magnetohydrodynamic Turbulence In Position-Position-Velocity Space
• Star-Gas Surface Density Correlations in Twelve Nearby Molecular Clouds I: Data Collection and Star-Sampled Analysis
• 2MASS wide field extinction maps: V. Corona Australis
• Modeling UV Radiation Feedback from Massive Stars: III. Escape of Radiation from Star-forming Giant Molecular Clouds
• The Anatomy of the Column Density Probability Distribution Function (N-PDF)
• The CO-to-H2 Conversion Factor across the Perseus Molecular Cloud
• The Role of Turbulence and Magnetic Fields in Simulated Filamentary Structure
• The Dynamics of Dense Cores in the Perseus Molecular Cloud II: The Relationship Between Dense Cores and the Cloud
• Does the CO-to-H2 conversion factor depend on the star formation rate?
• The Relationship Between the Dust and Gas-Phase CO Across the California Molecular Cloud
• The Spitzer c2d Survey of Large, Nearby, Interstellar Clouds. XII. The Perseus YSO Population as Observed with IRAC and MIPS
• The Carina Nebula and Gum 31 molecular complex: I. Molecular gas distribution, column densities and dust temperatures
• Characterizing the line emission from molecular clouds. Stratified random sampling of the Perseus cloud
• Evolving Molecular Cloud Structure and the Column Density Probability Distribution Function
• Do Lognormal Column-Density Distributions in Molecular Clouds Imply Supersonic Turbulence?
• Evidence for Grain Growth in Molecular Clouds: A Bayesian Examination of the Extinction Law in Perseus
• The Multi-phase Turbulence Density Power Spectra in the Perseus Molecular Cloud
• Synthetic observations of star formation and the interstellar medium
• 3D Extinction Mapping Using Hierarchical Bayesian Models
• GALACTICNUCLEUS: A high-angular-resolution $JH{K}_s$ imaging survey of the Galactic centre. IV. Extinction maps and de-reddened photometry
• Cloud formation in the atomic and molecular phase: HI self absorption (HISA) towards a Giant Molecular Filament
• Structure and Fragmentation of a high line-mass filament: Nessie
• The Dynamical State of Filamentary Infrared Dark Clouds
• Shock generated vorticity in the interstellar medium and the origin of the stellar initial mass function
• Mapping the three-dimensional dust extinction toward the supernova remnant S147 - the S147 dust cloud
• Three dimensional dust mapping of 12 supernovae remnants in the Galactic anticentre
• Numerical Simulations of Turbulent Molecular Clouds Regulated by Radiation Feedback Forces II: Radiation-Gas Interactions and Outflows
• 12CO, 13CO and C18O observations along the major axes of nearby bright infrared galaxies
• A Simple Perspective on the Mass-Area Relationship in Molecular Clouds
• On the compressive nature of turbulence driven by ionising feedback in the pillars of the Carina Nebula
• The Effects of Radiative Transfer on the PDFs of Molecular MHD Turbulence
• Relationship between turbulence energy and density variance in the Solar neighbourhood molecular clouds
• PDFchem: A new fast method to determine ISM properties and infer environmental parameters using probability distributions
• On the importance of scattering at 8 microns: Brighter than you think
• What is a GMC? Are Observers and Simulators Discussing the Same Star-forming Clouds?
• Characterizing the structure of diffuse emission in Hi-GAL maps
• Mid-J CO observations of Perseus B1-East 5: evidence for turbulent dissipation via low-velocity shocks
• Molecular Clouds in the Second Quadrant of the Milky Way Mid-plane from l$=$104$.{}^{\circ }$75 to l=119$.{}^{\circ }$75 and b=$-$5$.{}^{\circ }$25 to b=5$.{}^{\circ }$25
• Relationship between the column density distribution and evolutionary class of molecular clouds as viewed by ATLASGAL
• Estimating Extinction using Unsupervised Machine Learning
• First extragalactic measurement of the turbulence driving parameter: ALMA observations of the star-forming region N159E in the Large Magellanic Cloud
• Dense Gas in a Giant Molecular Filament
• On the Origin of the High Column Density Turnover in the HI Column Density Distribution
• Effect of feedback of massive stars in the fragmentation, distribution, and kinematics of the gas in two star forming regions in the Carina Nebula
• Gas Column Density Distribution of Molecular Clouds in the Third Quadrant of the Milky Way
• Large-Scale CO Maps of the Lupus Molecular Cloud Complex
• The Extinction and Distance of the MBM Molecular Clouds at High Galactic Latitude
• Structural and Dynamical Analysis of 0.1pc Cores and Filaments in the 30~Doradus-10 Giant Molecular Cloud
• A global view on star formation: The GLOSTAR Galactic plane survey VIII. Formaldehyde absorption in Cygnus~X
• On the Limitations of the Anomalous Microwave Emission Emissivity
• Atomic and molecular gas properties during cloud formation
• Probability distribution functions of gas in M31 and M51
• The "Maggie" filament: Physical properties of a giant atomic cloud
• Estimation of high-resolution dust column density maps. Comparison of modified black-body fits and radiative transfer modelling
• Formation of hub-filament structure triggered by cloud-cloud collision in W33 complex
• Molecular cloud distance determination from deep NIR survey extinction measurements
• Grey Milky Way Extinction from SDSS Stellar Photometry
• The location, clustering, and propagation of massive star formation in giant molecular clouds
• Determining Star Formation Thresholds from Observations
• Bird's eye view of molecular clouds in the Milky Way: II. Cloud kinematics from sub-pc to kpc scales
• The Effect of Shock Wave Duration on Star Formation and the Initial Condition of Massive Cluster Formation
• VISIONS: The VISTA Star Formation Atlas -- I. Survey overview
• TIMES I: a Systematic Observation in Multiple Molecular Lines Toward the Orion A and Ophiuchus Clouds
• Molecular Clouds: Internal Properties, Turbulence, Star Formation and Feedback
• Core Emergence in a Massive Infrared Dark Cloud: A Comparison Between Mid-IR Extinction and 1.3 mm Emission
• The Column Density Structure of Orion A Depicted by N-PDF
• A Synergy of the Velocity Gradients Technique and the Probability Density Functions for Identifying Gravitational Collapse in Self-Absorbing Media
• Simultaneous Deep Measurements of CO isotopologues and Dust Emission in Giant Molecular Clouds in the Andromeda Galaxy
• A Large-field J=1-0 Survey of CO and Its Isotopologues Toward the Cassiopeia A Supernova Remnant
• Mapping of interstellar clouds with infrared light scattered from dust: TMC-1N
• X Marks the Spot: Nexus of Filaments, Cores, and Outflows in a Young Star-Forming Region
• Metallicity dependence of the CO-to-H${}_2$ and the [CI]-to-H${}_2$ conversion factors in galaxies
• First Resolved Dust Continuum Measurements of Individual Giant Molecular Clouds in the Andromeda Galaxy
• On the Origin of the High Star-Formation Efficiency in Massive Galaxies at Cosmic Dawn
• Unbound Star-forming Molecular Clouds
• Reconstructing three-dimensional densities from two-dimensional observations of molecular gas
• Dust extinction map of the Galactic plane based on the VVV survey data
• Geometry-Independent Determination of Radial Density Distributions in Molecular Cloud Cores and Other Astronomical Objects
• Optical reconstruction of dust in the region of SNR RX J1713.7-3946 from astrometric data
• Photoionization feedback in turbulent molecular clouds
• Does the HCN/CO ratio trace the star-forming fraction of gas? I. A comparison with analytical models of star formation
• Multi log-normal density structure in Cygnus-X molecular clouds: A fitting for N-PDF without power-law
• Optimal extinction measurements - I. Single-object extinction inference
• H2CO and H110α observations towards NH3 sources
• Herschel 158$\mu$m [CII] Observations of "CO-dark" Gas in the Perseus Giant Molecular Cloud
• A Guide to Comparisons of Star Formation Simulations with Observations
• Solenoidal versus compressive turbulence forcing
• On the Flux-Intensity Relation of Molecular Clouds
• CU-JADE: A Method for Traversing Extinction Jumps along the Line of Sight
• The Correlation Between Dust and Gas Contents in Molecular Clouds
• Examining Turbulence in Galactic Molecular Clouds -- I: A Statistical Analysis of Velocity Structures
• The Structure of Molecular Clouds: III - A link between cloud structure and star formation mode
• Investigating star-formation activity towards the southern HII region RCW 42
• Cold atomic gas identified by HI self-absorption. Cold atomic clouds toward giant molecular filaments
• CO mapping of Cygnus-X -- volume density distribution
• Star Formation at the Periphery of a Molecular Superbubble: The Case of G12.79+0.43
• Contour Analysis Tool: an interactive tool for background and morphology analysis
• Systematic Investigation of Dust and Gaseous CO in 12 Nearby Molecular Clouds