Bailing Out the Milky Way: Variation in the Properties of Massive Dwarfs Among Galaxy-Sized Systems

Abstract

Recent kinematical constraints on the internal densities of the Milky Way's dwarf satellites have revealed a discrepancy with the subhalo populations of simulated Galaxy-scale halos in the standard CDM model of hierarchical structure formation. This has been dubbed the "too big to fail" problem, with reference to the improbability of large and invisible companions existing in the Galactic environment. In this paper, we argue that both the Milky Way observations and simulated subhalos are consistent with the predictions of the standard model for structure formation. Specifically, we show that there is significant variation in the properties of subhalos among distinct host halos of fixed mass and suggest that this can reasonably account for the deficit of dense satellites in the Milky Way. We exploit well-tested analytic techniques to predict the properties in a large sample of distinct host halos with a variety of masses spanning the range expected of the Galactic halo. The analytic model produces subhalo populations consistent with both Via Lactea II and Aquarius, and our results suggest that natural variation in subhalo properties suffices to explain the discrepancy between Milky Way satellite kinematics and these numerical simulations. At least ~10% of Milky Way-sized halos host subhalo populations for which there is no "too big to fail" problem, even when the host halo mass is as large as M_host = 10^12.2 h^-1 M_sun. Follow-up studies consisting of high-resolution simulations of a large number of Milky Way-sized hosts are necessary to confirm our predictions. In the absence of such efforts, the "too big to fail" problem does not appear to be a significant challenge to the standard model of hierarchical formation. [abridged]

12 pages, 3 figures; accepted by JCAP. Replaced with published version

References in corpus (9)

• Too big to fail? The puzzling darkness of massive Milky Way subhaloes
• The Kinematics of the Ultra-Faint Milky Way Satellites: Solving the Missing Satellite Problem
• The Milky Way's Circular Velocity Curve to 60 kpc and an Estimate of the Dark Matter Halo Mass from Kinematics of ~2400 SDSS Blue Horizontal Branch Stars
• Are the Magellanic Clouds on their First Passage about the Milky Way?
• Hundreds of Milky Way Satellites? Luminosity Bias in the Satellite Luminosity Function
• Baryons Matter: Why Luminous Satellite Galaxies Have Reduced Central Masses
• The M31 Velocity Vector. II. Radial Orbit Towards the Milky Way and Implied Local Group Mass
• The Excursion Set Theory of Halo Mass Functions, Halo Clustering, and Halo Growth
• The Destruction of Thin Stellar Disks Via Cosmologically Common Satellite Accretion Events

Cited by in corpus (50)

• Dark Matter Self-interactions and Small Scale Structure
• Beyond Collisionless Dark Matter: Particle Physics Dynamics for Dark Matter Halo Structure
• Sterile Neutrino Dark Matter
• A White Paper on keV Sterile Neutrino Dark Matter
• The Milky Way total mass profile as inferred from Gaia DR2
• Core Formation in Dwarf Halos with Self Interacting Dark Matter: No Fine-Tuning Necessary
• Too Big to Fail in the Local Group
• The SAGA Survey: I. Satellite Galaxy Populations Around Eight Milky Way Analogs
• A Baryonic Solution to the Missing Satellites Problem
• Is there a "too big to fail" problem in the field?
• Resonant Dark Forces and Small Scale Structure
• Can Feedback Solve the Too Big to Fail Problem?
• The mass of the Milky Way from satellite dynamics
• Gravitational probes of dark matter physics
• Constraining the WDM Particle Mass with Milky Way Satellites
• Organized Chaos: Scatter in the relation between stellar mass and halo mass in small galaxies
• The local high velocity tail and the Galactic escape speed
• The Dependence of Subhalo Abundance on Halo Concentration
• M31 Satellite Masses Compared to LCDM Subhaloes
• Galactic Archaeology. The dwarfs that survived and perished
• Hints on the Nature of Dark Matter from the Properties of Milky Way Satellites
• Generating Merger Trees for Dark Matter Haloes: A Comparison of Methods
• Warm dark matter does not do better than cold dark matter in solving small-scale inconsistencies
• The Dragonfly Nearby Galaxies Survey. III. The Luminosity Function of the M101 Group
• Cosmological Simulations of Decaying Dark Matter: Implications for Small-scale Structure of Dark Matter Halos
• SatGen: a semi-analytical satellite galaxy generator -- I. The model and its application to Local-Group satellite statistics
• Expanded haloes, abundance matching and too-big-to-fail in the Local Group
• Milky Way mass constraints from the Galactic satellite gap
• An assessment of the "too big to fail" problem for field dwarf galaxies in view of baryonic feedback effects
• A robust estimate of the Milky Way mass from rotation curve data
• Lyman-alpha Forest Constraints on Decaying Dark Matter
• A unified solution to the small scale problems of the $\Lambda$CDM model
• Massive Milky Way Satellites in Cold and Warm Dark Matter: Dependence on Cosmology
• The Cosmic Evolution of Faint Satellite Galaxies as a Test of Galaxy Formation and the Nature of Dark Matter
• Subhalo statistics of galactic halos: beyond the resolution limit
• Comprehensive Assessment of the Too-Big-to-Fail Problem
• Evolution of perturbations and cosmological constraints in decaying dark matter models with arbitrary decay mass products
• A unified solution to the small scale problems of the $\Lambda$CDM model II: introducing parent-satellite interaction
• Predictably Missing Satellites: Subhalo Abundance in Milky Way-like Halos
• The Massive Satellite Population of Milky-Way Sized Galaxies
• Constraints on Self Interacting Dark Matter from IceCube Results
• The connection between the host halo and the satellite galaxies of the Milky Way
• Small scale clustering of late forming dark matter
• Can decaying dark matter scenarios alleviate both $H_0$ and ${\sigma }_8$ tensions?
• The kinematics of the Local Group in a cosmological context
• Effects of Coupled Dark Energy on the Milky Way and its Satellites
• Explaining the observed velocity dispersion of dwarf galaxies by baryonic mass loss during the first collapse
• Lensing corrections on galaxy-lensing cross correlations and galaxy-galaxy auto correlations
• Tailoring cosmologies in cubic shift-symmetric Horndeski gravity
• Universal subhalo accretion in cold and warm dark matter cosmologies