Low-Resolution Sodium D Absorption is a Bad Proxy for Extinction

Abstract

Dust extinction is generally the least tractable systematic uncertainty in astronomy, and particularly in supernova science. Often in the past, studies have used the equivalent width of Na I D absorption measured from low-resolution spectra as proxies for extinction, based on tentative correlations that were drawn from limited data sets. We show here, based on 443 low-resolution spectra of 172 Type Ia supernovae for which we have measured the dust extinction as well as the equivalent width of Na I D, that the two barely correlate. We briefly examine the causes for this large scatter that effectively prevents one from inferring extinction using this method.

4 pages, MNRAS Letters in press

References in corpus (7)

• A 3% Solution: Determination of the Hubble Constant with the Hubble Space Telescope and Wide Field Camera 3
• Improved Dark Energy Constraints from ~100 New CfA Supernova Type Ia Light Curves
• Improved Distances to Type Ia Supernovae with Multicolor Light Curve Shapes: MLCS2k2
• CfA3: 185 Type Ia Supernova Light Curves from the CfA
• Determining the Type, Redshift, and Age of a Supernova Spectrum
• SiFTO: An Empirical Method for Fitting SNe Ia Light Curves
• The reddening law of Type Ia Supernovae: separating intrinsic variability from dust using equivalent widths

Cited by in corpus (107)

• Observational constraints on the progenitors of core-collapse supernovae : the case for missing high mass stars
• An Empirical Relation between Sodium Absorption and Dust Extinction
• Characterizing the V-band light-curves of hydrogen-rich type II supernovae
• PTF11kx: A Type-Ia Supernova with a Symbiotic Nova Progenitor
• The death of massive stars - II. Observational constraints on the progenitors of type Ibc supernovae
• On the Source of the Dust Extinction in Type Ia Supernovae and the Discovery of Anomalously Strong Na I Absorption
• Carnegie Supernova Project: Observations of Type IIn supernovae
• PTF12os and iPTF13bvn. Two stripped-envelope supernovae from low-mass progenitors in NGC 5806
• Early-time light curves of Type Ib/c supernovae from the SDSS-II Supernova Survey
• Photometric and Spectroscopic Properties of Type II-P Supernovae
• A Sample of Type II-L Supernovae
• Optical and near-infrared observations of SN 2011dh - The first 100 days
• The Progenitor of Supernova 2011dh/PTF11eon in Messier 51
• Very Early Ultraviolet and Optical Observations of the Type Ia Supernova 2009ig
• Investigating the properties of stripped-envelope supernovae, what are the implications for their progenitors?
• The Type IIb Supernova 2013df and Its Cool Supergiant Progenitor
• Extensive HST Ultraviolet Spectra and Multi-wavelength Observations of SN 2014J in M82 Indicate Reddening and Circumstellar Scattering by Typical Dust
• The Fast and Furious Decay of the Peculiar Type Ic Supernova 2005ek
• SN 2009md: Another faint supernova from a low mass progenitor
• Diversity in extinction laws of Type Ia supernovae measured between $0.2$ and $2\mu \mathrm{m}$
• The Very Young Type Ia Supernova 2013dy: Discovery, and Strong Carbon Absorption in Early-Time Spectra
• The Low-Velocity, Rapidly Fading Type Ia Supernova 2002es
• Supernova 2012aw - a high-energy clone of archetypal type IIP SN 1999em
• Type Ia Supernova Carbon Footprints
• The Berkeley Sample of Stripped-Envelope Supernovae
• Multi-Wavelength Observations of Supernova 2011ei: Time-Dependent Classification of Type IIb and Ib Supernovae and Implications for their Progenitors
• SN 2009E: a faint clone of SN 1987A
• Spectroscopic Observations of SN 2012fr: A Luminous Normal Type Ia Supernova with Early High Velocity Features and Late Velocity Plateau
• The Type II-P Supernova 2017eaw: from explosion to the nebular phase
• SN 2009N: Linking normal and subluminous type II-P SNe
• The bright Type IIP SN 2009bw, showing signs of interaction
• Optical and Near-IR Observations of the Faint and Fast 2008ha-like Supernova 2010ae
• The Massive Progenitor of the Possible Type II-Linear Supernova 2009hd in Messier 66
• A Search for New Candidate Super-Chandrasekhar-Mass Type Ia Supernovae in the Nearby Supernova Factory Dataset
• The Berkeley sample of Type II supernovae: BVRI light curves and spectroscopy of 55 SNe II
• SN 2009ib: A Type II-P Supernova with an Unusually Long Plateau
• PESSTO monitoring of SN 2012hn: further heterogeneity among faint type I supernovae
• Type II supernovae from the Carnegie Supernova Project-I. II. Physical parameter distributions from hydrodynamical modelling
• A Global Model of The Light Curves and Expansion Velocities of Type II-Plateau Supernovae
• SN 2018zd: An Unusual Stellar Explosion as Part of the Diverse Type II Supernova Landscape
• A Luminous Red Nova in M31 and its Progenitor System
• The Type II supernovae 2006V and 2006au: two SN 1987A-like events
• SN2010jp (PTF10aaxi): A Jet-Driven Type II Supernova
• The UV/optical spectra of the Type Ia supernova SN 2010jn: a bright supernova with outer layers rich in iron-group elements
• PTF10ops - a subluminous, normal-width lightcurve Type Ia supernova in the middle of nowhere
• SN 2016coi/ASASSN-16fp: An example of residual helium in a type Ic supernova?
• Supernova 2008J: early time observations of a heavily reddened SN 2002ic-like transient
• Observed Type II supernova colours from the Carnegie Supernova Project-I
• On the Ca-strong 1991bg-like type Ia supernova 2016hnk: evidence for a Chandrasekhar-mass explosion
• The Young and Nearby Normal Type Ia Supernova 2018gv: UV-Optical Observations and the Earliest Spectropolarimetry
• Optical and near infrared observations of SN 2014ck: an outlier among the Type Iax supernovae
• Optical and Ultraviolet Observations of A Low-Velocity Type II-Plateau Supernova 2013am in M65
• The ANU WiFeS SuperNovA Program (AWSNAP)
• A Type II Supernova Hubble diagram from the CSP-I, SDSS-II, and SNLS surveys
• Early Dust Formation and a Massive Progenitor for SN 2011ja?
• The distance to NGC1316 (Fornax A): yet another curious case
• Red and Reddened: Ultraviolet through Near-Infrared Observations of Type Ia Supernova 2017erp
• SN2012ab: A Peculiar Type IIn Supernova with Aspherical Circumstellar Material
• The nature of supernovae 2010O and 2010P in Arp 299 - I. Near-infrared and optical evolution
• Optical Follow-Up Observations of PTF10qts, a Luminous Broad-Lined Type Ic Supernova Found by the Palomar Transient Factory
• The double-peaked type Ic Supernova 2019cad: another SN 2005bf-like object
• The Carnegie Supernova Project I: methods to estimate host-galaxy reddening of stripped-envelope supernovae
• Supernova 2013fc in a circumnuclear ring of a luminous infrared galaxy: the big brother of SN 1998S
• SN 2005at - A neglected type Ic supernova at 10 Mpc
• A Long-Duration Luminous Type IIn Supernova KISS15s: Strong Recombination Lines from the Inhomogeneous Ejecta-CSM Interaction Region and Hot Dust Emission from Newly Formed Dust
• UV-Optical Observation of Type Ia Supernova SN 2013dy in NGC 7250
• MUSE stares into the shadows: the high-resolution dust attenuation curve of NGC 5626
• Massive stars exploding in a He-rich circumstellar medium - VIII. PSN J07285387+3349106, a highly reddened supernova Ibn
• Spectroscopy of the first resolved strongly lensed Type Ia supernova iPTF16geu
• A Luminous Peculiar Type Ia Supernova SN 2011hr: More Like SN 1991T or SN 2007if?
• ASASSN-14dq: A fast-declining type II-P Supernova in a low-luminosity host galaxy
• LSQ13fn: A type II-Plateau supernova with a possibly low metallicity progenitor that breaks the standardised candle relation
• Discovery and Follow-up Observations of the Young Type Ia Supernova 2016coj
• SN 2015ba: A type IIP supernova with a long plateau
• ASASSN-16fp (SN 2016coi): A transitional supernova between Type Ic and broad-lined Ic
• SN 2000cx and SN 2013bh: Extremely Rare, Nearly Twin Type Ia Supernovae
• Measuring the Hubble constant with kilonovae using the Expanding Photosphere Method
• On the progenitor of the Type Ic SN 2013dk in the Antennae Galaxies
• SN 2016esw: a luminous Type II supernova observed within the first day after the explosion
• The Early Light Curve of SN 2023bee: Constraining Type Ia Supernova Progenitors the Apian Way
• SN 2019zrk, a bright SN 2009ip analog with a precursor
• The Lick Observatory Supernova Search follow-up program: photometry data release of 70 stripped-envelope supernovae
• SN 2018is: a low-luminosity Type IIP supernova with narrow hydrogen emission lines at early phases
• Optical Observations of the Young Type Ic Supernova SN 2014L in M99
• SN 2017cfd: A Normal Type Ia Supernova Discovered Very Young
• Supernova 2010ev: A reddened high velocity gradient type Ia supernova
• The Interaction of Supernova 2018evt with a Substantial Amount of Circumstellar Matter -- An SN1997cy-like Event
• The Ultraviolet Colors of Type Ia Supernovae and their Photospheric Velocities
• Probing gas and dust in the tidal tail of NGC 5221 with the type Ia supernova iPTF16abc
• A Monte Carlo approach to magnetar-powered transients: II. Broad-lined type Ic supernovae not associated with GRBs
• SNhunt151: an explosive event inside a dense cocoon
• SN 2014ab: An Aspherical Type IIn Supernova with Low Polarization
• The optical properties of three type II supernovae: 2014cx, 2014cy and 2015cz
• SN 2020pvb: a Type IIn-P supernova with a precursor outburst
• Optical color of Type Ib and Ic supernovae and implications for their progenitors
• Investigating the observational properties of Type Ib supernova SN 2017iro
• Time varying Na I D absorption in ILRTs as a probe of circumstellar material
• Type Ia supernovae with and without blueshifted narrow Na I D lines - how different is their structure?
• SN 2023zaw: an ultra-stripped, nickel-poor supernova from a low-mass progenitor
• The Red Supergiant Progenitor of the Type II Supernova 2024abfl
• Narrow absorption lines from intervening material in supernovae I. Measurements and temporal evolution
• Bright but slow - Type II supernovae from OGLE-IV - Implications for magnitude limited surveys
• High Cadence TESS and ground-based data of SN 2019esa, the less energetic sibling of SN 2006gy
• Measuring the Diffuse Interstellar Bands at 5780, 5797, and 6614 Å in Low-Resolution Spectra of Cool Stars from LAMOST
• Intermediate-luminosity red transients: Spectrophotometric properties and connection to electron-capture supernova explosions
• SN 2024abvb: A Type Icn Supernova in the Outskirts of its Host Galaxy
• A long life of excess: The interacting transient SN 2017hcc