The distance to NGC1316 (Fornax A): yet another curious case
arXiv:1302.7132 · doi:10.1051/0004-6361/201220756
Abstract
The distance of NGC1316, the brightest galaxy in Fornax, is an interesting test for the cosmological distance scale. First, because Fornax is the 2nd largest cluster of galaxies at <~25 Mpc after Virgo and, in contrast to Virgo, has a small line-of-sight depth; and second, because NGC1316 is the galaxy with the largest number of detected SNeIa, giving the opportunity to test the consistency of SNeIa distances internally and against other indicators. We measure SBF mags in NGC1316 from ground and space-based imaging data, providing a homogeneous set of measurements over a wide wavelength interval. The SBF, coupled with empirical and theoretical calibrations, are used to estimate the distance to the galaxy. We present the first B-band SBF measurements of NGC1316 and use them together with the optical and near-IR SBF data to analyze the properties of field stars. Our distance modulus m-M=31.59 +-0.05(stat) +-0.14(sys), when placed in a consistent Cepheid distance scale, agrees with the results from other indicators. However, our result is ~17% larger than the most recent estimate based on SNeIa. Possible explanations for this disagreement are the uncertainties on internal extinction, or calibration issues. Concerning the stellar population analysis, we confirm earlier results from other indicators: the field stars in NGC1316 are dominated by a solar metallicity, intermediate age component. A substantial mismatch exists between B-band SBF models and data, a behavior that can be accounted for by an enhanced percentage of hot horizontal branch stars. Our study of the SBF distance to NGC1316, and the comparison with distances from other indicators, raises some concern about the homogeneity between the calibrations of different indicators. If not properly placed in the same reference scale, significant differences can occur, with dramatic impact on the cosmological distance ladder.
arXiv comment21 pages, 13 figures; A&A accepted
References in corpus (79)
- Observational Evidence from Supernovae for an Accelerating Universe and a Cosmological Constant
- Maps of Dust IR Emission for Use in Estimation of Reddening and CMBR Foregrounds
- Measuring Reddening with SDSS Stellar Spectra and Recalibrating SFD
- Final Results from the Hubble Space Telescope Key Project to Measure the Hubble Constant
- The SBF Survey of Galaxy Distances. IV. SBF Magnitudes, Colors, and Distances
- The Photometric Performance and Calibration of the HST Advanced Camera For Surveys
- Improved Distances to Type Ia Supernovae with Multicolor Light Curve Shapes: MLCS2k2
- The ACS Virgo Cluster Survey. XIII. SBF Distance Catalog and the Three-Dimensional Structure of the Virgo Cluster
- The Absolute Luminosities of the Calan/Tololo Type Ia Supernovae
- The ACS Fornax Cluster Survey. V. Measurement and Recalibration of Surface Brightness Fluctuations and a Precise Value of the Fornax--Virgo Relative Distance
- An Empirical Relation between Sodium Absorption and Dust Extinction
- The Hubble Constant
- The Carnegie Supernova Project: Analysis of the First Sample of Low-Redshift Type-Ia Supernovae
- The ACS Virgo Cluster Survey. XII. The Luminosity Function of Globular Clusters in Early Type Galaxies
- The Carnegie Supernova Project: Light Curve Fitting with SNooPy
- The ACS Virgo Cluster Survey. I. Introduction to the Survey
- The SBF Survey of Galaxy Distances. II. Local and Large-Scale Flows
- Planetary Nebulae as Standard Candles. XII. Connecting the Population I and Population II Distance Scales
- The HST Key Project on the Extragalactic Distance Scale XXVI. The Calibration of Population II Secondary Distance Indicators and the Value of the Hubble Constant
- Measuring Distances and Probing the Unresolved Stellar Populations of Galaxies Using Infrared Surface Brightness Fluctuations
- The ACS Virgo Cluster Survey X. Half-light Radii of Globular Clusters in Early-Type Galaxies: Environmental Dependencies and a Standard Ruler for Distance Estimation
- A Catalogue and Analysis of Local Galaxy Ages and Metallicities
- The ACS Fornax Cluster Survey. VIII. The Luminosity Function of Globular Clusters in Virgo and Fornax Early-Type Galaxies and its Use as a Distance Indicator
- A Second Case of Variable Na I D Lines in a Highly-Reddened Type Ia Supernova (with Erratum)
- Hubble Diagrams of Type Ia Supernovae in the Near Infrared
- Optical and Infrared Photometry of the Type Ia Supernovae 1991T, 1991bg, 1999ek, 2001bt, 2001cn, 2001cz, and 2002bo
- Detection and Photometry of Hot Horizontal Branch Stars in the Core of M32
- Kinematics, ages, and metallicities of star clusters in NGC 1316: A 3 Gyr old merger remnant
- Uniformity of V minus Near Infrared Color Evolution of Type Ia Supernovae, and Implications for Host Galaxy Extinction Determination
- Low-Resolution Sodium D Absorption is a Bad Proxy for Extinction
- The ACS Fornax Cluster Survey. II. The Central Brightness Profiles of Early-Type Galaxies: A Characteristic Radius on Nuclear Scales and the Transition from Central Luminosity Deficit to Excess
- Planetary Nebulae in Face-On Spiral Galaxies. I. Planetary Nebula Photometry and Distances
- Optical Light Curve of the Type Ia Supernova 1998bu in M96 and the Supernova Calibration of the Hubble Constant
- Surface Brightness Fluctuations in the Hubble Space Telescope ACS/WFC F814W Bandpass and an Update on Galaxy Distances
- The star cluster system of the 3 Gyr old merger remnant NGC 1316: Clues from optical and near-infrared photometry
- Reddening, Absorption, and Decline Rate Corrections for a Complete Sample of Type Ia Supernovae leading to a Fully Corrected Hubble Diagram to v<30,000kms-1
- The Distance to NGC 1316 (Fornax A) From Observations of Four Type Ia Supernovae
- Stellar Populations and Surface Brightness Fluctuations: New Observations and Models
- The ACS Virgo Cluster Survey II. Data Reduction Procedures
- Measuring Distances Using Infrared Surface Brightness Fluctuations
- The Extragalactic Distance Scale Key Project XXVII. A Derivation of the Hubble Constant Using the Fundamental Plane and Dn-Sigma Relations in Leo I, Virgo, and Fornax
- New Optical and Near-Infrared Surface Brightness Fluctuations Models. II. Young and Intermediate Age Stellar Populations
- Comparison of Distances from RR Lyrae Stars, the Tip of the Red-Giant Branch and Classical Cepheids
- Detection of Radial Surface Brightness Fluctuation and Color Gradients in elliptical galaxies with ACS
- Deep Luminosity Functions of Old and Intermediate-Age Globular Clusters in NGC 1316: Evidence for Dynamical Evolution of Second-Generation Globular Clusters
- A possible solution for the lack of EHB binaries in globular clusters
- New optical and near-infrared Surface Brightness Fluctuations models. A primary distance indicator ranging from Globular Clusters to distant galaxies?
- The ACS Fornax Cluster Survey VII. Half-Light Radii of Globular Clusters in Early-Type Galaxies
- Period-Luminosity Relations Derived from the OGLE-III Fundamental Mode Cepheids
- A New Approach to the Study of Stellar Populations in Early-Type Galaxies: K-band Spectral Indices and an Application to the Fornax Cluster
- The Infrared Surface Brightness Fluctuation Hubble Constant
- The Dearth of UV-Bright Stars in M32: Implications for Stellar Evolution Theory
- Distances from Surface Brightness Fluctuations
- The fast declining Type Ia supernova 2003gs, and evidence for a significant dispersion in near-infrared absolute magnitudes of fast decliners at maximum light
- Reconciliation of the Surface Brightness Fluctuations and Type Ia Supernovae Distance Scales
- A Search for the Progenitors of Two Type-Ia Supernovae in NGC 1316
- UV Bright Globular Clusters in M87: More Evidence for Super-helium-rich Stellar Populations?
- Surface Brightness Fluctuations of Fornax Cluster Galaxies: Calibration of Infrared SBFs and Evidence for Recent Star Formation
- Surface Brightness Fluctuations from archival ACS images: a stellar population and distance study
- Joint Analysis of near-infrared properties and surface brightness fluctuations of LMC star clusters
- The HST Key Project on the Extragalactic Distance Scale XIV. The Cepheids in NGC 1365
- Kinematic evidence for different Planetary Nebulae Populations in the elliptical galaxy NGC 4697
- Planetary nebulae and stellar kinematics in the flattened elliptical galaxy NGC 1344
- Calibrating Type Ia Supernovae using the Planetary Nebula Luminosity Function I. Initial Results
- Optical Surface Brightness Fluctuations of shell galaxies towards 100 Mpc
- Globular Clusters in Fornax: Does Depend on Environment?
- Tracers of stellar mass-loss. I. Optical and near-IR colours and surface brightness fluctuations
- The Globular Cluster System of NGC 1316 (Fornax A)
- Detection of Surface Brightness Fluctuations in Elliptical Galaxies imaged with the Advanced Camera for Surveys. B- and I-band measurements
- Surface Brightness Fluctuations as Primary and Secondary Distance Indicators
- Planetary nebulae in the elliptical galaxy NGC 821: kinematics and distance determination
- AGB Connection and Ultraviolet Luminosity Excess in Elliptical Galaxies
- The Star Cluster Population of the Spiral Galaxy NGC3370
- The rate and the origin of type Ia supernovae in radiogalaxies
- Rebirth of Novae as Distance Indicators Due to Efficient Large Telescopes
- Anomalous Surface Brightness Fluctuations in NGC 4489
- VLT Optical BVR observations of two bright Supernova Ia hosts in the Virgo cluster
- Abundance Patterns in the Interstellar Medium of the S0 Galaxy NGC 1316 (Fornax A) Revealed with Suzaku
- Ho Measurement from VLT Deep I-band Surface Brightness Fluctuations in NGC 564 and NGC 7619
Cited by in corpus (30)
- The Hubble Constant from Infrared Surface Brightness Fluctuation Distances
- A new measurement of the Hubble constant using Type Ia supernovae calibrated with surface brightness fluctuations
- The Next Generation Virgo Cluster Survey (NGVS). XVIII. Measurement and Calibration of Surface Brightness Fluctuation Distances for Bright Galaxies in Virgo (and Beyond)
- VEGAS: A VST Early-type GAlaxy Survey. I. Presentation, wide-field surface photometry, and substructures in NGC 4472
- The Fornax Deep Survey with VST. II. Fornax A: a two-phase assembly caught on act
- VEGAS-SSS II: Comparing the globular cluster systems in NGC3115 and NGC1399 using VEGAS and FDS survey data
- AGN feeding and feedback in Fornax A: kinematical analysis of the multi-phase ISM
- The flickering nuclear activity of Fornax A
- A MeerKAT view of pre-processing in the Fornax A group
- The Fornax Deep Survey with VST. X. The assembly history of the bright galaxies and intra-group light in the Fornax A subgroup
- Measuring Infrared Surface Brightness Fluctuation Distances with HST WFC3: Calibration and Advice
- The Carnegie-Chicago Hubble Program. V. The Distances to NGC 1448 and NGC 1316 via the Tip of the Red Giant Branch
- Broadband radio polarimetry of Fornax A, I: Depolarized patches generated by advected thermal material from NGC 1316
- Connecting Infrared Surface Brightness Fluctuation Distances to Type Ia Supernova Hosts: Testing the Top Rung of the Distance Ladder
- Neutral hydrogen gas within and around NGC 1316
- The complex star cluster system of NGC 1316 (Fornax A)
- Active Galactic Nuclei as potential Sources of Ultra-High Energy Cosmic Rays
- Mid-infrared dust in two nearby radio galaxies, NGC 1316 (Fornax A) and NGC 612 (PKS 0131-36)
- Complex distribution and velocity field of molecular gas in NGC 1316 as revealed by Morita Array of ALMA
- Resolving the Discrepancy of Distance to M60, a Giant Elliptical Galaxy in Virgo
- Nonthermal emission in the lobes of Fornax A
- The DIVING Survey -- Deep IFS View of Nuclei of Galaxies -- I. Definition and Sample Presentation
- Yonsei Evolutionary Population Synthesis (YEPS) Model. III. Surface Brightness Fluctuation of Normal and Helium-enhanced Simple Stellar Populations
- First VLBI detection of Fornax A
- A depolarizing HI tidal tail in the western lobe of Fornax A
- Dust and gas in the central region of NGC 1316 (Fornax A) -- Its origin and nature
- The globular cluster system of NGC 1316 IV. Nature of the star cluster complex SH2
- Clustering of Local Group distances: publication bias or correlated measurements? VII. A distance framework out to 100 Mpc
- Identification of a New Ultraluminous X-ray Source in NGC 1316
- Deep MOS Spectroscopy of NGC 1316 Globular Clusters