A Second Case of Variable Na I D Lines in a Highly-Reddened Type Ia Supernova (with Erratum)
arXiv:0811.0002 · doi:10.1088/0004-637X/693/1/207
Abstract
(Original) Recent high-resolution spectra of the Type Ia SN 2006X have revealed the presence of time-variable and blueshifted Na I D features, interpreted by Patat et al. as originating in circumstellar material within the progenitor system. The variation seen in SN 2006X induces relatively large changes in the total Na I D equivalent width ($Δ\rm{EW}\approx 0.5 \unicode{x212B}$ in just over two weeks), that would be detectable at lower resolutions. We have used a large data set comprising 2400 low-resolution spectra of 450 Type Ia supernovae (SNe Ia) obtained by the CfA Supernova Program to search for variable Na I D features. Out of the 31 SNe Ia (including SN 2006X) in which we could have detected similar EW variations, only one other (SN 1999cl) shows variable Na I D features, with an even larger change over a similar ~10-day timescale ($Δ\rm{EW} = 1.66 \pm 0.21 \unicode{x212B}$). Interestingly, both SN 1999cl and SN 2006X are the two most highly-reddened objects in our sample, raising the possibility that the variability is connected to dusty environments. (Erratum) The large variation in the Na I D equivalent width observed in SN 1999cl results in fact from a measurement error. Our new measurements show that the EW variation is significantly lower, at $0.43 \pm 0.14 \unicode{x212B}$. While the EW variation remains statistically significant (3.1 different from zero), it is now below the detection threshold of 0.5 $\unicode{x212B}$ derived from the Monte Carlo simulations published in the original paper. As a result, SN 1999cl should no longer be considered as an object displaying variable Na I D lines in our study. The fraction of SNe Ia in our sample displaying Na I D lines thus goes from 6% (2/31) in the original study to 3% (1/31) in the revised analysis, SN 2006X being the only SN Ia in our sample with variable Na I D lines.
arXiv comment10 pages, 5 figures (original paper); 6 pages, 6 figures (Erratum). ApJ, accepted
References in corpus (58)
- Maps of Dust IR Emission for Use in Estimation of Reddening and CMBR Foregrounds
- Dust Masses, PAH Abundances, and Starlight Intensities in the SINGS Galaxy Sample
- Improved Distances to Type Ia Supernovae with Multicolor Light Curve Shapes: MLCS2k2
- The Reddening-Free Decline Rate Versus Luminosity Relationship for Type Ia Supernovae
- BVRI Light Curves for 22 Type Ia Supernovae
- Explosions of O-Ne-Mg Cores, the Crab Supernova, and Subluminous Type II-P Supernovae
- Rates and properties of type Ia supernovae as a function of mass and star-formation in their host galaxies
- The type Ia supernova SNLS-03D3bb from a super-Chandrasekhar-mass white dwarf star
- The supernova rate per unit mass
- The Updated Zwicky Catalog (UZC)
- Evidence for an asymptotic giant branch star in the progenitor system of a type Ia supernova
- Detection of circumstellar material in a normal Type Ia Supernova
- The diversity of Type Ia Supernovae: evidence for systematics?
- UBVRI Light Curves of 44 Type Ia Supernovae
- Type Ia Supernova Explosions in Binary Systems: The Impact on the Secondary Star and its Consequences
- K-corrections and spectral templates of Type Ia supernovae
- The Type Ia Supernova Rate
- The rates of Type Ia Supernovae. I. Analytical Formulations
- The Luminous and Carbon-Rich Supernova 2006gz: A Double Degenerate Merger?
- Multi-Dimensional Simulations of the Accretion-Induced Collapse of White Dwarfs to Neutron Stars
- Nearby Supernova Factory Observations of SN 2005gj: Another Type Ia Supernova in a Massive Circumstellar Envelope
- Remnant evolution after a carbon-oxygen white dwarf merger
- A Search for Environmental Effects on Type Ia Supernovae
- Optical and Infrared Spectroscopy of the type IIn SN 1998S : Days 3-127
- Constraining the Type Ia Supernova Progenitor: The Search for Hydrogen in Nebular Spectra
- The Type Ia Supernova 1998bu in M96 and the Hubble Constant
- Optical and Near-Infrared Observations of the Highly Reddened, Rapidly Expanding Type Ia Supernova 2006X in M100
- Low R_v from circumstellar dust around supernovae
- Supernovae Rates: A Cosmic History
- Is there Evidence for a Hubble bubble? The Nature of Type Ia Supernova Colors and Dust in External Galaxies
- Early and late time VLT spectroscopy of SN 2001el - progenitor constraints for a type Ia supernova
- Variety in Supernovae
- Have the Elusive Progenitors of Supernovae Type Ia Been Discovered?
- Anomalous extinction behaviour towards the Type Ia SN 2003cg
- Optical Spectroscopy of Type Ia Supernovae
- Dust around Type Ia supernovae
- Off-Center Carbon Ignition in Rapidly Rotating, Accreting Carbon-Oxygen White Dwarfs
- SN 2005 gj: Evidence for LBV supernovae progenitors?
- The impact of type Ia supernovae on main sequence binary companions
- Hubble Space Telescope and Ground-Based Observations of SN 1993J and SN 1998S: CNO Processing in the Progenitors
- A Search for Radio Emission from Type Ia Supernovae
- The Progenitors of Type Ia Supernovae
- Magnetically-driven explosions of rapidly-rotating white dwarfs following Accretion-Induced Collapse
- Supernova 2002ic: the collapse of a stripped-envelope, massive star in a dense medium ?
- The Detection of a Light Echo from the Type Ia Supernova 2006X in M100
- Photometry of the Type Ia Supernovae 1999cc, 1999cl, and 2000cf
- Progenitors of Type Ia Supernovae: Binary Stars with White Dwarf Companions
- Interstellar atoms, molecules and diffuse bands toward SN2006X in M100
- Chandra Observations of Type Ia Supernovae: Upper Limits to the X-ray Flux of SN 2002bo, SN 2002ic, SN 2005gj, and SN 2005ke
- The Calibration of the Swift/UVOT Optical Observations: A Recipe for Photometry
- Reflections on Reflexions: II. Effects of Light Echoes on the luminosity and spectra of Type Ia Supernovae
- Circumstellar Na I and Ca II lines of type Ia supernovae in symbiotic scenario
- The host of GRB 060206: kinematics of a distant galaxy
- Upper limit for circumstellar gas around the Type Ia SN 2000cx
- The Nature and Geometry of the Light Echo from SN 2006X
- Interstellar and Circumstellar Optical & Ultraviolet Lines Towards SN1998S
- Strongly Variable z=1.48 FeII and MgII Absorption in the Spectra of z=4.05 GRB 060206
- Constraints on Circumstellar Material Around the Type Ia Supernova 2007af
Cited by in corpus (115)
- Spectra and Light Curves of Six Type Ia Supernovae at 0.511 < z < 1.12 and the Union2 Compilation
- Observational clues to the progenitors of Type-Ia supernovae
- Nearby Supernova Rates from the Lick Observatory Supernova Search. II. The Observed Luminosity Functions and Fractions of Supernovae in a Complete Sample
- An Empirical Relation between Sodium Absorption and Dust Extinction
- The First Systematic Study of Type Ibc Supernova Multi-band Light Curves
- Progenitors of type Ia supernovae
- The Carnegie Supernova Project: Analysis of the First Sample of Low-Redshift Type-Ia Supernovae
- Improved Distances to Type Ia Supernovae with Two Spectroscopic Subclasses
- On the Source of the Dust Extinction in Type Ia Supernovae and the Discovery of Anomalously Strong Na I Absorption
- Circumstellar Material in Type Ia Supernovae via Sodium Absorption Features
- Evidence for the White Dwarf Nature of Mira B
- Type Ia Supernovae Strongly Interacting with Their Circumstellar Medium
- Carnegie Supernova Project: Observations of Type IIn supernovae
- Type Ia Supernovae as Stellar Endpoints and Cosmological Tools
- SN 2008S: an electron capture SN from a super-AGB progenitor?
- Evidence for Two Distinct Populations of Type Ia Supernovae
- EVLA Observations Constrain the Environment and Progenitor System of Type Ia Supernova 2011fe
- A Golden Standard Type Ia Supernova SN 2005cf: Observations from the Ultraviolet to the Near-Infrared Wavebands
- The Standardized Candle Method for Type II Plateau Supernovae
- Variable Sodium Absorption in a Low-Extinction Type Ia Supernova
- Single-degenerate type Ia supernovae without hydrogen contamination
- SN~2012cg: Evidence for Interaction Between a Normal Type Ia Supernova and a Non-Degenerate Binary Companion
- Type Ia Supernova Explosions in Binary Systems: A Review
- The Ignition of Carbon Detonations via Converging Shock Waves in White Dwarfs
- Very Early Ultraviolet and Optical Observations of the Type Ia Supernova 2009ig
- Extensive HST Ultraviolet Spectra and Multi-wavelength Observations of SN 2014J in M82 Indicate Reddening and Circumstellar Scattering by Typical Dust
- Low-Resolution Sodium D Absorption is a Bad Proxy for Extinction
- One-dimensional delayed-detonation models of Type Ia supernovae: Confrontation to observations at bolometric maximum
- Inverse Compton X-ray Emission from Supernovae with Compact Progenitors: Application to SN2011fe
- A statistical analysis of circumstellar material in Type Ia supernovae
- A Deep Search for Prompt Radio Emission from Thermonuclear Supernovae with the Very Large Array
- Diversity in extinction laws of Type Ia supernovae measured between and
- The peculiar extinction law of SN2014J measured with The Hubble Space Telescope
- The Low-Velocity, Rapidly Fading Type Ia Supernova 2002es
- The Distance to NGC 1316 (Fornax A) From Observations of Four Type Ia Supernovae
- Constraints on dark energy with the LOSS SN Ia sample
- Linking Type Ia Supernova Progenitors and their Resulting Explosions
- Circumstellar absorption in double detonation Type Ia supernovae
- Progenitors of type Ia supernovae
- Using Spectral Flux Ratios to Standardize SN Ia Luminosities
- Connecting RS OPh to [some] Type Ia Supernovae
- The Type II-P Supernova 2017eaw: from explosion to the nebular phase
- Searching for swept-up Hydrogen and Helium in the late-time spectra of 11 nearby Type Ia supernovae
- A systematic study of carbon-oxygen white dwarf mergers: mass combinations for Type Ia supernovae
- The Origin of Kepler's Supernova Remnant
- The Massive Progenitor of the Possible Type II-Linear Supernova 2009hd in Messier 66
- Do spectra improve distance measurements of Type Ia supernovae?
- Photometric and Spectroscopic Evolution of the Type IIP SN 2007it to Day 944
- Multi-epoch high-resolution spectroscopy of SN2011fe - Linking the progenitor to its environment
- The Exceptionally Luminous Type Ia Supernova 2007if
- Modelling the circumstellar medium in RS Ophiuchi and its link to Type Ia supernovae
- A comprehensive progenitor model for SNe Ia
- Kepler's Supernova: An Overluminous Type Ia Event Interacting with a Massive Circumstellar Medium at a Very Late Phase
- The UV/optical spectra of the Type Ia supernova SN 2010jn: a bright supernova with outer layers rich in iron-group elements
- White Dwarf/M Dwarf Binaries as Single Degenerate Progenitors of Type Ia Supernovae
- Extending the supernova Hubble diagram to z~1.5 with the Euclid space mission
- A common-envelope wind model for Type Ia supernovae (I): binary evolution and birth rate
- Late-Time Spectral Observations of the Strongly Interacting Type Ia Supernova PTF11kx
- The early discovery of SN 2017ahn: signatures of persistent interaction in a fast declining Type II supernova
- Multi-Epoch High-Spectral-Resolution Observations of Neutral Sodium in 14 Type Ia Supernovae
- The Cold and Dusty Circumstellar Matter around Fast-expanding Type Ia Supernovae
- Time-Varying Potassium in High-Resolution Spectra of the Type Ia Supernova 2014J
- Astronomical Distance Determination in the Space Age. Secondary distance indicators
- Spitzer observations of SN 2014J and properties of mid-IR emission in Type Ia supernovae
- A Systematic Study of Ia-CSM Supernovae from the ZTF Bright Transient Survey
- On the Lira law and the nature of extinction towards Type Ia Supernovae
- Supernova tests of the timescape cosmology
- The distance to NGC1316 (Fornax A): yet another curious case
- The Most Slowly Declining Type Ia Supernova 2001ay
- Molecular gas at supernova local environments unveiled by EDGE
- Interaction Between The Broad-lined Type Ic Supernova 2012ap and Carriers of Diffuse Interstellar Bands
- Herschel limits on far-infrared emission from circumstellar dust around nearby Type Ia supernovae
- Shedding light on the Type Ia supernova extinction puzzle: dust location found
- The Late-Time Rebrightening of Type Ia SN 2005gj in the Mid-Infrared
- The Carnegie Supernova Project I: methods to estimate host-galaxy reddening of stripped-envelope supernovae
- A likely candidate of type Ia supernova progenitors: the X-ray pulsating companion of the hot subdwarf HD 49798
- Common continuum polarization properties: a possible link between proto-planetary nebulae and Type Ia Supernovae progenitors
- On the maximum luminosities of normal stripped-envelope supernovae -- brighter than explosion models allow
- Estimating dust distances to Type Ia supernovae from colour excess time-evolution
- Determining Type Ia Supernovae Host galaxy extinction probabilities and a statistical approach to estimating the absorption-to-reddening ratio
- Asymmetries in SN 2014J Near Maximum Light Revealed Through Spectropolarimetry
- Discovery and Follow-up Observations of the Young Type Ia Supernova 2016coj
- Evidence for asymmetric distribution of circumstellar material around Type Ia Supernovae
- Time-Varying Sodium Absorption in the Type Ia Supernova 2013gh
- Dense molecular clouds in the SN2008fp host galaxy
- The X-ray/radio and UV luminosity expected from symbiotic systems as the progenitor of SNe Ia
- Circumstellar Shells in Absorption in Type Ia Supernovae
- The Type Ia supernovae rate with Subaru/XMM-Newton Deep Survey
- What sodium absorption lines tell us about type Ia supernovae
- Continuum Foreground Polarization and Na~I Absorption in Type Ia SNe
- Type Ia Supernovae and their Environment: Theory and Applications to SN 2014J
- A Spectral Classification System for Hydrogen-deficient Carbon Stars
- Supernova 2010ev: A reddened high velocity gradient type Ia supernova
- Detection of a Light Echo from the Otherwise Normal SN 2007af
- Probing the Progenitors of Type Ia Supernovae using Circumstellar Material Interaction Signatures
- Insights into thermonuclear supernovae from the incomplete silicon burning process
- Thirty Years of Radio Observations of Type Ia SN 1972E and SN 1895B: Constraints on Circumstellar Shells
- Light curve properties of SN 2017fgc and HV SNe Ia
- Time varying Na I D absorption in ILRTs as a probe of circumstellar material
- Self-shielding of Soft X-rays in SN Ia Progenitors
- High-velocity feature as the indicator of the stellar population of Type Ia supernovae
- The Effects of Circumstellar Dust Scattering on the Light Curves and Polarizations of Type Ia Supernovae
- Type Ia supernovae with and without blueshifted narrow Na I D lines - how different is their structure?
- Narrow absorption lines from intervening material in supernovae I. Measurements and temporal evolution
- Is SN 2006X from a WD + MS system with optically thick wind?
- WD+MS Systems as the Progenitors of Type Ia Supernovae with Different Metallicities
- Discovery of Metastable Helium Absorption Lines in V1280 Scorpii
- Narrow absorption lines from intervening material in supernovae. II. Galaxy properties
- Intrinsic color diversity of nearby type Ia supernovae
- Photometric properties of intermediate redshift Type Ia Supernovae observed by SDSS-II Supernova Survey
- A New Insight into the Classification of Type Ia Supernovae
- WD + MS systems as the progenitor of SNe Ia
- Puzzling High-Velocity Calcium Absorption Features Of Type Ia Supernovae
- Seeking the Progenitors of Type Ia Supernovae
- SN 2017fgc: A Fast-Expanding Type Ia Supernova Exploded in Massive Shell Galaxy NGC 474