Searching for a Cosmological Preferred Axis: Union2 Data Analysis and Comparison with Other Probes

Abstract

We review, compare and extend recent studies searching for evidence for a preferred cosmological axis. We start from the Union2 SnIa dataset and use the hemisphere comparison method to search for a preferred axis in the data. We find that the hemisphere of maximum accelerating expansion rate is in the direction $(l,b)=({309^{\circ }}_{-3^{\circ }}^{+23^{\circ }},{18^{\circ }}_{-10^{\circ }}^{+11^{\circ }})$ ($\omm=0.19$) while the hemisphere of minimum acceleration is in the opposite direction $(l,b)=({129^{\circ }}_{-3^{\circ }}^{+23^{\circ }},{-18^{\circ }}_{-11^{\circ }}^{+10^{\circ }})$ ($\omm=0.30$). The level of anisotropy is described by the normalized difference of the best fit values of $\omm$ between the two hemispheres in the context of \lcdm fits. We find a maximum anisotropy level in the Union2 data of $\frac{Δ\ommax}{\bomm}=0.43\pm 0.06$. Such a level does not necessarily correspond to statistically significant anisotropy because it is reproduced by about $30$ of simulated isotropic data mimicking the best fit Union2 dataset. However, when combined with the axes directions of other cosmological observations (bulk velocity flow axis, three axes of CMB low multipole moments and quasar optical polarization alignment axis), the statistical evidence for a cosmological anisotropy increases dramatically. We estimate the probability that the above independent six axes directions would be so close in the sky to be less than $1$. Thus either the relative coincidence of these six axes is a very large statistical fluctuation or there is an underlying physical or systematic reason that leads to their correlation.

10 pages, 7 figures. Accepted in JCAP (to appear). Extended analysis with redshift tomography of SnIa, included errorbars and increased number of axes. The Mathematica 7 files with the data used for the production of the figures along with a Powerpoint file with additional figures may be downloaded from http://leandros.physics.uoi.gr/anisotropy

References in corpus (83)

• Seven-Year Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) Observations: Cosmological Interpretation
• HEALPix -- a Framework for High Resolution Discretization, and Fast Analysis of Data Distributed on the Sphere
• Type Ia Supernova Discoveries at z>1 From the Hubble Space Telescope: Evidence for Past Deceleration and Constraints on Dark Energy Evolution
• Where are the missing galactic satellites?
• Improved Cosmological Constraints from New, Old and Combined Supernova Datasets
• Spectra and Light Curves of Six Type Ia Supernovae at 0.511 < z < 1.12 and the Union2 Compilation
• Improved Dark Energy Constraints from ~100 New CfA Supernova Type Ia Light Curves
• A high resolution foreground cleaned CMB map from WMAP
• The cored distribution of dark matter in spiral galaxies
• Seven-Year Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) Observations: Are There Cosmic Microwave Background Anomalies?
• The axis of evil
• Cosmological Constraints from the Clustering of the Sloan Digital Sky Survey DR7 Luminous Red Galaxies
• Is the low-l microwave background cosmic?
• Dark Energy Anisotropic Stress and Large Scale Structure Formation
• Consistently Large Cosmic Flows on Scales of 100 Mpc/h: a Challenge for the Standard LCDM Cosmology
• Imprints of a Primordial Preferred Direction on the Microwave Background
• High-Resolution Measurements of the Halos of Four Dark Matter-Dominated Galaxies: Deviations from a Universal Density Profile
• A measurement of large-scale peculiar velocities of clusters of galaxies: results and cosmological implications
• Constraints on a Primordial Magnetic Field
• Galaxies in LCDM with Halo Abundance Matching: luminosity-velocity relation, baryonic mass-velocity relation, velocity function and clustering
• Could dark energy be vector-like?
• The Uncorrelated Universe: Statistical Anisotropy and the Vanishing Angular Correlation Function in WMAP Years 1-3
• The Surprisingly Steep Mass Profile of Abell 1689, from a Lensing Analysis of Subaru Images
• Large-angle anomalies in the CMB
• Estimators for CMB Statistical Anisotropy
• Instability of anisotropic cosmological solutions supported by vector fields
• Confronting Lemaitre-Tolman-Bondi models with Observational Cosmology
• The Dipole Observed in the COBE DMR Four-Year Data
• Testing LCDM with the Growth Function δ(a): Current Constraints
• Optimal limits on f_{NL}^{local} from WMAP 5-year data
• The Sloan Digital Sky Survey-II: Photometry and Supernova Ia Light Curves from the 2005 data
• Cosmic Microwave Background Statistics for a Direction-Dependent Primordial Power Spectrum
• Cosmic Flows on 100 Mpc/h Scales: Standardized Minimum Variance Bulk Flow, Shear and Octupole Moments
• Mapping extreme-scale alignments of quasar polarization vectors
• Ghost instabilities of cosmological models with vector fields nonminimally coupled to the curvature
• Cosmic flow from 2MASS redshift survey: The origin of CMB dipole and implications for LCDM cosmology
• (An)isotropy of the Hubble diagram: comparing hemispheres
• Primordial statistical anisotropy generated at the end of inflation
• The dwarf galaxy DDO 47 as a dark matter laboratory: testing cusps hiding in triaxial halos
• Instability of the ACW model, and problems with massive vectors during inflation
• Combining Lens Distortion and Depletion to Map the Mass Distribution of A1689
• Anisotropic Cosmological Constant and the CMB Quadrupole Anomaly
• Statistical anisotropy of the curvature perturbation from vector field perturbations
• Vector theories in cosmology
• Testing the Void against Cosmological data: fitting CMB, BAO, SN and H0
• Confirmation of the existence of coherent orientations of quasar polarization vectors on cosmological scales
• Low-order multipole maps of CMB anisotropy derived from WMAP
• Analyses of Type Ia Supernova Data in Cosmological Models with a Local Void
• Disformal Scalar Fields and the Dark Sector of the Universe
• Local Void vs Dark Energy: Confrontation with WMAP and Type Ia Supernovae
• Halo Mass Profiles and Low Surface Brightness Galaxies Rotation Curves
• CMB Temperature Anisotropy from Broken Spatial Isotropy due to an Homogeneous Cosmological Magnetic Field
• A Model of Universe Anisotropization
• The age problem in $\Lambda$CDM model
• Distinguishing Between Void Models and Dark Energy with Cosmic Parallax and Redshift Drift
• Cosmological perturbations from vector inflation
• Direction-Dependent CMB Power Spectrum and Statistical Anisotropy from Noncommutative Geometry
• Anisotropic dark energy and CMB anomalies
• How close can an Inhomogeneous Universe mimic the Concordance Model?
• On the Possibility of Anisotropic Curvature in Cosmology
• Constraints on Cosmological Anisotropy out to z=1 from Supernovae Ia
• The axis of evil - a polarization perspective
• Anisotropic bispectrum of curvature perturbations from primordial non-Abelian vector fields
• Creating Statistically Anisotropic and Inhomogeneous Perturbations
• Missing Power vs low-l Alignments in the Cosmic Microwave Background: No Correlation in the Standard Cosmological Model
• Six Puzzles for LCDM Cosmology
• Supernovae as seen by off-center observers in a local void
• Comparison of Recent SnIa datasets
• Direction Dependent Non-gaussianity in High-z Supernova Data
• Constraining dark energy fluctuations with supernova correlations
• Large scale directional anomalies in the WMAP 5yr ILC map
• Anisotropic cosmologies containing isotropic background radiation
• Cosmological Alfvén waves in the recent CMB data, and the observational bound on the primordial vector perturbation
• The study of topology of the universe using multipole vectors
• Giant Rings in the CMB Sky
• The Shape and Topology of the Universe
• Large-scale cosmic flows and moving dark energy
• CMB Isotropy Anomalies and the Local Kinetic Sunyaev-Zel'dovich Effect
• The dark matter crisis
• The dwarf galaxy DDO 47: testing cusps hiding in triaxial halos
• The motion of galaxy clusters in inhomogeneous cosmologies
• Evidence for a Preferred Handedness of Spiral Galaxies
• Non-gaussianity and Statistical Anisotropy in Cosmological Inflationary Models

Cited by in corpus (106)

• LSST: from Science Drivers to Reference Design and Anticipated Data Products
• Challenges for $\Lambda$CDM: An update
• The CosmoVerse White Paper: Addressing observational tensions in cosmology with systematics and fundamental physics
• Is the Observable Universe Consistent with the Cosmological Principle?
• Probing the anisotropic local universe and beyond with SNe Ia data
• Probing cosmic isotropy with a new X-ray galaxy cluster sample through the $L_{\text{X}}-T$ scaling relation
• Probing the isotropy of cosmic acceleration traced by Type Ia supernovae
• Is there Correlation between Fine Structure and Dark Energy Cosmic Dipoles?
• Testing the Isotropy of the Universe with Type Ia Supernovae
• Constraints on anisotropic cosmic expansion from supernovae
• Exact solution of vacuum field equation in Finsler spacetime
• Hints of a Local Matter Underdensity or Modified Gravity in the Low $z$ Pantheon data
• Complexity and Isotropization based Extended Models in the context of Electromagnetic Field: An Implication of Minimal Gravitational Decoupling
• Constraining the Anisotropic Expansion of Universe
• Direction Dependence of the Deceleration Parameter
• Hubble flow variance and the cosmic rest frame
• Observational constraints on the deceleration parameter in a tilted universe
• Probing the anisotropic expansion from supernovae and GRBs in a model-independent way
• Testing the isotropy of the Universe by using the JLA compilation of type-Ia supernovae
• Probing Cosmological Isotropy With Type IA Supernovae
• CMB Maximum Temperature Asymmetry Axis: Alignment with Other Cosmic Asymmetries
• Searching for a preferred direction with Union2.1 data
• Anisotropy of the Universe via the Pantheon supernovae sample revisited
• Peculiar motions, accelerated expansion and the cosmological axis
• Cosmological Solutions through Gravitational Decoupling in $f(\mathcal{R},\mathcal{T},{\mathcal{R}}_{\mathrm{ab}}{\mathcal{T}}^{\mathrm{ab}})$ Gravity
• Null Signal for the Cosmic Anisotropy in the Pantheon Supernovae Data
• Anisotropy of Cosmic Acceleration
• The significance of anisotropic signals hiding in the type Ia supernovae
• Cosmological model with local symmetry of very special relativity and constraints on it from supernovae
• Inference of the cosmic rest-frame from supernovae Ia
• Probing bulk flow with nearby SNe Ia data
• Light propagation in a homogeneous and anisotropic universe
• Testing the isotropy of the Universe with type Ia supernovae in a model-independent way
• Anisotropic cosmological reconstruction in $f(R,T)$ gravity
• Global and Local Effects of Rotation: Observational Aspects
• Geodesic-light-cone coordinates and the Bianchi I spacetime
• Directional dependence of CMB parity asymmetry
• Internal Robustness: systematic search for systematic bias in SN Ia data
• Bianchi I meets the Hubble diagram
• Constraining the anisotropy of the Universe via Pantheon supernovae sample
• Anisotropy of the galaxy cluster X-ray luminosity-temperature relation
• Isotropy of low redshift type Ia Supernovae: A Bayesian analysis
• Percent-Level Test of Isotropic Expansion Using Type Ia Supernovae
• Anisotropic expansion and SNIa: an open issue
• Constraining anisotropy of the universe from different groups of type-Ia supernovae
• The deceleration parameter in `tilted' Friedmann universes
• Testing the anisotropy of cosmic acceleration from Pantheon supernovae sample
• Dynamical analysis of cosmological models with non-Abelian gauge vector fields
• Testing cosmic anisotropy with Pantheon sample and quasars at high redshifts
• Generalized LTB model with Inhomogeneous Isotropic Dark Energy: Observational Constraints
• Probing cosmological isotropy with Planck Sunyaev-Zeldovich galaxy clusters
• Inflation and primordial power spectra at anisotropic spacetime inspired by Planck's constraints on isotropy of CMB
• Bianchi Type I model of universe with customized scale factors
• Light propagation in inhomogeneous and anisotropic cosmologies
• Weak-lensing by the large scale structure in a spatially anisotropic universe: theory and predictions
• Is there evidence for anomalous dipole anisotropy in the large-scale structure?
• Testing the Cosmic Anisotropy with Supernovae Data: Hemisphere Comparison and Dipole Fitting
• A Model-independent Test of Cosmic Isotropy with Low-z Pantheon Supernovae
• Constraining the Anisotropy of the Universe from Supernovae and Gamma-ray Bursts
• The multipole expansion of the local expansion rate
• Dynamical features of an anisotropic cosmological model
• Cosmological Constant, Fine Structure Constant and Beyond
• Constraining the local variance of $H_0$ from directional analyses
• The peculiar Raychaudhuri equation
• Ultra-compact radio sources and the isotropy and homogeneity of the Universe
• The deceleration parameter in `tilted' universes: generalising the Friedmann background
• Searching for a Cosmological Preferred Axis in complicated class of cosmological models:Case study $f(R,T)$ model
• A tomographic test of cosmological principle using the JLA compilation of type Ia supernovae
• Searching for a cosmological preferred direction with 147 rotationally supported galaxies
• Accelerating anisotropic cosmologies in Brans-Dicke gravity coupled to a mass-varying vector field
• Testing cosmic anisotropy with Pade approximation and Pantheon+ sample
• Testing the isotropy of cosmic acceleration with Pantheon+ and SH0ES: A cosmographic analysis
• Probing the isotropy of cosmic acceleration using different supernova samples
• Non-comoving Cosmology
• Two fluid anisotropic dark energy models in a scale invariant theory
• Cosmography of the Local Universe by Multipole Analysis of the Expansion Rate Fluctuation Field
• Extending Finch-Skea Isotropic Model to Anisotropic Domain in Modified $f(\mathcal{R},\mathcal{T})$ Gravity
• Supernovae anisotropy power spectrum
• Consistency of Pantheon+ supernovae with a large-scale isotropic universe
• Topological Quintessence
• Anisotropic universe with anisotropic dark energy
• Searching for Cosmological Preferred Axis using cosmographic approach
• Implications of Rastall Theory on Stellar Solutions admitting Vanishing Complexity: A New Perspective
• On Topological Modifications of Newton's Law
• SNe Ia Tests of Quintessence Tracker Cosmology in an Anisotropic Background
• Testing the anisotropy of the universe using the simulated gravitational wave events from advanced LIGO and Virgo
• Probing the anisotropic distribution of baryon matter in the Universe using fast radio bursts
• Testing Local Anisotropy Using the Method of Smoothed Residuals I - Methodology
• High-z Supernova Type Ia Data: non-Gaussianity and Direction Dependence
• Falsifying Cosmological Constant
• Testing the anisotropy of the Universe with the distance duality relation
• Cornering the axion-like particle explanation of quasar polarisations
• Constraints on Bianchi-I type universe with SH0ES anchored Pantheon+ SNIa data
• Expanding covariant cosmography of the local Universe: incorporating the snap and axial symmetry
• Analysis of recent type Ia supernova data based on evolving dark energy models
• Distance-Redshift Relations in an Anisotropic Cosmological Model
• Spinning Toroidal Brane Cosmology; A Classical and Quantum Survey
• New Constraints on Anisotropic Expansion from Supernovae Type Ia
• The prospects of gravitational waves on constraining the anisotropy of the Universe
• Large Scale Cosmological Anomalies and Inhomogeneous Dark Energy
• Constraining Axially Symmetric Bianchi Type I Model with Self-Consistent Recombination History and Observables
• Can Chameleon fields be the source of both the dark energy dipole and the CMB dipole?
• Expansion of a spherical dust gas -- the cosmological conundrum
• Constraints on the dark energy dipole from large-scale structures
• Dark Energy Induced Anisotropy in Cosmic Expansion
• Testing the cosmological principle on gigaparsec scales