Comparison of Recent SnIa datasets

Abstract

We rank the six latest Type Ia supernova (SnIa) datasets (Constitution (C), Union (U), ESSENCE (Davis) (E), Gold06 (G), SNLS 1yr (S) and SDSS-II (D)) in the context of the Chevalier-Polarski-Linder (CPL) parametrization $w(a)=w_0+w_1(1-a)$, according to their Figure of Merit (FoM), their consistency with the cosmological constant ($\Lambda$CDM), their consistency with standard rulers (Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) and Baryon Acoustic Oscillations (BAO)) and their mutual consistency. We find a significant improvement of the FoM (defined as the inverse area of the 95.4% parameter contour) with the number of SnIa of these datasets ((C) highest FoM, (U), (G), (D), (E), (S) lowest FoM). Standard rulers (CMB+BAO) have a better FoM by about a factor of 3, compared to the highest FoM SnIa dataset (C). We also find that the ranking sequence based on consistency with $\Lambda$CDM is identical with the corresponding ranking based on consistency with standard rulers ((S) most consistent, (D), (C), (E), (U), (G) least consistent). The ranking sequence of the datasets however changes when we consider the consistency with an expansion history corresponding to evolving dark energy $(w_0,w_1)=(-1.4,2)$ crossing the phantom divide line $w=-1$ (it is practically reversed to (G), (U), (E), (S), (D), (C)). The SALT2 and MLCS2k2 fitters are also compared and some peculiar features of the SDSS-II dataset when standardized with the MLCS2k2 fitter are pointed out. Finally, we construct a statistic to estimate the internal consistency of a collection of SnIa datasets. We find that even though there is good consistency among most samples taken from the above datasets, this consistency decreases significantly when the Gold06 (G) dataset is included in the sample.

13 pages, 9 figures. Included recently released SDSS-II dataset. Improved presentation. Main results unchanged. The mathematica files and datasets used for the production of the figures may be downloaded from http://leandros.physics.uoi.gr/datacomp/

References in corpus (39)

• Seven-Year Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) Observations: Cosmological Interpretation
• Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) Three Year Results: Implications for Cosmology
• Five-Year Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) Observations: Cosmological Interpretation
• Baryon Acoustic Oscillations in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey Data Release 7 Galaxy Sample
• New Hubble Space Telescope Discoveries of Type Ia Supernovae at z > 1: Narrowing Constraints on the Early Behavior of Dark Energy
• Improved Cosmological Constraints from New, Old and Combined Supernova Datasets
• Observational Constraints on the Nature of the Dark Energy: First Cosmological Results from the ESSENCE Supernova Survey
• Improved Dark Energy Constraints from ~100 New CfA Supernova Type Ia Light Curves
• Improved Distances to Type Ia Supernovae with Multicolor Light Curve Shapes: MLCS2k2
• Measuring the Baryon Acoustic Oscillation scale using the SDSS and 2dFGRS
• Two new diagnostics of dark energy
• Conditions for the cosmological viability of f(R) dark energy models
• First-year Sloan Digital Sky Survey-II (SDSS-II) Supernova Results: Hubble Diagram and Cosmological Parameters
• Report of the Dark Energy Task Force
• WMAP constraints on low redshift evolution of dark energy
• Matter density perturbations and effective gravitational constant in modified gravity models of dark energy
• Observational Tests of Modified Gravity
• Hubble expansion & Structure Formation in Time Varying Vacuum Models
• On the Growth of Perturbations as a Test of Dark Energy
• The acceleration of the universe and the physics behind it
• Holographic dark energy with varying gravitational constant
• Interacting models may be key to solve the cosmic coincidence problem
• Figure of Merit for Dark Energy Constraints from Current Observational Data
• Dark energy from a quintessence (phantom) field rolling near potential minimum (maximum)
• Model-Independent Distance Measurements from Gamma-Ray Bursts and Constraints on Dark Energy
• Is Modified Gravity Required by Observations? An Empirical Consistency Test of Dark Energy Models
• Evolving Newton's Constant, Extended Gravity Theories and SnIa Data Analysis
• Findings of the Joint Dark Energy Mission Figure of Merit Science Working Group
• Comparison of Standard Ruler and Standard Candle constraints on Dark Energy Models
• The Limits of Extended Quintessence
• A Completely Regular Quantum Stress Tensor with $w<-1$
• Constraining $f(R)$ gravity models with disappearing cosmological constant
• Tension in the Recent Type Ia Supernovae Datasets
• Cosmological Studies with Radio Galaxies and Supernovae
• Consistency Test of Dark Energy Models
• Constraints on dark energy from baryon acoustic peak and galaxy cluster gas mass measurements
• Current lookback time-redshift bounds on dark energy
• A primer on problems and prospects of dark energy
• Biased Cosmology: Pivots, Parameters, and Figures of Merit

Cited by in corpus (28)

• Searching for a Cosmological Preferred Axis: Union2 Data Analysis and Comparison with Other Probes
• Observational constraints on Galileon cosmology
• Power of Observational Hubble Parameter Data: a Figure of Merit Exploration
• Is there Correlation between Fine Structure and Dark Energy Cosmic Dipoles?
• Comprehensive cosmographic analysis by Markov Chain Method
• On holographic dark-energy models
• Current Observational Constraints to Holographic Dark Energy Model with New Infrared cut-off via Markov Chain Monte Carlo Method
• A model independent null test on the cosmological constant
• Cosmological constraints on extended Galileon models
• A Strategy to Measure the Dark Energy Equation of State using the HII galaxy Hubble Relation & X-ray AGN Clustering: Preliminary Results
• Constraints on Cosmological Models and Reconstructing the Acceleration History of the Universe with Gamma-Ray Burst Distance Indicators
• Observational constraints on cosmic neutrinos and dark energy revisited
• Supernova light-curve fitters and Dark Energy
• Testing nonstandard cosmological models with SNLS3 supernova data and other cosmological probes
• Probing the dynamical behavior of dark energy
• Consistency of LCDM with Geometric and Dynamical Probes
• Tension between SN and BAO: current status and future forecasts
• Consistency Test of Dark Energy Models
• Impacts of different SNLS3 light-curve fitters on cosmological consequences of interacting dark energy models
• Probing the course of cosmic expansion with a combination of observational data
• Figure of Merit and Different Combinations of Observational Data Sets
• Scaling cosmology with variable dark-energy equation of state
• Testing feasibility of scalar-tensor gravity by scale dependent mass and coupling to matter
• Reconstruction of the interaction term between dark matter and dark energy using SNe Ia
• Genetic algorithms and the analysis of SnIa data
• Generalized Holographic Cosmology: low-redshift observational constraint
• Can Chameleon fields be the source of both the dark energy dipole and the CMB dipole?
• Large Scale Cosmological Anomalies and Inhomogeneous Dark Energy