The Uncorrelated Universe: Statistical Anisotropy and the Vanishing Angular Correlation Function in WMAP Years 1-3

Abstract

The large-angle (low-ell) correlations of the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) as reported by the Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) after their first year of observations exhibited statistically significant anomalies compared to the predictions of the standard inflationary big-bang model. We suggested then that these implied the presence of a solar system foreground, a systematic correlated with solar system geometry, or both. We re-examine these anomalies for the data from the first three years of WMAP's operation. We show that, despite the identification by the WMAP team of a systematic correlated with the equinoxes and the ecliptic, the anomalies in the first-year Internal Linear Combination (ILC) map persist in the three-year ILC map, in all-but-one case at similar statistical significance. The three-year ILC quadrupole and octopole therefore remain inconsistent with statistical isotropy -- they are correlated with each other (99.6% C.L.), and there are statistically significant correlations with local geometry, especially that of the solar system. The angular two-point correlation function at scales >60 degrees in the regions outside the (kp0) galactic cut, where it is most reliably determined, is approximately zero in all wavebands and is even more discrepant with the best fit LambdaCDM inflationary model than in the first-year data - 99.97% C.L. for the new ILC map. The full-sky ILC map, on the other hand, has a non-vanishing angular two-point correlation function, apparently driven by the region inside the cut, but which does not agree better with LambdaCDM. The role of the newly identified low-ell systematics is more puzzling than reassuring.

18 pages, 7 figures, minor additions to refs and conclusions in v2. High resolution figures, multipole vector code and other information can be found at http://www.phys.cwru.edu/projects/mpvectors/

References in corpus (57)

• First Year Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) Observations: Determination of Cosmological Parameters
• HEALPix -- a Framework for High Resolution Discretization, and Fast Analysis of Data Distributed on the Sphere
• Efficient Computation of CMB anisotropies in closed FRW models
• First Year Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) Observations: Preliminary Maps and Basic Results
• First Year Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) Observations: Foreground Emission
• Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) First Year Observations: TE Polarization
• First Year Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) Observations: Angular Power Spectrum
• Asymmetries in the CMB anisotropy field
• A high resolution foreground cleaned CMB map from WMAP
• The significance of the largest scale CMB fluctuations in WMAP
• Detection of non-Gaussianity in the WMAP 1-year data using spherical wavelets
• The axis of evil
• Is the low-l microwave background cosmic?
• Dodecahedral space topology as an explanation for weak wide-angle temperature correlations in the cosmic microwave background
• Suppressing the lower Multipoles in the CMB Anisotropies
• Multipole Vectors--a new representation of the CMB sky and evidence for statistical anisotropy or non-Gaussianity at 2<=l<=8
• On the large-angle anomalies of the microwave sky
• On Foreground Removal from the Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe Data by an Internal Linear Combination Method: Limitations and Implications
• Spontaneous Isotropy Breaking: A Mechanism for CMB Multipole Alignments
• Non-Gaussian Signatures in the Temperature Fluctuation Observed by the Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe
• 2-Point Correlations in the COBE DMR 4-Year Anisotropy Maps
• Does the small CMB quadrupole moment suggest new physics?
• Asymmetries in the local curvature of the WMAP data
• Non-Gaussianity of the derived maps from the first-year WMAP data
• A Low CMB Quadrupole from Dark Energy Isocurvature Perturbations
• A high-significance detection of non-Gaussianity in the WMAP 1-year data using directional spherical wavelets
• CMB multipole measurements in the presence of foregrounds
• Is the Universe odd?
• The Virgo Alignment Puzzle in Propagation of Radiation on Cosmological Scales
• Wavelets and WMAP non-Gaussianity
• Low-order multipole maps of CMB anisotropy derived from WMAP
• Cosmic Microwave Background, Accelerating Universe and Inhomogeneous Cosmology
• Cosmological parameter estimation using Very Small Array data out to l=1500
• Assessing the effects of foregrounds and sky removal in WMAP
• Multipole vector anomalies in the first-year WMAP data: a cut-sky analysis
• Statistical Isotropy of the Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe Data: A Bipolar Power Spectrum Analysis
• Exact likelihood evaluations and foreground marginalization in low resolution WMAP data
• Global universe anisotropy probed by the alignment of structures in the cosmic microwave background
• Correlated isocurvature perturbations from mixed inflaton-curvaton decay
• Alignment tests for low CMB multipoles
• Isotropy of the early universe from CMB anisotropies
• The Multipole Vectors of WMAP, and their frames and invariants
• Well-proportioned universes suppress CMB quadrupole
• Polynomial Interpretation of Multipole Vectors
• Microwave sky and the local Rees-Sciama effect
• Examining the Effect of the Map-Making Algorithm on Observed Power Asymmetry in WMAP Data
• Canonical representation of spherical functions: Sylvester's theorem, Maxwell's multipoles and Majorana's sphere
• Large-scale power in the CMB and new physics: an analysis using Bayesian model comparison
• Statistics of phase correlations as a test for non-Gaussianity of the CMB maps
• Footprints of Statistical Anisotropies
• Did WMAP see Moving Local Structures?
• The CMB Quadrupole in a Polarized Light
• A full sky prediction of the SZ effect from diffuse hot gas in the local universe and the upper limit from the WMAP data
• CMB statistical anisotropy, multipole vectors and the influence of the dipole
• Tentative Identification of Interstellar Dust in the Nose of the Heliosphere
• Non-Gaussian Foreground Residuals of the WMAP First Year Maps
• Is there a common origin for the WMAP low multipole and for the ellipticity in BOOMERanG CMB maps?

Cited by in corpus (206)

• Five-Year Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) Observations: Cosmological Interpretation
• Five-Year Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) Observations: Data Processing, Sky Maps, and Basic Results
• Cosmology and Fundamental Physics with the Euclid Satellite
• Cosmology and fundamental physics with the Euclid satellite
• Seven-Year Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) Observations: Are There Cosmic Microwave Background Anomalies?
• Planck 2013 results. XXIII. Isotropy and statistics of the CMB
• Beyond $\Lambda$CDM: Problems, solutions, and the road ahead
• Planck 2018 results. VII. Isotropy and Statistics of the CMB
• Planck 2015 results. XVI. Isotropy and statistics of the CMB
• Gauge Fields and Inflation
• CMB Anomalies after Planck
• The CosmoVerse White Paper: Addressing observational tensions in cosmology with systematics and fundamental physics
• Hemispherical power asymmetry in the three-year Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe sky maps
• Small scale problems of the $\Lambda$CDM model: a short review
• Large-angle anomalies in the CMB
• Features and New Physical Scales in Primordial Observables: Theory and Observation
• Instability of anisotropic cosmological solutions supported by vector fields
• Probing the anisotropic local universe and beyond with SNe Ia data
• Scalar-Scalar, Scalar-Tensor, and Tensor-Tensor Correlators from Anisotropic Inflation
• Ghost instabilities of cosmological models with vector fields nonminimally coupled to the curvature
• (An)isotropy of the Hubble diagram: comparing hemispheres
• Searching for a Cosmological Preferred Axis: Union2 Data Analysis and Comparison with Other Probes
• Is there proof that backreaction of inhomogeneities is irrelevant in cosmology?
• A Cosmic Microwave Background feature consistent with a cosmic texture
• Power asymmetry in WMAP and Planck temperature sky maps as measured by a local variance estimator
• Primordial statistical anisotropy generated at the end of inflation
• No large-angle correlations on the non-Galactic microwave sky
• Instability of the ACW model, and problems with massive vectors during inflation
• Anisotropic Cosmological Constant and the CMB Quadrupole Anomaly
• Cuscuton Cosmology: Dark Energy meets Modified Gravity
• Observational Challenges for the Standard FLRW Model
• Vector theories in cosmology
• Detection of a Dipole in the Handedness of Spiral Galaxies with Redshifts z ~ 0.04
• Planck pre-launch status: the Planck-LFI programme
• Anomalous parity asymmetry of the Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe power spectrum data at low multipoles
• N-Body Simulations of DGP and Degravitation Theories
• The CMB cold spot: texture, cluster or void?
• Lack of large-angle TT correlations persists in WMAP and Planck
• Anisotropic Inflation from Charged Scalar Fields
• Testable polarization predictions for models of CMB isotropy anomalies
• Fingerprints of Galactic Loop I on the Cosmic Microwave Background
• Bianchi Model CMB Polarization and its Implications for CMB Anomalies
• New constraints on Parity Symmetry from a re-analysis of the WMAP-7 low resolution power spectra
• Anomalous parity asymmetry of WMAP power spectrum data at low multpoles: is it cosmological or systematics?
• Tests and problems of the standard model in Cosmology
• Correlating anomalies of the microwave sky: The Good, the Evil and the Axis
• Simple Types of Anisotropic Inflation
• Needlet Detection of Features in WMAP CMB Sky and the Impact on Anisotropies and Hemispherical Asymmetries
• Observational Evidence for Cosmological-Scale Extra Dimensions
• Disks in the sky: A reassessment of the WMAP "cold spot"
• A low CMB variance in the WMAP data
• The Signature of Proper Motion in the Microwave Sky
• The CMB Quadrupole depression produced by early fast-roll inflation: MCMC analysis of WMAP and SDSS data
• Non-isotropy in the CMB power spectrum in single field inflation
• Searching for a preferred direction with Union2.1 data
• Anisotropic dark energy and CMB anomalies
• LRS Bianchi type I universes exhibiting Noether symmetry in the scalar-tensor Brans-Dicke theory
• Testing Isotropy of Cosmic Microwave Background Radiation
• Parity Asymmetry in the CMBR Temperature Power Spectrum
• Cleaned Three-Year WMAP CMB Map: Magnitude of the Quadrupole and Alignment of Large Scale Modes
• A Complete Statistical Analysis for the Quadrupole Amplitude in an Ellipsoidal Universe
• Large scale anomalies in the CMB and non-Gaussianity in bouncing cosmologies
• Predictions of just-enough inflation
• A new analysis of Poincaré dodecahedral space model
• The axis of evil - a polarization perspective
• Anomalous CMB north-south asymmetry
• Translational Invariance and the Anisotropy of the Cosmic Microwave Background
• The Effective Theory of Inflation in the Standard Model of the Universe and the CMB+LSS data analysis
• Planck CMB Anomalies: Astrophysical and Cosmological Secondary Effects and the Curse of Masking
• New constraints on the observable inflaton potential from WMAP and SDSS
• Searching for a dipole modulation in the large-scale structure of the Universe
• Missing Power vs low-l Alignments in the Cosmic Microwave Background: No Correlation in the Standard Cosmological Model
• Covariance of CMB anomalies
• Anomalous variance in the WMAP data and Galactic Foreground residuals
• Low power on large scales in just enough inflation models
• Testing Isotropy in the Local Universe
• The cut-sky cosmic microwave background is not anomalous
• Evidence of a truncated spectrum in the angular correlation function of the cosmic microwave background
• Cosmological Perturbations in Elastic Dark Energy Models
• Can a primordial magnetic field originate large-scale anomalies in WMAP data?
• Signals of Statistical Anisotropy in WMAP Foreground-Cleaned Maps
• A Scaling Index Analysis of the WMAP three year data: Signatures of non-Gaussianities and Asymmetries in the CMB
• Issues on Generating Primordial Anisotropies at the End of Inflation
• Inflationary power asymmetry from primordial domain walls
• Cosmology Intertwined: A Review of the Particle Physics, Astrophysics, and Cosmology Associated with the Cosmological Tensions and Anomalies
• Constraining fundamental physics with the cosmic microwave background
• No evidence for the cold spot in the NVSS radio survey
• Spectrum of Perturbations in Anisotropic Inflationary Universe with Vector Hair
• Rogues' gallery: the full freedom of the Bianchi CMB anomalies
• Two-point Correlation Function of WMAP 9 year data
• Genus Topology of the Cosmic Microwave Background from the WMAP 3-Year Data
• Gauge field back-reaction in Born Infeld cosmologies
• Needlet Bispectrum Asymmetries in the WMAP 5-year Data
• Kolmogorov stochasticity parameter measuring the randomness in Cosmic Microwave Background
• Anisotropic universe with anisotropic sources
• Porosity criterion for hyperbolic voids and the cosmic microwave background
• A Theory of a Spot
• Large scale alignment anomalies of CMB anisotropies: a new test for residuals applied to WMAP 5yr maps
• Promise of Future Searches for Cosmic Topology
• Large scale directional anomalies in the WMAP 5yr ILC map
• Direction dependence of the power spectrum and its effect on the Cosmic Microwave Background Radiation
• ${\varphi }^4$ inflation is not excluded
• Instability of reconstruction of the low CMB multipoles
• Pearson's random walk in the space of the CMB phases: evidence for parity asymmetry
• Polarization Predictions for Inflationary CMB Power Spectrum Features
• Giant Rings in the CMB Sky
• Searching for non-Gaussianity in the WMAP data
• Observational Hints of a Pre--Inflationary Scale?
• Contamination cannot explain the lack of large-scale power in the cosmic microwave background radiation
• Bias in low-multipole CMB reconstructions
• Observation number correlation in WMAP data
• Modifying Gravity: You Can't Always Get What You Want
• The IR-Completion of Gravity: What happens at Hubble Scales?
• Probing statistical isotropy of cosmological radio sources using SKA
• Can residuals of the Solar system foreground explain low multipole anomalies of the CMB ?
• Non-gaussianity in the foreground-reduced CMB maps
• Is the cold spot responsible for the CMB North-South asymmetry?
• North-South non-Gaussian asymmetry in PLANCK CMB maps
• The One-dimensional Fourier Representation and Large Angular Scale Foreground Contamination in the 3-year Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe data
• Detectability of large-scale power suppression in the galaxy distribution
• Searching for hidden mirror symmetries in CMB fluctuations from WMAP 7 year maps
• Non-Gaussianity in WMAP Data Due to the Correlation of CMB Lensing Potential with Secondary Anisotropies
• Large Scale Plane-Mirroring in the Cosmic Microwave Background WMAP5 Maps
• Cosmological Applications of the Gaussian Kinematic Formula
• Preferred axis of CMB parity asymmetry in the masked maps
• Symmetry and anti-symmetry of the CMB anisotropy pattern
• Lack-of-correlation anomaly in CMB large scale polarisation maps
• Large-scale cosmic flows and moving dark energy
• Statistical Characterization of Temperature Patterns in Anisotropic Cosmologies
• Probing Large-Angle Correlations with the Microwave Background Temperature and Lensing Cross Correlation
• The Parity Odd Universe, Dark Energy and QCD
• CMB low multipole alignments in the $\mathbf{\Lambda }$CDM and Dipolar models
• Non-Bunch-Davies Anisotropy
• Can Relic Superhorizon Inhomogeneities be Responsible for Large-Scale CMB Anomalies?
• What kind of science is cosmology?
• Flat Universe with Hyperbolic Voids
• Can one reconstruct masked CMB sky?
• A model for CMB anisotropies on large angular scales
• Testing CMB Anomalies in E-mode Polarization with Current and Future Data
• Probability Density of the Multipole Vectors for a Gaussian Cosmic Microwave Background
• The ISW effect and the lack of large-angle CMB temperature correlations
• Effect of Foregrounds on the CMBR Multipole Alignment
• Large Scale Traces of Solar System Cold Dust on CMB Anisotropies
• An Anisotropic Model for the Universe
• Low-$\ell$ power suppression in punctuated inflation
• Large scale vector modes and the first CMB temperature multipoles
• On the suspected timing error in WMAP map-making
• The impact of dipole straylight contamination on the alignment of low multipoles of CMB anisotropies
• Deep redshift topological lensing: strategies for the T^3 candidate
• Real space tomography of the primordial Universe with cluster polarization
• Phase analysis of the cosmic microwave background from an incomplete sky coverage
• The size of the Universe according to the Poincare dodecahedral space hypothesis
• Testing the statistical isotropy of large scale structure with multipole vectors
• Testing isotropy of cosmos with WMAP and PLANCK data
• Statistical Isotropy violation of the CMB brightness fluctuations
• Peaks in the CMBR power spectrum. I. Mathematical analysis of the associated real space features
• Detection of Dipole Modulation in CMB Temperature Anisotropy Maps from WMAP and Planck using Artificial Intelligence
• Cosmology with moving bimetric fluids
• How Sensitive is the CMB to a Single Lens?
• Search for a direction in the forest of Lyman-$\alpha$
• Low-frequency line temperatures of the CMB
• Multipole vectors of completely random microwave skies for $l\le 50$
• Plane-mirroring anomaly in the cosmic microwave background maps
• Analysis of $\sim 10^6$ spiral galaxies from four telescopes shows large-scale patterns of asymmetry in galaxy spin directions
• Degree-scale anomalies in the CMB: localizing the first peak dip to a small patch of the north ecliptic sky
• Temperature and Polarization Patterns in Anisotropic Cosmologies
• Revisiting the large-scale CMB anomalies: The impact of the SZ signal from the Local Universe
• What have we learned from observational cosmology ?
• Cross-correlation analysis of CMB with foregrounds for residuals
• Statistics of the excursion sets in models with local primordial non-Gaussianity
• Correlation properties of the maps of the NVSS survey and WMAP ILC
• Modelling the WMAP large-angle anomalies as an effect of a local density inhomogeneity
• New views on the low-energy side of gravity
• Black-Body Anomaly: Analysis of Temperature Offsets
• CMB Anomalies from Relic Anisotropy
• Search for non-Gaussianities in the WMAP data with the Scaling Index Method
• Puzzling initial conditions in the R_h=ct model
• Large-scale asymmetry in galaxy spin directions -- analysis of galaxies with spectra in DES, SDSS, and DESI Legacy Survey
• Cosmological parameters from Planck data in SU(2)${}_{\mathrm{CMB}}$, their local $\Lambda$CDM values, and the modified photon Boltzmann equation
• Impact of Low ell's on Large Scale Structure Anomalies
• Entropy methods for CMB analysis of anisotropy and non-Gaussianity
• The anomaly of the CMB power with the latest Planck data
• Unraveling the CMB lack-of-correlation anomaly with the cosmological gravitational wave background
• Emergent universe revisited through the CSL theory
• Is the lack of power anomaly in the CMB correlated with the orientation of the Galactic plane?
• Cosmic microwave background constraints on cosmological models with large-scale isotropy breaking
• CMB two-point angular correlation function in the Ellipsoidal Universe
• CMB statistical anisotropies of classical and quantum origins
• Degree of randomness: numerical experiments for astrophysical signals
• Reconstruction of Missing Data using Iterative Harmonic Expansion
• Level correlations of the CMB temperature angular power spectrum
• Relic Vector Field and CMB Large Scale Anomalies
• Testing the Origin of the CMB Large-Angle Correlation Deficit with a Galaxy Imaging Survey
• An overview of the current status of CMB observations
• New Geometric Representations of the CMB 2pcf
• Isotropy in the two-point angular correlation function of the CMB
• Imprints of Anisotropy on the Power Spectrum in Matter Dominated Bouncing Universe as Background
• Large Scale Cosmological Anomalies and Inhomogeneous Dark Energy
• Which FLRW comoving 3-manifold is preferred observationally and theoretically?
• Dipole-independent measurements of nearly-zero CMB correlation: a possible symmetry of primordial causal quantum coherence
• The Primordial Magnetic Field (PMF) Generated in Large Field Inflation (LFI), Natural Inflation (NI) and $R^2$-Inflation by $f^{2}FF$ Model
• Recent results and perspectives on cosmology and fundamental physics from microwave surveys
• Dark energy as a spatial continuity condition
• Does gravity prefer the Poincare dodecahedral space?
• Lack of angular correlation and odd-parity preference in CMB data
• On the absence of a universal surface density, and a maximum Newtonian acceleration in dark matter haloes: consequences for MOND