Modifying Gravity: You Can't Always Get What You Want

Abstract

The combination of GR and the Standard Model disagrees with numerous observations on scales from our Solar System up. In the concordance model of cosmology, these contradictions are removed or alleviated by the introduction of three completely independent new components of stress-energy -- the inflaton, dark matter, and dark energy. Each of these in its turn is meant to have (or to currently) dominate the dynamics of the universe. There is still no non-gravitational evidence for any of these dark sectors; nor for the required extensions of the standard model. An alternative is to imagine that GR itself must be modified. Certain coincidences of scale even suggest that one might expect not to have to make three independent. Because they must address the most different types of data, attempts to replace dark matter with modified gravity are the most controversial. A phenomenological model (or family of models), Modified Newtonian Dynamics, has, over the last few years seen several covariant realizations. We discuss a number of challenges that any model that seeks to replace dark matter with modified gravity must face: the loss of Birkhoff's Theorem, and the calculational simplifications it implies; the failure to explain clusters, whether static or interacting, and the consequent need to introduce dark matter of some form, whether hot dark matter neutrinos, or dark fields that arise in new sectors of the modified gravity theory; the intrusion of cosmological expansion into the modified force law, that arises precisely because of the coincidence in scale between the centripetal acceleration at which Newtonian gravity fails in galaxies, and the cosmic acceleration. We conclude with the observation that, although modified gravity may indeed manage to replace dark matter, it is likely to do so by becoming or incorporating, a dark matter theory itself.

A talk given at the Royal Society Discussion Session "Gravity," Chicheley Hall, UK Feb. 2011

References in corpus (19)

• A direct empirical proof of the existence of dark matter
• Improved Cosmological Constraints from New, Old and Combined Supernova Datasets
• Spectra and Light Curves of Six Type Ia Supernovae at 0.511 < z < 1.12 and the Union2 Compilation
• Improved Dark Energy Constraints from ~100 New CfA Supernova Type Ia Light Curves
• CfA3: 185 Type Ia Supernova Light Curves from the CfA
• The Carnegie Supernova Project: Second Photometry Data Release of Low-Redshift Type Ia Supernovae
• The Uncorrelated Universe: Statistical Anisotropy and the Vanishing Angular Correlation Function in WMAP Years 1-3
• Bimetric MOND gravity
• On the Proof of Dark Matter, the Law of Gravity and the Mass of Neutrinos
• The Bullet Cluster 1E0657-558 evidence shows Modified Gravity in the absence of Dark Matter
• Can Cosmic Structure form without Dark Matter?
• Halo globular clusters observed with AAOmega: dark matter content, metallicity and tidal heating
• Testing Fundamental Physics with Distant Star Clusters: Analysis of Observational Data on Palomar 14
• On the growth of structure in theories with a dynamical preferred frame
• Support for temporally varying behavior of the Pioneer anomaly from the extended Pioneer 10 and 11 Doppler data sets
• MOND plus classical neutrinos not enough for cluster lensing
• Gravitational Lenses in Generalized Einstein-Aether theory: the Bullet Cluster
• Modified gravity and the origin of inertia
• Initial Hubble Diagram Results from the Nearby Supernova Factory

Cited by in corpus (11)

• Sterile Neutrino Dark Matter
• Hubble parameter measurement constraints on dark energy
• Quantum statistical modified entropic gravity as a theoretical basis for MOND
• Cosmic slowing down of acceleration using $f_{gas}$
• Exploring hints for dark energy density evolution in light of recent data
• Constraints on dark energy from the Lyα forest baryon acoustic oscillations measurement of the redshift 2.3 Hubble parameter
• Model Independent Tests of Cosmic Gravity
• Observational constraints on dark energy cosmological model parameters
• MOND-like acceleration in integrable Weyl geometric gravity
• The Radial Acceleration Relation and a Magnetostatic Analogy in Quasilinear MOND
• Mimicking the LCDM model with Stealths