Why RKKY exchange integrals are inappropriate to describe ferromagnetism in diluted magnetic semiconductors

Abstract

We calculate Curie temperatures and study the stability of ferromagnetism in diluted magnetic materials, taking as a model for the exchange between magnetic impurities a damped Ruderman-Kittel-Kasuya-Yosida (RKKY) interaction and a shor t range term representing the effects of superexchange. To properly include effects of spin and thermal fluctuations as well as geometric disorder, we solve the effective Heisenberg Hamiltonian by means of a recently developed semi-analytical approach. This approach, ``self-consistent local Random Phase Approximation (SC-L RPA)'', is explained. We show that previous mean-field treatments, which have been widely used in the literature, largely overestimate both the Curie temperatures and the stability of ferromagnetism as a function of carrier density. The discr epancy when compared to the current approach was that effects of frustration in RKKY oscillations had been strongly underestimated by such simple mea n-field theories. We argue that the use, as is frequent, of a weakly-disordered RKKY exchange to model ferromagnetism in diluted III-V systems is inconsistent with the observation of ferromagnetism over a wide region of itinerant carrier densities. This may be puzzling when compared to the apparent success of calculations based on {\it ab-initio} estimates of the coupling; we propose a resolution to this issue by taking RKKY-like interactions between resonant states close to the Fermi level.

Accepted for publication in Physical Review B. 22 pages, 7 figures

References in corpus (17)

• Hole-mediated ferromagnetism in tetrahedrally coordinated semiconductors
• Mn Interstitial Diffusion in (Ga,Mn)As
• Theory of Magnetic Anisotropy in III_{1-x}Mn_{x}V Ferromagnets
• Effects of annealing time on defect-controlled ferromagnetism in Ga1-xMnxAs
• Interlayer coupling in ferromagnetic semiconductor superlattices
• Unusual direction dependence of exchange energies in GaAs:Mn - Is the RKKY description relevant
• A disordered RKKY lattice mean field theory for ferromagnetism in diluted magnetic semiconductors
• Double exchange mechanisms for Mn doped III-V ferromagnetic semiconductors
• Calculating the Curie Temperature reliably in diluted III-V ferromagnetic semiconductors
• Exchange interactions and Curie temperature in (GaMn)As
• Magnetic properties of GaMnAS from an effective Heisenberg Hamiltonian
• Compensation, interstitial defects and ferromagnetism in diluted semiconductors
• Annealing-Dependent Magnetic Depth Profile in Ga[1-x]Mn[x]As
• Influence of non-local exchange on RKKY interactions in III-V diluted magnetic semiconductors
• Disorder effects in diluted ferromagnetic semiconductors
• Positional Disorder, Spin-Orbit Coupling and Frustration in GaMnAs
• Exchange anisotropy, disorder and frustration in diluted, predominantly ferromagnetic, Heisenberg spin systems

Cited by in corpus (26)

• Role of the conduction electrons in mediating exchange interactions in Heusler alloys
• Model for vacancy-induced d${}^0$ ferromagnetism in oxide compounds
• Long Range Intrinsic Ferromagnetism in Two Dimensional Materials and Dissipationless Future Technologies
• Observation of spontaneous spin-splitting in the band structure of an n-type zinc-blende ferromagnetic semiconductor
• Superexchange in Dilute Magnetic Dielectrics: Application to (Ti,Co)O_2
• Evolution of the magnetic anisotropy with carrier density in hydrogenated (Ga,Mn)As
• Non-perturbative $J_{pd}$ model and ferromagnetism in dilute magnets
• Unified picture for diluted magnetic semiconductors
• Precise tuning of the Curie temperature of (Ga,Mn)As-based magnetic semiconductors by hole compensation: Support for valence-band ferromagnetism
• Ultrafast Magnetization Dynamics in Diluted Magnetic Semiconductors
• Carrier induced ferromagnetism in diluted local-moment systems
• Magnetic and chemical nonuniformity in Ga[1-x]Mn[x]As films as probed by polarized neutron and x-ray reflectometry
• Superexchange induced canted ferromagnetism in dilute magnets
• The influence of structural short-range order on the phase diagrams of diluted FCC magnet with arbitrary spin and modified RKKY interaction
• Electronic structure of noble metal impurities in semiconductors: Cu in GaP
• Spin dynamics in the diluted ferromagnetic Kondo lattice model
• Optical conductivity of Mn doped GaAs
• Clustering induced suppression of ferromagnetism in diluted magnets
• Magnetic spin excitations in Mn doped GaAs : A model study
• Nonlocal effects on magnetism in the diluted magnetic semiconductor Ga_{1-x}Mn_{x}As
• Effects of dilution and disorder on magnetism in diluted spin systems
• A semiquantitative approach to the impurity-band-related transport properties of GaMnAs nanolayers
• Disordered Correlated Kondo-lattice model
• Curie temperatures of the concentrated and diluted Kondo-lattice model as a possible candidate to describe magnetic semiconductors and metals
• Comparison between ab-initio and phenomenological modeling of the exchange couplings in diluted magnetic semiconductors: the case of $Z{n}_{1-x}C{r}_{x}Te$
• On the reliability of recent Monte Carlo studies of dilute systems of localized spins interacting with itinerant carriers