The Thermal Memory of Reionization History

Abstract

The recent measurement by WMAP of a large electron scattering optical depth tau_e = 0.17 +- 0.04 is consistent with a simple model of reionization in which the intergalactic medium (IGM) is ionized at redshift z ~ 15, and remains highly ionized thereafter. Here, we show that existing measurements of the IGM temperature from the Lyman-alpha forest at z ~ 2 - 4 rule out this ``vanilla'' model. Under reasonable assumptions about the ionizing spectrum, as long as the universe is reionized before z = 10, and remains highly ionized thereafter, the IGM reaches an asymptotic thermal state which is too cold compared to observations. To simultaneously satisfy the CMB and forest constraints, the reionization history must be complex: reionization begins early at z >~ 15, but there must have been significant (order unity) changes in fractions of neutral hydrogen and/or helium at 6 < z < 10, and/or singly ionized helium at 4 < z < 10. We describe a physically motivated reionization model that satisfies all current observations. We also explore the impact of a stochastic reionization history and show that a late epoch of (HeII --> HeIII) reionization induces a significant scatter in the IGM temperature, but the scatter diminishes with time quickly. Finally, we provide an analytic formula for the thermal asymptote, and discuss possible additional heating mechanisms that might evade our constraints.

10 pages, submitted to ApJ, new references, additional discussion on earlier work and partial HeII reionization

References in corpus (9)

• First Year Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) Observations: Determination of Cosmological Parameters
• Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) First Year Observations: TE Polarization
• A Survey of z>5.7 Quasars in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey II: Discovery of Three Additional Quasars at z>6
• Galaxies and Intergalactic Matter at Redshift z~3: Overview
• The Universe Was Reionized Twice
• Reionization of Hydrogen and Helium by Early Stars and Quasars
• The Reionization History at High Redshifts I: Physical Models and New Constraints from CMB Polarization
• The Redshift Evolution of the 2-8 keV X-ray Luminosity Function
• Caught in the act: a helium-reionizing quasar near the line of sight to Q0302-003

Cited by in corpus (180)

• Ultralight scalars as cosmological dark matter
• Constraining the Evolution of the Ionizing Background and the Epoch of Reionization with z ~ 6 Quasars II: A Sample of 19 Quasars
• The First Stars
• Observational constraints on Cosmic Reionization
• A New Calculation of the Ionizing Background Spectrum and the Effects of HeII Reionization
• A high resolution foreground cleaned CMB map from WMAP
• New Constraints on Cosmic Reionization from the 2012 Hubble Ultra Deep Field Campaign
• 21 Centimeter Fluctuations from Cosmic Gas at High Redshifts
• Reionization after Planck: The Derived Growth of the Cosmic Ionizing Emissivity now matches the Growth of the Galaxy UV Luminosity Density
• Particle decays during the cosmic dark ages
• The observed ionization rate of the intergalactic medium and the ionizing emissivity at z >5: Evidence for a photon starved and extended epoch of reionization
• The First Cosmic Structures and their Effects
• The Evolution of the Intergalactic Medium
• Reionization and the Cosmic Dawn with the Square Kilometre Array
• Detection of Extended He II Reionization in the Temperature Evolution of the Intergalactic Medium
• Photoevaporation of Cosmological Minihalos during Reionization
• Concordance models of reionization: implications for faint galaxies and escape fraction evolution
• Lyman Alpha Emitting Galaxies as a Probe of Reionization
• Early reionization by miniquasars
• New Limits on 21cm EoR From PAPER-32 Consistent with an X-Ray Heated IGM at z=7.7
• 21 cm fluctuations from inhomogeneous X-ray heating before reionization
• HeII Reionization and its Effect on the IGM
• Lower-Luminosity Galaxies could reionize the Universe: Very Steep Faint-End Slopes to the UV Luminosity Functions at z>=5-8 from the HUDF09 WFC3/IR Observations
• Keeping the Universe ionised: Photo-heating and the clumping factor of the high-redshift intergalactic medium
• Toward Epoch of Reionization Measurements with Wide-Field Radio Observations
• Evolution of the Intergalactic Opacity: Implications for the Ionizing Background, Cosmic Star Formation, and Quasar Activity
• A Direct Precision Measurement of the Intergalactic Lyman-alpha Opacity at 2<z<4.2
• The Reionization History at High Redshifts I: Physical Models and New Constraints from CMB Polarization
• The Evolution of Optical Depth in the Ly-alpha Forest: Evidence Against Reionization at z~6
• Lower and Upper Bounds on CSL Parameters from Latent Image Formation and IGM Heating
• Taxing the Rich: Recombinations and Bubble Growth During Reionization
• Statistical Probes of Reionization With 21 cm Tomography
• The Impact of The IGM on High-Redshift Lyman Alpha Emission Lines
• Cosmic Reionisation by Stellar Sources: Population III Stars
• The Formation Rates of Population III Stars and Chemical Enrichment of Halos during the Reionization Era
• Galaxy UV-luminosity function and reionization constraints on axion dark matter
• On using visibility correlations to probe the HI distribution from the dark ages to the present epoch I: Formalism and the expected signal
• Was the Universe Reionized by Massive Population-III Stars?
• A Measurement of Small Scale Structure in the 2.2 < z < 4.2 Lyman-alpha Forest
• Reionization and high-redshift galaxies: the view from quasar absorption lines
• Imprint of Inhomogeneous Hydrogen Reionization on the Temperature Distribution of the Intergalactic Medium
• Nucleosynthesis, Reionization, and the Mass Function of the First Stars
• Improved measurements of the intergalactic medium temperature around quasars: possible evidence for the initial stages of He-II reionisation at z~6
• Experimental Constraints on Self-consistent Reionization Models
• Do We Need Stars to Reionize the Universe at High Redshifts? Early Reionization by Decaying Heavy Sterile Neutrinos
• The Epoch of Reionization
• Constraints on X-ray Emissions from the Reionization Era
• Ionizing radiation fluctuations and large-scale structure in the Lyman-alpha forest
• The multi-frequency angular power spectrum of the epoch of reionization 21 cm signal
• The influence of non-uniform reionization on the CMB
• The photoheating of the intergalactic medium in synthesis models of the UV background
• The thermal history of the intergalactic medium down to redshift z=1.5: a new curvature measurement
• On the Use of Ly-alpha Emitters as Probes of Reionization
• Large Opacity Variations in the High-Redshift Lyman-alpha Forest: the Signature of Relic Temperature Fluctuations from Patchy Reionization
• A Luminous Lyman-alpha Emitting Galaxy at Redshift z=6.535: Discovery and Spectroscopic Confirmation
• The Sources of Intergalactic Metals
• The Number of Supernovae from Primordial Stars in the Universe
• A consistent determination of the temperature of the intergalactic medium at redshift z=2.4
• Models of the Thermal Evolution of the Intergalactic Medium After Reionization
• Cutoff in the Lyman-$\alpha$ forest power spectrum: warm IGM or warm dark matter?
• How Very Massive Metal Free Stars Start Cosmological Reionization
• How to constrain warm dark matter with the Lyman $\alpha$ forest
• Cosmological parameters sigma_8, the baryon density, and the UV background intensity from a calibrated measurement of H I Lyman-alpha absorption at z = 1.9
• Is Double Reionization Physically Plausible?
• Correlated Primordial Perturbations in Light of CMB and LSS Data
• IGM Constraints from the SDSS-III/BOSS DR9 Ly-alpha Forest Flux Probability Distribution Function
• The intergalactic medium thermal history at redshift z=1.7--3.2 from the Lyman alpha forest: a comparison of measurements using wavelets and the flux distribution
• Constraining the Topology of Reionization Through Lyman-alpha Absorption
• A first direct measurement of the intergalactic medium temperature around a quasar at z=6
• Constraining Reionization with the Evolution of the Luminosity Function of Lyman Alpha mitting Galaxies
• The Epoch of Reionization in Models with Reduced Small Scale Power
• Probing non-Gaussian features in the HI distribution at the epoch of reionization
• The Lyman-alpha forest in a blazar-heated Universe
• The Lyman-$\alpha$ forest as a diagnostic of the nature of the dark matter
• Cosmic Star Formation, Reionization, and Constraints on Global Chemical Evolution
• Looking at cosmic near-infrared background radiation anisotropies
• The Cosmic Near Infrared Background: Remnant Light from Early Stars
• Precision era of the kinetic Sunyaev-Zeldovich effect: simulations, analytical models and observations and the power to constrain reionization
• Cosmological HII Bubble Growth During Reionization
• Probing the Dark Ages with the Square Kilometer Array
• Pressure Support vs. Thermal Broadening in the Lyman-alpha Forest I: Effects of the Equation of State on Longitudinal Structure
• Large-Scale Simulations of Reionization
• Possible Detection of Cosmological Reionization Sources
• The Equation of State of the Intergalactic Medium After Hydrogen Reionization
• Photo-heating and the fate of hard photons during the reionisation of HeII by quasars
• Plasma effects on fast pair beams II. Reactive versus kinetic instability of parallel electrostatic wave
• Inferring the IGM thermal history during reionisation with the Lyman-$\alpha$ forest power spectrum at redshift $z\simeq 5$
• A New Method to Directly Measure the Jeans Scale of the Intergalactic Medium Using Close Quasar Pairs
• Radio Afterglows of Gamma-Ray Bursts and Hypernovae at High Redshift, and their Potential for 21-cm Absorption Studies
• The Signatures of Large-scale Temperature and Intensity Fluctuations in the Lyman-alpha Forest
• Measurement of the small-scale structure of the intergalactic medium using close quasar pairs
• Cosmic Reionization After Planck and Before JWST: An Analytic Approach
• Probing Cosmic Reionization and Molecular Gas Growth with TIME
• The ionizing background at the end of overlap
• Tightening Constraints from the Lyman Alpha Forest with the Flux Probability Distribution Function
• Inhomogeneous Reionization Models in Cosmological Hydrodynamical Simulations
• Inhomogeneous Helium Reionization and the Equation of State of the Intergalactic Medium
• Constraining Reionization with the $z\sim 5-6$ Lyman-$\alpha$ Forest Power Spectrum: the Outlook after Planck
• Imprints of temperature fluctuations on the $z\sim 5$ Lyman-$\alpha$ forest: a view from radiation-hydrodynamic simulations of reionization
• Constraining reionization using 21 cm observations in combination with CMB and Lyman-alpha forest data
• A new Measurement of the Intergalactic Temperature at $z\sim 2.55-2.95$
• Quasar H II Regions During Cosmic Reionization
• Combining WMAP and SDSS Quasar Data on Reionization Constrains Cosmological Parameters and the Star Formation Efficiency
• Sample variance and Lyman-alpha forest transmission statistics
• Cosmological perturbations and the reionization epoch
• Constraints on First-Light Ionizing Sources from Optical Depth of the Cosmic Microwave Background
• Exploring the Thermal State of the Low-Density Intergalactic Medium at z=3 with an Ultra-High Signal-to-Noise QSO Spectrum
• On Modeling and Measuring the Temperature of the z~5 IGM
• 21 cm Tomography of the High-Redshift Universe with the Square Kilometer Array
• The Ionizing Efficiency of the First Stars
• Determining the Nature of Late Gunn-Peterson Troughs with Galaxy Surveys
• Formation of Massive Population III Galaxies through Photoionization Feedback: A Possible Explanation for CR7
• Observational constraints on key-parameters of cosmic reionisation history
• Inhomogeneous HeII reionization in Hydrodynamic Simulations
• Probing the Epoch of Reionization with the Lyman Alpha Forest at z~4-5
• Constraining the primordial magnetic field with dwarf galaxy simulations
• Thermal constraints on the reionisation of hydrogen by population-II stellar sources
• Adaptive Mesh Refinement Simulations of the Ionization Structure and Kinematics of Damped Ly$\alpha$ Systems with Self-consistent Radiative Transfer
• Partially ionizing the universe by decaying particles
• Measuring the reionization optical depth without large-scale CMB polarization
• Patchy He II reionization and the physical state of the IGM
• What will anisotropies in the clustering pattern in redshifted 21 cm maps tell us?
• Was the Universe Reionized at Redshift 10?
• The Impact of Temperature Fluctuations on the Lyman-alpha Forest Power Spectrum
• Small-scale structure and the Lyman-$\alpha$ forest baryon acoustic oscillation feature
• Approximate Analytic Spectra of Reionized CMB Anisotropies and Polarization generated by Relic Gravitational Waves
• Simulations of BAO reconstruction with a quasar Lyman-alpha survey
• The effects of primordial non-Gaussianity on the cosmological reionization
• A self-consistent 3D model of fluctuations in the helium-ionizing background
• The evolution of the Lyman-alpha forest effective optical depth following HeII reionisation
• The Effects of X-Ray Feedback from AGN on Host Galaxy Evolution
• A Linear Perturbation Theory of Inhomogeneous Reionization
• Probing the thermal history during reionization using a semi-numerical photon-conserving code SCRIPT
• The effect of inhomogeneous reionisation on the Lyman-$\alpha$ forest power spectrum at redshift $z>4$: implications for thermal parameter recovery
• Impact of inhomogeneous reionization on the Lyman-α forest
• The Thermal Proximity Effect: A New Probe of He II Reionization History and the Quasar Lifetime
• Low-mass galaxy formation and the ionizing photon budget during reionization
• The Contribution of the Intergalactic Medium to Cosmic Microwave Background Anisotropies
• Scaling defect decay and the reionization history of the Universe
• The 21-cm forest as a simultaneous probe of dark matter and cosmic heating history
• Limits on non-canonical heating and turbulence in the intergalactic medium from the low redshift Lyman-alpha forest
• The Formation and Evolution of the First Massive Black Holes
• Beyond Lyman-alpha: Constraints and Consistency Tests from the Lyman-beta Forest
• Chemical constraints on the contribution of Population III stars to cosmic reionization
• Imprint of Inhomogeneous Reionization on the Power Spectrum of Galaxy Surveys at High Redshifts
• Constraining the reionization and thermal history of the Universe using a semi-numerical photon-conserving code SCRIPT
• Heating and Ionization of the Primordial Intergalactic Medium by High Mass X-ray Binaries
• Observational Evidence for Large-Scale Gas Heating in a Galaxy Protocluster at z=2.30
• AGN Outflows in a Cosmological Context
• Constraining the epoch of reionization from the observed properties of the high-z Universe
• Cosmic Reionization History and Dark Matter Scenarios
• Early reionization by decaying particles and cosmic microwave background radiation
• The Effects of the Ionizing Radiation Background on Galaxy Evolution
• Possible evidence for a large-scale enhancement in the Lyman-$\alpha$ forest power spectrum at redshift $\text{z}\ge 4$
• A measurement of the Lyman-beta forest power spectrum and its cross with the Lyman-alpha forest in X-Shooter XQ-100
• Joint Bayesian Estimation of Quasar Continua and the Lyman-Alpha Forest Flux Probability Distribution Function
• SCORCH. III. Analytical Models of Reionization with Varying Clumping Factors
• High-Redshift Galaxy Surveys and the Reionization of the Universe
• Implications of the Lyman alpha Emission Line from a Candidate z=10 Galaxy
• Hunting Primordial Black Hole Dark Matter in Lyman-$\alpha$ Forest
• Improving IGM temperature constraints using wavelet analysis on high-redshift quasars
• Early reionization by decaying particles in the light of three year WMAP data
• The Lyman-beta forest as a cosmic thermometer
• Measuring the thermal and ionization state of the low-$z$ IGM using likelihood free inference
• Modeling the Intergalactic Medium during the Epoch of Reionization
• Statistical features of 21-cm emission from the epoch between reionization and Gunn-Peterson transparency
• Lensing and the Warm Hot Intergalactic Medium
• Cosmic reionization in a dynamic quintessence cosmology
• Dark-Ages Reionisation & Galaxy Formation Simulation XVI: The Thermal Memory of Reionisation
• Cosmic reionization constraints on the nature of cosmological perturbations
• A very extended reionization epoch ?
• Effect of Separate Initial Conditions on the Lyman-$\alpha$ Forest in Simulations
• An Improved Treatment of Cosmological Intergalactic Medium Evolution
• Efficient Photo-heating Algorithms in Time-dependent Photo-ionization Simulations
• Constraining the Temperature-Density Relation of the Inter-Galactic Medium from Analytically Modeling Lyman-alpha Forest Absorbers
• Simulating the epoch of Helium Reionization in photon-conserving semi-numerical code SCRIPT
• The Statistics of Cosmological Lyman-alpha Absorption
• Detecting the Transition From Pop III to Pop II Stars
• The Reionization History in the Lognormal Model
• Observing high redshift galaxy clusters through lensing of the Ostriker-Vishniac effect