Does the HCN/CO ratio trace the star-forming fraction of gas? II. Variations in CO and HCN Emissivity

Abstract

We model emissivities of the HCN and CO $J=1-0$ transitions using measured properties of clouds found in normal star forming galaxies and more extreme systems. These models are compared with observations of HCN and CO $J=1-0$ transitions. We combine these model emissivities with predictions of gravoturbulent models of star formation, explore the impact of excitation and optical depth on CO and HCN emission, and assess if observed HCN/CO ratios track the fraction of gravitationally-bound dense gas, $f_{\mathrm{grav}}$, in molecular clouds. Our modeled HCN/CO ratios and emissivities are consistent with measurements from observations. CO emission shows a range of optical depths across different environments, from optically thick in normal galaxies to moderately optically thin in extreme systems. HCN is only moderately optically thick, with significant subthermal excitation in both normal and extreme galaxies. We find an anticorrelation between HCN/CO and $f_{\mathrm{grav}}$ as predicted by gravoturbulent models of star formation. Instead this ratio tracks gas at moderate densities ($n>10^{3.5}{\mathrm{cm}}^{-3}$), which is below the standard dense gas threshold of $n>10^{4.5}{\mathrm{cm}}^{-3}$. Variations in CO emissivity depend strongly on optical depth, due to variations in the dynamics of the cloud gas. HCN emissivity depends more strongly on excitation, and thus does not directly track variations in CO emissivity. We conclude that a single line ratio, such as HCN/CO, will not consistently track the fraction of gravitationally-bound, star-forming gas if the critical density for star formation varies in molecular clouds. This work highlights important uncertainties that need to be considered when observationally applying an HCN conversion factor in order to estimate the dense (i.e. $n>10^{4.5}{\mathrm{cm}}^{-3}$) gas content in nearby galaxies.

Accepted for publication in A&A

References in corpus (68)

• Array Programming with NumPy
• The Astropy Project: Sustaining and Growing a Community-oriented Open-source Project and the Latest Major Release (v5.0) of the Core Package
• MAMBO Mapping of Spitzer c2d Small Clouds and Cores
• The Density Probability Distribution in Compressible Isothermal Turbulence: Solenoidal versus Compressive Forcing
• The Critical Density and the Effective Excitation Density of Commonly Observed Molecular Dense Gas Tracers
• On the Star Formation Efficiency of Turbulent Magnetized Clouds
• Physical properties of molecular clouds for the entire Milky Way disk
• Bias-free Measurement of Giant Molecular Cloud Properties
• Simulating the formation of molecular clouds. I. Slow formation by gravitational collapse from static initial conditions
• Simulating the formation of molecular clouds. II. Rapid formation from turbulent initial conditions
• Equilibrium Star Cluster Formation
• The anatomy of the Orion B Giant Molecular Cloud: A local template for studies of nearby galaxies
• The link between turbulence, magnetic fields, filaments, and star formation in the Central Molecular Zone cloud G0.253+0.016
• Starbursts triggered by inter-galactic tides and interstellar compressive turbulence
• Evidence of enhanced star formation efficiency in luminous and ultraluminous infrared galaxies
• PHANGS CO kinematics: disk orientations and rotation curves at 150 pc resolution
• Giant Molecular Cloud Catalogues for PHANGS-ALMA: Methods and Initial Results
• Cloud Scale ISM Structure and Star Formation in M51
• Dynamical Equilibrium in the Molecular ISM in 28 Nearby Star-Forming Galaxies
• Unfolding the Laws of Star Formation: The Density Distribution of Molecular Clouds
• High-resolution simulations of galaxy mergers: Resolving globular cluster formation
• Vibrationally Excited HCN in the Luminous Infrared Galaxy NGC 4418
• Molecular Line Emission as a Tool for Galaxy Observations (LEGO). I. HCN as a tracer of moderate gas densities in molecular clouds and galaxies
• The density structure and star formation rate of non-isothermal polytropic turbulence
• Turbulence sets the initial conditions for star formation in high-pressure environments
• Lambda = 3 mm line survey of nearby active galaxies
• Millimeter-Wave Line Ratios and Sub-beam Volume Density Distributions
• The environmental dependence of the X_CO conversion factor
• Giant Molecular Clouds in the Early-Type Galaxy NGC4526
• Dense gas is not enough: environmental variations in the star formation efficiency of dense molecular gas at 100pc scales in M51
• Optical Depth Estimates and Effective Critical Densities of Dense Gas Tracers in the Inner Parts of Nearby Galaxy Discs
• The Razor's Edge of Collapse: The Transition Point from Lognormal to Powerlaw in Molecular Cloud PDFs
• Core Mass Function: The Role of Gravity
• Understanding star formation in molecular clouds IV. Column density PDFs from quiescent to massive molecular clouds
• Star formation in a high-pressure environment: An SMA view of the Galactic centre dust ridge
• Spectral Line Survey toward Spiral Arm of M51 in the 3 mm and 2 mm Bands
• LEGO II: A 3 mm molecular line study covering 100 pc of one of the most actively star-forming portions within the Milky Way Disc
• Characterizing the line emission from molecular clouds. Stratified random sampling of the Perseus cloud
• Dependence of $X_{\mathrm{CO}}$ on metallicity, intensity, and spatial scale in a self-regulated interstellar medium
• Dense molecular gas properties on 100 pc scales across the disc of NGC 3627
• Thermal and turbulent properties of the Warm Neutral Medium in the solar neighborhood
• The ALMOND Survey: Molecular cloud properties and gas density tracers across 25 nearby spiral galaxies with ALMA
• On the compressive nature of turbulence driven by ionising feedback in the pillars of the Carina Nebula
• A multi-shock model for the density variance of anisotropic, highly-magnetised, supersonic turbulence
• A molecular line survey toward the nearby galaxies NGC 1068, NGC 253, and IC 342 at 3 mm with the Nobeyama 45 m radio telescope: The data
• Relationship between turbulence energy and density variance in the Solar neighbourhood molecular clouds
• Kiloparsec-scale Variations in the Star Formation Efficiency of Dense Gas: the Antennae Galaxies (NGC 4038/39)
• Molecular transitions as probes of the physical conditions of extragalactic environments
• A 2-3 mm high-resolution molecular line survey towards the centre of the nearby spiral galaxy NGC 6946
• Characterizing the line emission from molecular clouds. II. A comparative study of California, Perseus, and Orion A
• Cosmic rays across the star-forming galaxy sequence. II: Stability limits and the onset of cosmic ray-driven outflows
• Density-PDFs and Lagrangian Statistics of highly compressible Turbulence
• Transition from Coherent Cores to Surrounding Cloud in L1688
• A Complete HCN Survey of the Perseus Molecular Cloud
• Highly turbulent gas on GMC-scales in NGC 3256, the nearest luminous infrared galaxy
• Multicomponent kinematics in a massive filamentary IRDC
• The cosmic ray ionisation and $\gamma$-ray budgets of star-forming galaxies
• A new method for spatially resolving the turbulence driving mixture in the ISM with application to the Small Magellanic Cloud
• HCN emission from translucent gas and UV-illuminated cloud edges revealed by wide-field IRAM 30m maps of Orion B GMC: Revisiting its role as tracer of the dense gas reservoir for star formation
• A constant N${}_2$H${}^{+}$(1-0)-to-HCN(1-0) ratio on kiloparsec scales
• Resolution-dependent Subsonic Non-thermal Line Dispersion Revealed by ALMA
• TIMES I: a Systematic Observation in Multiple Molecular Lines Toward the Orion A and Ophiuchus Clouds
• Non-Equilibrium Abundances Treated Holistically (NEATH): the molecular composition of star-forming clouds
• The density gradient inside molecular-gas clumps as a booster of their star formation activity
• Extreme giant molecular clouds in the luminous infrared galaxy NGC 3256
• A nearly constant CN/HCN line ratio in nearby galaxies: CN as a new tracer of dense gas
• Sub-kiloparsec empirical relations and excitation conditions of HCN and HCO+ J=3-2 in nearby star-forming galaxies
• Does the HCN/CO ratio trace the star-forming fraction of gas? I. A comparison with analytical models of star formation

Cited by in corpus (2)

• Dense gas scaling relations at kiloparsec scales across nearby galaxies with the ALMA ALMOND and IRAM 30m EMPIRE surveys
• Estimating the dense gas mass of molecular clouds using spatially unresolved 3 mm line observations