Disorder-induced zero-bias peaks in Majorana nanowires

Abstract

Focusing specifically on the recently retracted Nature 2018 Zhang et al. work [Zhang et al., Nature (2021)] and the related recently available correctly analyzed data from this Delft experiment [Zhang et al., arXiv:2101.11456 (2021)], we discuss the general problem of confirmation bias in experiments verifying various theoretical topological quantization predictions. We show that the Delft Majorana experiment is most likely dominated by disorder, which produces trivial (but quite sharp and large) zero-bias Andreev tunneling peaks with large conductance $\sim 2e^2/h$ in the theory, closely mimicking the data. It is possible to misinterpret such disorder-induced zero-bias trivial peaks as the apparent Majorana quantization, as was originally done in 2018 arising from confirmation bias. One characteristic of the disorder-induced trivial peaks is that they manifest little stability as a function of Zeeman field and tunnel barrier, distinguishing their trivial behavior from the expected topological robustness of non-Abelian Majorana zero modes. We also analyze a more recent nanowire experiment [Yu et al., Nature Physics (2021)] which is known to have a huge amount of disorder, showing that such highly disordered nanowires may produce very small above-background trivial peaks with values $\sim 2e^2/h$.

arXiv comment13 pages, 8 figures

References in corpus (64)

• Quantum Spin Hall Insulator State in HgTe Quantum Wells
• Unpaired Majorana fermions in quantum wires
• Signatures of Majorana fermions in hybrid superconductor-semiconductor nanowire devices
• Experimental Observation of the Quantum Anomalous Hall Effect in a Magnetic Topological Insulator
• Majorana Fermions and a Topological Phase Transition in Semiconductor-Superconductor Heterostructures
• Discovery of a Weyl Fermion Semimetal and Topological Fermi Arcs
• Helical liquids and Majorana bound states in quantum wires
• Evidence of Majorana fermions in an Al - InAs nanowire topological superconductor
• Observation of Majorana Fermions in Ferromagnetic Atomic Chains on a Superconductor
• A generic new platform for topological quantum computation using semiconductor heterostructures
• Observation of Majorana Fermions in a Nb-InSb Nanowire-Nb Hybrid Quantum Device
• Observation of a topological 3D Dirac semimetal phase in high-mobility Cd3As2
• Kwant: a software package for quantum transport
• Exponential Protection of Zero Modes in Majorana Islands
• Observation of Weyl nodes in TaAs
• Realizing Majorana zero modes in superconductor-semiconductor heterostructures
• Discovery of a Weyl Fermion semimetal state in NbAs
• Majorana quantization and half-integer thermal quantum Hall effect in a Kitaev spin liquid
• Superconductor-Nanowire Devices from Tunneling to the Multichannel Regime: Zero-Bias Oscillations and Magnetoconductance Crossover
• Anomalous modulation of a zero bias peak in a hybrid nanowire-superconductor device
• Quantized Majorana conductance
• Non-Abelian quantum order in spin-orbit-coupled semiconductors: The search for topological Majorana particles in solid state systems
• Tunable Supercurrent Through Semiconductor Nanowires
• Chiral Majorana edge state in a quantum anomalous Hall insulator-superconductor structure
• Zero-bias peaks in spin-orbit coupled superconducting wires with and without Majorana end-states
• Hard gap in epitaxial semiconductor-superconductor nanowires
• Near-zero-energy end states in topologically trivial spin-orbit coupled superconducting nanowires with a smooth confinement
• Transport spectroscopy of NS nanowire junctions with Majorana fermions
• End states and subgap structure in proximity-coupled chains of magnetic adatoms
• Zero-voltage conductance peak from weak antilocalization in a Majorana nanowire
• Class D spectral peak in Majorana quantum wires
• Measurement of filling factor 5/2 quasiparticle interference: observation of charge e/4 and e/2 period oscillations
• Reproducing topological properties with quasi-Majorana states
• Physical mechanisms for zero-bias conductance peaks in Majorana nanowires
• Majorana bound states in non-homogeneous semiconductor nanowires
• Two terminal charge tunneling: Disentangling Majorana zero modes from partially separated Andreev bound states in semiconductor-superconductor heterostructures
• Majorana Fermions in superconducting 1D systems having periodic, quasiperiodic, and disordered potentials
• Quantized zero bias conductance plateau in semiconductor-superconductor heterostructures without non-Abelian Majorana zero modes
• Probability distribution of Majorana end-state energies in disordered wires
• Topological superconducting phases in disordered quantum wires with strong spin-orbit coupling
• Non-Majorana states yield nearly quantized conductance in superconductor-semiconductor nanowire devices
• Are the double Fermi arcs of Dirac semimetals topologically protected?
• Zero-energy Andreev bound states from quantum dots in proximitized Rashba nanowires
• Non-Majorana Origin of the Half-Quantized Conductance Plateau in Quantum Anomalous Hall Insulator and Superconductor Hybrid Structures
• Interplay of disorder and interaction in Majorana quantum wires
• Soft Superconducting Gap in Semiconductor Majorana Nanowires
• Experimental and materials considerations for the topological superconducting state in electron and hole doped semiconductors: searching for non-Abelian Majorana modes in 1D nanowires and 2D heterostructures
• Decaying spectral oscillations in a Majorana wire with finite coherence length
• Distinguishing topological Majorana bound states from trivial Andreev bound states: Proposed tests through differential tunneling conductance spectroscopy
• Effects of electron scattering on the topological properties of nanowires: Majorana fermions from disorder and superlattices
• Density of states of disordered topological superconductor-semiconductor hybrid nanowires
• Role of dissipation in realistic Majorana nanowires
• Generic quantized zero-bias conductance peaks in superconductor-semiconductor hybrid structures
• Spin-polarized Yu-Shiba-Rusinov states in an iron based superconductor
• Effects of large induced superconducting gap on semiconductor Majorana nanowires
• Quantized and unquantized zero-bias tunneling conductance peaks in Majorana nanowires: Conductance below and above $2e^2/h$
• Disorder driven itinerant quantum criticality of three dimensional massless Dirac fermions
• Conductance of a superconducting Coulomb blockaded Majorana nanowire
• Presence versus absence of end-to-end nonlocal conductance correlations in Majorana nanowires: Majorana bound states versus Andreev bound states
• Bulk disorder in the superconductor affects proximity-induced topological superconductivity
• Bound states of a ferromagnetic wire in a superconductor
• Enhanced topological protection in planar quasi-one-dimensional channels with periodically-modulated width
• Theory of Coulomb blockaded transport in realistic Majorana nanowires
• Curvature of gap closing features and the extraction of Majorana nanowire parameters

Cited by in corpus (104)

• Controlled length-dependent interaction of Majorana modes in Yu-Shiba-Rusinov chains
• Majorana nanowires for topological quantum computation
• Estimating disorder and its adverse effects in semiconductor Majorana nanowires
• Superconducting phenomena in systems with unconventional magnets
• In search of Majorana
• Plateau regions for zero-bias peaks within 5% of the quantized conductance value $2e^2/h$
• Large zero bias peaks and dips in a four-terminal thin InAs-Al nanowire device
• Selective area epitaxy of PbTe-Pb hybrid nanowires on a lattice-matched substrate
• Numerical study of PbTe-Pb hybrid nanowires for engineering Majorana zero modes
• In Situ Epitaxy of Pure Phase Ultra-Thin InAs-Al Nanowires for Quantum Devices
• Partially-separated Majorana modes in a disordered medium
• Spectral properties, topological patches, and effective phase diagrams of finite disordered Majorana nanowires
• Enhanced topological superconductivity in spatially modulated planar Josephson junctions
• Observation of edge and bulk states in a three-site Kitaev chain
• Majorana/Andreev crossover and the fate of the topological phase transition in inhomogeneous nanowires
• Recent progress on Majorana in semiconductor-superconductor heterostructures--Engineering and detection
• Crossover between trivial zero modes in Majorana nanowires
• Gate-Defined Topological Josephson Junctions in Bernal Bilayer Graphene
• Planar Josephson junctions in germanium: Effect of cubic spin-orbit interaction
• Identifying Majorana bound states by tunneling shot-noise tomography
• Single-shot fabrication of semiconducting-superconducting nanowire devices
• Conductance Quantization in PbTe Nanowires
• On-demand large-conductance in trivial zero-bias tunneling peaks in Majorana nanowires
• Parametric exploration of zero-energy modes in three-terminal InSb-Al nanowire devices
• Ballistic PbTe Nanowire Devices
• Detecting Majorana Zero Modes via Strong Field Dynamics
• Observation of Aharonov-Bohm effect in PbTe nanowire networks
• Proximity effect in PbTe-Pb hybrid nanowire Josephson junctions
• Progress in superconductor-semiconductor topological Josephson junctions
• Braiding higher-order Majorana corner states through their spin degree of freedom
• Joule spectroscopy of hybrid superconductor-semiconductor nanodevices
• Suppressing Andreev bound state zero bias peaks using a strongly dissipative lead
• Identifying trivial and Majorana zero-energy modes using the Majorana polarization
• Universal conductance scaling of Andreev reflections using a dissipative probe
• From perfect to imperfect poor man's Majoranas in minimal Kitaev chains
• Mitigating disorder-induced zero-energy states in weakly-coupled semiconductor-superconductor hybrid systems
• Density of states, transport, and topology in disordered Majorana nanowires
• Majorana zero modes in gate-defined germanium hole nanowires
• Majorana zero modes induced by superconducting phase bias
• Majorana bound states in germanium Josephson junctions via phase control
• Dirac-Fermion-Assisted Interfacial Superconductivity in Epitaxial Topological Insulator/Iron Chalcogenide Heterostructures
• Quality factor for zero-bias conductance peaks in Majorana nanowire
• Non-Hermitian zero-energy pinning of Andreev and Majorana bound states in superconductor-semiconductor systems
• Robust topological superconductivity in weakly coupled nanowire-superconductor hybrid structures
• Entanglement measures of Majorana bound states
• Majorana bound states in encapsulated bilayer graphene
• Topological isoconductance signatures in Majorana nanowires
• Fate of poor man's Majoranas in the long Kitaev chain limit
• Machine learning optimization of Majorana hybrid nanowires
• Out of Equilibrium Majoranas in Interacting Kitaev Chains
• Hard superconducting gap in PbTe nanowires
• Evidence for $\pi$-shifted Cooper quartets and few-mode transport in PbTe nanowire three-terminal Josephson junctions
• Differential current noise as an identifier of Andreev bound states that induce nearly quantized conductance plateaus
• Effect of impurities and disorder on the braiding dynamics of Majorana zero modes
• Large Andreev bound state zero bias peaks in a weakly dissipative environment
• Machine-learned tuning of artificial Kitaev chains from tunneling-spectroscopy measurements
• Disordered Majorana nanowires: Studying disorder without any disorder
• Machine Learning the Disorder Landscape of Majorana Nanowires
• Josephson effect and critical currents in trivial and topological full-shell hybrid nanowires
• Random matrix theory for the robustness, quantization, and end-to-end correlation of zero-bias conductance peaks in a class D ensemble
• Role of Bath-Induced Many-Body Interactions in the Dissipative Phases of the Su-Schrieffer-Heeger Model
• Topological Quantum Gates in Homotopy Type Theory
• Germanium-based hybrid semiconductor-superconductor topological quantum computing platforms: Disorder effects
• Absence of Majorana oscillations in finite-length full-shell hybrid nanowires
• Gate-tunable subband degeneracy in semiconductor nanowires
• Majorana excitons in a Kitaev chain of semiconductor quantum dots in a nanowire
• Microwave Signatures of Topological Superconductivity in Planar Josephson Junctions
• Disorder effects on the so-called Andreev band in Majorana nanowires
• Nonequilibrium Fractional Josephson Effect
• Odd-frequency pairing due to Majorana and trivial Andreev bound states
• Vision transformer based Deep Learning of Topological indicators in Majorana Nanowires
• Majorana-magnon interactions in topological Shiba chains
• Electric field-induced edge state oscillations in GaSb/InAs quantum wells
• Beyond the standard model of topological Josephson junctions: From crystalline anisotropy to finite-size and diode effects
• Reducing disorder in PbTe nanowires for Majorana research
• Topological gap protocol based machine learning optimization of Majorana hybrid wires
• Disorder effects in planar semiconductor-superconductor structures: Majorana wires versus Josephson junctions
• Anomalous proximity effect under Andreev and Majorana bound states
• Quantized Andreev conductance in semiconductor nanowires
• Challenges in detecting topological superconducting transitions via supercurrent and phase probes in planar Josephson junctions
• Honing in on a topological zero-bias conductance peak
• Anisotropy of PbTe nanowires with and without a superconductor
• Spin Signature of Majorana Fermions in Topological Nodal-Point Superconductors
• Mirror-protected Majorana zero modes in $f$-wave multilayer graphene superconductors
• Quantum spin Hall insulator in proximity with a superconductor: Transition to the Fulde-Ferrell-Larkin-Ovchinnikov state driven by a Zeeman field
• Multiple Majorana bound states and their resilience against disorder in planar Josephson junctions
• Majorana zero modes in semiconductor-superconductor hybrid structures: Defining topology in short and disordered nanowires through Majorana splitting
• Majorana polarization in disordered heterostructures
• Enhanced superconductivity in PbTe-In hybrids
• Spectrum of localized states in fermionic chains with defect and adiabatic charge pumping
• Properties and prevalence of false poor man's Majoranas in two- and three-site artificial Kitaev chains
• Gate tunable enhancement of supercurrent in hybrid planar Josephson junctions
• Mitigating disorder and optimizing topological indicators with vision-transformer-based neural networks in Majorana nanowires
• Excess photon-assisted noise of Majorana and Andreev bound states
• Absence of Quasi-Majorana False Positives in Full-Shell Hybrid Nanowires
• Proximity-induced superconductivity generated by thin films: Effects of Fermi surface mismatch and disorder in the superconductor
• Gate-tunable superconductor-semiconductor coupling and its impact on zero-energy modes in PbTe-Pb nanowires
• Signatures of Majorana bound states in scanning gate microscopy of hybrid nanowires
• Few-Mode and Anisotropic Quantum Transport in InSb Nanoribbons Using an All-van der Waals Material-Based Gate
• Probing the Design Space of InSb Topological Superconductor Nanowires for the Realization of Majorana Zero Modes
• Rashba spin-orbit coupling and artificially engineered topological superconductors
• Ballistic transport in 1D Rashba systems in the context of Majorana nanowires
• Majorana modes in graphene strips: polarization, wavefunctions, disorder, and Andreev states
• Presence versus absence of charging energies in PbTe quantum dots