Searches after Gravitational Waves Using ARizona Observatories (SAGUARO): Observations and Analysis from Advanced LIGO/Virgo's Third Observing Run

Abstract

With the conclusion of the third observing run for Advanced LIGO/Virgo (O3), we present a detailed analysis of both triggered and serendipitous observations of 17 gravitational wave (GW) events (7 triggered and 10 purely serendipitous) from the Searches After Gravitational-waves Using ARizona Observatories (SAGUARO) program. We searched a total of 4935 deg${}^2$ down to a median 5$\sigma$ transient detection depth of 21.1 AB mag using the Mt Lemmon 1.5 m telescope, the discovery engine for SAGUARO. In addition to triggered events within 24~hours, our transient search encompassed a time interval following GW events of $<120$~hrs, providing observations on $\sim$ 1/2 of the events accessible to the Mt Lemmon 1.5 m telescope. We covered 2.1--86\% of the LVC total probability ($P_{\mathrm{total}}$) for individual events, with a median $P_{\mathrm{total}}\approx 8\%$ within $<120$~hours. Following improvements to our pipeline and the addition of serendipitous observations, we find a total of 7 new optical candidates across 5 GW events which we are unable to rule out after searching for additional information and comparing to kilonova models. Using both publicly available and our own late-time data, we investigated a total of 252 optical candidates for these 17 events, finding only 65\% were followed up in some capacity by the community. Of the total 252 candidates, we are able to rule out an additional 12 previously reported counterpart candidates. In light of these results, we discuss lessons learned from the SAGUARO GW counterpart search. We discuss how community coordination of observations and candidate follow-up, as well as the role of archival data, are crucial to improving the efficiency of follow-up efforts and preventing unnecessary duplication of effort with limited EM resources.

arXiv comment44 pages, 21 figures, 2 tables, submitted to ApJ

References in corpus (100)

• Astropy: A Community Python Package for Astronomy
• GW170817: Observation of Gravitational Waves from a Binary Neutron Star Inspiral
• Gaia Data Release 2. Summary of the contents and survey properties
• The Astropy Project: Building an inclusive, open-science project and status of the v2.0 core package
• The Gaia mission
• Advanced Virgo: a 2nd generation interferometric gravitational wave detector
• Multi-messenger Observations of a Binary Neutron Star Merger
• GWTC-1: A Gravitational-Wave Transient Catalog of Compact Binary Mergers Observed by LIGO and Virgo during the First and Second Observing Runs
• The Eleventh and Twelfth Data Releases of the Sloan Digital Sky Survey: Final Data from SDSS-III
• The Swift Ultra-Violet/Optical Telescope
• Overview of the DESI Legacy Imaging Surveys
• GW190814: Gravitational Waves from the Coalescence of a 23 M${}_{\odot }$ Black Hole with a 2.6 M${}_{\odot }$ Compact Object
• GW190425: Observation of a Compact Binary Coalescence with Total Mass $\sim 3.4M_{\odot }$
• GW190521: A Binary Black Hole Merger with a Total Mass of $150M_{\odot }$
• The Zwicky Transient Facility: Data Processing, Products, and Archive
• ATLAS: A High-Cadence All-Sky Survey System
• LIGO: The Laser Interferometer Gravitational-Wave Observatory
• Origin of the heavy elements in binary neutron-star mergers from a gravitational wave event
• Swope Supernova Survey 2017a (SSS17a), the Optical Counterpart to a Gravitational Wave Source
• The Electromagnetic Counterpart of the Binary Neutron Star Merger LIGO/VIRGO GW170817. II. UV, Optical, and Near-IR Light Curves and Comparison to Kilonova Models
• Spectroscopic identification of r-process nucleosynthesis in a double neutron star merger
• A kilonova as the electromagnetic counterpart to a gravitational-wave source
• The Zwicky Transient Facility: Science Objectives
• Light Curves of the Neutron Star Merger GW170817/SSS17a: Implications for R-Process Nucleosynthesis
• Illuminating Gravitational Waves: A Concordant Picture of Photons from a Neutron Star Merger
• The Emergence of a Lanthanide-Rich Kilonova Following the Merger of Two Neutron Stars
• Properties and astrophysical implications of the 150 Msun binary black hole merger GW190521
• Optical emission from a kilonova following a gravitational-wave-detected neutron-star merger
• The Electromagnetic Counterpart of the Binary Neutron Star Merger LIGO/Virgo GW170817. I. Dark Energy Camera Discovery of the Optical Counterpart
• The Combined Ultraviolet, Optical, and Near-Infrared Light Curves of the Kilonova Associated with the Binary Neutron Star Merger GW170817: Unified Data Set, Analytic Models, and Physical Implications
• The Electromagnetic Counterpart of the Binary Neutron Star Merger LIGO/VIRGO GW170817. IV. Detection of Near-infrared Signatures of r-process Nucleosynthesis with Gemini-South
• A Radio Counterpart to a Neutron Star Merger
• Assisted Inspirals of Stellar Mass Black Holes Embedded in AGN Disks: Solving the "Final AU Problem"
• The Electromagnetic Counterpart of the Binary Neutron Star Merger LIGO/VIRGO GW170817. III. Optical and UV Spectra of a Blue Kilonova From Fast Polar Ejecta
• Neutrino-driven winds from neutron star merger remnants
• The discovery of the electromagnetic counterpart of GW170817: kilonova AT 2017gfo/DLT17ck
• Method for detection and reconstruction of gravitational wave transients with networks of advanced detectors
• Kilonovae
• The 1% Concordance Hubble Constant
• Red or blue? A potential kilonova imprint of the delay until black hole formation following a neutron star merger
• Candidate Electromagnetic Counterpart to the Binary Black Hole Merger Gravitational Wave Event S190521g
• The Electromagnetic Counterpart of the Binary Neutron Star Merger LIGO/VIRGO GW170817. V. Rising X-ray Emission from an Off-Axis Jet
• Compact radio emission indicates a structured jet was produced by a binary neutron star merger
• A mildly relativistic wide-angle outflow in the neutron star merger GW170817
• The Binary Neutron Star event LIGO/VIRGO GW170817 a hundred and sixty days after merger: synchrotron emission across the electromagnetic spectrum
• Early Spectra of the Gravitational Wave Source GW170817: Evolution of a Neutron Star Merger
• Kilonova Light Curves from the Disk Wind Outflows of Compact Object Mergers
• The Locations of Short Gamma-ray Bursts as Evidence for Compact Object Binary Progenitors
• On stellar-mass black hole mergers in AGN disks detectable with LIGO
• MASTER optical detection of the first LIGO/Virgo neutron stars merging GW170817
• Proper image subtraction - optimal transient detection, photometry and hypothesis testing
• 2MASS Photometric Redshift catalog: a comprehensive three-dimensional census of the whole sky
• A Deep Chandra X-ray Study of Neutron Star Coalescence GW170817
• J-GEM observations of an electromagnetic counterpart to the neutron star merger GW170817
• A Decline in the X-ray through Radio Emission from GW170817 Continues to Support an Off-Axis Structured Jet
• GLADE: A Galaxy Catalogue for Multi-Messenger Searches in the Advanced Gravitational-Wave Detector Era
• A year in the life of GW170817: the rise and fall of a structured jet from a binary neutron star merger
• A Precise Distance to the Host Galaxy of the Binary Neutron Star Merger GW170817 Using Surface Brightness Fluctuations
• The Rapid Reddening and Featureless Optical Spectra of the optical counterpart of GW170817, AT 2017gfo, During the First Four Days
• A reanalysis of the Gaia Data Release 2 photometric sensitivity curves using HST/STIS spectrophotometry
• Two years of non-thermal emission from the binary neutron star merger GW170817: rapid fading of the jet afterglow and first constraints on the kilonova fastest ejecta
• Observations of the first electromagnetic counterpart to a gravitational wave source by the TOROS collaboration
• The Multi-Messenger Matrix: the Future of Neutron Star Merger Constraints on the Nuclear Equation of State
• GROWTH on S190425z: Searching thousands of square degrees to identify an optical or infrared counterpart to a binary neutron star merger with the Zwicky Transient Facility and Palomar Gattini IR
• GRB170817A associated with GW170817: multifrequency observations and modeling of prompt gamma-ray emission
• The Electromagnetic Counterpart of the Binary Neutron Star Merger LIGO/VIRGO GW170817. VIII. A Comparison to Cosmological Short-duration Gamma-ray Bursts
• GROWTH on S190814bv: Deep Synoptic Limits on the Optical/Near-Infrared Counterpart to a Neutron Star-Black Hole Merger
• Searching for Electromagnetic Counterparts to Gravitational-wave Merger Events with the Prototype Gravitational-wave Optical Transient Observer (GOTO-4)
• Optical follow-up of the neutron star-black hole mergers S200105ae and S200115j
• Kilonova Luminosity Function Constraints based on Zwicky Transient Facility Searches for 13 Neutron Star Mergers
• Transient processing and analysis using $\text{AMPEL}$: Alert Management, Photometry and Evaluation of Lightcurves
• The Optical Afterglow of GW170817: An Off-axis Structured Jet and Deep Constraints on a Globular Cluster Origin
• GRANDMA Observations of Advanced LIGO's and Advanced Virgo's Third Observational Campaign
• Follow-up of the Neutron Star Bearing Gravitational Wave Candidate Events S190425z and S190426c with MMT and SOAR
• Optical Observations of LIGO Source GW 170817 by the Antarctic Survey Telescopes at Dome A, Antarctica
• The Diversity of Kilonova Emission in Short Gamma-Ray Bursts
• Observational constraints on the optical and near-infrared emission from the neutron star-black hole binary merger S190814bv
• A luminosity distribution for kilonovae based on short gamma-ray burst afterglows
• Machine learning for transient discovery in Pan-STARRS1 difference imaging
• Searches After Gravitational-waves Using ARizona Observatories (SAGUARO): System Overview and First Results from Advanced LIGO/Virgo's Third Observing Run
• A Galaxy-Targeted Search for the Optical Counterpart of the Candidate NS-BH Merger S190814bv with Magellan
• A self-consistent method to estimate the rate of compact binary coalescences with a Poisson mixture model
• Updated Parameter Estimates for GW190425 Using Astrophysical Arguments and Implications for the Electromagnetic Counterpart
• Implications of the search for optical counterparts during the second part of the Advanced LIGO's and Advanced Virgo's third observing run: lessons learned for future follow-up observations
• GROWTH on S190426c. II. Real-Time Search for a Counterpart to the Probable Neutron Star-Black Hole Merger using an Automated Difference Imaging Pipeline for DECam
• A Deep CFHT Optical Search for a Counterpart to the Possible Neutron Star -- Black Hole Merger GW190814
• The Gravitational Wave Treasure Map: A Tool to Coordinate, Visualize, and Assess the Electromagnetic Follow-Up of Gravitational Wave Events
• A search for optical and near-infrared counterparts of the compact binary merger GW190814
• Constraints on the Physical Properties of GW190814 through Simulations based on DECam Follow-up Observations by the Dark Energy Survey
• GROWTH on S190510g: DECam Observation Planning and Follow-Up of a Distant Binary Neutron Star Merger Candidate
• Does GW190425 require an alternative formation pathway than a fast-merging channel?
• Lanthanides or dust in kilonovae: lessons learned from GW170817
• Constraint on the ejecta mass for a black hole-neutron star merger event candidate S190814bv
• J-GEM Follow-Up Observations to Search for an Optical Counterpart of The First Gravitational Wave Source GW150914
• Binary Black Hole Mergers within the LIGO Horizon: Statistical Properties and prospects for detecting Electromagnetic Counterparts
• Limits on electromagnetic counterparts of gravitational wave-detected binary black hole mergers
• An Empirical Study of Contamination in Deep, Rapid, and Wide-Field Optical Follow-Up of Gravitational Wave Events
• Optical follow-up observation for GW event S190510g using Subaru/Hyper Suprime-Cam
• Swift Multiwavelength Follow-up of LVC S200224ca and the Implications for Binary Black Hole Mergers
• Search for high energy $\gamma$-rays from the direction of the candidate electromagnetic counterpart to the binary black hole merger gravitational-wave event S190521g

Cited by in corpus (21)

• GWTC-3: Compact Binary Coalescences Observed by LIGO and Virgo During the Second Part of the Third Observing Run
• GLADE+: An Extended Galaxy Catalogue for Multimessenger Searches with Advanced Gravitational-wave Detectors
• Kilonova Detectability with Wide-Field Instruments
• Continued radio observations of GW170817 3.5 years post-merger
• Probing Kilonova Ejecta Properties Using a Catalog of Short Gamma-Ray Burst Observations
• The Gravity Collective: A Search for the Electromagnetic Counterpart to the Neutron Star-Black Hole Merger GW190814
• An Infrared Search for Kilonovae with the WINTER Telescope. I. Binary Neutron Star Mergers
• Swift/UVOT follow-up of Gravitational Wave Alerts in the O3 era
• A Systematic Exploration of Kilonova Candidates from Neutron Star Mergers During the Third Gravitational Wave Observing Run
• What if GW190425 did not produce a black hole promptly?
• Panning for gold, but finding helium: discovery of the ultra-stripped supernova SN2019wxt from gravitational-wave follow-up observations
• Black-Hole Neutron Star Simulations with the BAM code: First Tests and Simulations
• SAGUARO: Time-domain Infrastructure for the Fourth Gravitational-wave Observing Run and Beyond
• Quasi-periodic oscillation in short gamma-ray bursts from black hole-neutron star mergers
• Mechanisms for high spin in black-hole neutron-star binaries and kilonova emission: inheritance and accretion
• Investigating the detection rates and inference of gravitational-wave and radio emission from black hole neutron star mergers
• Searching for Gravitational-Wave Counterparts using the Transiting Exoplanet Survey Satellite
• 3D Localization of FRB 20190425A for Its Potential Host Galaxy and Implications
• ASAS-SN search for optical counterparts of gravitational-wave events from the third observing run of Advanced LIGO/Virgo
• Host galaxies and electromagnetic counterparts to binary neutron star mergers across the cosmic time: Detectability of GW170817-like events
• Early Warning From Eccentric Compact Binaries: Template Initialization And Sub-dominant Mode Effects