The Electromagnetic Counterpart of the Binary Neutron Star Merger LIGO/VIRGO GW170817. VIII. A Comparison to Cosmological Short-duration Gamma-ray Bursts

Abstract

We present a comprehensive comparison of the properties of the radio through X-ray counterpart of GW170817 and the properties of short-duration gamma-ray bursts (GRBs). For this effort, we utilize a sample of 36 short GRBs spanning a redshift range of $z\approx 0.12-2.6$ discovered over 2004-2017. We find that the counterpart to GW170817 has an isotropic-equivalent luminosity that is $\approx 3000$ times less than the median value of on-axis short GRB X-ray afterglows, and $\gtrsim 10^4$ times less than that for detected short GRB radio afterglows. Moreover, the allowed jet energies and particle densities inferred from the radio and X-ray counterparts to GW170817 and on-axis short GRB afterglows are remarkably similar, suggesting that viewing angle effects are the dominant, and perhaps only, difference in their observed radio and X-ray behavior. From comparison to previous claimed kilonovae following short GRBs, we find that the optical and near-IR counterpart to GW170817 is comparatively under-luminous by a factor of $\approx 3-5$, indicating a range of kilonova luminosities and timescales. A comparison of the optical limits following short GRBs on $\lesssim 1$ day timescales also rules out a "blue" kilonova of comparable optical isotropic-equivalent luminosity in one previous short GRB. Finally, we investigate the host galaxy of GW170817, NGC4993, in the context of short GRB host galaxy stellar population properties. We find that NGC4993 is superlative in terms of its large luminosity, old stellar population age, and low star formation rate compared to previous short GRB hosts. Additional events within the Advanced LIGO/VIRGO volume will be crucial in delineating the properties of the host galaxies of NS-NS mergers, and connecting them to their cosmological counterparts.

arXiv comment11 Pages, 4 Figures, 1 Table. ApJL, In Press. Keywords: GW170817, LVC

References in corpus (62)

• GW170817: Observation of Gravitational Waves from a Binary Neutron Star Inspiral
• The Swift X-ray Telescope
• Stellar mass-to-light ratios and the Tully-Fisher relation
• Methods and results of an automatic analysis of a complete sample of Swift-XRT observations of GRBs
• An Ordinary Short Gamma-Ray Burst with Extraordinary Implications: Fermi-GBM Detection of GRB 170817A
• Gamma-Ray Bursts as the Death Throes of Massive Binary Stars
• Electromagnetic Counterparts of Compact Object Mergers Powered by the Radioactive Decay of R-process Nuclei
• Swope Supernova Survey 2017a (SSS17a), the Optical Counterpart to a Gravitational Wave Source
• The Galaxy Luminosity Function and Luminosity Density at Redshift z=0.1
• Short-Duration Gamma-Ray Bursts
• The Electromagnetic Counterpart of the Binary Neutron Star Merger LIGO/VIRGO GW170817. II. UV, Optical, and Near-IR Light Curves and Comparison to Kilonova Models
• An online repository of Swift/XRT light curves of GRBs
• A "kilonova" associated with short-duration gamma-ray burst 130603B
• A short gamma-ray burst apparently asssociated with an elliptical galaxy at redshift z=0.225
• Effect of a High Opacity on the Light Curves of Radioactively Powered Transients from Compact Object Mergers
• The Electromagnetic Counterpart of the Binary Neutron Star Merger LIGO/Virgo GW170817. I. Dark Energy Camera Discovery of the Optical Counterpart
• Swift and NuSTAR observations of GW170817: detection of a blue kilonova
• The Electromagnetic Counterpart of the Binary Neutron Star Merger LIGO/VIRGO GW170817. IV. Detection of Near-infrared Signatures of r-process Nucleosynthesis with Gemini-South
• The supernova rate per unit mass
• A Decade of Short-duration Gamma-ray Burst Broad-band Afterglows: Energetics, Circumburst Densities, and Jet Opening Angles
• The afterglow of GRB050709 and the nature of the short-hard gamma-ray bursts
• The Electromagnetic Counterpart of the Binary Neutron Star Merger LIGO/VIRGO GW170817. III. Optical and UV Spectra of a Blue Kilonova From Fast Polar Ejecta
• An r-Process Kilonova Associated with the Short-Hard GRB 130603B
• The discovery of the electromagnetic counterpart of GW170817: kilonova AT 2017gfo/DLT17ck
• Kilonovae
• Red or blue? A potential kilonova imprint of the delay until black hole formation following a neutron star merger
• The Electromagnetic Counterpart of the Binary Neutron Star Merger LIGO/VIRGO GW170817. V. Rising X-ray Emission from an Off-Axis Jet
• The DEEP2 Galaxy Redshift Survey: The Galaxy Luminosity Function to z ~ 1
• The gamma-ray burst GRB060614 requires a novel explosive process
• The afterglow and elliptical host galaxy of the short gamma-ray burst GRB 050724
• The Electromagnetic Counterpart of the Binary Neutron Star Merger LIGO/VIRGO GW170817. VI. Radio Constraints on a Relativistic Jet and Predictions for Late-Time Emission from the Kilonova Ejecta
• Kilonova Light Curves from the Disk Wind Outflows of Compact Object Mergers
• The Locations of Short Gamma-ray Bursts as Evidence for Compact Object Binary Progenitors
• A possible Macronova in the late afterglow of the `long-short' burst GRB 060614
• Closing in on a Short-Hard Burst Progenitor: Constraints from Early-Time Optical Imaging and Spectroscopy of a Possible Host Galaxy of GRB 050509b
• A Study of Compact Object Mergers as Short Gamma-ray Burst Progenitors
• The optical afterglow of the short gamma-ray burst GRB 050709
• The Afterglow, Energetics and Host Galaxy of the Short-Hard Gamma-Ray Burst 051221a
• Hubble Space Telescope Observations of Short GRB Host Galaxies: Morphologies, Offsets, and Local Environments
• A Deep Chandra X-ray Study of Neutron Star Coalescence GW170817
• The Macronova in GRB 050709 and the GRB/macronova connection
• Demographics of the Galaxies Hosting Short-duration Gamma-Ray Bursts
• GRB 080503: Implications of a Naked Short Gamma-Ray Burst Dominated by Extended Emission
• Short GRB 130603B: Discovery of a jet break in the optical and radio afterglows, and a mysterious late-time X-ray excess
• The lightcurve of the macronova associated with the long-short burst GRB 060614
• A Short GRB "No-Host'' Problem? Investigating Large Progenitor Offsets for Short GRBs with Optical Afterglows
• The Electromagnetic Counterpart of the Binary Neutron Star Merger LIGO/VIRGO GW170817. VII. Properties of the Host Galaxy and Constraints on the Merger Timescale
• The Host Galaxies of Short-Duration Gamma-Ray Bursts: Luminosities, Metallicities, and Star Formation Rates
• GRB 050509B: Constraints on short gamma-ray burst models
• The Stellar Ages and Masses of Short GRB Host Galaxies: Investigating the Progenitor Delay Time Distribution and the Role of Mass and Star Formation in the Short GRB Rate
• An origin in the local Universe for some short gamma-ray bursts
• The rest-frame optical luminosity functions of galaxies at 2<z<3.5
• An achromatic break in the afterglow of the short GRB 140903A: evidence for a narrow jet
• Short Gamma-Ray Bursts and Binary Mergers in Spiral and Elliptical Galaxies: Redshift Distribution and Hosts
• On the nature of the 'hostless' short GRBs
• Discovery of the afterglow and host galaxy of the low redshift short GRB 080905A
• The Afterglow and Early-Type Host Galaxy of the Short GRB 150101B at z=0.1343
• Deducing the Lifetime of Short Gamma-Ray Burst Progenitors from Host Galaxy Demography
• Infrared emission from kilonovae: the case of the nearby short hard burst GRB 160821B
• Limits on Radioactive-Powered Emission Associated With a Short-Hard GRB 070724A in a Star-Forming Galaxy
• The Afterglow and ULIRG Host Galaxy of the Dark Short GRB 120804A
• The Luminous Infrared Host Galaxy of Short-Duration GRB 100206A

Cited by in corpus (95)

• Constraining the Maximum Mass of Neutron Stars From Multi-Messenger Observations of GW170817
• The Electromagnetic Counterpart of the Binary Neutron Star Merger LIGO/Virgo GW170817. I. Dark Energy Camera Discovery of the Optical Counterpart
• The Electromagnetic Counterpart of the Binary Neutron Star Merger LIGO/VIRGO GW170817. III. Optical and UV Spectra of a Blue Kilonova From Fast Polar Ejecta
• Kilonovae
• The Electromagnetic Counterpart of the Binary Neutron Star Merger LIGO/VIRGO GW170817. V. Rising X-ray Emission from an Off-Axis Jet
• The Binary Neutron Star event LIGO/VIRGO GW170817 a hundred and sixty days after merger: synchrotron emission across the electromagnetic spectrum
• The Electromagnetic Counterpart of the Binary Neutron Star Merger LIGO/VIRGO GW170817. VI. Radio Constraints on a Relativistic Jet and Predictions for Late-Time Emission from the Kilonova Ejecta
• Neutron Star Mergers Might not be the Only Source of r-Process Elements in the Milky Way
• A Decline in the X-ray through Radio Emission from GW170817 Continues to Support an Off-Axis Structured Jet
• Search for High-energy Neutrinos from Binary Neutron Star Merger GW170817 with ANTARES, IceCube, and the Pierre Auger Observatory
• Fast Radio Bursts from Magnetars Born in Binary Neutron Star Mergers and Accretion Induced Collapse
• Rapidly evolving transients in the Dark Energy Survey
• Two years of non-thermal emission from the binary neutron star merger GW170817: rapid fading of the jet afterglow and first constraints on the kilonova fastest ejecta
• The Electromagnetic Counterpart of the Binary Neutron Star Merger LIGO/VIRGO GW170817. VII. Properties of the Host Galaxy and Constraints on the Merger Timescale
• Brightening X-ray Emission from GW170817/GRB170817A: Further Evidence for an Outflow
• Short GRB Host Galaxies I: Photometric and Spectroscopic Catalogs, Host Associations, and Galactocentric Offsets
• Improved constraints on H0 from a combined analysis of gravitational-wave and electromagnetic emission from GW170817
• Searching for Electromagnetic Counterparts to Gravitational-wave Merger Events with the Prototype Gravitational-wave Optical Transient Observer (GOTO-4)
• The Optical Afterglow of GW170817: An Off-axis Structured Jet and Deep Constraints on a Globular Cluster Origin
• The Science of the Einstein Telescope
• The Diversity of Kilonova Emission in Short Gamma-Ray Bursts
• A comparison between short GRB afterglows and AT2017gfo: shedding light on kilonovae properties
• The Broad-band Counterpart of the Short GRB 200522A at $z=0.5536$: A Luminous Kilonova or a Collimated Outflow with a Reverse Shock?
• Formation channels of single and binary stellar-mass black holes
• Chronicling the Host Galaxy Properties of the Remarkable Repeating FRB 20201124A
• EM counterparts of structured jets from 3D GRMHD simulations
• A new delay time distribution for merging neutron stars tested against Galactic and cosmic data
• A Program for Multi-Messenger Standard Siren Cosmology in the Era of LIGO A+, Rubin Observatory, and Beyond
• Neutron Star Mergers and How to Study Them
• Optical measurement of superluminal motion in the neutron-star merger GW170817
• Fading of the X-ray Afterglow of Neutron Star Merger GW170817/GRB170817A at 260 days
• Self-consistent picture of the mass ejection from a one second-long binary neutron star merger leaving a short-lived remnant in general-relativistic neutrino-radiation magnetohydrodynamic simulation
• A Search for Neutron Star-Black Hole Binary Mergers in the Short Gamma-Ray Burst Population
• The lanthanide fraction distribution in metal-poor stars: a test of neutron star mergers as the dominant r-process site
• GRMHD simulations of neutron-star mergers with weak interactions: r-process nucleosynthesis and electromagnetic signatures of dynamical ejecta
• GW170817 Afterglow Reveals that Short Gamma-Ray Bursts are Neutron Star Mergers
• Evidence for $\gtrsim 4$ Gyr timescales of neutron star mergers from Galactic archaeology
• The host galaxies of double compact objects merging in the local Universe
• Dynamical ejecta synchrotron emission as possible contributor to the changing behaviour of GRB170817A
• Constraints on the Physical Properties of GW190814 through Simulations based on DECam Follow-up Observations by the Dark Energy Survey
• Probing Kilonova Ejecta Properties Using a Catalog of Short Gamma-Ray Burst Observations
• The host galaxy of the short GRB111117A at $z=2.211$: impact on the short GRB redshift distribution and progenitor channels
• The chemical evolution of r-process elements from neutron star mergers: the role of a 2-phase interstellar medium
• Double Neutron Star Formation: Merger Times, Systemic Velocities, and Travel Distances
• A Late-time Radio Survey of Short GRBs at $z<0.5$: New Constraints on the Remnants of Neutron Star Mergers
• NGC 4993, the shell galaxy host of GW170817: constraints on the recent galactic merger
• The Gravity Collective: A Search for the Electromagnetic Counterpart to the Neutron Star-Black Hole Merger GW190814
• GROWTH on S190510g: DECam Observation Planning and Follow-Up of a Distant Binary Neutron Star Merger Candidate
• An upper-limit on the linear polarization fraction of the GW170817 radio continuum
• Localization of binary mergers with gravitational-wave detectors of second and third generation
• Searches after Gravitational Waves Using ARizona Observatories (SAGUARO): Observations and Analysis from Advanced LIGO/Virgo's Third Observing Run
• Stochastic Chemical Evolution of Radioactive Isotopes with a Monte Carlo Approach
• Is the macronova in GW170817 powered by the central engine?
• The host galaxies of double compact objects across cosmic time
• Exploring compact binary merger host galaxies and environments with $\mathrm{zELDA}$
• A multi-wavelength analysis of a collection of short-duration GRBs observed between 2012-2015
• Discovery of the optical afterglow and host galaxy of short GRB181123B at $z=1.754$: Implications for Delay Time Distributions
• Outflows from black hole hyperaccretion systems: short and long-short gamma-ray bursts and "quasi-supernovae"
• No velocity-kicks are required to explain large-distance offsets of Ca-rich supernovae and short-GRBs
• Radioactive $\gamma$-Ray Emissions from Neutron Star Mergers
• Thermal evolution of neo-neutron stars. I: envelopes, Eddington luminosity phase and implications for GW170817
• The binary-host connection: astrophysics of gravitational wave binaries from their host galaxy properties
• Swift/UVOT follow-up of Gravitational Wave Alerts in the O3 era
• Determine the Lorentz factor and the viewing angle of GRB 170817A
• Astrophysical Implications of Neutron Star Inspiral and Coalescence
• Predicted rates of merging neutron stars in galaxies
• Neutron stars mergers in a stochastic chemical evolution model: impact of time delay distributions
• Radio sky maps of the GRB 170817A afterglow from simulations
• Jet Geometry and Rate Estimate of Coincident Gamma Ray Burst and Gravitational Wave Observations
• Search for Neutron Star Binaries in the Local Group Galaxies Using LISA
• Constraints On Short, Hard Gamma-Ray Burst Beaming Angles From Gravitational Wave Observations
• Constraining Delay Time Distribution of Binary Neutron Star Mergers from Host Galaxy Properties
• Modeling kilonova afterglows: Effects of the thermal electron population and interaction with GRB outflows
• MAXI upper limits of the electromagnetic counterpart of GW170817
• An Empirical Study of Contamination in Deep, Rapid, and Wide-Field Optical Follow-Up of Gravitational Wave Events
• Observational constraints on the origin of the elements. VI. Origin and evolution of neutron-capture elements as probed by the Gaia-ESO survey
• How Special Is GRB 170817A?
• Short duration gamma-ray bursts and their outflows in light of GW170817
• Galactic r-process abundance feature shaped by radial migration
• r-Process enrichment in the Galactic halo characterized by nucleosynthesis variation in the ejecta of coalescing neutron star binaries
• Rapid-response radio observations of short GRB 181123B with the Australia Telescope Compact Array
• Europium enrichment and hierarchical formation of the Galactic halo
• The Environments of Fast Radio Bursts Viewed Using Adaptive Optics
• Synthetic radio images of structured GRB and kilonova afterglows
• Search for radio remnants of nearby off-axis Gamma-Ray Bursts in a sample of Swift/BAT events
• A magnetically driven origin for the low luminosity GRB 170817A associated with GW170817
• Late afterglow emission statistics: a clear link between GW170817 and bright short GRBs
• The Lagrangian Numerical Relativity code SPHINCS_BSSN_v1.0
• Properties of jet and surrounding material of GW/GRB~170817A
• Multi-scale VLBI observations of the candidate host galaxy of GRB 200716C
• Binary Neutron Star (BNS) merger: What we learned from relativistic ejecta of GW/GRB~170817A
• Optimized Radio Follow Up of Binary Neutron-Star Mergers
• Similar Fermi-GBM sGRBs to GW/sGRB 170817A in MeV-GeV energies
• SOAR/Goodman Spectroscopic Assessment of Candidate Counterparts of the LIGO-Virgo Event GW190814
• Two Sites of r-Process Production Assessed on the Basis of the Age-tagged Abundances of Solar Twins