Is HR 6819 a triple system containing a black hole? -- An alternative explanation

Abstract

HR 6819 was recently proposed to be a triple system consisting of an inner B-type giant + black hole binary with an orbital period of 40d and an outer Be tertiary. This interpretation is mainly based on two inferences: that the emission attributed to the outer Be star is stationary, and that the inner star, which is used as mass calibrator for the black hole, is a B-type giant. We re-investigate the properties of HR 6819 by spectral disentangling and an atmosphere analysis of the disentangled spectra to search for a possibly simpler alternative explanation for HR 6819. Disentangling implies that the Be component is not a static tertiary, but rather a component of the binary in the 40-d orbit. The inferred radial velocity amplitudes imply an extreme mass ratio of M_2/M_1 = 15 +/- 3. We infer spectroscopic masses of 0.4${}_{-0.1}^{+0.3}$ Msun and 6${}_{-3}^{+5}$ Msun for the primary and secondary, which agree well with the dynamical masses for an inclination of i = 32 deg. This indicates that the primary might be a stripped star rather than a B-type giant. Evolutionary modelling suggests that a possible progenitor system would be a tight (P_i ~ 2d) B+B binary system that experienced conservative mass transfer. While the observed nitrogen enrichment of the primary conforms with the predictions of the evolutionary models, we find no indications for the predicted He enrichment. We suggest that HR 6819 is a binary system consisting of a stripped B-type primary and a rapidly-rotating Be star that formed from a previous mass-transfer event. In the framework of this interpretation, HR 6819 does not contain a black hole. Interferometry can distinguish between these two scenarios by providing an independent measurement of the separation between the visible components.

arXiv commentSubmitted to A&A, 13 pages (16 figures and 2 tables); 4 pages supplementary material (4 figures and 4 tables). Comments are welcome

References in corpus (73)

• Modules for Experiments in Stellar Astrophysics (MESA)
• Modules for Experiments in Stellar Astrophysics (MESA): Giant Planets, Oscillations, Rotation, and Massive Stars
• Modules for Experiments in Stellar Astrophysics (MESA): Binaries, Pulsations, and Explosions
• Binary interaction dominates the evolution of massive stars
• Modules for Experiments in Stellar Astrophysics (MESA): Convective Boundaries, Element Diffusion, and Massive Star Explosions
• Gaia Data Release 2: The astrometric solution
• Estimating distances from parallaxes IV: Distances to 1.33 billion stars in Gaia Data Release 2
• Modules for Experiments in Stellar Astrophysics (MESA): Pulsating Variable Stars, Rotation, Convective Boundaries, and Energy Conservation
• Mind your Ps and Qs: the Interrelation between Period (P) and Mass-ratio (Q) Distributions of Binary Stars
• Pre-Supernova Evolution of Massive Single and Binary Stars
• A Comprehensive Study of Binary Compact Objects as Gravitational Wave Sources: Evolutionary Channels, Rates, and Physical Properties
• A Grid of NLTE Line-Blanketed Model Atmospheres of Early B-type Stars
• SB9: The Ninth Catalogue of Spectroscopic Binary Orbits
• A new route towards merging massive black holes
• Classical Be Stars: Rapidly Rotating B Stars with Viscous Keplerian Decretion Disks
• The rotation rates of massive stars: the role of binary interaction through tides, mass transfer and mergers
• Merging binary black holes formed through chemically homogeneous evolution in short-period stellar binaries
• The VLT-FLAMES Tarantula Survey VIII. Multiplicity properties of the O-type star population
• HERMES: a high-resolution fibre-fed spectrograph for the Mercator telescope
• Catalogue of high-mass X-ray binaries in the Galaxy ($4^{th}$ edition)
• The formation of the first stars and galaxies
• Be-star rotation: how close to critical?
• The IACOB project: I. Rotational velocities in Northern Galactic O and early B-type stars revisited. The impact of other sources of line-broadening
• Discovery of a Candidate Black Hole - Giant Star Binary System in the Galactic Field
• Merging black holes in young star clusters
• Formation of contact in massive close binaries
• Toward Complete Statistics of Massive Binary Stars: Penultimate Results from the Cygnus OB2 Radial Velocity Survey
• A Be-type star with a black hole companion
• A wide star-black-hole binary system from radial-velocity measurements
• Black hole and neutron star mergers in galactic nuclei
• Viscous Effects on the Interaction between the Coplanar Decretion Disc and the Neutron Star in Be/X-Ray Binaries
• The VLT-FLAMES Tarantula Survey XXII. Multiplicity properties of the B-type stars
• Fourier method in the determination of rotational velocities in OB stars
• The Be/X-ray transient 4U 0115+63/V635 Cas I. A consistent model
• Low-frequency gravity waves in blue supergiants revealed by high-precision space photometry
• Signatures of internal rotation discovered in the Kepler data of five slowly pulsating B stars
• On the consistent treatment of the quasi-hydrostatic layers in hot star atmospheres
• The IACOB project: III. New observational clues to understand macroturbulent broadening in massive O- and B-type stars
• The 'hidden' companion in LB-1 unveiled by spectral disentangling
• Collective pulsational velocity broadening due to gravity modes as a physical explanation for macroturbulence in hot massive stars
• Masses and Luminosities of O and B - type stars and red super giants
• Detection of additional Be+sdO systems from IUE spectroscopy
• Properties of OB star-black hole systems derived from detailed binary evolution models
• Photometric detection of internal gravity waves in upper main-sequence stars. II. Combined TESS photometry and high-resolution spectroscopy
• A naked-eye triple system with a nonaccreting black hole in the inner binary
• PoWR grids of non-LTE model atmospheres for OB-type stars of various metallicities
• Fundamental properties of nearby single early B-type stars
• Not so fast: LB-1 is unlikely to contain a 70 $M_{\odot }$ black hole
• A Study of Pi Aquarii During a Quasi-normal Star Phase: Refined Fundamental Parameters and Evidence for Binarity
• No signature of the orbital motion of a putative 70 solar mass black hole in LB-1
• Cyclic variability of the circumstellar disk of the Be star zetaTau - I. Long-term monitoring observations
• Disk Loss and Disk Renewal Phases in Classical Be Stars I: Analysis of Long-Term Spectropolarimetric Data
• High resolution optical spectroscopy of Plaskett's star
• A stripped helium star in the potential black hole binary LB-1
• Primordial-black-hole mergers in dark-matter spikes
• Population Synthesis of Black Hole Binaries with Normal-Star Companions: I. Detached Systems
• Evidence for a physically bound third component in HD 150136
• Toward Understanding the B[e] Phenomenon. VII. AS 386, a single-lined binary with a candidate black hole component
• Clues on the Origin and Evolution of Massive Contact Binaries: Atmosphere Analysis of VFTS 352
• Comment on "A non-interacting low-mass black hole -- giant star binary system"
• On the importance of the few most massive stars: the ionizing cluster of NGC 588
• Evidence of a Massive Black Hole Companion in the Massive Eclipsing Binary V Puppis
• The Shortest-period Wolf-Rayet binary in the Small Magellanic Cloud: Part of a high-order multiple system
• A detailed non-LTE analysis of LB-1: Revised parameters and surface abundances
• Mining for Candidates of Galactic Stellar-mass Black Hole Binaries with LAMOST
• Spectro-interferometric observations of a sample of Be stars. Setting limits to the geometry and kinematics of stable Be disks
• A New Diagnostic of the Radial Density Structure of Be Disks
• Observational studies of early-type binary stars: VV Orionis
• The nearest discovered black hole is likely not in a triple configuration
• Absolute Dimensions and Apsidal Motion of the Young Detached System LT Canis Majoris
• Study of Eclipsing Binary and Multiple Systems in OB Associations: I. Ori OB1a - IM Mon
• New Observations and Analysis of the Bright Semi-Detached Eclipsing Binary mu1 Sco
• Close Binary System GO Cyg

Cited by in corpus (76)

• A Sun-like star orbiting a black hole
• A Unicorn in Monoceros: the $3M_{\odot }$ dark companion to the bright, nearby red giant V723 Mon is a non-interacting, mass-gap black hole candidate
• Merger rate density of Population III binary black holes below, above, and in the pair-instability mass gap
• A non-interacting Galactic black hole candidate in a binary system with a main-sequence star
• An X-ray quiet black hole born with a negligible kick in a massive binary within the Large Magellanic Cloud
• The Detection and Characterization of Be+sdO Binaries from HST/STIS FUV Spectroscopy
• Identifying quiescent compact objects in massive Galactic single-lined spectroscopic binaries
• A stripped-companion origin for Be stars: clues from the putative black holes HR 6819 and LB-1
• Partial-envelope stripping and nuclear-timescale mass transfer from evolved supergiants at low metallicity
• A sensitive search for wormholes
• The Tarantula Massive Binary Monitoring VI: Characterisation of hidden companions in 51 single-lined O-type binaries, a flat mass-ratio distribution, and black-hole binary candidates
• Unicorns and Giraffes in the binary zoo: stripped giants with subgiant companions
• Search for a Black Hole Binary in Gaia DR3 Astrometric Binary Stars with Spectroscopic Data
• The young massive SMC cluster NGC 330 seen by MUSE II. Multiplicity properties of the massive-star population
• A massive helium star with a sufficiently strong magnetic field to form a magnetar
• Uncovering astrometric black hole binaries with massive main-sequence companions with Gaia
• The B-type Binaries Characterisation Programme I. Orbital solutions for the 30 Doradus population
• Multiplicity of Galactic Luminous Blue Variable stars
• Population Synthesis of Galactic Be-star Binaries with A Helium-star Companion
• A magnetic massive star has experienced a stellar merger
• Gaia Data Release 3: Ellipsoidal Variables with Possible Black-Hole or Neutron Star secondaries
• HR 6819 is a binary system with no black hole -- revisiting the source with infrared interferometry and optical integral field spectroscopy
• Astrometric excess noise in Gaia DR2 and the search for X-ray emitting binaries
• A partially stripped massive star in a Be binary at low metallicity: A missing link towards Be X-ray binaries and double neutron star mergers
• Astrometric excess noise in Gaia EDR3 and the search for X-ray binaries
• Optical Analysis and Modeling of HD96670, a new Black Hole X-ray Binary Candidate
• The X-ray emission of Be+stripped star binaries
• Birth of a Be star: an APOGEE search for Be stars forming through binary mass transfer
• The B-type Binaries Characterisation Programme II. VFTS 291: A stripped star from a recent mass transfer phase
• MWC 656 is unlikely to contain a black hole
• Forming merging double compact objects with stable mass transfer
• X-Shooting ULLYSES: Massive Stars at low metallicity VIII. Stellar and wind parameters of newly revealed stripped stars in Be binaries
• Probable Dormant Neutron Star in a Short-Period Binary System
• Exploring the borderline between stable mass transfer and mergers in close binary evolution
• The "Giraffe": Discovery of a stripped red giant in an interacting binary with a $\sim 2M_{\odot }$ lower giant
• Formation and Destiny of White Dwarf and Be Star Binaries
• A search for compact object companions to high mass function single-lined spectroscopic binaries in Gaia DR3
• Updated radial velocities and new constraints on the nature of the unseen source in NGC1850 BH1
• Binarity at Low Metallicity (BLOeM) -- Multiplicity properties of Oe and Be stars
• Properties of the Be-type stars in 30 Doradus
• The spins of stripped B stars support magnetic internal angular momentum transport
• Binarity at LOw Metallicity (BLOeM): Enhanced multiplicity of early B-type dwarfs and giants at $Z=0.2{\mathrm{Z}}_{\odot }$
• Hubble spectroscopy of LB-1: comparison with B+black-hole and Be+stripped-star models
• Search for Dormant Black Holes in Ellipsoidal Variables II. A Binary Modified Minimum Mass Ratio
• Analysis of high-resolution FEROS spectroscopy for a sample of variable B-type stars assembled from TESS photometry
• Binarity at LOw Metallicity (BLOeM): The multiplicity properties and evolution of BAF-type supergiants
• On the evolutionary nature of puffed-up stripped star binaries and their occurrence in stellar populations
• The mass distribution of stars stripped in binaries: The effect of metallicity
• To be or not to be a black hole: detailed binary population models as a sanity check
• Resolving the dynamical mass tension of the massive binary 9 Sagittarii
• Newborn Be star systems observed shortly after mass transfer
• Extreme mass ratios and fast rotation in three massive binaries
• Ups!... I did it again: unveiling the hidden companion in Upsilon Sagittarii, a unique binary system at a second mass transfer stage
• Lagrange vs. Lyapunov stability of hierarchical triple systems: dependence on the mutual inclination between inner and outer orbits
• Detection of single-degenerate massive binaries with Gaia: The impact of blue supergiants, triples, mass precision, and high-precision parallax requirements
• VFTS 243 as predicted by the BPASS fiducial models
• Autonomous Disentangling for Spectroscopic Surveys
• Classical Be stars
• Using radial velocities to reveal black holes in binaries: a test case
• HIP 15429: A newborn Be star on an eccentric binary orbit
• Searching for compact objects in the single-lined spectroscopic binaries of the young Galactic cluster NGC 6231
• Binarity at LOw Metallicity (BLOeM): Projected rotational velocities
• Mapping Progenitors of Binary Black Holes and Neutron Stars with Binary Population Synthesis
• A search for Be stars in multiple systems within the solar neighborhood
• One of Everything: The Breakthrough Listen Exotica Catalog
• New Field OB and OBe Binaries of the SMC Wing: Observational Properties and Population Modeling
• Everything that glitters is not gold: V1315 Cas is not a dormant black hole
• Testing the presence of a dormant black hole inside HR 6819
• Stellar response after stripping as a model for common-envelope outcomes
• Ultraviolet spectroscopy reveals a hot and luminous companion to the Be star+black hole candidate MWC 656
• Two unseen massive white dwarf candidates in close binaries
• The VLT-FLAMES survey of massive stars. NGC2004#115: A triple system hosting a possible short period B+BH binary
• NGC 1850 BH1 is another stripped-star binary masquerading as a black hole
• Was there a (super)nova in 1408?
• NGC 2004 #115: a black hole imposter containing three luminous stars
• Astrometry of variable compact radio sources: A search for Galactic black hole X-ray binaries