Kepler's Earth-like Planets Should Not Be Confirmed Without Independent Detection: The Case of Kepler-452b

Abstract

We show that the claimed confirmed planet Kepler-452b (a.k.a. K07016.01, KIC 8311864) can not be confirmed using a purely statistical validation approach. Kepler detects many more periodic signals from instrumental effects than it does from transits, and it is likely impossible to confidently distinguish the two types of event at low signal-to-noise. As a result, the scenario that the observed signal is due to an instrumental artifact can't be ruled out with 99\% confidence, and the system must still be considered a candidate planet. We discuss the implications for other confirmed planets in or near the habitable zone.

Accepted for publication in AJ

References in corpus (7)

• Most 1.6 Earth-Radius Planets are not Rocky
• Planetary Candidates Observed by Kepler. VIII. A Fully Automated Catalog With Measured Completeness and Reliability Based on Data Release 25
• Planetary Candidates Observed by Kepler VI: Planet Sample from Q1-Q16 (47 Months)
• Modeling Kepler transit light curves as false positives: Rejection of blend scenarios for Kepler-9, and validation of Kepler-9d, a super-Earth-size planet in a multiple system
• Planetary Candidates Observed by Kepler V: Planet Sample from Q1-Q12 (36 Months)
• The Challenge of Wide-Field Transit Surveys: The Case of GSC 01944-02289
• Validation of small Kepler transiting planet candidates in or near the habitable zone

Cited by in corpus (22)

• The TESS Objects of Interest Catalog from the TESS Prime Mission
• Revised Radii of Kepler Stars and Planets Using Gaia Data Release 2
• A Revised Exoplanet Yield from the Transiting Exoplanet Survey Satellite (TESS)
• Occurrence Rates of Planets orbiting FGK Stars: Combining Kepler DR25, Gaia DR2 and Bayesian Inference
• The Gaia-Kepler Stellar Properties Catalog. II. Planet Radius Demographics as a Function of Stellar Mass and Age
• Multicolour photometry for exoplanet candidate validation
• MuSCAT2 multicolour validation of TESS candidates: an ultra-short-period substellar object around an M dwarf
• The future lifespan of Earth's oxygenated Atmosphere
• A Compact Multi-Planet System With A Significantly Misaligned Ultra Short Period Planet
• The First Habitable Zone Earth-Sized Planet From TESS II: $Spitzer$ Confirms TOI-700 d
• The impact of stripped cores on the frequency of Earth-size planets in the habitable zone
• TOI-519 b: a short-period substellar object around an M dwarf validated using multicolour photometry and phase curve analysis
• The Stellar Variability Noise Floor for Transiting Exoplanet Photometry with PLATO
• Transit least-squares survey IV. Earth-like transiting planets expected from the PLATO mission
• Evolution of Novel Activation Functions in Neural Network Training with Applications to Classification of Exoplanets
• Re-Evaluating Small Long-Period Confirmed Planets From Kepler
• Updated Catalog of Kepler Planet Candidates: Focus on Accuracy and Orbital Periods
• Kepler-62f: Kepler's First Small Planet in the Habitable Zone, but Is It Real?
• Transit least-squares survey -- III. A $1.9R_{\oplus }$ transit candidate in the habitable zone of Kepler-160 and a nontransiting planet characterized by transit-timing variations
• An Independent Search for Small Long-period Planets in Kepler Data I: Detection Pipeline
• A Cool Earth-sized Planet Candidate Transiting a Tenth Magnitude K-dwarf From K2
• What the Solar System Can Teach Us About Rocky Exoplanets