Prediction of the 21-cm signal from reionization: comparison between 3D and 1D radiative transfer schemes
arXiv:1710.09397 · doi:10.1093/mnras/sty314
Abstract
Three-dimensional radiative transfer simulations of the epoch of reionization can produce realistic results, but are computationally expensive. On the other hand, simulations relying on one-dimensional radiative transfer solutions are faster but limited in accuracy due to their more approximate nature. Here, we compare the performance of the reionization simulation codes grizzly and C2-ray which use 1D and 3D radiative transfer schemes respectively. The comparison is performed using the same cosmological density fields, halo catalogues and source properties. We find that the ionization maps, as well as the 21-cm signal maps from these two simulations are very similar even for complex scenarios which include thermal feedback on low mass halos. The comparison between the schemes in terms of the statistical quantities such as the power spectrum of the brightness temperature fluctuation agree with each other within 10% error throughout the entire reionization history. grizzly seems to perform slightly better than the semi-numerical approaches considered in Majumdar et al. (2014) which are based on the excursion set principle. We argue that grizzly can be efficiently used for exploring parameter space, establishing observations strategies and estimating parameters from 21-cm observations.
arXiv comment16 pages, Submitted to MNRAS
References in corpus (74)
- Planck 2015 results. XIII. Cosmological parameters
- Seven-Year Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) Observations: Cosmological Interpretation
- Planck 2013 results. XVI. Cosmological parameters
- Nine-Year Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) Observations: Cosmological Parameter Results
- LOFAR: The LOw-Frequency ARray
- A luminous quasar at a redshift of z = 7.085
- Cosmology at Low Frequencies: The 21 cm Transition and the High-Redshift Universe
- The Murchison Widefield Array: the Square Kilometre Array Precursor at low radio frequencies
- UV Luminosity Functions at redshifts z~4 to z~10: 10000 Galaxies from HST Legacy Fields
- Concentrations of Dark Halos from their Assembly Histories
- An All-Sky Analysis of Polarization in the Microwave Background
- 21-cm cosmology
- Evidence for Reionization at z ~ 6: Detection of a Gunn-Peterson Trough in a z=6.28 Quasar
- Formation of the First Supermassive Black Holes
- 21cmFAST: A Fast, Semi-Numerical Simulation of the High-Redshift 21-cm Signal
- Model-independent evidence in favor of an end to reionization by z~6
- A Survey of z>5.7 Quasars in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey IV: Discovery of Seven Additional Quasars
- Reionization and Cosmology with 21 cm Fluctuations
- Efficient Simulations of Early Structure Formation and Reionization
- The Birth of a Galaxy - III. Propelling reionisation with the faintest galaxies
- Simulating Cosmic Reionization at Large Scales I: the Geometry of Reionization
- The morphology of HII regions during reionization
- Simulations and Analytic Calculations of Bubble Growth During Hydrogen Reionization
- A simulation calibrated limit on the HI power spectrum from the GMRT Epoch of Reionization experiment
- Science with the Murchison Widefield Array
- Upper limits on the 21-cm Epoch of Reionization power spectrum from one night with LOFAR
- Planck 2015 results. XV. Gravitational lensing
- Accretion onto the First Stellar Mass Black Holes
- New Limits on 21cm EoR From PAPER-32 Consistent with an X-Ray Heated IGM at z=7.7
- Studying Reionization with Ly-alpha Emitters
- 21CMMC: an MCMC analysis tool enabling astrophysical parameter studies of the cosmic 21 cm signal
- Completing the Census of Ly-alpha Emitters at the Reionization Epoch
- Cosmological Radiative Transfer Codes Comparison Project I: The Static Density Field Tests
- Galaxy Properties and UV Escape Fractions During Epoch of Reionization: Results from the Renaissance Simulations
- Comparison Of Reionization Models: Radiative Transfer Simulations And Approximate, Semi-Numeric Models
- Simulating Cosmic Reionization at Large Scales II: the 21-cm Emission Features and Statistical Signals
- Statistical Probes of Reionization With 21 cm Tomography
- The observable signature of late heating of the Universe during cosmic reionization
- Charting the Parameter Space of the Global 21-cm Signal
- Inside-out or Outside-in: The topology of reionization in the photon-starved regime suggested by Lyman-alpha forest data
- Inhomogeneous recombinations during cosmic reionization
- Cosmological Reionization Around the First Stars: Monte Carlo Radiative Transfer
- Fast Large Volume Simulations of the 21 cm Signal from the Reionization and pre-Reionization Epochs
- High Performance P3M N-body code: CUBEP3M
- The Detectability of Lyman Alpha Emission from Galaxies during the Epoch of Reionization
- Cosmic reionization after Planck
- Cosmological Radiative Transfer Comparison Project II: The Radiation-Hydrodynamic Tests
- Lyman-alpha emitters gone missing: evidence for late reionization?
- 21 cm signal from cosmic dawn: Imprints of spin temperature fluctuations and peculiar velocities
- Characterizing Foreground for redshifted 21-cm radiation: 150 MHz GMRT observations
- Cosmic Reionization and the 21-cm signal: Comparison between an analytical model and a simulation
- Fast Large-Scale Reionization Simulations
- The simulated 21 cm signal during the epoch of reionization : full modeling of the Ly-alpha pumping
- Can 21-cm observations discriminate between high-mass and low-mass galaxies as reionization sources?
- Topology and Sizes of HII Regions during Cosmic Reionization
- Analysing the 21cm signal from the Epoch of Reionization with artificial neural networks
- On the use of semi-numerical simulations in predicting the 21-cm signal from the epoch of reionization
- The Volume Fraction of Ionized Intergalactic Gas at Redshift z=6.5
- Updating reionization scenarios after recent data
- Bubble size statistics during reionization from 21-cm tomography
- Cosmological HII Bubble Growth During Reionization
- X-ray emission from high-redshift miniquasars: self-regulating the population of massive black holes through global warming
- Imaging the redshifted 21-cm pattern around the first sources during the cosmic dawn using the SKA
- Connecting Reionization to the Local Universe
- Constraining the epoch of reionization with the variance statistic: simulations of the LOFAR case
- Joint QSO-CMB constraints on reionization history
- Reionization Through the Lens of Percolation Theory
- Reionization constraints using Principal Component Analysis
- Simulating the Impact of X-ray Heating during the Cosmic Dawn
- Heating of the Intergalactic Medium by Primordial Miniquasars
- An improved model of HII bubbles during the epoch of reionization
- X-Ray Luminous Binaries, Metallicity, and the Early Universe
- A Gunn-Peterson test with a QSO at z=6.4
- Heating and Ionization of the Primordial Intergalactic Medium by High Mass X-ray Binaries
Cited by in corpus (37)
- Improved upper limits on the 21-cm signal power spectrum of neutral hydrogen at from LOFAR
- Constraining the intergalactic medium at 9.1 using LOFAR Epoch of Reionization observations
- Interpreting LOFAR 21-cm signal upper limits at z~9.1 in the context of high-z galaxy and reionisation observations
- Exploring reionisation and high-z galaxy observables with recent multi-redshift MWA upper limits on the 21-cm signal
- Constraining the state of the intergalactic medium during the Epoch of Reionization using MWA 21-cm signal observations
- Photon number conservation and the large-scale 21 cm power spectrum in semi-numerical models of reionization
- An Effective Model for the Cosmic-Dawn 21-cm Signal
- A halo model approach for the 21-cm power spectrum at cosmic dawn
- Large scale simulations of H and He reionization and heating driven by stars and more energetic sources
- Elevated UV luminosity density at Cosmic Dawn explained by non-evolving, weakly mass-dependent star formation efficiency
- Redshifted 21-cm bispectrum II: Impact of the spin temperature fluctuations and redshift space distortions on the signal from the Cosmic Dawn
- Precision requirements for interferometric gridding in 21-cm power spectrum analysis
- The need for obscured supermassive black hole growth to explain quasar proximity zones in the epoch of reionization
- Deeper multi-redshift upper limits on the Epoch of Reionization 21-cm signal power spectrum from LOFAR between z=8.3 and z=10.1
- Studying Cosmic Dawn using redshifted HI 21-cm signal: A brief review
- BEoRN: A fast and flexible framework to simulate the epoch of reionisation and cosmic dawn
- Reionisation & Cosmic Dawn Astrophysics from the Square Kilometre Array: Impact of Observing Strategies
- Cosmological implications of the composite spectra of galactic X-ray binaries constructed using MAXI data
- 21cmFirstCLASS I. Cosmological tool for CDM and beyond
- Probing early universe through redshifted 21-cm signal: Modelling and observational challenges
- POLAR -- I: linking the 21-cm signal from the epoch of reionization to galaxy formation
- Constraints on the state of the IGM at using redshifted 21-cm observations with LOFAR
- Bayesian approach to constraining the properties of ionized bubbles during reionization
- A galaxy-free phenomenological model for the 21-cm power spectrum during reionization
- Redshifted 21-cm bispectrum: Impact of the source models on the signal and the IGM physics from the Cosmic Dawn
- Opening Reionization: Quantitative Morphology of the Epoch of Reionization and Its Connection to the Cosmic Density Field
- PINION: Physics-informed neural network for accelerating radiative transfer simulations for cosmic reionization
- Efficient simulation of discrete galaxy populations and associated radiation fields during the first billion years
- Mapping reionization bubbles in the JWST era II: inferring the position and characteristic size of individual bubbles
- First upper limits on the 21-cm signal power spectrum of neutral hydrogen at from the LOFAR 3C196 field
- Studying the Multi-frequency Angular Power Spectrum of the Cosmic Dawn 21-cm Signal
- Probing the Epoch of Reionization using synergies of line intensity mapping
- Large HI optical depth and Redshifted 21-cm signal from cosmic dawn
- Comparison of Bayesian inference methods using the Loreli II database of hydro-radiative simulations of the 21-cm signal
- Predictions of the 21cm global signal in the JWST and ALMA era
- The Effect of Large Optical Depths on the Non-Gaussian 21-cm signal from Cosmic Dawn
- Impact of anisotropic photon emission from sources during the epoch of reionisation