GW170817 Falsifies Dark Matter Emulators

Abstract

On August 17, 2017 the LIGO interferometers detected the gravitational wave (GW) signal (GW170817) from the coalescence of binary neutron stars. This signal was also simultaneously seen throughout the electromagnetic (EM) spectrum from radio waves to gamma-rays. We point out that this simultaneous detection of GW and EM signals rules out a class of modified gravity theories, termed ``dark matter emulators,'' which dispense with the need for dark matter by making ordinary matter couple to a different metric from that of GW. We discuss other kinds of modified gravity theories which dispense with the need for dark matter and are still viable. This simultaneous observation also provides the first observational test of Einstein's Weak Equivalence Principle (WEP) between gravitons and photons. We estimate the Shapiro time delay due to the gravitational potential of the total dark matter distribution along the line of sight (complementary to the calculation in arXiv:1710.05834) to be about 400 days. Using this estimate for the Shapiro delay and from the time difference of 1.7 seconds between the GW signal and gamma-rays, we can constrain violations of WEP using the parameterized post-Newtonian (PPN) parameter $\gamma$, and is given by $|{\gamma }_{\mathrm{GW}}-{\gamma }_{\mathrm{EM}}|<9.8\times 10^{-8}$.

arXiv comment6 pages, 2 figures. Accepted for publication in Physical Review D (Rapid Communication)

References in corpus (62)

• Observation of Gravitational Waves from a Binary Black Hole Merger
• GW170817: Observation of Gravitational Waves from a Binary Neutron Star Inspiral
• Particle Dark Matter: Evidence, Candidates and Constraints
• Shapiro delay measurement of a two solar mass neutron star
• The Confrontation between General Relativity and Experiment
• Multi-messenger Observations of a Binary Neutron Star Merger
• Gravitational Waves and Gamma-rays from a Binary Neutron Star Merger: GW170817 and GRB 170817A
• GW151226: Observation of Gravitational Waves from a 22-Solar-Mass Binary Black Hole Coalescence
• Final Results from the Hubble Space Telescope Key Project to Measure the Hubble Constant
• GW170104: Observation of a 50-Solar-Mass Binary Black Hole Coalescence at Redshift 0.2
• GW170814: A Three-Detector Observation of Gravitational Waves from a Binary Black Hole Coalescence
• An Ordinary Short Gamma-Ray Burst with Extraordinary Implications: Fermi-GBM Detection of GRB 170817A
• Relativistic gravitation theory for the MOND paradigm
• Gravity with a dynamical preferred frame
• INTEGRAL Detection of the First Prompt Gamma-Ray Signal Coincident with the Gravitational Wave Event GW170817
• Modified Newtonian Dynamics (MOND): Observational Phenomenology and Relativistic Extensions
• A kilonova as the electromagnetic counterpart to a gravitational-wave source
• Scalar-Tensor-Vector Gravity Theory
• The relativistic pulsar-white dwarf binary PSR J1738+0333 II. The most stringent test of scalar-tensor gravity
• Confirmation of general relativity on large scales from weak lensing and galaxy velocities
• Modifying gravity with the Aether: an alternative to Dark Matter
• Electromagnetic Evidence that SSS17a is the Result of a Binary Neutron Star Merger
• Theory of Dark Matter Superfluidity
• "Skinny Milky Way, Please", says Sagittarius
• Bimetric MOND gravity
• Electromagnetic Counterparts to Black Hole Mergers Detected by LIGO
• Lower Bound on the Propagation Speed of Gravity from Gravitational Cherenkov Radiation
• The Measurement of the Light Deflection from Jupiter: Experimental Results
• Can We See Lorentz-Violating Vector Fields in the CMB?
• Testing Einstein's Equivalence Principle with Fast Radio Bursts
• The Real Problem with MOND
• Nonlocal metric formulations of MOND with sufficient lensing
• Cosmic Transients Test Einstein's Equivalence Principle out to GeV Energies
• Constraints on frequency-dependent violations of Shapiro delay from GW150914
• A centrally heated dark halo for our Galaxy
• Arrival time differences between gravitational waves and electromagnetic signals due to gravitational lensing
• GW170817/GRB 170817A/AT2017gfo association: some implications for physics and astrophysics
• Limits on Einstein's Equivalence Principle from the first localized Fast Radio Burst FRB 150418
• Testing Einstein's Weak Equivalence Principle With Gravitational Waves
• On Testing the Equivalence Principle with Extragalactic Bursts
• Field equations and cosmology for a class of nonlocal metric models of MOND
• A Generic Test of Modified Gravity Models which Emulate Dark Matter
• Tests of the Einstein Equivalence Principle using TeV Blazars
• Modified gravity approach based on a preferred time foliation
• Gravity Gets There First with Dark Matter Emulators
• Limits on the Neutrino Velocity, Lorentz Invariance, and the Weak Equivalence Principle with TeV Neutrinos from Gamma-Ray Bursts
• Multimessenger tests of the weak equivalence principle from GW170817 and its electromagnetic counterparts
• A Shapiro delay detection in the binary system hosting the millisecond pulsar PSR J1910-5959A
• Constraining Relativistic Generalizations of Modified Newtonian Dynamics with Gravitational Waves
• Astrophysically Triggered Searches for Gravitational Waves: Status and Prospects
• Gravitational waves in bimetric MOND
• Determining Cosmology for a Nonlocal Realization of MOND
• A Decisive test to confirm or rule out the existence of dark matter emulators using gravitational wave observations
• Apparent Correction to the Speed of Light in a Gravitational Potential
• Testing Einstein's weak equivalence principle with a 0.4-nanosecond giant pulse of the Crab pulsar
• Hiding Lorentz Invariance Violation with MOND
• New test of weak equivalence principle using polarized light from astrophysical events
• A useful guide for gravitational wave observers to test modified gravity models
• Test of Weak Equivalence Principle with the multi-band timing of the Crab Pulsar
• The Galactic One-Way Shapiro Delay to PSR B1937+21
• Dipolar Dark Matter as an Effective Field Theory
• Test of the Weak Equivalence Principle using LIGO observations of GW150914 and Fermi observations of GBM transient 150914

Cited by in corpus (112)

• Tests of General Relativity with GW170817
• A New Era in the Quest for Dark Matter
• Ultra-Light Dark Matter
• Dark Energy Survey Year 1 Results: Constraints on Extended Cosmological Models from Galaxy Clustering and Weak Lensing
• The Astrophysics of Nanohertz Gravitational Waves
• Black holes with scalar hair in light of the Event Horizon Telescope
• Strong-field Gravity Tests with the Double Pulsar
• A new relativistic theory for Modified Newtonian Dynamics
• Dark Energy in light of Multi-Messenger Gravitational-Wave astronomy
• Primordial gravitational waves from NANOGrav: a broken power-law approach
• First Multimessenger Observations of a Neutron Star Merger
• From galactic bars to the Hubble tension: weighing up the astrophysical evidence for Milgromian gravity
• Brane-world extra dimensions in light of GW170817
• $f(R)$ Gravity Inflation with String-Corrected Axion Dark Matter
• Alive and well: mimetic gravity and a higher-order extension in light of GW170817
• Listening to the sound of dark sector interactions with gravitational wave standard sirens
• Gravitational wave probes of dark matter: challenges and opportunities
• Do we have any hope of detecting scattering between dark energy and baryons through cosmology?
• Probing observational bounds on scalar-tensor theories from standard sirens
• The Novel Probes Project -- Tests of Gravity on Astrophysical Scales
• A standard siren measurement of the Hubble constant using gravitational wave events from the first three LIGO/Virgo observing runs and the DESI Legacy Survey
• Gravitational wave lensing beyond general relativity: birefringence, echoes and shadows
• Gravitational Waves Probes of Parity Violation in Compact Binary Coalescence
• Neutron Star Mergers and How to Study Them
• A general class of gravitational theories as alternatives to dark matter where the speed of gravity always equals the speed of light
• Phenomenological consequences of superfluid dark matter with baryon-phonon coupling
• Multimessenger Constraints on Radiatively Decaying Axions from GW170817
• Dark degeneracy I: Dynamical or interacting dark energy?
• Testing Modified Gravity with Wide Binaries in GAIA DR2
• Generalized framework for testing gravity with gravitational-wave propagation. III. Future prospect
• Modified Gravity (MOG), the speed of gravitational radiation and the event GW170817/GRB170817A
• Formation and Evolution of Binary Neutron Stars: Mergers and Their Host Galaxies
• Testing the Schwarzschild metric in a strong field region with the Event Horizon Telescope
• Quasinormal modes-shadow correspondence for rotating regular black holes
• Hints of Modified Gravity in Cosmos and in the Lab?
• Nonlocal Cosmology II --- Cosmic acceleration without fine tuning or dark energy
• Forecast constraints on $f(T)$ gravity with gravitational waves from compact binary coalescences
• A special class of solutions in $F(R)$-gravity
• Tests of general relativity using multiband observations of intermediate mass binary black hole mergers
• Optimising growth of structure constraints on modified gravity
• Neutron star merger GW170817 strongly constrains doubly coupled bigravity
• Primordial regular black holes as all the dark matter. II. Non-time-radial-symmetric and loop quantum gravity-inspired metrics
• Primordial regular black holes as all the dark matter. I. Time-radial-symmetric metrics
• Constraints on $f(R)$ theories of gravity from GW170817
• Testing Modified Gravity Theories via Wide Binaries and GAIA
• Limits on the Weak Equivalence Principle and Photon Mass with FRB 121102 Sub-pulses
• Transition from Inspiral to Plunge: A Complete Near-Extremal Trajectory and Associated Waveform
• Direct Detection of Dark Matter -- APPEC Committee Report
• Static and rotating black strings in dynamical Chern-Simons modified gravity
• Apparent Superluminality of Lensed Gravitational Waves
• What is the price of abandoning dark matter? Cosmological constraints on alternative gravity theories
• Gravitational wave as probe of superfluid dark matter
• Constraints from the Time Lag between Gravitational Waves and Gamma Rays: Implications of GW 170817 and GRB 170817A
• Model Comparison tests of modified gravity from the Eöt-Wash experiment
• Shortcomings of Shapiro delay-based tests of the equivalence principle on cosmological scales
• Nanohertz Gravitational Wave Astronomy during the SKA Era: An InPTA perspective
• Testing gravity with cosmic variance-limited pulsar timing array correlations
• Implication of GW170817 for cosmological bounces
• Constraining Energy-Momentum-Squared Gravity by binary pulsar observations
• Does GW170817 falsify MOND?
• Two Dimensional Clustering of Gamma-Ray Bursts using durations and hardness
• Strong lensing with superfluid dark matter
• Aether scalar tensor theory confronted with weak lensing data at small accelerations
• Gravity in mimetic scalar-tensor theories after GW170817
• Testing the Speed of Gravity with Black Hole Ringdown
• Time delay of timelike particles in gravitational lensing of Schwarzschild spacetime
• Constraints on differential Shapiro delay between neutrinos and photons from IceCube-170922A
• Consequences of the external field effect for MOND disk galaxies in galaxy clusters
• Blandford-Znajek jets in MOdified Gravity
• Astrophysical and Cosmological Searches for Lorentz Invariance Violation
• Planetary seismology as a test of modified gravity proposals
• Dark Matter in Fractional Gravity I: Astrophysical Tests on Galactic Scales
• Structure Formation in Nonlocal MOND
• Testing Non-minimally Coupled BEC Dark Matter with Gravitational Waves
• First Electromagnetic Pulse Associated with a Gravitational-Wave Event: Profile, Duration, and Delay
• A test of Radial Acceleration Relation for the {\it Giles et al Chandra} cluster sample
• Testing General Relativity with Gravitational Waves
• Testing MOG theory in the Milky Way
• Primordial regular black holes as all the dark matter. III. Covariant canonical quantum gravity models
• Testing Modified Gravity theory (MOG) with Type Ia Supernovae, Cosmic Chronometers and Baryon Acoustic Oscillations
• Constraints on Equivalence Principle Violation from Gamma Ray Bursts
• Scalar-tensor black holes in an expanding universe
• Prospects of Probing Dark Matter Condensates with Gravitational Waves
• Three problems of superfluid dark matter and their solution
• Consistent equivalence principle tests with fast radio bursts
• Superfluid dark matter in tension with weak gravitational lensing data
• Cosmology with LIGO/Virgo dark sirens: Hubble parameter and modified gravitational wave propagation
• Unveiling the Universe with Emerging Cosmological Probes
• A new scale in the quasi-static limit of Aether Scalar Tensor Theory
• Constraints on higher curvature gravity from time delay between GW170817 and GRB 170817A
• The role of the chemical potential in coupling superfluid dark matter to baryons
• A Critique of Covariant Emergent Gravity
• Does Gravity Fall Down? Evidence for Gravitational Wave Deflection Along the Line of Sight to GW 170817
• Cosmological Constant Effects on the Properties of Mass Twin Compact Stars
• Why did the dark matter hypothesis supersede modified gravity in the 1980s?
• On Filaments, Prolate Halos and Rotation Curves
• Galaxy clusters, cosmic chronometers and the Einstein equivalence principle
• Dark matter effect attributed to the inherent structure of cosmic space
• Higher order mimetic gravity after GW170817
• The Atacama Cosmology Telescope: A Test of the Gravitational Force Law on Cosmological Scales Using the Kinematic Sunyaev-Zeldovich Effect
• Constraining Einstein's Equivalence Principle With Multi-Wavelength Polarized astrophysical Sources
• Looking for ancillary signals around GW150914
• Gravitational Waves and Electromagnetic Transients
• No Proca Photons
• Embedding Cosmology and Gravity
• Eikonal gravitational-wave lensing in Einstein-aether theory
• Probing the parameters of a Schwarzschild black hole surrounded by quintessence and cloud of strings through four standard astrophysical tests
• Graviton spectrum in simplified Dark Matter models with graviton mediators in the de Sitter space
• Search for Cosmological time dilation from Gamma-Ray Bursts -- A 2021 status update
• A test of MOND and Emergent Gravity with SMACS J0723.3-7327 using eROSITA observations
• Light scalars in neutron star mergers
• Gravitomagnetism in Modified theory of Gravity