Shortcomings of Shapiro delay-based tests of the equivalence principle on cosmological scales
arXiv:1907.12453 · doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.100.104047
Abstract
The "Shapiro delay" experienced by an astronomical messenger traveling through a gravitational field has been used to place constraints on possible deviations from the equivalence principle. The standard Shapiro delay used to obtain these constraints is not itself an observable in general relativity, but is rather obtained by comparing with a fiducial Euclidean distance. There is not a mapping between the constraints obtained in this manner and alternative theories that exhibit equivalence principle violations. However, even assuming that the comparison with the fiducial Euclidean distance is carried out in a way that is useful for some class of alternative theories, we show that the standard calculation of these constraints cannot be applied on cosmological scales, as is often done. Specifically, we find that the Shapiro delay computed in the standard way (taking the Newtonian potential to vanish at infinity) diverges as one includes many remote sources. We use an infinite homogeneous lattice model to illustrate this divergence, and also show how the divergence can be cured by using Fermi coordinates associated with an observer. With this correction, one finds that the Shapiro delay is no longer monotonic with the number of sources. Thus, one cannot compute a conservative lower bound on the Shapiro delay using a subset of the sources of the gravitational field without further assumptions and/or observational input. As an illustration, we compute the Shapiro delay by applying the Fermi coordinate expression to two catalogs of galaxy clusters, illustrating the dependence of the result on the completeness of the catalogue and the mass estimates.
arXiv comment15 pages, 7 figures. Accepted manuscript in Phys. Rev. D
References in corpus (57)
- GW170817: Observation of Gravitational Waves from a Binary Neutron Star Inspiral
- The Confrontation between General Relativity and Experiment
- Gravitational Waves and Gamma-rays from a Binary Neutron Star Merger: GW170817 and GRB 170817A
- The galileon as a local modification of gravity
- The VizieR database of Astronomical Catalogues
- Properties of the binary neutron star merger GW170817
- Swope Supernova Survey 2017a (SSS17a), the Optical Counterpart to a Gravitational Wave Source
- The IAU 2000 resolutions for astrometry, celestial mechanics and metrology in the relativistic framework: explanatory supplement
- Gravitational Lensing in Astronomy
- Theorems on gravitational time delay and related issues
- A New Method for Determining Cumulative Gravitational Lensing Effects in Inhomogeneous Universes
- GW170817 Falsifies Dark Matter Emulators
- Galaxy Groups: A 2MASS Catalog
- Testing Einstein's Equivalence Principle with Fast Radio Bursts
- How well is our universe described by an FLRW model?
- General post-Minkowskian expansion of time transfer functions
- The Dipole Repeller
- The blackness of the cosmic microwave background spectrum as a probe of the distance-duality relation
- Friends-of-friends galaxy group finder with membership refinement. Application to the local Universe
- Cosmic Transients Test Einstein's Equivalence Principle out to GeV Energies
- Constraints on frequency-dependent violations of Shapiro delay from GW150914
- Arrival time differences between gravitational waves and electromagnetic signals due to gravitational lensing
- GW170817/GRB 170817A/AT2017gfo association: some implications for physics and astrophysics
- Testing the equivalence principle and Lorentz invariance with PeV neutrinos from blazar flares
- Limits on Einstein's Equivalence Principle from the first localized Fast Radio Burst FRB 150418
- Testing Einstein's Weak Equivalence Principle With Gravitational Waves
- On Testing the Equivalence Principle with Extragalactic Bursts
- Accurate light-time correction due to a gravitating mass
- Relativistic Celestial Mechanics with PPN Parameters
- A Generic Test of Modified Gravity Models which Emulate Dark Matter
- Tests of the Einstein Equivalence Principle using TeV Blazars
- Parameterized Post-Newtonian Cosmology
- Limits on the Neutrino Velocity, Lorentz Invariance, and the Weak Equivalence Principle with TeV Neutrinos from Gamma-Ray Bursts
- Gravity Gets There First with Dark Matter Emulators
- GRB/GW association: Long-short GRB candidates, time-lag, measuring gravitational wave velocity and testing Einstein's equivalence principle
- Multimessenger tests of the weak equivalence principle from GW170817 and its electromagnetic counterparts
- Limits on the Weak Equivalence Principle and Photon Mass with FRB 121102 Sub-pulses
- The Local Effects of Cosmological Variations in Physical 'Constants' and Scalar Fields I. Spherically Symmetric Spacetimes
- Post-Newtonian Cosmological Modelling
- Constraints on neutrino speed, weak equivalence principle violation, Lorentz invariance violation, and dual lensing from the first high-energy astrophysical neutrino source TXS 0506+056
- Constraints from the Time Lag between Gravitational Waves and Gamma Rays: Implications of GW 170817 and GRB 170817A
- Testing Einstein's weak equivalence principle with a 0.4-nanosecond giant pulse of the Crab pulsar
- Cosmological backreaction in the presence of radiation and a cosmological constant
- New test of weak equivalence principle using polarized light from astrophysical events
- Testing Einstein's Equivalence Principle with Short Gamma-ray Bursts
- A New Method to Test the Einstein's Weak Equivalence Principle
- A useful guide for gravitational wave observers to test modified gravity models
- Test of Weak Equivalence Principle with the multi-band timing of the Crab Pulsar
- The Galactic One-Way Shapiro Delay to PSR B1937+21
- Time transfer functions in Schwarzschild-like metrics in the weak-field limit: A unified description of Shapiro and lensing effects
- Testing the Einstein's equivalence principle with polarized gamma-ray bursts
- Constraints on differential Shapiro delay between neutrinos and photons from IceCube-170922A
- Galactic Shapiro Delay to the Crab Pulsar and limit on Einstein's Equivalence Principle Violation
- Test of the Weak Equivalence Principle using LIGO observations of GW150914 and Fermi observations of GBM transient 150914
- Testing the Weak Equivalence Principle using Optical and Near-Infrared Crab Pulses
- Cosmic Transients, Einstein's Equivalence Principle and Dark Matter Halos
- Precision Test of the Weak Equivalence Principle from Gamma-Ray Burst Polarization
Cited by in corpus (15)
- Neutron Star Mergers and How to Study Them
- Testing Theories of Gravity with Planetary Ephemerides
- Consistent Constraints on the Equivalence Principle from localised Fast Radio Bursts
- Testing General Relativity with Gravitational Waves
- Quantum gravity phenomenology at the dawn of the multi-messenger era -- A review
- Constraints on Equivalence Principle Violation from Gamma Ray Bursts
- Consistent equivalence principle tests with fast radio bursts
- Impact of Cosmology on Lorentz Invariance Violation Constraints from GRB Time-Delays
- How limiting is optical follow-up for fast radio burst applications? Forecasts for radio and optical surveys
- Constraining violations of the Weak Equivalence Principle Using CHIME FRBs
- Constraining Einstein's Equivalence Principle With Multi-Wavelength Polarized astrophysical Sources
- Strong lensing in multimessenger astronomy as a test of the equivalence principle
- Some applications of the Shapiro time delay
- Upper limits on Einstein's weak equivalence principle placed by uncertainties of dispersion measures of fast radio bursts
- Observing GW190521-like binary black holes and their environment with LISA