ALMA Reveals Transition of Polarization Pattern with Wavelength in HL Tau's Disk

Abstract

The mechanism for producing polarized emission from protostellar disks at (sub)millimeter wavelengths is currently uncertain. Classically, polarization is expected from non-spherical grains aligned with the magnetic field. Recently, two alternatives have been suggested. One polarization mechanism is caused by self-scattering from dust grains of sizes comparable to the wavelength while the other mechanism is due to grains aligned with their short axes along the direction of radiation anisotropy. The latter has recently been shown as a likely mechanism for causing the dust polarization detected in HL Tau at 3.1 mm. In this paper, we present ALMA polarization observations of HL Tau for two more wavelengths: 870 $\mu$m and 1.3 mm. The morphology at 870 $\mu$m matches the expectation for self-scattering, while that at 1.3 mm shows a mix between self-scattering and grains aligned with the radiation anisotropy. The observations cast doubt on the ability of (sub)millimeter continuum polarization to probe disk magnetic fields for at least HL Tau. By showing two distinct polarization morphologies at 870 $\mu$m and 3.1 mm and a transition between the two at 1.3 mm, this paper provides definitive evidence that the dominant (sub)millimeter polarization mechanism transitions with wavelength. In addition, if the polarization at 870 $\mu$m is due to scattering, the lack of polarization asymmetry along the minor axis of the inclined disk implies that the large grains responsible for the scattering have already settled into a geometrically thin layer, and the presence of asymmetry along the major axis indicates that the HL Tau disk is not completely axisymmetric.

Accepted to ApJ, typos corrected from proof

References in corpus (11)

• Radiative torques: Analytical Model and Basic Properties
• Tracing Magnetic Fields with Aligned Grains
• Magnetic Fields in the Formation of Sun-Like Stars
• The evidence of radio polarization induced by the radiative grain alignment and self-scattering of dust grains in a protoplanetary disk
• Spatially Resolved Magnetic Field Structure in the Disk of a T Tauri Star
• Submillimeter polarization observation of the protoplanetary disk around HD 142527
• The Magnetic Field in the Class 0 Protostellar Disk of L1527
• Investigating dust trapping in transition disks with millimeter-wave polarization
• An Ordered Magnetic Field in the Protoplanetary Disk of AB Aur Revealed by Mid-Infrared Polarimetry
• 1.3mm polarized emission in the circumstellar disk of a massive protostar
• Mid-Infrared Polarization of Herbig Ae/Be Discs

Cited by in corpus (56)

• The anomalously low (sub)millimeter spectral indices of some protoplanetary disks may be explained by dust self-scattering
• Interferometric observations of magnetic fields in forming stars
• The role of magnetic fields in the formation of protostellar discs
• Nonsticky Ice at the Origin of the Uniformly Polarized Submillimeter Emission from the HL Tau Disk
• Dust Polarization Toward Embedded Protostars in Ophiuchus with ALMA. II. IRAS 16293-2422
• What Produces Dust Polarization in the HH 212 Protostellar Disk at 878 μm: Dust Self-Scattering or Dichroic Extinction?
• Radial variations in grain sizes and dust scale heights in the protoplanetary disk around HD 163296 revealed by ALMA polarization observation
• How large are the monomers of dust aggregates in planet-forming disks?: Insights from quantitative optical and near-infrared polarimetry
• On Internal and External Alignment of Dust Grains in Protostellar Environments
• Intrinsic polarisation of elongated porous dust grains
• Porous Dust Particles in Protoplanetary Disks: Application to the HL Tau Disk
• Collisional Growth and Fragmentation of Dust Aggregates with Low Mass Ratios. I: Critical Collision Velocity for Water Ice
• Millimeter-wave polarization due to grain alignment by the gas flow in protoplanetary disks
• The impact of non-ideal magnetohydrodynamic processes on discs, outflows, counter-rotation and magnetic walls during the early stages of star formation
• Solving grain size inconsistency between ALMA polarization and VLA continuum in the Ophiuchus IRS 48 protoplanetary disk
• Millimeter-sized Dust Grains Appear Surviving the Water-sublimating Temperature in the Inner 10 au of the FU Ori Disk
• A Pseudodisk Threaded with a Toroidal and Pinched Poloidal Magnetic Field Morphology in the HH 211 Protostellar System
• Impact of Differential Dust Settling on the SED and Polarization: Application to the Inner Region of the HL Tau Disk
• Self-scattering of non-spherical dust grains
• Do we need non-ideal magnetohydrodynamics to model protostellar discs?
• Polarized emission by aligned grains in the Mie regime : application to protoplanetary disks observed by ALMA
• On the stickiness of CO${}_2$ and H${}_2$O ice particles
• On the magnetic field properties of protostellar envelopes in Orion
• Low Level Carbon Monoxide Line Polarization in two Protoplanetary Disks: HD 142527 and IM Lup
• SOFIA observations of 30 Doradus: I -- Far-Infrared dust polarization and implications for grain alignment and disruption by radiative torques
• Modeling of the ALMA HL Tau Polarization by Mixture of Grain Alignment and Self-scattering
• Size limit of superparamagnetic inclusions in dust grains and difficulty of magnetic grain alignment in protoplanetary disks
• (Sub)millimeter Dust Polarization of Protoplanetary Disks from Scattering by Large Millimeter-Sized Irregular Grains
• Constraining the magnetic field properties of Bok globule B335 using SOFIA/HAWC+
• Self-scattering in protoplanetary disks with dust settling
• JCMT POL-2 and ALMA polarimetric observations of 6000-100 au scales in the protostar B335: linking magnetic field and gas kinematics in observations and MHD simulations
• Magnetohydrodynamics of protoplanetary discs
• Discovery of Molecular Line Polarization in the Disk of TW Hya
• Self-scattering on large, porous grains in protoplanetary disks with dust settling
• Thermal Emission and Scattering by Aligned Grains: Plane-Parallel Model and Application to Multiwavelength Polarization of the HL Tau Disk
• Polarization from Aligned Dust Grains in the $\beta$ Pic Debris Disk
• Rotational Disruption of Porous Dust Aggregates due to Gas Flow in Protoplanetary Disks
• Probing the Temperature Structure of Optically Thick Disks Using Polarized Emission of Aligned Grains
• Three-dimensional magnetic field imaging of protoplanetary disks using Zeeman broadening and linear polarization observations
• On Far-Infrared and Submm Circular Polarization
• Linear dust polarization during the embedded phase of protostar formation
• Investigating the Bouncing Barrier with Collision Simulations of Compressed Dust Aggregates
• Evidence of Grain Alignment by Magnetically Enhanced Radiative Torques from Multiwavelength Dust Polarization Modeling of HL Tau
• Tracing the large-scale magnetic field morphology in protoplanetary disks using molecular line polarization
• Dust ring and gap formation by gas flow induced by low-mass planets embedded in protoplanetary disks $\mathrm{I}$. Steady-state model
• Synthetic Modelling of Polarized Dust Emission in Intermediate-Mass YSOs: I: Constraining the Role of Iron Inclusions and Inelastic Relaxation on Grain Alignment with ALMA Polarization
• Multi-frequency analysis of the ALMA and VLA high resolution continuum observations of the substructured disc around CI Tau. Preference for sub-mm-sized low-porosity amorphous carbon grains
• Characterization of mid-infrared polarization due to scattering in protoplanetary disks
• Dynamics of magnetic flux tubes in accretion discs of T Tauri stars
• Physicochemical Controls on the Compositions of the Earth and Planets
• Probing Magnetic Fields in Protoplanetary Disk Atmospheres through Polarized Optical/IR Light Scattered by Aligned Grains
• Wavelength-dependent far-infrared polarization of HL Tau observed with SOFIA/HAWC+
• GTC/CanariCam Mid-IR Polarimetry of Magnetic Fields in Star-Forming Region W51 IRS2
• Exploring Polarized Millimeter Emission from Protoplanetary Disks with Irregular Dust Grains
• Constraints on axion-like ultralight dark matter from observations of the HL Tauri protoplanetary disk
• History of the Solar Nebula from Meteorite Paleomagnetism