The Open Flux Problem

Abstract

The heliospheric magnetic field is of pivotal importance in solar and space physics. The field is rooted in the Sun's photosphere, where it has been observed for many years. Global maps of the solar magnetic field based on full disk magnetograms are commonly used as boundary conditions for coronal and solar wind models. Two primary observational constraints on the models are (1) the open field regions in the model should approximately correspond to coronal holes observed in emission, and (2) the magnitude of the open magnetic flux in the model should match that inferred from in situ spacecraft measurements. In this study, we calculate both MHD and PFSS solutions using fourteen different magnetic maps produced from five different types of observatory magnetograms, for the time period surrounding July, 2010. We have found that for all of the model/map combinations, models that have coronal hole areas close to observations underestimate the interplanetary magnetic flux, or, conversely, for models to match the interplanetary flux, the modeled open field regions are larger than coronal holes observed in EUV emission. In an alternative approach, we estimate the open magnetic flux entirely from solar observations by combining automatically detected coronal holes for Carrington rotation 2098 with observatory synoptic magnetic maps. This approach also underestimates the interplanetary magnetic flux. Our results imply that either typical observatory maps underestimate the Sun's magnetic flux, or a significant portion of the open magnetic flux is not rooted in regions that are obviously dark in EUV and X-ray emission.

References in corpus (17)

• A Model for the Sources of the Slow Solar Wind
• Magnetic Landscape of Sun's Polar Region
• The Sun's Global Photospheric and Coronal Magnetic Fields: Observations and Models
• Advancements in the ADAPT Photospheric Flux Transport Model
• Magnetic Topology of Coronal Hole Linkages
• Automated Coronal Hole Detection using Local Intensity Thresholding Techniques
• Coronal Holes and Open Magnetic Flux over Cycles 23 and 24
• Synchronic coronal hole mapping using multi-instrument EUV images: Data preparation and detection method
• Low-Latitude Coronal Holes at the Minimum of the 23rd Solar Cycle
• Interpretation of Solar Magnetic Field Strength Observations
• Measurements of EUV Coronal Holes and Open Magnetic Flux
• A Steady-State Picture of Solar Wind Acceleration and Charge State Composition Derived from a Global Wave-Driven MHD Model
• The 2008 August 1 Eclipse Solar-Minimum Corona Unraveled
• Segmentation of Coronal Holes Using Active Contours Without Edges
• Sources of The Slow Solar wind During the Solar Cycle 23/24 Minimum
• Coronal Mass Ejections and the Solar Cycle Variation of the Sun's Open Flux
• Influence of Non-Potential Coronal Magnetic Topology on Solar-Wind Models

Cited by in corpus (80)

• The Solar Orbiter mission -- Science overview
• The Polarimetric and Helioseismic Imager on Solar Orbiter
• Sun-to-Earth MHD Simulation of the 14 July 2000 "Bastille Day" Eruption
• Parker Solar Probe: Four Years of Discoveries at Solar Cycle Minimum
• Critical Science Plan for the Daniel K. Inouye Solar Telescope (DKIST)
• The role of Alfvén wave dynamics on the large scale properties of the solar wind: comparing an MHD simulation with PSP E1 data
• Validation of the Alfvén Wave Solar atmosphere Model (AWSoM) with Observations from the Low Corona to 1 AU
• Statistical Analysis and Catalog of Non-polar Coronal Holes Covering the SDO-era using CATCH
• Enhancing SDO/HMI images using deep learning
• Global Non-Potential Magnetic Models of the Solar Corona During the March 2015 Eclipse
• Estimating Total Open Heliospheric Magnetic Flux
• Do non-dipolar magnetic fields contribute to spin-down torques?
• Defining the Middle Corona
• Coronal Hole Detection and Open Magnetic Flux
• COCONUT, a novel fast-converging MHD model for solar corona simulations: I. Benchmarking and optimization of polytropic solutions
• The Effect of Magnetic Variability on Stellar Angular Momentum Loss I: The Solar Wind Torque During Sunspot Cycles 23 & 24
• Small-scale Flux Emergence, Coronal Hole Heating, and Flux-tube Expansion: A Hybrid Solar Wind Model
• Coronal Magnetic Field Topology From Total Solar Eclipse Observations
• Evolution of star-planet systems under magnetic braking and tidal interaction
• Reconstructing coronal hole areas with EUHFORIA and adapted WSA model: optimising the model parameters
• Measurement of the Open Magnetic Flux in the Inner Heliosphere down to 0.13AU
• Alfvén-wave driven magnetic rotator winds from low-mass stars I: rotation dependences of magnetic braking and mass-loss rate
• Using Parker Solar Probe observations during the first four perihelia to constrain global magnetohydrodynamic models
• Magnetograph Saturation and the Open Flux Problem
• COCONUT, a novel fast-converging MHD model for solar corona simulations: II. Assessing the impact of the input magnetic map on space-weather forecasting at minimum of activity
• Implementing the MULTI-VP coronal model in EUHFORIA: test case results and comparisons with the WSA coronal model
• The Observational Uncertainty of Coronal Hole Boundaries in Automated Detection Schemes
• The Sun's Dynamic Extended Corona Observed in Extreme Ultraviolet
• Forecasting the Ambient Solar Wind with Numerical Models. II. An Adaptive Prediction System for Specifying Solar Wind Speed Near the Sun
• Variations in Finite Difference Potential Fields
• Energetic Proton Propagation and Acceleration Simulated for the Bastille Day Event of July 14, 2000
• Assessing the Influence of Input Magnetic Maps on Global Modeling of the Solar Wind and CME-driven Shock in the 2013 April 11 Event
• Simulations of solar wind variations during an 11-year cycle and the influence of north-south asymmetry
• SWASTi-SW: Space Weather Adaptive SimulaTion framework for Solar Wind and its relevance to ADITYA-L1 mission
• Non-LTE inversions of a confined X2.2 flare: I. Vector magnetic field in the photosphere and chromosphere
• Linking the Sun to the Heliosphere Using Composition Data and Modelling. A Test Case with a Coronal Jet
• Application of a Modified Spheromak Model to Simulations of Coronal Mass Ejection in the Inner Heliosphere
• Predicting the Solar Wind at Parker Solar Probe Using an Empirically Driven MHD Model
• Ensemble simulations of the 12 July 2012 Coronal Mass Ejection with the Constant Turn Flux Rope Model
• The winds of young Solar-type stars in the Hyades
• Observation of Alfvén Wave Reflection in the Solar Chromosphere: Ponderomotive Force and First Ionization Potential Effect
• Global Coronal Equilibria with Solar Wind Outflow
• Machine-learning approach to identification of coronal holes in solar disk images and synoptic maps
• Does Nearby Open Flux Affect the Eruptivity of Solar Active Regions?
• Coupled MHD-Focused Transport Simulations for Modeling Solar Particle Events
• Calibrating GONG Magnetograms with End-to-end Instrument Simulation III: Comparison, Calibration, and Results
• Improved detection of farside solar active regions using deep learning
• Statistical Evidence for Small-Scale Interchange Reconnection at a Coronal Hole Boundary
• How to Estimate the Far-Side Open Flux using STEREO Coronal Holes
• Magnetograms underestimate even unipolar magnetic flux nearly everywhere on the solar disk
• Solar wind modeling with the Alfven Wave Solar atmosphere Model driven by HMI-based Near-Real-Time maps by the National Solar Observatory
• Limitations and biases in the retrieval of the polar magnetic field I: the role of the magnetic filling factor in Milne-Eddington inversions of simulated Hinode/SP data
• Calibrating GONG Magnetograms with End-to-end Instrument Simulation I: Background, the GONG Instrument, and End-to-end Simulation
• A journey of exploration to the polar regions of a star: probing the solar poles and the heliosphere from high helio-latitude
• Accounting for Differential Rotation in Calculations of the Sun's Angular Momentum-loss Rate
• Solar Polar Flux Redistribution based on Observed Coronal Holes
• Modeling CME encounters at Parker Solar Probe with OSPREI: Dependence on photospheric and coronal conditions
• Which Component of Solar Magnetic Field Drives the Evolution of Interplanetary Magnetic Field over Solar Cycle?
• Calibrating GONG Magnetograms with End-to-end Instrument Simulation II: Theory of Calibration
• Uncertainty Estimates of Solar Wind Prediction using HMI Photospheric Vector and Spatial Standard Deviation Synoptic Maps
• Rotational evolution of young-to-old stars with data-driven three-dimensional wind models
• The nonuniformity of poleward flux transport on the solar surface: a statistical method applied to solar cycles 21-24
• Straight outta photosphere: Open solar flux without coronal modeling
• Coronal magnetic field evolution over the cycle 24
• Space weather: the solar perspective -- an update to Schwenn (2006)
• The Sun's open-closed flux boundary and the origin of the slow solar wind
• Evaluation of Coronal and Interplanetary Magnetic Field Extrapolation Using PSP Solar Wind Observation
• Ensemble Modeling of the Solar Wind Flow with Boundary Conditions Governed by Synchronic Photospheric Magnetograms. I. Multi-point Validation in the Inner Heliosphere
• Magnetic Field-Constrained Ensemble Image Segmentation of Coronal Holes in Chromospheric Observations
• Using sunRunner3D to interpret the global structure of the heliosphere from in situ measurements
• Simulating the Solar Corona with Multiple Solar Photospheric Magnetic Maps during the 8 April 2024 Total Solar Eclipse
• Existence of The Closed Magnetic Field Lines Crossing The Coronal Hole Boundaries
• The impact of stellar winds and tidal locking effects on the habitability of Earth-like exoplanets around M dwarf stars
• The mean solar butterfly diagram and poloidal field generation rate at the surface of the Sun
• The rush to the poles and the role of magnetic buoyancy in the solar dynamo
• Solar Energetic Particle Events with Short and Long Onset Times
• Investigating the Relationship Between Physical Properties and Spatial Irregularities at Coronal Hole Boundaries
• Enhancing MHD model accuracy and CME forecasting by constraining coronal plasma properties with Faraday rotation
• What Determines the Brightness of the Magnetically Open Solar Corona?: Insights from Three-dimensional Radiative Magnetohydrodynamic Simulations and Observations
• Testing the Alfvén-wave model of the solar wind with interplanetary scintillation