The Effect of Magnetic Variability on Stellar Angular Momentum Loss I: The Solar Wind Torque During Sunspot Cycles 23 & 24

Abstract

The rotational evolution of cool stars is governed by magnetised stellar winds which slow the stellar rotation during their main sequence lifetimes. Magnetic variability is commonly observed in Sun-like stars, and the changing strength and topology of the global field is expected to affect the torque exerted by the stellar wind. We present three different methods for computing the angular momentum loss in the solar wind. Two are based on MHD simulations from Finley & Matt (2018), with one using the open flux measured in the solar wind, and the other using remotely-observed surface magnetograms. Both methods agree in the variation of the solar torque seen through the solar cycle and show a 30-40% decrease from cycle 23 to 24. The two methods calculate different average values, $2.9\times 10^{30}$erg (open flux) and $0.35\times 10^{30}$erg (surface field). This discrepancy results from the already well-known difficulty with reconciling the magnetograms with observed open flux, which is currently not understood, leading to an inability to discriminate between these two calculated torques. The third method is based on the observed spin-rates of Sun-like stars, which decrease with age, directly probing the average angular momentum loss. This method gives $6.2\times 10^{30}$erg for the solar torque, larger than the other methods. This may be indicative of further variability in the solar torque on timescales much longer than the magnetic cycle. We discuss the implications for applying the formula to other Sun-like stars, where only surface field measurements are available, and where the magnetic variations are ill-constrained.

arXiv comment16 pages + 4 figures, accepted for publication to ApJ

References in corpus (79)

• PLUTO: a Numerical Code for Computational Astrophysics
• New evolutionary models for pre-main sequence and main sequence low-mass stars down to the hydrogen-burning limit
• On the rotational evolution of solar- and late-type stars, its magnetic origins, and the possibility of stellar gyrochronology
• Self-consistent Coronal Heating and Solar Wind Acceleration from Anisotropic Magnetohydrodynamic Turbulence
• Measuring the rotation period distribution of field M-dwarfs with Kepler
• Solar Orbiter: Exploring the Sun-heliosphere connection
• Stellar magnetism: empirical trends with age and rotation
• Weakened magnetic braking as the origin of anomalously rapid rotation in old field stars
• Improved angular momentum evolution model for solar-like stars
• Simulations of dynamo action in fully convective stars
• The Mass-Dependence of Angular Momentum Evolution in Sun-Like Stars
• A spin-down clock for cool stars from observations of a 2.5-billion-year-old cluster
• Toroidal versus poloidal magnetic fields in Sun-like stars: a rotation threshold
• The Dependence of Differential Rotation on Temperature and Rotation
• The Kepler Cluster Study: Stellar Rotation in NGC6811
• Magnetic Braking Formulation for Sun-Like Stars: Dependence on Dipole Field Strength and Rotation Rate
• Evidence for Magnetic Flux Saturation in Rapidly Rotating M Stars
• The large-scale axisymmetric magnetic topology of avery-low-mass fully-convective star
• The effect of magnetic topology on thermally-driven winds: towards a general formulation of the braking law
• Patterns of photometric and chromospheric variation among Sun-like stars: A 20-year perspective
• Improved angular momentum evolution model for solar-like stars II. Exploring the mass dependence
• Rotation in the Pleiades with K2: I. Data and First Results
• Fast Star, Slow Star; Old Star, Young Star: Subgiant Rotation as a Population and Stellar Physics Diagnostic
• The Sun in Time: Activity and Environment
• A Volume-limited Sample of 63 M7-M9.5 Dwarfs II. Activity, magnetism, and the fade of the rotation-dominated dynamo
• Observations of Cool-Star Magnetic Fields
• The Open Flux Problem
• Can we predict the global magnetic topology of a pre-main sequence star from its position in the Hertzsprung-Russell diagram?
• Magnetic cycles of the planet-hosting star tauBootis
• The evolution of surface magnetic fields in young solar-type stars I: the first 250 Myr
• The stable magnetic field of the fullly-convective star V374 Peg
• Stellar rotation in the Hyades and Praesepe: gyrochronology and braking timescale
• Origins of the Ambient Solar Wind: Implications for Space Weather
• Solar Magnetic Field Reversals and the Role of Dynamo Families
• The evolution of surface magnetic fields in young solar-type stars II: The early main sequence (250-650 Myr)
• The Mount Wilson Observatory S-index of the Sun
• Stellar Evidence that the Solar Dynamo may be in Transition
• Mass loss in pre-main sequence stars via coronal mass ejections and implications for angular momentum loss
• Rotating models of young solar-type stars : Exploring braking laws and angular momentum transport processes
• Poking the Beehive From Space: K2 Rotation Periods For Praesepe
• Rotation periods for cool stars in the 4 Gyr-old open cluster M67, the solar-stellar connection, and the applicability of gyrochronology to at least solar age
• Strong dipole magnetic fields in fast rotating fully convective stars
• Asymptotic g modes: Evidence for a rapid rotation of the solar core
• Evolution of the solar magnetic flux on time scales of years to millenia
• Stellar Winds on the Main-Sequence I: Wind Model
• A Global Wave-Driven MHD Solar Model with a Unified Treatment of Open and Closed Magnetic Field Topologies
• Coupling the solar dynamo and the corona: wind properties, mass and momentum losses during an activity cycle
• A solar-like magnetic cycle on the mature K-dwarf 61 Cyg A (HD 201091)
• Long-term magnetic field monitoring of the Sun-like star ξBootis A
• The Effect of Combined Magnetic Geometries on Thermally Driven Winds II: Dipolar, Quadrupolar and Octupolar Topologies
• The energy budget of stellar magnetic fields
• The Factory and The Beehive I. Rotation Periods For Low-Mass Stars in Praesepe
• Prospects for Detection of Exoplanet Magnetic Fields Through Bow-Shock Observations During Transits
• Coronal Holes and Open Magnetic Flux over Cycles 23 and 24
• A multiple flux-tube solar wind model
• Stellar winds, dead zones, and coronal mass ejections
• The Missing Magnetic Morphology Term in Stellar Rotation Evolution
• Simulating the environment around planet-hosting stars - II. Stellar winds and inner astrospheres
• Rotational evolution of slow-rotators sequence stars
• Inbound waves in the solar corona: a direct indicator of Alfvén Surface location
• The dependence of stellar mass and angular momentum losses on latitude and on active region and dipolar magnetic fields
• The Independency of Stellar Mass Loss Rates on stellar X-ray Luminosity and Activity Level based on Solar X-ray flux and Solar Wind Observations
• Direct observation of magnetic cycles in Sun-like stars
• Exoplanets as probes of the winds of host stars: the case of the M dwarf GJ 436
• Convection and Differential Rotation Properties of G & K Stars Computed with the ASH Code
• Age dependence of wind properties for solar type stars: a 3d study
• Sounding stellar cycles with Kepler - II. Ground-based observations
• Why are rapidly rotating M dwarfs in the Pleiades so (infra)red? New period measurements confirm rotation-dependent color offsets from the cluster sequence
• The Effect of Combined Magnetic Geometries on Thermally Driven Winds I: Interaction of Dipolar and Quadrupolar Fields
• Global solar magnetic field organization in the outer corona: influence on the solar wind speed and mass flux over the cycle
• Magnetic braking of Sun-like and low-mass stars: Dependence on coronal temperature
• A semi-empirical model for magnetic braking of solar-type stars
• The open flux evolution of a solar-mass star on the main sequence
• Flux-tube geometry and solar wind speed during an activity cycle
• The Solar Wind Environment in Time
• Linking Stellar Coronal Activity and Rotation at 500 Myr: A Deep Chandra Observation of M37
• Influence of Non-Potential Coronal Magnetic Topology on Solar-Wind Models
• Polar Field Correction for HMI Line-of-Sight Synoptic Data
• A survey of TiOλ567 nm absorption in solar-type stars

Cited by in corpus (39)

• First grids of low-mass stellar models and isochrones with self-consistent treatment of rotation : From 0.2 to 1.5 M_\odot at 7 metallicities from PMS to TAMS
• Do non-dipolar magnetic fields contribute to spin-down torques?
• Direct evidence of a full dipole flip during the magnetic cycle of a sun-like star
• Alfvén-wave driven magnetic rotator winds from low-mass stars I: rotation dependences of magnetic braking and mass-loss rate
• The solar wind from a stellar perspective: how do low-resolution data impact the determination of wind properties?
• The Solar Wind in Time II: 3D stellar wind structure and radio emission
• The Magnetic Nature of the Cataclysmic Variable Period Gap
• Direct Detection of Solar Angular Momentum Loss with the Wind Spacecraft
• The space weather around the exoplanet GJ 436 b. II. Stellar wind-exoplanet interactions
• Flux conservation, radial scalings, Mach numbers, and critical distances in the solar wind: magnetohydrodynamics and Ulysses observations
• Linear Stability in the Inner Heliosphere: Helios Reëvaluated
• Magnetic braking with MESA evolutionary models in the single star and LMXB regimes
• Constraints on Magnetic Braking from the G8 Dwarf Stars 61 UMa and $\tau$ Cet
• An Earth-like stellar wind environment for Proxima Centauri c
• Lambda And: A post-main sequence wind from a solar-mass star
• The winds of young Solar-type stars in the Hyades
• Solar Angular Momentum Loss Over the Past Several Millennia
• Asteroseismology and Spectropolarimetry of the Exoplanet Host Star $\lambda$ Serpentis
• The Effect of Magnetic Variability on Stellar Angular Momentum Loss II: The Sun, 61 Cygni A, $\epsilon$ Eridani, $\xi$ Bootis A and $\tau$ Bootis A
• Modeling Solar Wind Variations over an 11-yr Cycle with Alfvén Wave Dissipation: a Parameter Study
• Eruption and propagation of twisted flux ropes from the base of the solar corona to 1 au
• Numerical quantification of the wind properties of cool main sequence stars
• The Solar Wind Angular Momentum Flux as Observed by Parker Solar Probe
• Kepler main-sequence solar-like stars: surface rotation and magnetic-activity evolution
• The Contribution of Alpha Particles to the Solar Wind Angular Momentum Flux in the Inner Heliosphere
• Impact of Changing Stellar and Planetary Magnetic Fields on (Exo)planetary Environments and Atmospheric Mass Loss
• How much do underestimated field strengths from Zeeman-Doppler imaging affect spin-down torque estimates?
• Transition of latitudinal differential rotation as a possible cause of weakened magnetic braking of solar-type stars
• A journey of exploration to the polar regions of a star: probing the solar poles and the heliosphere from high helio-latitude
• Weakened Magnetic Braking Signals the Collapse of the Global Stellar Dynamo
• Effect of Differential Rotation on Magnetic Braking of Low-Mass and Solar-Like Stars: A Proof-of-Concept Study
• Testing the Rossby Paradigm: Weakened Magnetic Braking in early K-type Stars
• Rotational evolution of young-to-old stars with data-driven three-dimensional wind models
• The effect of turbulence on the angular momentum of the solar wind
• The solar-wind angular-momentum flux observed during Solar Orbiter's first orbit
• Magnetic braking and dynamo evolution of $\beta$ Hydri
• Reconstructing the Sun's Alfvén surface and wind braking torque with Parker Solar Probe
• Zeeman Doppler Imaging of $\tau$Ceti: The Weakest Magnetic Field Detected in a Sun-like Star
• The winds of young Solar-type stars in Coma Berenices and Hercules-Lyra