Coronal Hole Detection and Open Magnetic Flux

Abstract

Many scientists use coronal hole (CH) detections to infer open magnetic flux. Detection techniques differ in the areas that they assign as open, and may obtain different values for the open magnetic flux. We characterize the uncertainties of these methods, by applying six different detection methods to deduce the area and open flux of a near-disk center CH observed on 9/19/2010, and applying a single method to five different EUV filtergrams for this CH. Open flux was calculated using five different magnetic maps. The standard deviation (interpreted as the uncertainty) in the open flux estimate for this CH was about 26%. However, including the variability of different magnetic data sources, this uncertainty almost doubles to 45%. We use two of the methods to characterize the area and open flux for all CHs in this time period. We find that the open flux is greatly underestimated compared to values inferred from in-situ measurements (by 2.2-4 times). We also test our detection techniques on simulated emission images from a thermodynamic MHD model of the solar corona. We find that the methods overestimate the area and open flux in the simulated CH, but the average error in the flux is only about 7%. The full-Sun detections on the simulated corona underestimate the model open flux, but by factors well below what is needed to account for the missing flux in the observations. Under-detection of open flux in coronal holes likely contributes to the recognized deficit in solar open flux, but is unlikely to resolve it.

arXiv comment28 pages, 10 figures, submitted to ApJ

References in corpus (24)

• Self-consistent Coronal Heating and Solar Wind Acceleration from Anisotropic Magnetohydrodynamic Turbulence
• Alfven Wave Solar Model (AWSoM): Coronal Heating
• CHIANTI - An atomic database for Emission Lines. Version 8
• A Model for the Sources of the Slow Solar Wind
• The Open Flux Problem
• Advancements in the ADAPT Photospheric Flux Transport Model
• Heliophysics Event Knowledgebase for the Solar Dynamics Observatory and Beyond
• The SWAP EUV Imaging Telescope Part I: Instrument Overview and Pre-Flight Testing
• Automated Coronal Hole Detection using Local Intensity Thresholding Techniques
• The role of Alfvén wave dynamics on the large scale properties of the solar wind: comparing an MHD simulation with PSP E1 data
• Towards a Realistic, Data-Driven Thermodynamic MHD Model of the Global Solar Corona
• Coronal Holes and Open Magnetic Flux over Cycles 23 and 24
• Statistical Analysis and Catalog of Non-polar Coronal Holes Covering the SDO-era using CATCH
• Synchronic coronal hole mapping using multi-instrument EUV images: Data preparation and detection method
• Automated Coronal Hole Identification via Multi-Thermal Intensity Segmentation
• Estimating Total Open Heliospheric Magnetic Flux
• Closed-Field Coronal Heating Driven by Wave Turbulence
• Characteristics of Low-Latitude Coronal Holes near the Maximum of Solar cycle 24
• Measurements of EUV Coronal Holes and Open Magnetic Flux
• Measurement of the Open Magnetic Flux in the Inner Heliosphere down to 0.13AU
• The Evolution of Inverted Magnetic Fields Through the Inner Heliosphere
• Using Parker Solar Probe observations during the first four perihelia to constrain global magnetohydrodynamic models
• Segmentation of Coronal Holes Using Active Contours Without Edges
• Variations in Finite Difference Potential Fields

Cited by in corpus (5)

• Magnetograph Saturation and the Open Flux Problem
• Improved AI-generated Solar Farside Magnetograms by STEREO and SDO Data Sets and Their Release
• Validation scheme for solar coronal models -- constraints from multi-perspective observations in EUV and white-light
• Solar Polar Flux Redistribution based on Observed Coronal Holes
• Existence of The Closed Magnetic Field Lines Crossing The Coronal Hole Boundaries