Selection bias in dynamically-measured supermassive black hole samples: Scaling relations and correlations between residuals in semi-analytic galaxy formation models

Abstract

Recent work has confirmed that the masses of supermassive black holes, estimated from scaling relations with global properties such as the stellar masses of their host galaxies, may be biased high. Much of this may be caused by the requirement that the gravitational sphere of influence of the black hole must be resolved for the black-hole mass to be reliably estimated. We revisit this issue by using a comprehensive galaxy evolution semi-analytic model, which self-consistently evolves supermassive black holes from high-redshift seeds via gas accretion and mergers, and also includes AGN feedback. Once tuned to reproduce the (mean) correlation of black-hole mass with velocity dispersion, the model is unable to also account for the correlation with stellar mass. This behaviour is independent of the model's parameters, thus suggesting an internal inconsistency in the data. The predicted distributions, especially at the low-mass end, are also much broader than observed. However, if selection effects are included, the model's predictions tend to align with the observations. We also demonstrate that the correlations between the residuals of the local scaling relations are more effective than the scaling relations themselves at constraining AGN feedback models. In fact, we find that our semi-analytic model, while in apparent broad agreement with the scaling relations when accounting for selection biases, yields very weak correlations between their residuals at fixed stellar mass, in stark contrast with observations. This problem persists when changing the AGN feedback strength, and is also present in the $z\sim 0$ outputs of the hydrodynamic cosmological simulation Horizon-AGN, which includes state-of-the-art treatments of AGN feedback. This suggests that current AGN feedback models may be too weak or are simply not capturing the effect of the black hole on the stellar velocity dispersion.

11 pages, 7 figures. Minor changes to match version to be published in MNRAS

References in corpus (13)

• The hierarchical formation of the brightest cluster galaxies
• An Observational Determination of the Bolometric Quasar Luminosity Function
• The Illustris simulation: the evolving population of black holes across cosmic time
• The MORGANA model for the rise of galaxies and active nuclei
• A catalogue of 2D photometric decompositions in the SDSS-DR7 spectroscopic main galaxy sample: preferred models and systematics
• Black Hole Growth in Hierarchical Galaxy Formation
• The cosmic growth of the active black hole population at 1<z<2 in zCOSMOS, VVDS and SDSS
• Small scatter and nearly-isothermal mass profiles to four half-light radii from two-dimensional stellar dynamics of early-type galaxies
• Hunting for Supermassive Black Holes in Nearby Galaxies with the Hobby-Eberly Telescope
• On the inconsistency between the black hole mass function inferred from M_bh-sigma and M_bh-L correlation
• The imprint of massive black-hole mergers on the correlation between nuclear clusters and their host galaxies
• Selection bias in dynamically-measured super-massive black hole samples: dynamical masses and dependence on Sérsic index
• How Special are Brightest Cluster Galaxies? The Impact of Near-Infrared Luminosities on Scaling Relations for BCGs

Cited by in corpus (26)

• Gravitational wave searches for ultralight bosons with LIGO and LISA
• Testing modified gravity at cosmological distances with LISA standard sirens
• Post-Newtonian Evolution of Massive Black Hole Triplets in Galactic Nuclei: IV. Implications for LISA
• Science with the TianQin observatory: Preliminary results on massive black hole binaries
• Massive black hole merger rates: the effect of kpc separation wandering and supernova feedback
• LeMMINGs. I. The eMERLIN legacy survey of nearby galaxies. 1.5-GHz parsec-scale radio structures and cores
• Black hole scaling relations of active and quiescent galaxies: Addressing selection effects and constraining virial factors
• Post-Newtonian evolution of massive black hole triplets in galactic nuclei -- III. A robust lower limit to the nHz stochastic background of gravitational waves
• Black Hole -- Galaxy Correlations in Simba
• Ultra-High Energy Cosmic Rays and Neutrinos from Tidal Disruptions by Massive Black Holes
• Effect of data gaps on the detectability and parameter estimation of massive black hole binaries with LISA
• Probing black hole accretion tracks, scaling relations and radiative efficiencies from stacked X-ray active galactic nuclei
• The nightmare scenario: measuring the stochastic gravitational-wave background from stalling massive black-hole binaries with pulsar-timing arrays
• LeMMINGs. II. The e-MERLIN legacy survey of nearby galaxies. The deepest radio view of the Palomar sample on parsec scale
• pAGN: the one-stop solution for AGN disc modeling
• Implications of the pulsar timing array detections for massive black hole mergers in the LISA band
• LeMMINGs. III. The e-MERLIN Legacy Survey of the Palomar sample. Exploring the origin of nuclear radio emission in active and inactive galaxies through the [O III] -- radio connection
• Detection of faint broad emission lines in type 2 AGN: III. On the $M_{BH}-{\sigma }_{\star }$ relation of type 2 AGN
• Revisiting the bulge-halo conspiracy II: Towards explaining its puzzling dependence on redshift
• Outflows in the Gaseous Discs of Active Galaxies and their impact on Black Hole Scaling Relations
• Predictions for LISA and PTA based on SHARK galaxy simulations
• Robust Supermassive Black Hole Spin Mass-Energy Characteristics: A New Method and Results
• Massive Black Hole Mergers
• Inferring Mbh-Mbulge Evolution from the Gravitational Wave Background
• A note on the interpretation of the statistical analysis of the $M_{\bullet }-M_G{\sigma }^2$ scaling relation
• Discriminating between different scenarios for the formation and evolution of massive black holes with LISA