On the kinematic detection of accreted streams in the Gaia era: a cautionary tale
arXiv:1611.07193 · doi:10.1051/0004-6361/201629691
Abstract
The CDM cosmological scenario predicts that our Galaxy should contain hundreds of stellar streams at the solar vicinity, fossil relics of the merging history of the Milky Way and more generally of the hierarchical growth of galaxies. Because of the mixing time scales in the inner Galaxy, it has been claimed that these streams should be difficult to detect in configuration space but can still be identifiable in kinematic-related spaces like the energy/angular momenta spaces, E-Lz and Lperp-Lz, or spaces of orbital/velocity parameters. By means of high-resolution, dissipationless N-body simulations, containing between 25 and 35 particles, we model the accretion of a series of up to four 1:10 mass ratio satellites then up to eight 1:100 satellites and we search systematically for the signature of these accretions in these spaces. In all spaces considered (1) each satellite gives origin to several independent overdensities; (2) overdensities of multiple satellites overlap; (3) satellites of different masses can produce similar substructures; (4) the overlap between the in-situ and the accreted population is considerable everywhere; (5) in-situ stars also form substructures in response to the satellite(s) accretion. These points are valid even if the search is restricted to kinematically-selected halo stars only. As we are now entering the 'Gaia era', our results warn that an extreme caution must be employed before interpreting overdensities in any of those spaces as evidence of relics of accreted satellites. Reconstructing the accretion history of our Galaxy will require a substantial amount of accurate spectroscopic data, that, complemented by the kinematic information, will possibly allow us to (chemically) identify accreted streams and measure their orbital properties. (abridged)
arXiv commentAccepted on A&A. A high-resolution version of the paper is available at http://aramis.obspm.fr/~paola/ELZ/Elz.pdf
References in corpus (89)
- SDSS-III: Massive Spectroscopic Surveys of the Distant Universe, the Milky Way Galaxy, and Extra-Solar Planetary Systems
- The Average Star Formation Histories of Galaxies in Dark Matter Halos from z=0-8
- GAIA: Composition, Formation and Evolution of the Galaxy
- Tracing Galaxy Formation with Stellar Halos I: Methods
- The Radial Velocity Experiment (RAVE): first data release
- The GALAH Survey: Scientific Motivation
- Observational and Theoretical Constraints on Singular Dark Matter Halos
- Kinematics of Metal-Poor Stars in the Galaxy. III. Formation of the Stellar Halo and Thick Disk as Revealed from a Large Sample of Non-Kinematically Selected Stars
- Two Stellar Components in the Halo of the Milky Way
- Debris streams in the solar neighbourhood as relicts from the formation of the Milky Way
- Galactic stellar haloes in the CDM model
- Two distinct halo populations in the solar neighborhood. Evidence from stellar abundance ratios and kinematics
- Mass Density Profiles of LSB Galaxies
- The age structure of stellar populations in the solar vicinity. Clues of a two-phase formation history of the Milky Way disk
- The stellar mass assembly of galaxies in the Illustris simulation: growth by mergers and the spatial distribution of accreted stars
- Quantifying the Fragility of Galactic Disks in Minor Mergers
- The RAdial Velocity Experiment (RAVE): Fourth data release
- The thick disks of spiral galaxies as relics from gas-rich, turbulent, clumpy disks at high redshift
- Galaxy mergers with various mass ratios: properties of remnants
- The Dual Origin of Stellar Halos
- Mass Models for Low Surface Brightness Galaxies with High Resolution Optical Velocity Fields
- Cosmological simulations of the formation of the stellar haloes around disc galaxies
- An Orphan in the "Field of Streams"
- Thin, thick and dark discs in LCDM
- Galactic Halo substructure in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey: the ancient tidal stream from the Sagittarius dwarf galaxy
- The Radial Velocity Experiment (RAVE): second data release
- Merger Histories of Galaxy Halos and Implications for Disk Survival
- The stellar halo of the Galaxy
- Orbital Parameters of Merging Dark Matter Halos
- Mapping the substructure in the Galactic halo with the next generation of astrometric satellites
- The Galaxy and its stellar halo: insights on their formation from a hybrid cosmological approach
- Thin disc, Thick Disc and Halo in a Simulated Galaxy
- 4MOST - 4-metre Multi-Object Spectroscopic Telescope
- Reconstructing the star formation history of the Milky Way disc(s) from chemical abundances
- Two distinct halo populations in the solar neighborhood. II. Evidence from stellar abundances of Mn, Cu, Zn, Y, and Ba
- Pieces of the puzzle: Ancient substructure in the Galactic disk
- The Star Formation & Chemical Evolution History of the Fornax Dwarf Spheroidal Galaxy
- Building Late-Type Spiral Galaxies by In-Situ and Ex-Situ Star Formation
- Observations of Thick Disks in the Hubble Space Telescope Ultra Deep Field
- MASSIV: Mass Assembly Survey with SINFONI in VVDS - II. Kinematics and close environment classification
- Constraining Sub-Grid Physics with High-Redshift Spatially-Resolved Metallicity Distributions
- Chemical signatures of formation processes in the stellar populations of simulated galaxies
- Kinematics of SDSS subdwarfs: Structure and substructure of the Milky Way halo
- The RAdial Velocity Experiment (RAVE): Third Data Release
- APOGEE: The Apache Point Observatory Galactic Evolution Experiment
- High Resolution Optical Velocity Fields of 11 Low Surface Brightness Galaxies
- The dominant epoch of star formation in the Milky Way formed the thick disc
- Global structure and kinematics of stellar haloes in cosmological hydrodynamic simulations
- The dwarf galaxy DDO 47 as a dark matter laboratory: testing cusps hiding in triaxial halos
- Accretion relicts in the solar neighbourhood: debris from omegaCen's parent galaxy
- Formation of In Situ Stellar Haloes in Milky Way-Mass Galaxies
- Halpha rotation curves: the soft core question
- Phase-Space Distributions of Chemical Abundances in Milky Way-type Galaxy Halos
- The phase-space structure of cold dark-matter halos: Insights into the Galactic halo
- Two distinct halo populations in the solar neighborhood. III. Evidence from stellar ages and orbital parameters
- Can Gas prevent the Destruction of Thin Stellar Discs by Minor Mergers?
- The nucleosynthetic history of elements in the Galactic disk: [X/Fe] - age relations from high-precision spectroscopy
- Formation and evolution of galactic disks with a multiphase numerical model
- The Eating Habits of Milky Way Mass Halos: Destroyed Dwarf Satellites and the Metallicity Distribution of Accreted Stars
- Halo Star Streams in the Solar Neighborhood
- On the identification of merger debris in the {\it Gaia} Era
- Fashionably Late? Building up the Milky Way's Inner Halo
- High-precision abundances of Sc, Mn, Cu, and Ba in solar twins. Trends of element ratios with stellar age
- Halo streams in the 7th SDSS data release
- On the identification of substructure in phase-space using orbital frequencies
- Identifying stellar streams in the 1st RAVE public data release
- Characteristics of thick disks formed through minor mergers: stellar excesses and scale lengths
- An Iterative Method for Constructing Equilibrium Phase Models of Stellar Systems
- Signatures of minor mergers in Milky Way-like disc kinematics: Ringing revisited
- The dynamics of tidal tails from massive satellites
- The Gaia-ESO Survey: a quiescent Milky Way with no significant dark/stellar accreted disc
- The disc origin of the Milky Way bulge
- Simulations of minor mergers. II. The phase-space structure of thick discs
- Streams in the Aquarius stellar haloes
- The formation of a thick disk through the heating of a thin disk: Agreement with orbital eccentricities of stars in the solar neighborhood
- The Fractions of Inner- and Outer-Halo Stars in the Local Volume
- Stellar halo streams in the Solar neighbourhood
- Chemodynamics of a Simulated Disc Galaxy: Initial Mass Functions and SNIa Progenitors
- The Milky Way as a High Redshift Galaxy: The Importance of Thick Disk Formation in Galaxies
- Mapping Substructures in Dark Matter Halos
- Two distinct halo populations in the solar neighborhood. IV. Lithium abundances
- Detection of satellite remnants in the Galactic Halo with Gaia - I. The effect of the Galactic background, observational errors and sampling
- The hunt for the Milky Way's accreted disc
- The slowing down of galaxy disks in dissipationless minor mergers
- An Upper Limit on the Granularity of the Local Stellar Halo
- MOONS: a Multi-Object Optical and Near-infrared Spectrograph for the VLT
- New Signatures of the Milky Way Formation in the Local Halo and Inner Halo Streamers in the Era of Gaia
- Signatures of star streams in the phase space distribution of nearby halo stars
- The history of stellar metallicity in a simulated disc galaxy
Cited by in corpus (78)
- The merger that led to the formation of the Milky Way's inner stellar halo and thick disk
- Gaia Data Release 2: Mapping the Milky Way disc kinematics
- Streams, substructures and the early history of the Milky Way
- Evidence from the H3 Survey that the Stellar Halo is Entirely Comprised of Substructure
- In disguise or out of reach: first clues about in-situ and accreted stars in the stellar halo of the Milky Way from Gaia DR2
- The Biggest Splash
- Evidence from APOGEE for the presence of a major building block of the halo buried in the inner Galaxy
- The Milky Way has no in-situ halo other than the heated thick disc. Composition of the stellar halo and age-dating the last significant merger with Gaia DR2 and APOGEE
- The Global Dynamical Atlas of the Milky Way mergers: Constraints from Gaia EDR3 based orbits of globular clusters, stellar streams and satellite galaxies
- Mapping the Stellar Halo with the H3 Spectroscopic Survey
- The chemical characterisation of halo substructure in the Milky Way based on APOGEE
- The shape of the Galactic halo with DR2 RR Lyrae. Anatomy of an ancient major merger
- Origin of the excess of high-energy retrograde stars in the Galactic halo
- Chemo-kinematics of the RR Lyrae: the halo and the disc
- The GALAH Survey: Chemical tagging and chrono-chemodynamics of accreted halo stars with GALAH+ DR3 and eDR3
- Kinematics of Highly R-Process-Enhanced Field Stars: Evidence for an Accretion Origin and Detection of Several Groups from Disrupted Satellites
- VINTERGATAN II: the history of the Milky Way told by its mergers
- Galactic Archaeology with Gaia
- GASTRO library I: the simulated chemodynamical properties of several GSE-like stellar halos
- A massive mess: When a large dwarf and a Milky Way-like galaxy merge
- Reviving old controversies: is the early Galaxy flat or round? Investigations into the early phases of the Milky Way formation through stellar kinematics and chemical abundances
- StarGO: A New Method to Identify the Galactic Origins of Halo Stars
- VINTERGATAN III: how to reset the metallicity of the Milky Way
- Constraints on the assembly history of the Milky Way's smooth, diffuse stellar halo from the metallicity-dependent, radially-dominated velocity anisotropy profiles probed with K giants and BHB stars using LAMOST, SDSS/SEGUE, and Gaia
- The tale of the tail -- disentangling the high transverse velocity stars in Gaia DR2
- The Kinematic Properties of Milky Way Stellar Halo Populations
- Chemo-kinematics of the Milky Way spiral arms and bar resonances: connection to ridges and moving groups in the Solar vicinity
- Substructure in the stellar halo near the Sun. II. Characterisation of independent structures
- Substructure in the stellar halo near the Sun. I. Data-driven clustering in Integrals of Motion space
- The distribution of globular clusters in kinematic spaces does not trace the accretion history of the host galaxy
- Energy wrinkles and phase-space folds of the last major merger
- Mergers, tidal interactions, and mass exchange in a population of disc globular clusters
- Stellar disc streams as probes of the Galactic potential and satellite impacts
- Bars and boxy/peanut bulges in thin and thick discs. II. Can bars form in hot thick discs?
- Reading the CARDs: the Imprint of Accretion History in the Chemical Abundances of the Milky Way's Stellar Halo
- The stellar halo in Local Group Hestia simulations I. The in-situ component and the effect of mergers
- Age Determination of Galaxy Merger Remnant Stars using Asteroseismology
- Metallicity distributions of halo stars: do they trace the Galactic accretion history?
- Targeting Bright Metal-poor Stars in the Disk and Halo Systems of the Galaxy
- The observable properties of galaxy accretion events in Milky Way-like galaxies in the FIRE-2 cosmological simulations
- The Cetus-Palca stream: A disrupted small dwarf galaxy. A prequel to the science possible with WEAVE with precise spectro-photometric distances
- Contribution of Gaia Sausage to the Galactic Stellar Halo Revealed by K Giants and Blue Horizontal Branch Stars from the Large Sky Area Multi-Object Fiber Spectroscopic Telescope, Sloan Digital Sky Survey, and Gaia
- The stellar halo in Local Group Hestia simulations II. The accreted component
- The stellar halo in Local Group Hestia simulations III. Chemical abundance relations for accreted and in-situ stars
- Star Formation Timescales of the Halo Populations from Asteroseismology and Chemical Abundances
- Exploring the diversity and similarity of radially anisotropic Milky Way-like stellar haloes: implications for disrupted dwarf galaxy searches
- Chronology of the chemical enrichment of the old Galactic stellar populations
- The GALAH Survey: Accreted stars also inhabit the Spite Plateau
- The metal-rich halo component extended in z: a characterization with Gaia DR2 and APOGEE
- Genesis of morpho-kinematic lopsidedness in minor merger of galaxies
- High-speed stars. II. An unbound star, young stars, bulge metal-poor stars, and Aurora candidates
- Exploring the chemodynamics of metal-poor stellar populations
- Abundance ties: Nephele and the globular cluster population accreted with Cen. Based on APOGEE DR17 and Gaia EDR3
- Evidence For Multiple Accretion Events in the -Sausage/Enceladus Structures
- Frequencies, chaos and resonances: a study of orbital parameters of nearby thick disc and halo stars
- The Reduced Proper Motion selected halo: methods and description of the catalogue
- The GALAH Survey: No chemical evidence of an extragalactic origin for the Nyx stream
- The heavy-elements heritage of the falling sky
- G112-43/44: A metal-poor binary star with a unique chemical composition and kinematics like the Helmi streams
- Chemo-dynamics and asteroseismic ages of seven metal-poor red giants from the Kepler field
- Evidence of Gaia Enceladus experiencing at least two passages around the Milky Way
- How well can we unravel the accreted constituents of the Milky Way stellar halo? A test on cosmological hydrodynamical simulations
- Rediscovering the Milky Way with orbit superposition approach and APOGEE data I. Method validation
- Resolved SPLASH Chemodynamics in Andromeda's PHAT Stellar Halo and Disk: On the Nature of the Inner Halo Along the Major Axis
- Cosmological Simulations of Stellar Halos with Gaia Sausage-Enceladus Analogues: Two Sausages, One Bun?
- Chronology of our Galaxy from Gaia colour-magnitude diagram fitting (ChronoGal) -- III. Age and metallicity distribution of Gaia-Sausage-Enceladus stars near the Sun
- Nearby stellar substructures in the Galactic halo from DESI Milky Way Survey Year 1 Data Release
- The Nephele ecosystem: stars, globular clusters, and stellar streams associated with the progenitor galaxy of Centauri
- Milky Way's Metal-Poor Stars display Chemical Transition near the Solar Radius
- The metal-poorest tail of the Galactic halo: hypothesis on its origin from precise spectral analysis
- Rediscovering the Milky Way with orbit superposition approach and APOGEE data III. Panoramic view of the bulge
- Main-sequence Turnoff Stars as Probes of the Ancient Galactic Relic: Chemo-dynamical Analysis of a Pilot Sample
- Stellar halo striations from assumptions of axisymmetry
- HR-GO II: chemical abundances of low- retrograde dynamically-tagged-groups: Revealing Thamnos as a very metal-poor substructure
- Two faces of Gaia-Sausage-Enceladus: Mining the chemical abundance space with graph attention networks
- Stirring Things Up: Bar-induced substructures in the stellar halo of a cosmological Milky Way analogue
- Tracing Milky Way substructure with an RR Lyrae hierarchical clustering forest
- Unravelling the role of merger histories in the population of In situ stars: linking IllustrisTNG cosmological simulation to H3 survey