Is Turbulence in the Interstellar Medium Driven by Feedback or Gravity? An Observational Test

Abstract

Galaxies' interstellar media (ISM) are observed to be supersonically-turbulent, but the ultimate power source that drives turbulent motion remains uncertain. The two dominant models are that the turbulence is driven by star formation feedback and/or that it is produced by gravitational instability in the gas. Here we show that, while both models predict that the galaxies' ISM velocity dispersions will be positively correlated with their star formation rates, the forms of the correlation predicted by these two models are subtly but measurably different. A feedback-driven origin for the turbulence predicts a velocity dispersion that rises more sharply with star formation rate, and that does not depend on the gas fraction (i.e. ${\dot{M}}_{\ast }\propto {\sigma }^2$), while a gravity-driven model yields a shallower rise and a strong dependence on gas fraction (i.e. ${\dot{M}}_{\ast }\propto f_g^2\sigma$). We compare the models to a collection of data on local and high-redshift galaxies culled from the literature, and show that the correlation expected for gravity-driven turbulence is a better match to the observations than a feedback-driven model. This suggests that gravity is the ultimate source of ISM turbulence, at least in the rapidly-star-forming, high velocity dispersion galaxies for which our test is most effective. We conclude by discussing the limitations of the present data set, and the prospects for future measurements to enable a more definitive test of the two models.

8 pages, 3 figures, MNRAS in press; minor text edits from previous version, no substantive changes

References in corpus (19)

• Combined CO & Dust Scaling Relations of Depletion Time and Molecular Gas Fractions with Cosmic Time, Specific Star Formation Rate and Stellar Mass
• Slow Star Formation in Dense Gas: Evidence and Implications
• Rapid formation of exponential disks and bulges at high redshift from the dynamical evolution of clump cluster and chain galaxies
• What is Driving the HI Velocity Dispersion?
• Ionized gas outflows and global kinematics of low-z luminous star forming galaxies
• A scheme for radiation pressure and photon diffusion with the M1 closure in RAMSES-RT
• The Global Evolution of Giant Molecular Clouds. I: Model Formulation and Quasi-Equilibrium Behavior
• Dependence of Interstellar Turbulent Pressure on Supernova Rate
• High star formation rates as the origin of turbulence in early and modern disk galaxies
• GHASP : An Halpha kinematic survey of 203 spiral and irregular galaxies - VII. Revisiting the analysis of Halpha data cubes for 97 galaxies
• Understanding star formation in molecular clouds II. Signatures of gravitational collapse of IRDCs
• Radiation Feedback in ULIRGS: Are Photons Movers and Shakers?
• Scaling Relations of Compressible MHD Turbulence
• What controls the ionized gas turbulent motions in dwarf galaxies?
• Mass Transport and Turbulence in Gravitationally Unstable Disk Galaxies. I: The Case of Pure Self-Gravity
• Density probability distribution functions of diffuse gas in the Milky Way
• HI velocity dispersion in NGC 1058
• Three Dimensional Hydrodynamic Simulations of Multiphase Galactic Disks with Star Formation Feedback: II. Synthetic HI 21 cm Line Observations
• Spatially extended and high-velocity dispersion molecular component in spiral galaxies: single-dish vs. interferometric observations

Cited by in corpus (136)

• First Results from the TNG50 Simulation: The evolution of stellar and gaseous disks across cosmic time
• A Unified Model for Galactic Discs: Star Formation, Turbulence Driving, and Mass Transport
• Introducing the NewHorizon simulation: Galaxy properties with resolved internal dynamics across cosmic time
• Magnetic field formation in the Milky Way-like disk galaxies of the Auriga project
• The Evolution and Origin of Ionized Gas Velocity Dispersion from $z\sim 2.6$ to $z\sim 0.6$ with KMOS${}^{3D}$
• Dynamical Equilibrium in the Molecular ISM in 28 Nearby Star-Forming Galaxies
• SILCC-Zoom: The dynamical and chemical evolution of molecular clouds
• The physical origin of long gas depletion times in galaxies
• Bar quenching in gas-rich galaxies
• The KMOS Redshift One Spectroscopic Survey (KROSS): the origin of disk turbulence in z~0.9 star-forming galaxies
• Lyman Radiation Hydrodynamics of Turbulent H II Regions in Molecular Clouds: A Physical Origin of LyC Leakage and the Associated Ly$\alpha$ Spectra
• A Model for the Onset of Self-gravitation and Star Formation in Molecular Gas Governed by Galactic Forces: I. Cloud-scale Gas Motions
• Turbulent Gas in Lensed Planck-selected Starbursts at redshifts 1-3.5
• Inside Out and Upside-Down: The Roles of Gas Cooling and Dynamical Heating in Shaping the Stellar Age-Velocity Relation
• Feedback from massive stars at low metallicities: MUSE observations of N44 and N180 in the Large Magellanic Cloud
• The impact of stellar feedback on the density and velocity structure of the interstellar medium
• PHANGS-JWST First Results: A statistical view on bubble evolution in NGC628
• Evidence for supernova feedback sustaining gas turbulence in nearby star-forming galaxies
• Systematic difference between ionized and molecular gas velocity dispersion in $z\sim 1-2$ disks and local analogues
• Velocity dispersion in the interstellar medium of early galaxies
• A three-phase amplification of the cosmic magnetic field in galaxies
• SILCC VII -- Gas kinematics and multiphase outflows of the simulated ISM at high gas surface densities
• Swirls of FIRE: Spatially Resolved Gas Velocity Dispersions and Star Formation Rates in FIRE-2 Disk Environments
• Physical properties and scaling relations of molecular clouds: the effect of stellar feedback
• The KMOS${}^{3D}$ Survey: Investigating the Origin of the Elevated Electron Densities in Star-Forming Galaxies at $1\lesssim z\lesssim 3$
• The SAMI Galaxy Survey: energy sources of the turbulent velocity dispersion in spatially-resolved local star-forming galaxies
• EDGE-CALIFA survey: Self-regulation of Star formation at kpc scales
• Seed magnetic fields in turbulent small-scale dynamos
• Star formation from dense shocked regions in supersonic isothermal magneto-turbulence
• Impact of galactic shear and stellar feedback on star formation
• What drives the evolution of gas kinematics in star-forming galaxies?
• Morphology and enhanced star formation in a Cartwheel-like ring galaxy
• The scaling relations and star formation laws of ministarburst complexes
• Chemodynamics of Green Pea galaxies -- I. Outflows and turbulence driving the escape of ionising photons and chemical enrichment
• GASKAP-HI Pilot Survey Science I: ASKAP Zoom Observations of HI Emission in the Small Magellanic Cloud
• New insights into the structure of open clusters in the Gaia era
• The Multi-phase Turbulence Density Power Spectra in the Perseus Molecular Cloud
• A Simple Non-equilibrium Feedback Model for Galaxy-Scale Star Formation: Delayed Feedback and SFR Scatter
• The SAMI Galaxy Survey: Gas velocity dispersions in low-$z$ star-forming galaxies and the drivers of turbulence
• Synthetic observations of star formation and the interstellar medium
• Testing Feedback Regulated Star Formation in Gas Rich, Turbulent Disk Galaxies
• Towards a radially-resolved semi-analytic model for the evolution of disc galaxies tuned with machine learning
• GA-NIFS: Early-stage feedback in a heavily obscured AGN at $z=4.76$
• Magnetic field fluctuations in anisotropic, supersonic turbulence
• What drives the velocity dispersion of ionized gas in star-forming galaxies?
• Relations Between Molecular Cloud Structure Sizes and Line Widths in the Large Magellanic Cloud
• From giant clumps to clouds -- III. The connection between star formation and turbulence in the ISM
• Measuring Turbulence with Young Stars in the Orion Complex
• Tracing the Dynamical Mass in Galaxy Disks Using HI Velocity Dispersion and its Implications for the Dark Matter Distribution in Galaxies
• The Origin of Interstellar Turbulence in M33
• The most ancient spiral galaxy: a 2.6-Gyr-old disk with a tranquil velocity field
• Cosmic rays across the star-forming galaxy sequence. I: Cosmic ray pressures and calorimetry
• Formation and settling of a disc galaxy during the last 8 billion years in a cosmological simulation
• The ALMA-ALPAKA survey II. Evolution of turbulence in galaxy disks across cosmic time: difference between cold and warm gas
• MHD simulation of the formation of clumps and filaments in quiescent diffuse medium by thermal instability
• The Simons Observatory: Galactic Science Goals and Forecasts
• Turbulence and Energetic Particles in Radiative Shock Waves in the Cygnus Loop I: Shock Properties
• SDSS-IV MaNGA: Understanding Ionized Gas Turbulence using Integral Field Spectroscopy of 4500 Star-Forming Disk Galaxies
• Numerical simulations of supernova remnants in turbulent molecular clouds
• Large-scale turbulent driving regulates star formation in high-redshift gas-rich galaxies
• Gas Accretion Can Drive Turbulence in Galaxies
• Quantifying the effects of spatial resolution and noise on galaxy metallicity gradients
• Mapping Spatial Variations of HI Turbulent Properties in the Small and Large Magellanic Cloud
• The physical drivers of gas turbulence in simulated disc galaxies
• The Velocity Statistics of Turbulent Clouds in the Presence of Gravity, Magnetic fields, Radiation, and Outflow Feedback
• Radio Scattering Horizons for Galactic and Extragalactic Transients
• Spiral Arms are Metal Freeways: Azimuthal Gas-Phase Metallicity Variations in Simulated Cosmological Zoom-in Flocculent Disks
• Cosmological simulations of Milky Way-sized galaxies
• Nonuniversal interstellar density spectra probed by pulsars
• The dawn of disks: unveiling the turbulent ionised gas kinematics of the galaxy population at $z\sim 4-6$ with JWST/NIRCam grism spectroscopy
• The HIX galaxy survey I: Study of the most gas rich galaxies from HIPASS
• The connection between the peaks in velocity dispersion and star-forming clumps of turbulent galaxies
• How Cosmic Rays Mediate the Evolution of the Interstellar Medium
• Quantifying the energy balance between the turbulent ionised gas and young stars
• A ~600 pc view of the strongly-lensed, massive main sequence galaxy J0901: a baryon-dominated, thick turbulent rotating disk with a clumpy cold gas ring at z = 2.259
• The SATIN project I: Turbulent multi-phase ISM in Milky Way simulations with SNe feedback from stellar clusters
• The driving scale -- density decorrelation scale relation in a turbulent medium
• SH$\alpha$DE: Survey description and mass-kinematics scaling relations for dwarf galaxies
• Turbulence and Particle Acceleration in Radiative Shock Waves in the Cygnus Loop II: Development of Postshock Turbulence
• The mass-metallicity relation as a ruler for galaxy evolution: insights from the James Webb Space Telescope
• From Peculiar Morphologies to Hubble-type Spirals: The relation between galaxy dynamics and morphology in star-forming galaxies at z~1.5
• Searching for Molecular Outflows with Support Vector Machines: Dark Cloud Complex in Cygnus
• Kinematic analysis of the super-extended HI disk of the nearby spiral galaxy M83
• Energy balance and Alfvén Mach numbers in compressible magnetohydrodynamic turbulence with a large-scale magnetic field
• The major mechanism to drive turbulence in star-forming galaxies
• Metallicities in the Outer Regions of Spiral Galaxies
• Radiation pressure in galactic disks: stability, turbulence, and winds in the single-scattering limit
• Evidence of large scale energy cascade in the spiral galaxy NGC 5236
• Spatial variations of turbulent properties of neutral hydrogen gas in the Small Magellanic Cloud using structure function analysis
• Dynamical modelling and origin of gas turbulence in z $\sim$ 4.5 galaxies
• The Impact of Unresolved Turbulence on the Escape Fraction of Lyman Continuum Photons
• VALES VII: Molecular and ionized gas properties in pressure balanced interstellar medium of starburst galaxies at z ~ 0.15
• WISDOM Project XII. Clump properties and turbulence regulated by clump-clump collisions in the dwarf galaxy NGC404
• Probes of turbulent driving mechanisms in molecular clouds from fluctuations in synchrotron intensity
• Finite Resolution Deconvolution of Multi-Wavelength Imaging of 20,000 Galaxies in the COSMOS Field: The Evolution of Clumpy Galaxies Over Cosmic Time
• Gaia-ESO Survey: Gas dynamics in the Carina Nebula through optical emission lines
• The VMC survey -- XLVII. Turbulence-Controlled Hierarchical Star Formation in the Large Magellanic Cloud
• Possible origins of anomalous HI gas around MHONGOOSE galaxy, NGC 5068
• Fundamental MHD scales -- II: the kinematic phase of the supersonic small-scale dynamo
• Starbursts with suppressed velocity dispersion revealed in a forming cluster at z=2.51
• Diagnostics of ionized gas in galaxies with the "BPT--radial velocity dispersion" relation
• Dynamo effect in unstirred self-gravitating turbulence
• Large-scale turbulent driving regulates star formation in high-redshift gas-rich galaxies II: Influence of the magnetic field and the turbulent compressive fraction
• Growth or Decay -- I: universality of the turbulent dynamo saturation
• Universal gravity-driven isothermal turbulence cascade in disk galaxies
• SDSS IV MaNGA -- Star-Formation Driven Biconical Outflows in the Local Univers
• Unveiling the inner morphology and gas kinematics of NGC 5135 with ALMA
• Molecular Gas Toward the Gemini OB1 Molecular Cloud Complex II: CO Outflow Candidates with Possible WISE Associations
• Regulation of star formation by large scale gravito-turbulence
• Bringing Stellar Evolution & Feedback Together: Summary of proposals from the Lorentz Center Workshop, 2022
• MOSEL Survey: Tracking the Growth of Massive Galaxies at 2<z<4 using Kinematics and the IllustrisTNG Simulation
• Two-component gravitational instability in spiral galaxies
• Spatially resolved gas and stellar kinematics in compact starburst galaxies
• Multiline observations of hydrogen, helium, and carbon radio-recombination lines toward Orion A: A detailed dynamical study and direct determination of physical conditions
• Centrally concentrated molecular gas driving galactic-scale ionised gas outflows in star-forming galaxies
• VALES V: A kinematic analysis of the molecular gas content in $H$-ATLAS galaxies at $z\sim 0.03-0.35$ using ALMA
• Turbulence in compact to giant H II regions
• Predicting HCN, HCO + , multi-transition CO, and dust emission of star-forming galaxies: Constraining the properties of resolved gas and dust disks of local spiral galaxies
• Understanding the radio luminosity function of star-forming galaxies and its cosmological evolution
• Studying Interstellar Turbulence Driving Scales using the Bispectrum
• Analytic characterization of sub-Alfvénic turbulence energetics
• Unveiling the gravitationally unstable disc of a massive star-forming galaxy using NOEMA and MUSE
• SDSS IV MaNGA -- Star-Formation Driven Biconical Outflows in Face-On Galaxies
• Star Cluster Formation in Clouds with Externally Driven Turbulence
• Applying a star formation model calibrated on high-resolution interstellar medium simulations to cosmological simulations of galaxy formation
• Time-average properties of $z\sim 0.6$ major mergers: mergers significantly scatter high-z scaling relations
• Turbulent Action at a Distance due to Stellar Feedback in Magnetized Clouds
• The universality of the relation between magnetic fields and star formation in galaxies
• Massive Star Clusters in the Semi-Analytical Galaxy Formation Model L-Galaxies 2020
• Thermal damping of Weak Magnetosonic Turbulence in the Interstellar Medium
• Towards convergence of turbulent dynamo amplification in cosmological simulations of galaxies
• Magnetic field and kinetic helicity evolution in simulations of interacting disk galaxies
• Random fragmentation of turbulent molecular clouds lying in the central region of giant galaxies
• CO Structures with Narrow Lines in Nearby Quiescent Regions
• Heavy interstellar scattering toward the near end of the Galactic bar
• Supernova origin of galactic turbulence revealed by superbubbles