The Influence of Spatial Resolution on Nonlinear Force-Free Modeling
arXiv:1508.05455 · doi:10.1088/0004-637X/811/2/107
Abstract
The nonlinear force-free field (NLFFF) model is often used to describe the solar coronal magnetic field, however a series of earlier studies revealed difficulties in the numerical solution of the model in application to photospheric boundary data. We investigate the sensitivity of the modeling to the spatial resolution of the boundary data, by applying multiple codes that numerically solve the NLFFF model to a sequence of vector magnetogram data at different resolutions, prepared from a single Hinode/SOT-SP scan of NOAA Active Region 10978 on 2007 December 13. We analyze the resulting energies and relative magnetic helicities, employ a Helmholtz decomposition to characterize divergence errors, and quantify changes made by the codes to the vector magnetogram boundary data in order to be compatible with the force-free model. This study shows that NLFFF modeling results depend quantitatively on the spatial resolution of the input boundary data, and that using more highly resolved boundary data yields more self-consistent results. The free energies of the resulting solutions generally trend higher with increasing resolution, while relative magnetic helicity values vary significantly between resolutions for all methods. All methods require changing the horizontal components, and for some methods also the vertical components, of the vector magnetogram boundary field in excess of nominal uncertainties in the data. The solutions produced by the various methods are significantly different at each resolution level. We continue to recommend verifying agreement between the modeled field lines and corresponding coronal loop images before any NLFFF model is used in a scientific setting.
arXiv commentAccepted to ApJ; comments/corrections to this article are welcome via e-mail, even after publication
References in corpus (16)
- The Solar Optical Telescope for the Hinode Mission: An Overview
- The Helioseismic and Magnetic Imager (HMI) Vector Magnetic Field Pipeline: Overview and Performance
- Preprocessing of vector magnetograph data for a non-linear force-free magnetic field reconstruction
- A Critical Assessment of Nonlinear Force-Free Field Modeling of the Solar Corona for Active Region 10953
- Non-linear force-free field modeling of a solar active region around the time of a major flare and coronal mass ejection
- How to optimize nonlinear force-free coronal magnetic field extrapolations from SDO/HMI vector magnetograms?
- Using Coronal Loops to Reconstruct the Magnetic Field of an Active Region Before and After a Major Flare
- Testing magnetofrictional extrapolation with the Titov-Démoulin model of solar active regions
- Accuracy of magnetic energy computations
- Magnetic Field Extrapolations in the Corona: Success and Future Improvements
- A comparison of preprocessing methods for solar force-free magnetic field extrapolation
- Modelling and Interpreting The Effects of Spatial Resolution on Solar Magnetic Field Maps
- Comment on "Resolving the 180-deg Ambiguity in Solar Vector Magnetic Field Data: Evaluating the Effects of Noise, Spatial Resolution, and Method Assumptions"
- Comparison of force-free coronal magnetic field modeling using vector fields from Hinode and Solar Dynamics Observatory
- Response to "Comment on `Resolving the 180deg Ambiguity in Solar Vector Magnetic Field Data: Evaluating the Effects of Noise, Spatial Resolution, and Method Assumptions'"
- Resolving the Azimuthal Ambiguity in Vector Magnetogram Data with the Divergence-Free Condition: the Effects of Noise and Limited Spatial Resolution
Cited by in corpus (57)
- Flare-productive active regions
- Solar Force-free Magnetic Fields
- Hooked flare ribbons and flux-rope related QSL footprints
- Enhancing SDO/HMI images using deep learning
- Magnetohydrodynamic Simulation of the X9.3 Flare on 2017 September 6: Evolving Magnetic Topology
- Global Non-Potential Magnetic Models of the Solar Corona During the March 2015 Eclipse
- Probing the Physics of the Solar Atmosphere with the Multi-slit Solar Explorer (MUSE): II. Flares and Eruptions
- Magnetic helicity budget of solar active regions prolific of eruptive and confined flares
- Reconnection fluxes in eruptive and confined flares and implications for superflares on the Sun
- On flare-CME characteristics from Sun to Earth combining remote-sensing image data with in-situ measurements supported by modeling
- Magnetic helicity and energy budget around large confined and eruptive solar flares
- The Vertical Current Approximation Nonlinear Force-Free Field Code - Description, Performance Tests, and Measurements of Magnetic Energies Dissipated in Solar Flares
- Casting the Coronal Magnetic Field Reconstruction Tools in 3D Using MHD Bifrost Model
- Effect of transport coefficients on excitation of flare-induced standing slow-mode waves in coronal loops
- Magneto-static modelling from SUNRISE/IMaX: Application to an active region observed with SUNRISE II
- Comparative Study of Data-driven Solar Coronal Field Models Using a Flux Emergence Simulation as a Ground-truth Data Set
- Generation mechanisms of quasi-parallel and quasi-circular flare ribbons in a confined flare
- On the reliability of magnetic energy and helicity computations based on nonlinear force-free coronal magnetic field models
- The nonpotentiality of coronae of solar active regions, the dynamics of the surface magnetic field, and the potential for large flares
- Transition from circular-ribbon to parallel-ribbon flares associated with a bifurcated magnetic flux rope
- Tracing the Chromospheric and Coronal Magnetic Field with AIA, IRIS, IBIS, and ROSA Data
- Successive Injection of Opposite Magnetic Helicity in Solar Active Region NOAA 11928
- Comparison of Two Coronal Magnetic Field Models for Reconstructing a Sigmoidal Solar Active Region With Coronal Loops
- Evolutionary stages and triggering process of a complex eruptive flare with circular and parallel ribbons
- Eruptive-Impulsive Homologous M-class Flares Associated with Double-Decker Flux Rope Configuration in Mini-Sigmoid of NOAA 12673
- Force-Free Field Reconstructions Enhanced by Chromospheric Magnetic Field Data
- Magnetic helicity estimations in models and observations of the solar magnetic field. Part IV: Application to solar observations
- Towards a Quantitative Comparison of Magnetic Field Extrapolations and Observed Coronal Loops
- A Fixed-point Scheme for the Numerical Construction of Magnetohydrostatic Atmospheres in Three Dimensions
- Deducing the reliability of relative helicities from nonlinear force-free coronal models
- Probing the effect of cadence on the estimates of photospheric energy and helicity injections in eruptive active region NOAA AR 11158
- Data-Optimized Coronal Field Model: I. Proof of Concept
- Successive occurrences of quasi-circular ribbon flares in a fan-spine-like configuration involving hyperbolic flux tube
- Observational and model analysis of a two-ribbon flare possibly induced by a neighbouring blowout jet
- Exploring spectropolarimetric inversions using neural fields. Solar chromospheric magnetic field under the weak-field approximation
- Chromospheric magnetic field: A comparison of He I 10830 A observations with nonlinear force-free field extrapolation
- Studying the transfer of magnetic helicity in solar active regions with the connectivity-based helicity flux density method
- Arcade Implosion Caused by a Filament Eruption in a Flare
- Energy budget of plasma motions, heating, and electron acceleration in a three-loop solar flare
- Flare Energy Release in the Magnetic Field Polarity Inversion Line During M1.2 Solar Flare of March 15, 2015. Paper I. Onset of Plasma Heating and Electrons Acceleration
- Multiwavelength Signatures of Episodic Null Point Reconnection in a Quadrupolar Magnetic Configuration and the Cause of Failed Flux Rope Eruption
- Stereoscopic disambiguation of vector magnetograms: first applications to SO/PHI-HRT data
- On estimating the force-freeness based on observed magnetograms
- A novel inversion method to determine the coronal magnetic field including the impact of bound-free absorption
- On measuring divergence for magnetic field modeling
- The effect of spatial sampling on magnetic field modeling and helicity computation
- The Initiation Mechanism of the First On-disk X-Class Flare of Solar Cycle 25
- Solar coronal magnetic field measurements using spectral lines available in Hinode/EIS observations: Strong and weak field techniques and temperature diagnostics
- An Optimization Principle for Computing Stationary MHD Equilibria With Solar Wind Flow
- Extrapolation of Three-dimensional Magnetic Field Structure in Flare-productive Active Regions with Different Initial Conditions
- The configuration and failed eruption of a complex magnetic flux rope above a δ sunspot region
- An observationally-driven kinetic approach to coronal heating
- Temporal and spatial relationship of flare signatures and the force-free coronal magnetic field
- Nonlinear force-free modeling of flare-related magnetic field changes at the photosphere and chromosphere
- Coronal magnetic field evolution over the cycle 24
- Comparison of Two Methods for Calculating Magnetic Helicity in the Solar Corona
- Aditya-L1 and SDO Observations of a Confined X-Class Flare with an EUV Late Phase: Thermal and Nonthermal Emission, Magnetic Topology, and Flux Rope Confinement