Casting the Coronal Magnetic Field Reconstruction Tools in 3D Using MHD Bifrost Model

Abstract

Quantifying coronal magnetic field remains a central problem in solar physics. Nowadays the coronal magnetic field is often modelled using nonlinear force-free field (NLFFF) reconstructions, whose accuracy has not yet been comprehensively assessed. Here we perform a detailed casting of the NLFFF reconstruction tools, such as pi-disambiguation, photospheric field preprocessing, and volume reconstruction methods using a 3D snapshot of the publicly available full-fledged radiative MHD model. Specifically, from the MHD model we know the magnetic field vector in the entire 3D domain, which enables us to perform "voxel-by-voxel" comparison of the restored and the true magnetic field in the 3D model volume. Our tests show that the available pi-disambiguation methods often fail at the quiet sun areas dominated by small-scale magnetic elements, while they work well at the AR photosphere and (even better) chromosphere. The preprocessing of the photospheric magnetic field, although does produce a more force-free boundary condition, also results in some effective `elevation' of the magnetic field components. This `elevation' height is different for the longitudinal and transverse components, which results in a systematic error in absolute heights in the reconstructed magnetic data cube. The extrapolations performed starting from actual AR photospheric magnetogram are free from this systematic error, while have other metrics comparable with those for extrapolations from the preprocessed magnetograms. This finding favors the use of extrapolations from the original photospheric magnetogram without preprocessing. Our tests further suggest that extrapolations from a force-free chromospheric boundary produce measurably better results, than those from the photospheric boundary.

arXiv commentReplaces the previous submission to fix minor errors in a few figures and Tables 12 and 14. No conclusion is affected by the identified errors. 26 pages, 18 Figures, 14 Tables; 6 animated Figures are published in the journal version

References in corpus (27)

• The stellar atmosphere simulation code Bifrost
• Optimization code with weighting function for the reconstruction of coronal magnetic fields
• Preprocessing of vector magnetograph data for a non-linear force-free magnetic field reconstruction
• A Critical Assessment of Nonlinear Force-Free Field Modeling of the Solar Corona for Active Region 10953
• The formation of the Halpha line in the solar chromosphere
• The formation of IRIS diagnostics II. The formation of the Mg II h&k lines in the solar atmosphere
• A publicly available simulation of an enhanced network region of the Sun
• The Magnetic Field in the Solar Atmosphere
• The formation of IRIS diagnostics I. A quintessential model atom of Mg II and general formation properties of the Mg II h&k lines
• Nonlinear force-free modeling of the solar coronal magnetic field
• How to optimize nonlinear force-free coronal magnetic field extrapolations from SDO/HMI vector magnetograms?
• The formation of IRIS diagnostics. III. Near-ultraviolet Spectra and Images
• The Formation of IRIS diagnostics. IV. The Mg II triplet lines as a new diagnostic for lower chromospheric heating
• The Influence of Spatial Resolution on Nonlinear Force-Free Modeling
• On fibrils and field lines: The nature of H$\alpha$ fibrils in the solar chromosphere
• The formation of IRIS diagnostics V. A quintessential model atom of C II and general formation properties of the C II lines at 133.5 nm
• Millimeter radiation from a 3D model of the solar atmosphere I. Diagnosing chromospheric thermal structure
• The formation of IRIS diagnostics VI. The Diagnostic Potential of the C II Lines at 133.5 nm in the Solar Atmosphere
• Heating of the magnetic chromosphere: observational constraints from Ca II 8542 spectra
• Three-dimensional radiative transfer simulations of the scattering polarization of the hydrogen Ly$\alpha$ line in a MHD model of the chromosphere-corona transition region
• The Formation of IRIS Diagnostics. VII. The Formation of the OI 135.56 nm Line in the Solar Atmosphere
• Preprocess the Photospheric Vector Magnetograms for NLFFF Extrapolation using a Potential Field Model and an Optimization Method
• A comparison of preprocessing methods for solar force-free magnetic field extrapolation
• The Hanle effect of Ly$\alpha$ in an MHD model of the Solar Transition Region
• Resolving Azimuth Ambiguity Using Vertical Nature of Solar Quiet-Sun Magnetic Fields
• Resolving the Azimuthal Ambiguity in Vector Magnetogram Data with the Divergence-Free Condition: the Effects of Noise and Limited Spatial Resolution
• Evidence of the Relationship between the Emerging Magnetic Fields, Electric Currents, and Solar Flares Observed on May 10, 2012

Cited by in corpus (14)

• Solar Force-free Magnetic Fields
• Statistical Analysis of Torus and Kink Instabilities in Solar Eruptions
• Record-breaking coronal magnetic field in solar active region 12673
• Three-dimensional Forward-fit Modeling of the Hard X-Ray and the Microwave Emissions of the 2015 June 22 M6.5 Flare
• Data-Constrained Solar Modeling with GX Simulator
• Measuring the magnetic origins of solar flares, CMEs and Space Weather
• Force-Free Field Reconstructions Enhanced by Chromospheric Magnetic Field Data
• Revealing evolution of nonthermal electrons in solar flares using 3D modeling
• Rapid Variability in the SOL2011-08-04 Flare: Implications for Electron Acceleration
• Spatio-temporal energy partitioning in a non-thermally dominated two-loop solar flare
• Exploring spectropolarimetric inversions using neural fields. Solar chromospheric magnetic field under the weak-field approximation
• Energy budget of plasma motions, heating, and electron acceleration in a three-loop solar flare
• Coronal Heating Law Constrained by Microwave Gyroresonant Emission
• Nonlinear force-free modeling of flare-related magnetic field changes at the photosphere and chromosphere