Comparison of Two Coronal Magnetic Field Models for Reconstructing a Sigmoidal Solar Active Region With Coronal Loops

Abstract

Magnetic field extrapolation is an important tool to study the three-dimensional (3D) solar coronal magnetic field which is difficult to directly measure. Various analytic models and numerical codes exist but their results often drastically differ. Thus a critical comparison of the modeled magnetic field lines with the observed coronal loops is strongly required to establish the credibility of the model. Here we compare two different non-potential extrapolation codes, a non-linear force-free field code (CESE-MHD-NLFFF) and a non-force-free field (NFFF) code in modeling a solar active region (AR) that has a sigmoidal configuration just before a major flare erupted from the region. A 2D coronal-loop tracing and fitting method is employed to study the 3D misalignment angles between the extrapolated magnetic field lines and the EUV loops as imaged by SDO/AIA. It is found that the CESE-MHD-NLFFF code with preprocessed magnetogram performs the best, outputting a field which matches the coronal loops in the AR core imaged in AIA 94 Å with a misalignment angle of ~10 degree. This suggests that the CESE-MHD-NLFFF code, even without using the information of coronal loops in constraining the magnetic field, performs as good as some coronal-loop forward-fitting models. For the loops as imaged by AIA 171 Å in the outskirts of the AR, all the codes including the potential-field give comparable results of mean misalignment angle (~30 degree). Thus further improvement of the codes is needed for a better reconstruction of the long loops enveloping the core region.

arXiv comment13 pages, 6 figures, accepted by ApJ

References in corpus (43)

• The Helioseismic and Magnetic Imager (HMI) Vector Magnetic Field Pipeline: SHARPs -- Space-weather HMI Active Region Patches
• The Helioseismic and Magnetic Imager (HMI) Vector Magnetic Field Pipeline: Overview and Performance
• Optimization code with weighting function for the reconstruction of coronal magnetic fields
• Evolution of Magnetic Field and Energy in A Major Eruptive Active Region Based on SDO/HMI Observation
• A Critical Assessment of Nonlinear Force-Free Field Modeling of the Solar Corona for Active Region 10953
• Structure, Stability, and Evolution of Magnetic Flux Ropes from the Perspective of Magnetic Twist
• Non-linear force-free field modeling of a solar active region around the time of a major flare and coronal mass ejection
• The solar magnetic field
• The standard flare model in three dimensions III. Slip-running reconnection properties
• Nonlinear force-free modeling of the solar coronal magnetic field
• MHD Simulation of a Sigmoid Eruption of Active Region 11283
• How to optimize nonlinear force-free coronal magnetic field extrapolations from SDO/HMI vector magnetograms?
• Magnetohydrodynamic Modeling of the Solar Eruption on 2010 April 8
• Formation of a Double-decker Magnetic Flux Rope in the Sigmoidal Solar Active Region 11520
• Slipping Magnetic Reconnection, Chromospheric Evaporation, Implosion, and Precursors in the 2014 September 10 X1.6-Class Solar Flare
• Quasi-periodic Slipping Magnetic Reconnection During an X-class Solar Flare Observed by the Solar Dynamics Observatory and Interface Region Imaging Spectrograph
• Extrapolation of the Solar Coronal Magnetic Field from SDO/HMI Magnetogram by a CESE--MHD--NLFFF Code
• Magnetohydrodynamic Simulation of the X2.2 Solar Flare on 2011 February 15: I. Comparison with the Observations
• The Influence of Spatial Resolution on Nonlinear Force-Free Modeling
• Hooked flare ribbons and flux-rope related QSL footprints
• Nonlinear Force-Free Field Extrapolation of a Coronal Magnetic Flux Rope Supporting a Large-Scale Filament from Photospheric Vector Magnetogram
• Using Coronal Loops to Reconstruct the Magnetic Field of an Active Region Before and After a Major Flare
• An optimization principle for the computation of MHD equilibria in the solar corona
• Testing magnetofrictional extrapolation with the Titov-Démoulin model of solar active regions
• Accuracy of magnetic energy computations
• Imaging and Spectroscopic Diagnostics on the Formation of Two Magnetic Flux Ropes Revealed by SDO/AIA and IRIS
• Including stereoscopic information in the reconstruction of coronal magnetic fields
• Magnetic Field Extrapolations in the Corona: Success and Future Improvements
• A New Implementation of the Magnetohydrodynamics-Relaxation Method for Nonlinear Force-Free Field Extrapolation in the Solar Corona
• Guiding Nonlinear Force-Free Modeling Using Coronal Observations: First Results Using a Quasi Grad-Rubin Scheme
• A Practical Approach to Coronal Magnetic Field Extrapolation Based on the Principle of Minimum Dissipation Rate
• The Magnetic Field of Active Region 11158 During the 2011 February 12-17 Flares : Differences between Photospheric Extrapolation and Coronal Forward-Fitting Methods
• Three-dimensional Magnetic Restructuring in Two Homologous Solar Flares in the Seismically Active NOAA AR 11283
• A New Code for Nonlinear Force-Free Field Extrapolation of the Global Corona
• Nonlinear Force-Free Magnetic Field Fitting to Coronal Loops with and without Stereoscopy
• Preprocess the Photospheric Vector Magnetograms for NLFFF Extrapolation using a Potential Field Model and an Optimization Method
• A Nonlinear Force-Free Magnetic Field Approximation Suitable for Fast Forward-Fitting to Coronal Loops. I. Theory
• Chromospheric polarimetry through multi-line observations of the 850 nm spectral region
• Optimization of Curvi-Linear Tracing Applied to Solar Physics and Biophysics
• A comparison of preprocessing methods for solar force-free magnetic field extrapolation
• Direct Measurements of Magnetic Twist in the Solar Corona
• A Comparison Between Nonlinear Force-Free Field and Potential Field Models Using Full-Disk SDO/HMI Magnetogram
• Nonlinear force-free modeling of the corona in spherical coordinates

Cited by in corpus (12)

• Drifting of the line-tied footpoints of CME flux-ropes
• A Study of Pre-Flare Solar Coronal Magnetic Fields: Magnetic Flux Ropes
• Magnetohydrodynamic Simulation of the X9.3 Flare on 2017 September 6: Evolving Magnetic Topology
• Magnetohydrodynamic Simulation of Magnetic Null-point Reconnections and Coronal dimmings during the X2.1 flare in NOAA AR 11283
• Magnetohydrodynamic simulation of magnetic null-point reconnections in NOAA AR12192 initiated with an extrapolated non-force-free-field
• Quantitative Characterization of Magnetic Flux Rope Properties for Two Solar Eruption Events
• Formation of an observed eruptive flux rope above the torus instability threshold through tether-cutting magnetic reconnection
• A Study of Pre-flare Solar Coronal Magnetic Fields: Magnetic Energy and Helicity
• Magnetohydrodynamics evolution of three-dimensional magnetic null in NOAA active region 11515 initiated using non-force-free field extrapolation
• Magnetic field extrapolation in active region well comparable with observations in multiple layers
• The Initiation Mechanism of the First On-disk X-Class Flare of Solar Cycle 25
• The Properties of Non-Potential Magnetic Field Parameters in a Super-Active Region with Complex Structures and Strong Solar Flares