Accuracy of magnetic energy computations

Abstract

For magnetically driven events, the magnetic energy of the system is the prime energy reservoir that fuels the dynamical evolution. In the solar context, the free energy is one of the main indicators used in space weather forecasts to predict the eruptivity of active regions. A trustworthy estimation of the magnetic energy is therefore needed in three-dimensional models of the solar atmosphere, eg in coronal fields reconstructions or numerical simulations. The expression of the energy of a system as the sum of its potential energy and its free energy (Thomson's theorem) is strictly valid when the magnetic field is exactly solenoidal. For numerical realizations on a discrete grid, this property may be only approximately fulfilled. We show that the imperfect solenoidality induces terms in the energy that can lead to misinterpreting the amount of free energy present in a magnetic configuration. We consider a decomposition of the energy in solenoidal and nonsolenoidal parts which allows the unambiguous estimation of the nonsolenoidal contribution to the energy. We apply this decomposition to six typical cases broadly used in solar physics. We quantify to what extent the Thomson theorem is not satisfied when approximately solenoidal fields are used. The quantified errors on energy vary from negligible to significant errors, depending on the extent of the nonsolenoidal component. We identify the main source of errors and analyze the implications of adding a variable amount of divergence to various solenoidal fields. Finally, we present pathological unphysical situations where the estimated free energy would appear to be negative, as found in some previous works, and we identify the source of this error to be the presence of a finite divergence. We provide a method of quantifying the effect of a finite divergence in numerical fields, together with detailed diagnostics of its sources.

References in corpus (5)

• Global Energetics of Thirty-Eight Large Solar Eruptive Events
• Preprocessing of vector magnetograph data for a non-linear force-free magnetic field reconstruction
• Non-linear force-free field modeling of a solar active region around the time of a major flare and coronal mass ejection
• The standard flare model in three dimensions. II. Upper limit on solar flare energy
• Sigmoid-to-Flux-Rope Transition Leading to A Loop-Like Coronal Mass Ejection

Cited by in corpus (39)

• Structure, Stability, and Evolution of Magnetic Flux Ropes from the Perspective of Magnetic Twist
• Relative magnetic helicity as a diagnostic of solar eruptivity
• The Influence of Spatial Resolution on Nonlinear Force-Free Modeling
• Magnetic helicity estimations in models and observations of the solar magnetic field. Part I: Finite volume methods
• Testing magnetic helicity conservation in a solar-like active event
• Threshold of non-potential magnetic helicity ratios at the onset of solar eruptions
• Validation and Benchmarking of a Practical Free Magnetic Energy and Relative Magnetic Helicity Budget Calculation in Solar Magnetic Structures
• Magnetic helicity budget of solar active regions prolific of eruptive and confined flares
• Flux rope, hyperbolic flux tube, and late EUV phases in a non-eruptive circular-ribbon flare
• An Observationally-Constrained Model of a Flux Rope that Formed in the Solar Corona
• Magnetic helicity and energy budget around large confined and eruptive solar flares
• Magnetic Helicity Estimations in Models and Observations of the Solar Magnetic Field. Part III: Twist Number Method
• The origin of net electric currents in solar active regions
• Magnetic helicity and eruptivity in active region 12673
• Analysis and modelling of recurrent solar flares observed with Hinode/EIS on March 9, 2012
• Observations of a Footpoint Drift of an Erupting Flux Rope
• Time variations of the non-potential and volume-threading magnetic helicities
• On the reliability of magnetic energy and helicity computations based on nonlinear force-free coronal magnetic field models
• Comparison of Two Coronal Magnetic Field Models for Reconstructing a Sigmoidal Solar Active Region With Coronal Loops
• Magnetic helicity estimations in models and observations of the solar magnetic field. Part IV: Application to solar observations
• Deducing the reliability of relative helicities from nonlinear force-free coronal models
• Relative field line helicity of a large eruptive solar active region
• Computation of Relative Magnetic Helicity in Spherical Coordinates
• The 2019 International Women's Day event: A two-step solar flare with multiple eruptive signatures and low Earth impact
• Tracking magnetic flux and helicity from Sun to Earth -- Multi-spacecraft analysis of a magnetic cloud and its solar source
• Studying the transfer of magnetic helicity in solar active regions with the connectivity-based helicity flux density method
• Comparison of magnetic energy and helicity in coronal jet simulations
• A Study of Pre-flare Solar Coronal Magnetic Fields: Magnetic Energy and Helicity
• The 17 February 2013 sunquake in the context of the active region's magnetic field configuration
• Energy and helicity fluxes in line-tied eruptive simulations
• On measuring divergence for magnetic field modeling
• The effect of spatial sampling on magnetic field modeling and helicity computation
• Extrapolation of Three-dimensional Magnetic Field Structure in Flare-productive Active Regions with Different Initial Conditions
• Additivity of relative magnetic helicity in finite volumes
• Comparison of Two Methods for Calculating Magnetic Helicity in the Solar Corona
• Estimating electric current densities in solar active regions
• Relative Magnetic Helicity Based on a Periodic Potential Field
• Deriving Potential Coronal Magnetic Fields from Vector Magnetograms
• Formation and rising phase of a flux rope through data-constrained simulations