Towards a Quantitative Comparison of Magnetic Field Extrapolations and Observed Coronal Loops

Abstract

It is widely believed that loops observed in the solar atmosphere trace out magnetic field lines. However, the degree to which magnetic field extrapolations yield field lines that actually do follow loops has yet to be studied systematically. In this paper we apply three different extrapolation techniques - a simple potential model, a NLFF model based on photospheric vector data, and a NLFF model based on forward fitting magnetic sources with vertical currents - to 15 active regions that span a wide range of magnetic conditions. We use a distance metric to assess how well each of these models is able to match field lines to the 12,202 loops traced in coronal images. These distances are typically 1-2". We also compute the misalignment angle between each traced loop and the local magnetic field vector, and find values of 5-12${}^{\circ }$. We find that the NLFF models generally outperform the potential extrapolation on these metrics, although the differences between the different extrapolations are relatively small. The methodology that we employ for this study suggests a number of ways that both the extrapolations and loop identification can be improved.

arXiv commentAccepted for publication in ApJ

References in corpus (31)

• The Interface Region Imaging Spectrograph (IRIS)
• Optimization code with weighting function for the reconstruction of coronal magnetic fields
• Solar Orbiter: Exploring the Sun-heliosphere connection
• Preprocessing of vector magnetograph data for a non-linear force-free magnetic field reconstruction
• A Critical Assessment of Nonlinear Force-Free Field Modeling of the Solar Corona for Active Region 10953
• A Systematic Survey of High Temperature Emission in Solar Active Regions
• How to optimize nonlinear force-free coronal magnetic field extrapolations from SDO/HMI vector magnetograms?
• Constraints on the Heating of High Temperature Active Region Loops: Observations from Hinode and SDO
• The Magnetic Topology of Coronal Mass Ejection sources
• Extrapolation of the Solar Coronal Magnetic Field from SDO/HMI Magnetogram by a CESE--MHD--NLFFF Code
• The Influence of Spatial Resolution on Nonlinear Force-Free Modeling
• Hydrostatic Modeling of the Integrated Soft X-Ray and EUV Emission in Solar Active Regions
• Static and Dynamic Modeling of a Solar Active Region. I: Soft X-Ray Emission
• Guiding Nonlinear Force-Free Modeling Using Coronal Observations: First Results Using a Quasi Grad-Rubin Scheme
• Modeling X-ray Loops and EUV "Moss" in an Active Region Core
• First 3D Reconstructions of Coronal Loops with the STEREO A+B Spacecraft: IV. Magnetic Modeling with Twisted Force-Free Fields
• The Vertical Current Approximation Nonlinear Force-Free Field Code - Description, Performance Tests, and Measurements of Magnetic Energies Dissipated in Solar Flares
• Plasma parameters and geometry of cool and warm active region loops
• Nonlinear Force-Free Magnetic Field Fitting to Coronal Loops with and without Stereoscopy
• A Nonlinear Force-Free Magnetic Field Approximation Suitable for Fast Forward-Fitting to Coronal Loops. I. Theory
• Patterns of Activity in a Global Model of a Solar Active Region
• Bootstrapping the Coronal Magnetic Field with STEREO: I. Unipolar Potential Field Modeling
• Spectroscopic Observations of Fe XVIII in Solar Active Regions
• LEMUR: Large European Module for solar Ultraviolet Research. European contribution to JAXA's Solar-C mission
• Optimization of Curvi-Linear Tracing Applied to Solar Physics and Biophysics
• Tracing the Chromospheric and Coronal Magnetic Field with AIA, IRIS, IBIS, and ROSA Data
• A Nonlinear Force-Free Magnetic Field Approximation Suitable for Fast Forward-Fitting to Coronal Loops. II. Numeric Code and Tests
• Constraining 3D Magnetic Field Extrapolations Using The Twin Perspectives of STEREO
• Modeling Coronal Response in Decaying Active Regions with Magnetic Flux Transport and Steady Heating
• Nonlinear force-free coronal magnetic stereoscopy
• Solar Stereoscopy with STEREO/EUVI A and B spacecraft from small (6 deg) to large (170 deg) spacecraft separation angles

Cited by in corpus (7)

• Probing the Physics of the Solar Atmosphere with the Multi-slit Solar Explorer (MUSE): II. Flares and Eruptions
• The Magnetic Properties of Heating Events on High-Temperature Active Region Loops
• Helical Twisting Number and Braiding Linkage Number of Solar Coronal Loops
• Torsional Alfvénic Oscillations Discovered in the Magnetic Free Energy During Solar Flares
• Global Energetics of Solar Flares. IX. Refined Magnetic Modeling
• On the spectroscopic detection of periodic plasma flows in loops undergoing thermal non-equilibrium
• Spectropolarimetric synthesis of forbidden lines in MHD models of coronal bright points