Comparison of force-free coronal magnetic field modeling using vector fields from Hinode and Solar Dynamics Observatory

Abstract

Photospheric magnetic vector maps from two different instruments are used to model the nonlinear force-free coronal magnetic field above an active region. We use vector maps inferred from polarization measurements of the Solar Dynamics Observatory/Helioseismic and Magnetic Imager (HMI) and the Solar Optical Telescope Spectropolarimeter (SP) aboard Hinode. Besides basing our model calculations on HMI data, we use both, SP data of original resolution and scaled down to the resolution of HMI. This allows us to compare the model results based on data from different instruments and to investigate how a binning of high-resolution data effects the model outcome. The resulting 3D magnetic fields are compared in terms of magnetic energy content and magnetic topology. We find stronger magnetic fields in the SP data, translating into a higher total magnetic energy of the SP models. The net Lorentz forces of the HMI and SP lower boundaries verify their force-free compatibility. We find substantial differences in the absolute estimates of the magnetic field energy but similar relative estimates, e.g., the fraction of excess energy and of the flux shared by distinct areas. The location and extension of neighboring connectivity domains differs and the SP model fields tend to be higher and more vertical. Hence, conclusions about the magnetic connectivity based on force-free field models are to be drawn with caution. We find that the deviations of the model solution when based on the lower-resolution SP data are small compared to the differences of the solutions based on data from different instruments.

8 pages, 10 figures, APJ, accepted

References in corpus (4)

• Free Magnetic Energy in Solar Active Regions above the Minimum-Energy Relaxed State
• First nonlinear force-free field extrapolations of SOLIS/VSM data
• Quiet Sun magnetic fields from space-borne observations: simulating Hinode's case
• Understanding the white-light flare on 2012 March 9 : Evidence of a two-step magnetic reconnection

Cited by in corpus (8)

• The Influence of Spatial Resolution on Nonlinear Force-Free Modeling
• Global Energetics of Solar Flares: I. Magnetic Energies
• Force-free field modeling of twist and braiding-induced magnetic energy in an active-region corona
• The effect of spatial sampling on magnetic field modeling and helicity computation
• Extrapolation of Three-dimensional Magnetic Field Structure in Flare-productive Active Regions with Different Initial Conditions
• How transverse MHD wave-driven turbulence influences the density filling factor in the solar corona?
• Temporal and spatial relationship of flare signatures and the force-free coronal magnetic field
• Open and closed magnetic configurations of twisted flux tubes