Effects of uncertainties in simulations of extragalactic UHECR propagation, using CRPropa and SimProp

Abstract

The results of simulations of the extragalactic propagation of ultra-high energy cosmic rays (UHECRs) have intrinsic uncertainties due to poorly known physical quantities and approximations used in the codes. We quantify the uncertainties in the simulated UHECR spectrum and composition due to different models for the extragalactic background light (EBL), different photodisintegration setups, approximations concerning photopion production and the use of different simulation codes. We discuss the results for several representative source scenarios with proton, nitrogen or iron at injection. For this purpose we used SimProp and CRPropa, two publicly available codes for Monte Carlo simulations of UHECR propagation. CRPropa is a detailed and extensive simulation code, while SimProp aims to achieve acceptable results using a simpler code. We show that especially the choices for the EBL model and the photodisintegration setup can have a considerable impact on the simulated UHECR spectrum and composition.

Published as JCAP10(2015)063

References in corpus (12)

• Depth of Maximum of Air-Shower Profiles at the Pierre Auger Observatory: Measurements at Energies above 10^17.8 eV
• A dip in the UHECR spectrum and the transition from galactic to extragalactic cosmic rays
• A complete model of the CR spectrum and composition across the Galactic to Extragalactic transition
• Propagation of high-energy cosmic rays in extragalactic turbulent magnetic fields: resulting energy spectrum and composition
• Indications of Negative Evolution for the Sources of the Highest Energy Cosmic Rays
• Inhomogeneous extragalactic magnetic fields and the second knee in the cosmic ray spectrum
• Corrected Table for the Parametric Coefficients for the Optical Depth of the Universe to Gamma-rays at Various Redshifts
• Cosmogenic neutrinos and ultra-high energy cosmic ray models
• CRPropa: A Numerical Tool for the Propagation of UHE Cosmic Rays, Gamma-rays and Neutrinos
• Diffusion of cosmic rays at EeV energies in inhomogeneous extragalactic magnetic fields
• Non-Universal Spectra of Ultra-High Energy Cosmic Ray Primaries and Secondaries in a Structured Universe
• Cosmic rays: the spectrum and chemical composition from $10^{10}$ to $10^{20}$ eV

Cited by in corpus (50)

• Combined fit of spectrum and composition data as measured by the Pierre Auger Observatory
• CRPropa 3 - a Public Astrophysical Simulation Framework for Propagating Extraterrestrial Ultra-High Energy Particles
• Open Questions in Cosmic-Ray Research at Ultrahigh Energies
• Ultra-High-Energy Cosmic Rays
• Origin of the ankle in the ultra-high energy cosmic ray spectrum and of the extragalactic protons below it
• Cosmic-ray energy spectrum and composition up to the ankle - the case for a second Galactic component
• Cosmogenic photon and neutrino fluxes in the Auger era
• A new view on Auger data and cosmogenic neutrinos in light of different nuclear disintegration and air-shower models
• CRPropa 3.2 -- an advanced framework for high-energy particle propagation in extragalactic and galactic spaces
• Cosmic-Ray and Neutrino Emission from Gamma-Ray Bursts with a Nuclear Cascade
• Tidally disrupted stars as a possible origin of both cosmic rays and neutrinos at the highest energies
• Particle acceleration in astrophysical jets
• Ultra-High Energy Cosmic Rays and Neutrinos from Tidal Disruptions by Massive Black Holes
• The Gamma-Ray Window to Intergalactic Magnetism
• On the common origin of cosmic rays across the ankle and diffuse neutrinos at the highest energies from low-luminosity Gamma-Ray Bursts
• Constraining the sources of ultra-high-energy cosmic rays across and above the ankle with the spectrum and composition data measured at the Pierre Auger Observatory
• Fornax A, Centaurus A and other radio galaxies as sources of ultra-high energy cosmic rays
• Ultra-High-Energy Cosmic Rays from Radio Galaxies
• Implications of Strong Intergalactic Magnetic Fields for Ultra-High-Energy Cosmic-Ray Astronomy
• White Paper and Roadmap for Quantum Gravity Phenomenology in the Multi-Messenger Era
• The Imprint of Large Scale Structure on the Ultra-High-Energy Cosmic Ray Sky
• SimProp v2r4: Monte Carlo simulation code for UHECR propagation
• Nuclear Physics Meets the Sources of the Ultra-High Energy Cosmic Rays
• Production and propagation of ultra-high energy photons using CRPropa 3
• Ultrahigh-energy cosmic rays from tidally-ignited white dwarfs
• Testing effects of Lorentz invariance violation in the propagation of astroparticles with the Pierre Auger Observatory
• Improved photomeson model for interactions of cosmic ray nuclei
• Bayesian Inference Constraints on Astrophysical Production of Ultra-high Energy Cosmic Rays and Cosmogenic Neutrino Flux Predictions
• Gamma-ray Cosmology and Tests of Fundamental Physics
• Systematic parameter space study for the UHECR origin from GRBs in models with multiple internal shocks
• Cosmogenic Neutrinos Through the GRAND Lens Unveil the Nature of Cosmic Accelerators
• Curious case of the maximum rigidity distribution of cosmic-ray accelerators
• Secondary neutrino and gamma-ray fluxes from SimProp and CRPropa
• Ultra high energy cosmic rays from non-relativistic quasar outflows
• Energy Spectrum of Fast Second Order Fermi Accelerators as Sources of Ultra-High-Energy Cosmic Rays
• Ultrahigh energy cosmic rays and neutrinos from light nuclei composition
• PeV-EeV neutrinos from gamma-ray blazars due to ultrahigh-energy cosmic-ray propagation
• Quantum gravity phenomenology at the dawn of the multi-messenger era -- A review
• The photo-disintegration of ${}^4$He on the cosmic microwave background is less severe than earlier thought
• Cosmic ray acceleration to ultrahigh energy in radio galaxies
• Surprises from extragalactic propagation of UHECRs
• Astrophysical neutrino production and impact of associated uncertainties in photo-hadronic interactions of UHECRs
• Modification of the Dipole in Arrival Directions of Ultra-high-energy Cosmic Rays due to the Galactic Magnetic Field
• Recent results from the Pierre Auger Observatory
• Evaluations of uncertainties in simulations of propagation of ultrahigh-energy cosmic-ray nuclei derived from microscopic nuclear models
• Combined Fit of Spectrum and Composition for FR0 Radio-galaxy-emitted Ultra-high-energy Cosmic Rays with Resulting Secondary Photons and Neutrinos
• Revisiting Propagation Delays of Ultra-High-Energy Cosmic Rays from Long-lived Sources
• SimProp v2r3: Monte Carlo simulation code of UHECR propagation
• Extragalactic Sources and Propagation of UHECRs
• Astrophysical interpretation of Pierre Auger Observatory measurements of the UHECR energy spectrum and mass composition