Tracing galaxy populations through cosmic time: A critical test of methods for connecting the same galaxies between different redshifts at $z<3$

Abstract

Connecting galaxies with their descendants (or progenitors) at different redshifts can yield strong constraints on galaxy evolution. Observational studies have historically selected samples of galaxies using a physical quantity, such as stellar mass, either above a constant limit or at a constant cumulative number density. Investigation into the efficacy of these selection methods has not been fully explored. Using a set of four semi-analytical models based on the output of the Millennium Simulation, we find that selecting galaxies at a constant number density (in the range $-4.3<\log n[{\mathrm{Mpc}}^{-3}{h}^3]<-3.0$) is superior to a constant stellar mass selected sample, although it still has significant limitations. Recovery of the average stellar mass, stellar mass density and average star-formation rate is highly dependent on the choice of number density but can all be recovered to within $<50\%$ at the commonly employed choice of $\log n[{\mathrm{Mpc}}^{-3}{h}^3]=-4.0$, corresponding to $\log M_{\odot }/h\sim 11.2$ at $z=0$, but this increases at lower mass limits. We show that there is a large scatter between the location of a given galaxy in a rank ordering based on stellar mass between different redshifts. We find that the inferred velocity dispersion may be a better tracer of galaxy properties, although further investigation is warranted into simulating this property. Finally, we find that over large redshift ranges selection at a constant number density is more effective in tracing the progenitors of modern galaxies than vice-versa.

arXiv commentAccepted to MNRAS

References in corpus (41)

• Seven-Year Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) Observations: Cosmological Interpretation
• Planck 2013 results. XVI. Cosmological parameters
• Simulating the joint evolution of quasars, galaxies and their large-scale distribution
• The many lives of active galactic nuclei: cooling flows, black holes and the luminosities and colours of galaxies
• The broken hierarchy of galaxy formation
• Introducing the Illustris Project: Simulating the coevolution of dark and visible matter in the Universe
• Hierarchical Galaxy Formation
• The hierarchical formation of the brightest cluster galaxies
• 3D-HST+CANDELS: The Evolution of the Galaxy Size-Mass Distribution since $z=3$
• From dwarf spheroidals to cDs: Simulating the galaxy population in a LCDM cosmology
• The SAURON project - IV. The mass-to-light ratio, the virial mass estimator and the fundamental plane of elliptical and lenticular galaxies
• Introducing the Illustris Project: the evolution of galaxy populations across cosmic time
• The Growth of Massive Galaxies Since z=2
• Galaxy formation in the Planck Cosmology - I. Matching the observed evolution of star formation rates, colours and stellar masses
• A concise reference to (projected) Sersic R^{1/n} quantities, including Concentration, Profile Slopes, Petrosian indices, and Kron Magnitudes
• A Direct Measurement of Major Galaxy Mergers at z < 3
• The cosmological size and velocity dispersion evolution of massive early-type galaxies
• Galaxy formation in WMAP1 and WMAP7 cosmologies
• Bulge mass is king: The dominant role of the bulge in determining the fraction of passive galaxies in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey
• A marked correlation function analysis of halo formation times in the Millennium Simulation
• The Structures of Distant Galaxies - III: The Merger History of over 20,000 Massive Galaxies at z < 1.2
• Galaxy luminosities, stellar masses, sizes, velocity dispersions as a function of morphological type
• The Rising Star-Formation Histories of Distant Galaxies and Implications for Gas Accretion with Time
• The Redshift and Mass Dependence on the Formation of The Hubble Sequence at z>1 from CANDELS/UDS
• Using Cumulative Number Densities to Compare Galaxies across Cosmic Time
• Revealing velocity dispersion as the best indicator of a galaxy's color, compared to stellar mass, surface mass density or morphology
• Mild Velocity Dispersion Evolution of Spheroid-like Massive Galaxies since z~2
• Halpha Equivalent Widths from the 3D-HST survey: evolution with redshift and dependence on stellar mass
• A Comparison between Semi-Analytic Model Predictions for the CANDELS Survey
• The Progenitors of Local Ultra-massive Galaxies Across Cosmic Time: from Dusty Star-bursting to Quiescent Stellar Populations
• The Pair Fraction of Massive Galaxies at 0 < z < 3
• Evidence for a correlation between the sizes of quiescent galaxies and local environment to z ~ 2
• The Bulge-Disk Decomposed Evolution of Massive Galaxies at 1<z<3 in CANDELS
• A Surprisingly High Pair Fraction for Extremely Massive Galaxies at z ~ 3 in the GOODS NICMOS Survey
• Tracing Galaxies Through Cosmic Time with Number Density Selection
• The Stellar Mass Growth of Brightest Cluster Galaxies in the IRAC Shallow Cluster Survey
• Gas Accretion as a Dominant Formation Mode in Massive Galaxies from the GOODS NICMOS Survey
• Minor vs Major Mergers: The Stellar Mass Growth of Massive Galaxies from z=3 using Number Density Selection Techniques
• A Comparison of Galaxy Merger History Observations and Predictions from Semi-Analytic Models
• Galaxy Formation as a Cosmological Tool. I: The Galaxy Merger History as a Measure of Cosmological Parameters
• Evolution of Quiescent and Star-Forming Galaxies Since z~1.5 as a Function of Their Velocity Dispersions

Cited by in corpus (32)

• A consistent measure of the merger histories of massive galaxies using close-pair statistics I: Major mergers at $z<3.5$
• The impact of assembly bias on the halo occupation in hydrodynamical simulations
• The Scaling of Stellar Mass and Central Stellar Velocity Dispersion for Quiescent galaxies at z < 0.7
• The morphologies of massive galaxies from z~3 - Witnessing the 2 channels of bulge growth
• An analysis of the evolving comoving number density of galaxies in hydrodynamical simulations
• The Evolution of Assembly Bias
• The ALPINE-ALMA [CII] survey: The contribution of major mergers to the galaxy mass assembly at z~5
• A direct measurement of galaxy major and minor merger rates and stellar mass accretion histories at $z<3$ using galaxy pairs in the REFINE survey
• Galaxy Evolution in all Five CANDELS Fields and IllustrisTNG: Morphological, Structural, and the Major Merger Evolution to $z\sim 3$
• Deriving star formation histories from photometry using energy balance spectral energy distribution modelling
• X-shooter Spectroscopy and HST Imaging of 15 Ultra Massive Quiescent Galaxies at $z\gtrsim 2$
• The kinematics of massive quiescent galaxies at $1.4<z<2.1$: dark matter fractions, IMF variation, and the relation to local early-type galaxies
• Mergers and Star Formation: The environment and Stellar Mass Growth of the Progenitors of Ultra-Massive Galaxies since z = 2
• The formation history of massive cluster galaxies as revealed by CARLA
• Forward and backward galaxy evolution in comoving number density space
• Unbiased Differential Size Evolution and the Inside-Out Growth of Galaxies in the Deep CANDELS GOODS Fields at $1\le z\le 7$
• The evolution of the galaxy content of dark matter haloes
• The Evolution of Galaxies at Constant Number Density: A Less Biased View of Star Formation, Quenching, and Structural Formation
• Stellar Mass Growth of Brightest Cluster Galaxy Progenitors in COSMOS Since z ~ 3
• Cosmic CARNage II: the evolution of the galaxy stellar mass function in observations and galaxy formation models
• Surface Brightness Evolution of Galaxies in the CANDELS GOODS Fields up to $z\sim 6$: High-z Galaxies are Unique or Remain Undetected
• A large difference in the progenitor masses of active and passive galaxies in the EAGLE simulation
• Stellar populations, stellar masses and the formation of galaxy bulges and discs at $z<3$ in CANDELS
• The Effect of Assembly Bias on Redshift Space Distortions
• Exploring the progenitors of brightest cluster galaxies at z~2
• Detection of Prominent Stellar Disks in the Progenitors of Present-day Massive Elliptical Galaxies
• Galaxy growth from redshift 5 to 0 at fixed comoving number density
• Connecting the Dots: Tracking Galaxy Evolution Using Constant Cumulative Number Density at 3<z<7
• Emission Line Galaxies in the SHARDS Frontier Fields I: Candidate Selection and the Discovery of Bursty Hα Emitters
• The significant effects of stellar mass estimation on galaxy pair fractions
• Astraeus VII: The environmental-dependent assembly of galaxies in the Epoch of Reionization
• The average structural evolution of massive galaxies can be reliably estimated using cumulative galaxy number densities