On the gap-opening criterion of migrating planets in protoplanetary disks

Abstract

We perform two-dimensional hydrodynamical simulations to quantitatively explore the torque balance criterion for gap-opening (as formulated by Crida et al. 2006) in a variety of disks when considering a migrating planet. We find that even when the criterion is satisfied, there are instances when planets still do not open gaps. We stress that gap-opening is not only dependent on whether a planet has the ability to open a gap, but whether it can do so quickly enough. This can be expressed as an additional condition on the gap-opening timescale versus the crossing time, i.e. the time it takes the planet to cross the region which it is carving out. While this point has been briefly made in the previous literature, our results quantify it for a range of protoplanetary disk properties and planetary masses, demonstrating how crucial it is for gap-opening. This additional condition has important implications for the survival of planets formed by core accretion in low mass disks as well as giant planets or brown dwarfs formed by gravitational instability in massive disks. It is particularly important for planets with intermediate masses susceptible to Type III-like migration. For some observed transition disks or disks with gaps, we expect that estimates on the potential planet masses based on the torque balance gap-opening criterion alone may not be sufficient. With consideration of this additional timescale criterion theoretical studies may find a reduced planet survivability or that planets may migrate further inwards before opening a gap.

arXiv commentAccepted by ApJ, 22 pages, 13 figures, 6 tables

References in corpus (47)

• Disk Frequencies and Lifetimes in Young Clusters
• Nonlinear Outcome of Gravitational Instability in Cooling, Gaseous Disks
• Towards a Deterministic Model of Planetary Formation I: a Desert in the Mass and Semi Major Axis Distributions of Extra Solar Planets
• The Keck Planet Search: Detectability and the Minimum Mass and Orbital Period Distribution of Extrasolar Planets
• Planet-disk interaction and orbital evolution
• On the width and shape of gaps in protoplanetary disks
• FARGO: a fast eulerian transport algorithm for differentially rotating disks
• A comparative study of disc-planet interaction
• Runaway migration and the formation of hot Jupiters
• Investigating fragmentation conditions in self-gravitating accretion discs
• On the Dynamical Foundations of Alpha Disks
• Three-dimensional Calculations of High and Low-mass Planets Embedded in Protoplanetary Discs
• The evolution of a supermassive binary caused by an accretion disc
• Clumps in the Outer Disk by Disk Instability: Why They are Initially Gas Giants and the Legacy of Disruption
• On the corotation torque in a radiatively inefficient disk
• Challenges in Forming Planets by Gravitational Instability: Disk Irradiation and Clump Migration, Accretion & Tidal Destructio
• Migration and giant planet formation
• Characterising the Gravitational Instability in Cooling Accretion Discs
• On the formation of planetary systems via oligarchic growth in thermally evolving viscous discs
• Planet migration and gap formation by tidally-induced shocks
• Gap Opening by Extremely Low Mass Planets in a Viscous Disk
• On the migration of protogiant solid cores
• Small vs large dust grains in transitional disks: do different cavity sizes indicate a planet?
• Formation of planets by tidal downsizing of giant planet embryos
• Rapid inward migration of planets formed by gravitational instability
• Type I planetary migration in a self-gravitating disk
• Gaps in the HD169142 protoplanetary disk revealed by polarimetric imaging: Signs of ongoing planet formation?
• On the convergence of the critical cooling timescale for the fragmentation of self-gravitating discs
• Meridional circulation of gas into gaps opened by giant planets in three-dimensional low-viscosity disks
• Formation of giant planets and brown dwarfs on wide orbits
• Treating gravity in thin disk simulations
• Towards a Population Synthesis Model of Objects formed by Self-Gravitating Disc Fragmentation and Tidal Downsizing
• ALMA hints at the presence of two companions in the disk around HD 100546
• Numerical convergence in self-gravitating shearing sheet simulations and the stochastic nature of disc fragmentation
• On the fragmentation criteria of self-gravitating protoplanetary discs
• Range of outward migration and influence of the disc's mass on the migration of giant planet cores
• Resolution requirements for Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics simulations of self-gravitating accretion discs
• On the width and shape of the corotation region for low-mass planets
• The dynamical role of the circumplanetary disc in planetary migration
• Numerical convergence in self-gravitating disc simulations: initial conditions and edge effects
• Resolved images of the protoplanetary disk around HD 100546 with ALMA
• The collapse of protoplanetary clumps formed through disc instability: 3D simulations of the pre-dissociation phase
• Convergence of simulations of self-gravitating accretion discs II: Sensitivity to the implementation of radiative cooling and artificial viscosity
• The fragmentation of protostellar discs: the Hill criterion for spiral arms
• Giant Planet Migration in Viscous Power-Law Discs
• Type III migration in a low viscosity disc
• Two-Dimensional Study of the Propagation of Planetary Wake and the Indication to Gap Opening in an Inviscid Protoplanetary Disk

Cited by in corpus (55)

• On the formation of multiple concentric rings and gaps in protoplanetary disks
• The VLT/NaCo large program to probe the occurrence of exoplanets and brown dwarfs at wide orbits. IV. Gravitational instability rarely forms wide, giant planets
• Final Masses of Giant Planets II: Jupiter Formation in a Gas-Depleted Disk
• Towards a population synthesis model of self-gravitating disc fragmentation and tidal downsizing II: The effect of fragment-fragment interactions
• An opening criterion for dust gaps in protoplanetary discs
• On the origin of the spiral morphology in the Elias 2-27 circumstellar disc
• Anisotropic Infall and Substructure formation in Embedded Disks
• Formation, Orbital and Internal Evolutions of Young Planetary Systems
• Convergence of the critical cooling rate for protoplanetary disk fragmentation achieved; the key role of numerical dissipation of angular momentum
• Testing giant planet formation in the transitional disk of SAO 206462 using deep VLT/SPHERE imaging
• Supermassive black hole pairs in clumpy galaxies at high redshift: delayed binary formation and concurrent mass growth
• Circumplanetary disks around young giant planets: a comparison between core-accretion and disk instability
• The Pairing of Accreting Massive Black Holes in Multiphase Circumnuclear Disks: the Interplay between Radiative Cooling, Star Formation, and Feedback Processes
• Is the ring inside or outside the planet?: The effect of planet migration on dust rings
• In-situ extreme mass ratio inspirals via sub-parsec formation and migration of stars in thin, gravitationally unstable AGN discs
• Runaway gas accretion and gap opening versus type~I migration
• Save the Planet, Feed the Star: How Super-Earths Survive Migration and Drive Disk Accretion
• Hunting for planets in the HL Tau disk
• Triggered fragmentation in self-gravitating discs: forming fragments at small radii
• Inner Super-Earths, Outer Gas Giants: How Pebble Isolation and Migration Feedback Keep Jupiters Cold
• The influence of infall on the properties of protoplanetary discs
• On the diversity in mass and orbital radius of giant planets formed via disk instability
• On the fragmentation boundary in magnetised self-gravitating discs
• A scaled-up planetary system around a supernova progenitor
• Giant planets and brown dwarfs on wide orbits: a code comparison project
• Formation of satellites in circumplanetary discs generated by disc instability
• Changes in the metallicity of gas giant planets due to pebble accretion
• Planet Migration in Self-Gravitating Discs: Survival of Planets
• The diverse lives of massive protoplanets in self-gravitating discs
• The evolution of self-gravitating accretion discs
• A Theoretical Framework for the Mass Distribution of Gas Giant Planets forming through the Core Accretion Paradigm
• Constraining the initial planetary population in the gravitational instability model
• Migration of accreting planets in radiative discs from dynamical torques
• Efficient radiative transfer techniques in hydrodynamic simulations
• Inward and outward migration of massive planets: moving towards a stalling radius
• Constraining the masses of planets in protoplanetary discs from the presence or absence of vortices -- Comparison with ALMA observations
• Analytic Approach to the Late Stages of Giant Planet Formation
• Direct detection of precursors of gas giants formed by gravitational instability with the Atacama Large Millimetre/sub-millimetre Array
• Characterizing fragmentation and sub-Jovian clump properties in magnetized young protoplanetary disks
• The implications of stochastic gas torques for asymmetric binaries in the LISA band
• On the origin of wide-orbit ALMA planets: giant protoplanets disrupted by their cores
• Turbulent Disk Viscosity and the Bifurcation of Planet Formation Histories
• Gap formation by inclined massive planets in locally isothermal three-dimensional discs
• Can chondrules be produced by the interaction of Jupiter with the protosolar disk?
• DIPSY: A new Disc Instability Population SYnthesis, II. The Populations of Companions Formed Through Disc Instability
• Calibrated Gas Accretion and Orbital Migration of Protoplanets in 1D Disc Models
• Iceline Variations Driven by Protoplanetary Disc Gaps
• Searching for wide-orbit gravitational instability protoplanets with ALMA in the dust continuum
• Pebble accretion in self-gravitating protostellar discs
• DIPSY: A new Disc Instability Population SYnthesis, I. Modeling, evolution of individual systems, and tests
• Continuing to Hide Signatures of Gravitational Instability in Protoplanetary Discs with Planets
• Stellar Stripping and Disruption in Disks around Supermassive Black Hole Binaries: Repeating nuclear transients prior to LISA events
• The role of migration traps in the formation of binary black holes in AGN disks
• The imprint of gas on gravitational waves from LISA intermediate-mass black hole binaries
• Gravitational instability in planet-forming discs