Giant planets and brown dwarfs on wide orbits: a code comparison project

Abstract

Gas clumps formed within massive gravitationally unstable circumstellar discs are potential seeds of gas giant planets, brown dwarfs and companion stars. Simulations show that competition between three processes -- migration, gas accretion and tidal disruption -- establishes what grows from a given seed. Here we investigate the robustness of numerical modelling of clump migration and accretion with the codes PHANTOM, GADGET, SPHINX, SEREN, GIZMO-MFM, SPHNG and FARGO. The test problem comprises a clump embedded in a massive disc at an initial separation of 120 AU. There is a general qualitative agreement between the codes, but the quantitative agreement in the planet migration rate ranges from $\sim 10$% to $\sim 50$%, depending on the numerical setup. We find that the artificial viscosity treatment and the sink particle prescription may account for much of the differences between the codes. In order to understand the wider implications of our work, we also attempt to reproduce the planet evolution tracks from our hydrodynamical simulations with prescriptions from three previous population synthesis studies. We find that the disagreement amongst the population synthesis models is far greater than that between our hydrodynamical simulations. The results of our code comparison project are therefore encouraging in that uncertainties in the given problem are probably dominated by the physics not yet included in the codes rather than by how hydrodynamics is modelled in them.

submitted to MNRAS. This is version 2 of the paper after considering referees comments and changes

References in corpus (72)

• The cosmological simulation code GADGET-2
• A Survey of Stellar Families: Multiplicity of Solar-Type Stars
• GIZMO: A New Class of Accurate, Mesh-Free Hydrodynamic Simulation Methods
• Nonlinear Outcome of Gravitational Instability in Cooling, Gaseous Disks
• Modelling Accretion in Protobinary Systems
• The Occurrence and Architecture of Exoplanetary Systems
• The Formation of a Star Cluster: Predicting the Properties of Stars and Brown Dwarfs
• Improving convergence in smoothed particle hydrodynamics simulations without pairing instability
• Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics and Magnetohydrodynamics
• On the width and shape of gaps in protoplanetary disks
• FARGO: a fast eulerian transport algorithm for differentially rotating disks
• Gravitational Instabilities in Circumstellar Disks
• Can giant planets form by direct gravitational instability?
• Dust Filtration by Planet-Induced Gap Edges: Implications for Transitional Disks
• The Burst Mode of Protostellar Accretion
• Extrasolar planet population synthesis IV. Correlations with disk metallicity, mass and lifetime
• Investigating fragmentation conditions in self-gravitating accretion discs
• On the diversity and statistical properties of protostellar discs
• Inviscid SPH
• The Runts of the Litter: Why planets formed through gravitational instability can only be failed binary stars
• The burst mode of accretion and disk fragmentation in the early embedded stages of star formation
• The Origin of Episodic Accretion Bursts in the Early Stages of Star Formation
• Clumps in the Outer Disk by Disk Instability: Why They are Initially Gas Giants and the Legacy of Disruption
• The Close Binary Fraction of Solar-type Stars is Strongly Anti-correlated with Metallicity
• A Triple Protostar System Formed via Fragmentation of a Gravitationally Unstable Disk
• Challenges in Forming Planets by Gravitational Instability: Disk Irradiation and Clump Migration, Accretion & Tidal Destructio
• A Very Fast and Momentum-Conserving Tree Code
• The evolution of gravitationally unstable protoplanetary disks: fragmentation and possible giant planet formation
• The Gemini NICI Planet-Finding Campaign: The Frequency of Planets around Young Moving Group Stars
• Satellites in Discs: Regulating the Accretion Luminosity
• Towards optimal softening in 3D N-body codes: I. Minimizing the force error
• Formation of planets by tidal downsizing of giant planet embryos
• The VLA Nascent Disk And Multiplicity Survey of Perseus Protostars (VANDAM). IV. Free-Free Emission from Protostars: Links to Infrared Properties, Outflow Tracers, and Protostellar Disk Masses
• Galactic Centre stellar winds and Sgr A* accretion
• Rapid inward migration of planets formed by gravitational instability
• The International Deep Planet Survey I. The frequency of wide-orbit massive planets around A-stars
• Type I planetary migration in a self-gravitating disk
• Recurrent Planet Formation and Intermittent Protostellar Outflows Induced by Episodic Mass Accretion
• The co-orbital corotation torque in a viscous disk: numerical simulations
• Can giant planets form by gravitational fragmentation of discs?
• Treating gravity in thin disk simulations
• Towards a Population Synthesis Model of Objects formed by Self-Gravitating Disc Fragmentation and Tidal Downsizing
• The VLT/NaCo large program to probe the occurrence of exoplanets and brown dwarfs at wide orbits. IV. Gravitational instability rarely forms wide, giant planets
• Angular momentum transport and disk morphology in SPH simulations of galaxy formation
• The VLT/NaCo large program to probe the occurrence of exoplanets and brown dwarfs at wide orbits: II- Survey description, results and performances
• Saturated torque formula for planetary migration in viscous disks with thermal diffusion: recipe for protoplanet population synthesis
• Towards a population synthesis model of self-gravitating disc fragmentation and tidal downsizing II: The effect of fragment-fragment interactions
• Observational evidence for two distinct giant planet populations
• SEREN - A new SPH code for star and planet formation simulations
• A numerical simulation of a "super-Earth" core delivery from ~ 100 AU to ~ 8 AU
• On the gap-opening criterion of migrating planets in protoplanetary disks
• The role of thermodynamics in disc fragmentation
• Exploring the conditions required to form giant planets via gravitational instability in massive protoplanetary discs
• Stability of self-gravitating discs under irradiation
• Convergence of the critical cooling rate for protoplanetary disk fragmentation achieved; the key role of numerical dissipation of angular momentum
• The Effects of Metallicity, and Grain Growth and Settling on the Early Evolution of Gaseous Protoplanets
• Companions to APOGEE Stars I: A Milky Way-Spanning Catalog of Stellar and Substellar Companion Candidates and their Diverse Hosts
• Dawes Review. The tidal downsizing hypothesis of planet formation
• Near-Infrared High-Resolution Imaging Polarimetry of FU Ori-Type Objects: Towards A Unified Scheme for Low-Mass Protostellar Evolution
• The collapse of protoplanetary clumps formed through disc instability: 3D simulations of the pre-dissociation phase
• Identifying and Analysing Protostellar Disc Fragments in Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics Simulations
• On the Evolution and Survival of Protoplanets Embedded in a Protoplanetary Disk
• Disc fragmentation rarely forms planetary-mass objects
• The VLT/NaCo large program to probe the occurrence of exoplanets and brown dwarfs at wide orbits. III. The frequency of brown dwarfs and giant planets as companions to solar-type stars
• The migration of gas giant planets in gravitationally unstable discs
• Radiative feedback from protoplanets in self-gravitating protoplanetary discs
• The effect of radiative feedback on disc fragmentation
• Tidal Downsizing Model. III. Planets from sub-Earths to Brown Dwarfs: structure and metallicity preferences
• The Effect of Irradiation on the Jeans Mass in Fragmenting Self-Gravitating Protostellar Discs
• On the diversity in mass and orbital radius of giant planets formed via disk instability
• The diverse lives of massive protoplanets in self-gravitating discs
• Tidal Downsizing Model. IV. Destructive feedback in planets

Cited by in corpus (19)

• Molecules with ALMA at Planet-forming Scales (MAPS). A Circumplanetary Disk Candidate in Molecular Line Emission in the AS 209 Disk
• Planet formation around M dwarfs via disc instability: Fragmentation conditions and protoplanet properties
• In-situ extreme mass ratio inspirals via sub-parsec formation and migration of stars in thin, gravitationally unstable AGN discs
• Formation of intermediate-mass planets via magnetically-controlled disk fragmentation
• Forming Pop III binaries in self-gravitating disks: how to keep the orbital angular momentum
• Constraining the initial planetary population in the gravitational instability model
• Extreme evaporation of planets in hot thermally unstable protoplanetary discs: the case of FU Ori
• Episodic accretion and mergers during growth of massive protostars
• On the origin of wide-orbit ALMA planets: giant protoplanets disrupted by their cores
• Orbital Migration of Protoplanets in a Marginally Gravitationally Unstable Disk. II. Migration, Merging, and Ejection
• Greening of the Brown Dwarf Desert. EPIC 212036875 b -- a 51 M${}_{\mathrm{J}}$ object in a 5 day orbit around an F7 V star
• DIPSY: A new Disc Instability Population SYnthesis, II. The Populations of Companions Formed Through Disc Instability
• Formation of inner planets in the presence of a Cold Jupiter: orbital evolution and relative velocities of planetesimals
• Calibrated Gas Accretion and Orbital Migration of Protoplanets in 1D Disc Models
• Searching for wide-orbit gravitational instability protoplanets with ALMA in the dust continuum
• The paradox of youth for ALMA planet candidates
• DIPSY: A new Disc Instability Population SYnthesis, I. Modeling, evolution of individual systems, and tests
• Planetesimal Dynamics in the Presence of a Giant Planet II: Dependence on Planet Mass and Eccentricity
• The 3D structure of disc-instability protoplanets