Absence of Quantum Time Crystals

Abstract

In analogy with crystalline solids around us, Wilczek recently proposed the idea of "time crystals" as phases that spontaneously break the continuous time translation into a discrete subgroup. The proposal stimulated further studies and vigorous debates whether it can be realized in a physical system. However, a precise definition of the time crystal is needed to resolve the issue. Here we first present a definition of time crystals based on the time-dependent correlation functions of the order parameter. We then prove a no-go theorem that rules out the possibility of time crystals defined as such, in the ground state or in the canonical ensemble of a general Hamiltonian, which consists of not-too-long-range interactions.

arXiv comment5 pages, 1 figure; v3: A typo is corrected; the version to appear in Phys. Rev. Lett

References in corpus (13)

• Quantum Time Crystals
• Impossibility of Spontaneously Rotating Time-Crystals: A No-Go Theorem
• Space-time crystals of trapped ions
• Comment on "Quantum Time Crystals": a new paradigm or just another proposal of perpetuum mobile?
• Superfluidity and Space-Time Translation Symmetry Breaking
• Time crystals: can diamagnetic currents drive a charge density wave into rotation?
• Symmetry Breaking and Finite Size Effects in Quantum Many-Body Systems
• Comment on "Space-Time Crystals of Trapped Ions": And Yet it Moves Not !
• Spontaneous Symmetry Probing
• On the broken time translation symmetry in macroscopic systems: precessing states and off-diagonal long-range order
• Semiclassical time crystal in the chiral Gross-Neveu model
• Reply to Comment on "Space-Time Crystals of Trapped Ions"
• On the dynamics of fluctuations in time crystals

Cited by in corpus (314)

• Non-Hermitian Physics
• Atomic quantum gases in periodically driven optical lattices
• Observation of a Discrete Time Crystal
• Observation of discrete time-crystalline order in a disordered dipolar many-body system
• Floquet Time Crystals
• On the phase structure of driven quantum systems
• Discrete time crystals: rigidity, criticality, and realizations
• Time crystals: a review
• Observation of Time-Crystalline Eigenstate Order on a Quantum Processor
• Discrete Time Crystals
• Boundary time crystals
• Absolute Stability and Spatiotemporal Long-Range Order in Floquet systems
• Weak Ergodicity Breaking and Quantum Many-Body Scars in Spin-1 XY Magnets
• Pre-thermal phases of matter protected by time-translation symmetry
• Observation of a dissipative time crystal
• Discrete Time-Crystalline Order in Cavity and Circuit QED Systems
• Floquet time crystal in the Lipkin-Meshkov-Glick model
• Observation of time quasicrystal and its transition to superfluid time crystal
• Observation of a continuous time crystal
• Observation of a many-body-localized discrete time crystal with a programmable spin-based quantum simulator
• 1D Many-body localized Floquet systems II: Symmetry-Broken phases
• Colloquium: Quantum and Classical Discrete Time Crystals
• An Introduction to Spontaneous Symmetry Breaking
• Observation of a space-time crystal in a superfluid quantum gas
• Temporal order in periodically driven spins in star-shaped clusters
• Quantum Many-Body Scars and Space-Time Crystalline Order from Magnon Condensation
• Discrete time crystals in the absence of manifest symmetries or disorder in open quantum systems
• Dicke time crystals in driven-dissipative quantum many-body systems
• Classical Discrete Time Crystals
• Clean Floquet Time Crystals: Models and Realizations in Cold Atoms
• Quantum Time Crystals from Hamiltonians with Long-Range Interactions
• All-Optical Dissipative Discrete Time Crystals
• Generalized Bloch theorem and chiral transport phenomena
• Observation of a symmetry-protected topological time crystal with superconducting qubits
• The isolated Heisenberg magnet as a quantum time crystal
• Simulation of non-Abelian braiding in Majorana time crystals
• Floquet time crystals in clock models
• Emergent limit cycles and time crystal dynamics in an atom-cavity system
• Time crystals in periodically driven systems
• Photonic Metamaterial Analogue of a Continuous Time Crystal
• ${}^{31}$P NMR study of discrete time-crystalline signatures in an ordered crystal of ammonium dihydrogen phosphate
• Shattered Time: Can a Dissipative Time Crystal Survive Many-Body Correlations?
• Counting Rules of Nambu-Goldstone Modes
• Dynamical quantum phase transitions: a brief survey
• Discrete Time Quasi-Crystals
• Time crystal platform: from quasi-crystal structures in time to systems with exotic interactions
• Dissipative time crystal in a strongly interacting Rydberg gas
• Photonic time crystals: Theory and applications
• Time Crystals Protected by Floquet Dynamical Symmetry in Hubbard Models
• Time crystals: analysis of experimental conditions
• Dynamical quantum phase transitions in discrete time crystals
• From a continuous to a discrete time crystal in a dissipative atom-cavity system
• Out-of-equilibrium dynamics of quantum many-body systems with long-range interactions
• Discrete time crystal in globally driven interacting quantum systems without disorder
• Defining Time Crystals via Representation Theory
• Spin Currents and Magnon Dynamics in Insulating Magnets
• Quantum metrology with boundary time crystals
• Symmetries and conserved quantities of boundary time crystals in generalized spin models
• Universality in driven open quantum matter
• Time crystals in a shaken atom-cavity system
• Time crystal behavior of excited eigenstates
• Floquet Quantum Criticality
• Time evolution of correlation functions in quantum many-body systems
• Real space observation of magnon interaction with driven space-time crystals
• Analytic approaches to periodically driven closed quantum systems: Methods and Applications
• Condensed Matter Physics in Time Crystals
• Prethermal time crystals in a one-dimensional periodically driven Floquet system
• Topological Time Crystals
• Boundary time crystals in collective $d$-level systems
• Interaction-induced time-symmetry breaking in driven quantum oscillators
• Period-doubling in period-$1$ steady states
• Bounds in Nonequilibrium Quantum Dynamics
• Classical Stochastic Discrete Time Crystals
• Integrability and chemical potential in the (3+1)-dimensional Skyrme model
• Discrete time-crystalline response stabilized by domain-wall confinement
• Optically trapped polariton condensates as semiclassical time crystals
• Anderson localization in the time domain
• Prethermal quantum many-body Kapitza phases of periodically driven spin systems
• Continuous time crystal in an electron-nuclear spin system: stability and melting of periodic auto-oscillations
• Discrete time crystal enabled by Stark many-body localization
• Fractional Time Crystals
• Floquet Majorana zero and $\pi$ modes in planar Josephson junctions
• Multiple-period Floquet states and time-translation symmetry breaking in quantum oscillators
• Time Crystals from Minimum Time Uncertainty
• Building continuous time crystals from rare events
• Dissipative time crystals with long-range Lindbladians
• On quantum time crystals and interacting gauge theories in atomic Bose-Einstein condensates
• Symmetry-breaking dynamics of the finite-size Lipkin-Meshkov-Glick model near ground state
• Floquet time-crystals as sensors of AC fields
• Three-dimensional localized-delocalized Anderson transition in the time domain
• Quantum time crystals with programmable disorder in higher dimensions
• Discrete time crystal in a finite chain of Rydberg atoms without disorder
• Quantum trajectories of dissipative time-crystals
• An instanton-like excitation of a discrete time crystal
• Creating big time crystals with ultracold atoms
• Dynamical quantum phase transitions in systems with broken continuous time and space translation symmetries
• Mode softening in time-crystalline transitions of open quantum systems
• Perspective on Reversible to Irreversible Transitions in Periodic Driven Many Body Systems and Future Directions For Classical and Quantum Systems
• Tunable space-time crystal in room-temperature magnetodielectrics
• Stark time crystals: Symmetry breaking in space and time
• Anderson localization of a Rydberg electron along a classical orbit
• Non-thermalization in trapped atomic ion spin chains
• Spatial-Translation-Induced Discrete Time Crystals
• Statistical Mechanics of Floquet Quantum Matter: Exact and Emergent Conservation Laws
• Rigorous bounds on dynamical response functions and time-translation symmetry breaking
• Analytic (3+1)-dimensional gauged Skyrmions, Heun and Whittaker-Hill equations and resurgence
• Analytic topologically non-trivial solutions of the (3+1)-dimensional $U(1)$ gauged Skyrme model and extended duality
• Photonic Floquet time crystals
• Synthetic dimensions for topological and quantum phases: Perspective
• Discrete Time Crystal Phase as a Resource for Quantum Enhanced Sensing
• Many-Body Open Quantum Systems
• An eternal discrete time crystal beating the Heisenberg limit
• (Quasi)Periodic revivals in periodically driven interacting quantum systems
• Discrete time crystals in many-body quantum chaos
• Effective field theory of time-translational symmetry breaking in nonequilibrium open system
• Entangled time-crystal phase in an open quantum light-matter system
• Spontaneous symmetry breaking and Nambu-Goldstone modes in open classical and quantum systems
• Cosmological Time Crystal: Cyclic Universe with a small $\Lambda$ in a toy model approach
• Phase diagram and optimal control for n-tupling discrete time crystal
• Floquet time crystals in driven spin systems with all-to-all $p$-body interactions
• Analytical solutions for a boundary driven XY chain
• Floquet Scalar Dynamics in Global AdS
• Experimental Realization of Discrete Time Quasi-Crystals
• Dynamics of a Space-Time Crystal in an Atomic Bose-Einstein Condensate
• Genuine Multipartite Correlations in a Boundary Time Crystal
• Critical Theory for the Breakdown of Photon Blockade
• Proof of the absence of long-range temporal orders in Gibbs states
• Stochastic discrete time crystals: Entropy production and subharmonic synchronization
• Comment on "Quantum Time Crystals and Interacting Gauge Theories in Atomic Bose-Einstein Condensates"
• Coherent dynamics in frustrated coupled parametric oscillators
• Nonequilibrium Criticality at the Onset of Time-Crystalline Order
• Black resonators and geons in AdS${}_5$
• Quantum Time Crystal By Decoherence: Proposal With Incommensurate Charge Density Wave Ring
• Dissipative prethermal discrete time crystal
• Chimera Time-Crystalline order in quantum spin networks
• Realizing time crystals in discrete quantum few-body systems
• Chiral soliton lattice in QCD-like theories
• Prethermal Floquet time crystals in chiral multiferroic chains and applications as quantum sensors of AC fields
• Stabilization and manipulation of multispin states in quantum-dot time crystals with Heisenberg interactions
• Time Quasilattices in Dissipative Dynamical Systems
• Relaxation dynamics and dissipative phase transition in quantum oscillators with period tripling
• Realization of an inherent time crystal in a dissipative many-body system
• Critical properties of the prethermal Floquet Time Crystal
• Homogeneous Floquet time crystal from weak ergodicity breaking
• Boundary Time Crystals as AC sensors: enhancements and constraints
• Universal presence of time-crystalline phases and period-doubling oscillations in one-dimensional Floquet topological insulators
• Circular Dichroism in Rotating Particles
• A Decade of Time Crystals: Quo Vadis?
• Lack of a genuine time crystal in a chiral soliton model
• Quantum thermodynamics of boundary time-crystals
• Anharmonic classical time crystals: A coresonance pattern formation mechanism
• Probing non-equilibrium topological order on a quantum processor
• Polynomial filter diagonalization of large Floquet unitary operators
• Nonequilibrium transition between dissipative time crystals
• Stroboscopic aliasing in long-range interacting quantum systems
• Imaginary time crystal of thermal quantum matter
• Dissipative time crystals originating from parity-time symmetry
• Time Glass: A Fractional Calculus Approach
• Critical properties of the Floquet time crystal within the Gaussian approximation
• Holographic dissipative space-time supersolids
• Nonequilibrium thermodynamics and power generation in open quantum optomechanical systems
• Entanglement Transitions in Unitary Circuit Games
• Time Crystal in a Single-mode Nonlinear Cavity
• Dynamical exciton condensates in biased electron-hole bilayers
• Exotic synchronization in continuous time crystals outside the symmetric subspace
• Space-time crystalline order of a high-critical-temperature superconductor with intrinsic Josephson junctions
• Time-crystalline Topological Superconductors
• Anomalous Goos-Hänchen shift in the Floquet scattering of Dirac fermions
• Effective Field Theory for Spontaneously Broken Symmetry
• Space-Time Quasicrystal Structures and Inflationary and Late Time Evolution Dynamics in Accelerating Cosmology
• High-frequency Expansion for Floquet Prethermal Phases with Emergent Symmetries: Application to Time Crystals and Floquet Engineering
• Algebraic Time Crystallization in a Two-dimensional Superfluid
• Temporally, Spatially or Light-like Modulated Vacua in Lorentz Invariant Theories
• Time Crystals in the Driven Transverse Field Ising Model under Quasiperiodic Modulation
• Discrete time crystal in the gradient field Heisenberg model
• Simulation of many body localization and time crystals in two dimensions with the neighborhood tensor update
• Emergent symmetries in prethermal phases of periodically driven quantum systems
• Floquet dynamics of classical and quantum cavity fields
• Exploring nonlinear dynamics in periodically driven time crystal: from synchronized to chaotic motion
• Emergent Continuous Time Crystal in Dissipative Quantum Spin System without Driving
• Dynamical nonlocality in quantum time via modular operators
• Time-crystal ground state and production of gravitational waves from QCD phase transition
• Integrable Floquet Hamiltonian for a Periodically Tilted 1D Gas
• Nonlocal discrete time crystals in periodically driven surface codes
• Thermal melting of discrete time crystals: a dynamical phase transition induced by thermal fluctuations
• Continuous Space-Time Crystal State Driven by Nonreciprocal Optical Forces
• On the long-term stability of space-time crystals
• Experimental observation of a time rondeau crystal: Temporal Disorder in Spatiotemporal Order
• Prethermal time-crystalline spin ice and monopole confinement in a driven magnet
• Feasible model for photo-induced interband pairing
• Time-crystalline behavior in an engineered spin chain
• Criticality and Rigidity of Dissipative Discrete Time Crystals in Solids
• Fisher zeros and persistent temporal oscillations in non-unitary quantum circuits
• Out of equilibrium chiral higher order topological insulator on a $\pi$-flux square lattice
• Crystal gravity
• Thermodynamics and Phase Transition in Shapere-Wilczek {\it fgh} model: Cosmological Time Crystal in Quadratic Gravity
• Route to Extend the Lifetime of a Discrete Time Crystal in a Finite Spin Chain Without Disorder
• Mean-field thermodynamic quantum time-space crystal: spontaneous breaking of time-translation symmetry in a macroscopic fermion system
• Anderson Molecules
• Provenance of classical Hamiltonian time crystals
• Topologically protected boundary discrete time crystal for a solvable model
• Space- and time-crystallization effects in multicomponent superfluids
• Classes of metastable Thermodynamic Quantum Time Crystals
• Spontaneous Symmetry Breaking of Time-Reversal-Symmetry and Time-Crystal States in Chiral Atomic Systems
• Discrete time-crystals in unbounded potentials
• Liquid Time Crystals
• Light, the universe, and everything -- 12 Herculean tasks for quantum cowboys and black diamond skiers
• Clean two-dimensional Floquet time-crystal
• Space-time symmetry breaking in nonequilibrium frustrated magnetism
• Theory of parametric resonance for discrete time crystals in fully-connected spin-cavity systems
• Non-equilibration, synchronization, and time crystals in isotropic Heisenberg models
• Magnetization oscillations in a periodically driven transverse field Ising chain
• Comment on "Quantum Time Crystals from Hamiltonians with Long-Range Interactions"
• Kardar-Parisi-Zhang scaling in time-crystalline matter
• Non-Hermitian quantum gases: a platform for imaginary time crystals
• Discrete time crystal in an open optomechanical system
• Superconducting Quantum Simulation for Many-Body Physics beyond Equilibrium
• Nanoscopic time crystal obtained by nonergodic spin dynamics
• Symmetries & Correlations in Continous Time Crystals
• Classical and quantum time crystals in a levitated nanoparticle without drive
• Theory for dissipative time crystals in coupled parametric oscillators
• Can a bright soliton model reveal a genuine time crystal for a finite number of bosons?
• Spatio-temporal Symmetry - Point Groups with Time Translations
• Boundary Time Crystals Induced by Local Dissipation and Long-Range Interactions
• Topologically ordered time crystals
• Unveiling clean two-dimensional discrete time crystals on a digital quantum computer
• Time crystal and chaos in the hybrid atom-optomechanics system
• Continuous time crystal from a spontaneous many-body Floquet state
• Seasonal epidemic spreading on small-world networks: Biennial outbreaks and classical discrete time crystals
• How periodic driving stabilises and destabilises Anderson localisation on random trees
• Swapping Floquet time crystal
• Correspondence between dissipative phase transitions of light and time crystals
• On the stability of dissipatively-prepared Mott insulators of photons
• Quantum black holes as classical space factories
• Fragility to quantum fluctuations of classical Hamiltonian period doubling
• A metronome spin stabilizes time-crystalline dynamics
• Non-dispersing wave packets in lattice Floquet systems
• Emergent time crystal from a fractional Langevin equation with white and colored noise
• Trial wave functions for ring-trapped ions and neutral atoms: Microscopic description of the quantum space-time crystal
• A Solvable Model for Discrete Time Crystal Enforced by Nonsymmorphic Dynamical Symmetry
• Discrete time-crystalline order in Bose-Hubbard model with dissipation
• Discrete time crystal made of topological edge magnons
• Counter-flow induced clustering: Exact results
• Thermodynamics of coupled time crystals with an application to energy storage
• From time crystals to time quasicrystals: Exploring quasiperiodic phases in transverse field Ising chains
• Dynamics of one-dimensional quantum many-body systems in time-periodic linear potentials
• Temporal localization of optical waves supported by a copropagating quasiperiodic structure
• Discrete Lorentz symmetry and discrete spacetime translational symmetry in two- and three-dimensional crystals
• Localized solutions of the Dirac equation in free space and electromagnetic space-time crystals
• Topologically protected quantized changes of the distance between atoms
• Emergence of spatial patterns and synchronization in superconducting time crystals
• Dirac electron in a chiral space-time crystal created by counterpropagating circularly polarized plane electromagnetic waves
• Time-tronics: from temporal printed circuit board to quantum computer
• The time crystal phase emerges from the qubit network under unitary random operations
• Programmable time crystals from higher-order packing fields
• Absence of temporal order in states with spatial correlation decay
• Simultaneous symmetry breaking in spontaneous Floquet states: temporal Floquet-Nambu-Goldstone modes, Floquet thermodynamics, and the time operator
• Discrete Lorentz symmetry and discrete time translational symmetry
• Discrete Time Crystal Phase of Higher Dimensional Integrable Models
• Time crystal optomechanics
• Ancilla assisted Discrete Time Crystals in Non-interacting Spin Systems
• The Symmetry Principle in Condensed Matter Physics (I)
• Generalized criteria of symmetry breaking. A strategy for quantum time crystals
• Non-stationarity and Dissipative Time Crystals: Spectral Properties and Finite-Size Effects
• Precision measurement for open systems by non-hermitian linear response
• More is less in unpercolated active solids
• From Kardar-Parisi-Zhang scaling to soliton proliferation in Josephson junction arrays
• Quantum Correlations in Space-Time: Foundations and Applications
• Discrete time crystals enhanced by Stark potentials in Rydberg atom arrays
• Time crystal embodies chimeralike state in periodically driven quantum spin system
• Hilbert Space Fragmentation and Subspace Scar Time-Crystallinity in Driven Homogeneous Central-Spin Models
• The Sub-Exponential Critical Slowing Down at Floquet Time Crystal Phase Transition
• Nonexistence of spontaneous symmetry breakdown of time-translation symmetry on general quantum systems: Any macroscopic order parameter moves not!
• The robustness condition for general disordered discrete time crystals, and subspace-thermal DTCs from phase transitions between different n-tuple DTCs
• Condensed matter physics in big discrete time crystals
• Continuous time crystals as a PT symmetric state and the emergence of critical exceptional points
• Energy gap of neutral excitations implies vanishing charge susceptibility
• Correlations in Circular Quantum Cascades
• Stability of emergent time periodicity in a few-body interacting system
• Nonperturbative decay of bipartite discrete time crystals
• Chiral supersolid and dissipative time crystal in Rydberg-dressed Bose-Einstein condensates with Raman-induced spin-orbit coupling
• Critical behavior of a programmable time-crystal lattice gas
• Effects of leakage on the realization of a discrete time crystal in a chain of singlet-triplet qubits
• Nonlinear dynamics determines the thermodynamic instability of condensed matter in vacuo
• Universality in Non-Equilibrium Quantum Systems
• Emergent time crystals from phase-space noncommutative quantum mechanics
• Emergence of prethermal time quasicrystalline order in a quasiperiodically driven non-interacting spin chain
• Slowly decaying real-time oscillations in instanton crystal
• Discrete time crystal order in spin chains enabled by Floquet flat bands
• Fock space prethermalization and time-crystalline order on a quantum processor
• Harnessing Floquet dynamics for selective metrology in few-qubit systems
• Shift of quantum critical point of discrete time crystal on a noisy quantum simulator
• Time Crystals in Actively Mode-locked Lasers
• Star-topology Registers: NMR and Quantum Information Perspectives
• Eight-fold classification of superconducting orders
• Time Crystal from Self-Amplification of Spontaneous Analog Hawking Radiation
• Macroscopic theory of multipartite correlations in permutation-invariant open quantum systems
• Phase Transition of Topological Index driven by Dephasing
• Realizable time crystal of four silicon quantum dot qubits
• Discrete time crystal for periodic-field sensing with quantum-enhanced precision
• Reply to "Comment on "Quantum Time Crystals from Hamiltonians with Long-Range Interactions""
• Many-body state and dynamic behaviour of the pair-correlation function of a small Bose-Einstein condensate confined in a ring potential
• Pre-Floquet states facilitating coherent subharmonic response of periodically driven many-body systems
• Formation of Complex Discrete Time Crystals with Ultracold Atoms
• Discrete time crystals in Bose-Einstein Condensates and symmetry-breaking edge in a simple two-mode theory
• Intrinsic space-time crystalline order in a hybrid Josephson junction
• Existence of quantum time crystals
• Unpolarized prethermal discrete time crystal
• Metastable discrete time-crystal resonances in a dissipative central spin system
• Adiabatic and irreversible classical discrete time crystals
• The role of atomic interactions in cavity-induced continuous time crystals
• Quantum repetition codes as building blocks of large period discrete time crystals
• A Quantum Informational Approach to the Problem of Time
• Logarithmic quantum time crystal