Variations in the initial mass function in early-type galaxies: A critical comparison between dynamical and spectroscopic results

Abstract

I present a comparison between published dynamical (ATLAS3D) and spectroscopic (Conroy & van Dokkum) constraints on the stellar initial mass function (IMF) in early-type galaxies, using the 34 galaxies in common between the two works. Both studies infer an average IMF mass factor $\alpha$ (the stellar mass relative to a Kroupa-IMF population of similar age and metallicity) greater than unity, i.e. both methods favour an IMF which is heavier than that of the Milky Way, on average over the sample. However, on a galaxy-by-galaxy basis, there is no correlation between $\alpha$ inferred from the two approaches. I investigate how the two estimates of $\alpha$ are correlated systematically with the galaxy velocity dispersion, $\sigma$, and with the Mg/Fe abundance ratio. The spectroscopic method, based on the strengths of metal absorption lines, yields a correlation only with metal abundance ratios: at fixed Mg/Fe, there is no residual correlation with $\sigma$. The dynamical method, applied to exactly the same galaxy sample, yields the opposite result: the IMF variation correlates only with dynamics, with no residual correlation with Mg/Fe after controlling for $\sigma$. Hence although both methods indicate a heavy IMF on average in ellipticals, they lead to incompatible results for the systematic trends, when applied to the same set of galaxies. The sense of the disagreement could suggest that one (or both) of the methods has not accounted fully for the main confounding factors, i.e. element abundance ratios or dark matter contributions. Alternatively, the poor agreement might indicate additional variation in the detailed shape of the IMF, beyond what can currently be inferred from the spectroscopic features.

MNRAS in press

References in corpus (18)

• On the variation of the Initial Mass Function
• A large stellar evolution database for population synthesis studies. I. Scaled solar models and isochrones
• The Atlas3D project - XX. Mass-size and mass-sigma distributions of early-type galaxies: bulge fraction drives kinematics, mass-to-light ratio, molecular gas fraction and stellar initial mass function
• A systematic variation of the stellar initial mass function in early-type galaxies
• The Sloan Lens ACS Survey. X. Stellar, Dynamical, and Total Mass Correlations of Massive Early-type Galaxies
• A Substantial Population of Low Mass Stars in Luminous Elliptical Galaxies
• The Stellar Initial Mass Function in Early-Type Galaxies From Absorption Line Spectroscopy. II. Results
• The initial mass function of early-type galaxies
• SPIDER VIII - Constraints on the Stellar Initial Mass Function of Early-type Galaxies from a Variety of Spectral Features
• Counting Low-Mass Stars in Integrated Light
• Radial variations in the stellar initial mass function of early-type galaxies
• Evidence For A Mild Steepening And Bottom-Heavy IMF In Massive Galaxies From Sodium And Titanium-Oxide Indicators
• The SAURON Project - XIV. No escape from V${}_{\mathrm{esc}}$: a global and local parameter in early-type galaxy evolution
• A giant elliptical galaxy with a lightweight initial mass function
• The SLUGGS survey: Exploring the metallicity gradients of nearby early-type galaxies to large radii
• A low-mass cut-off near the hydrogen burning limit for Salpeter-like initial mass functions in early-type galaxies
• Galactic Globular Clusters as a test for Very Low-Mass stellar models
• The stellar initial mass function in red-sequence galaxies: 1-micron spectroscopy of Coma Cluster galaxies with Subaru/FMOS

Cited by in corpus (80)

• Structure and Kinematics of Early-Type Galaxies from Integral-Field Spectroscopy
• A unified multi-wavelength model of galaxy formation
• Modelling and interpreting spectral energy distributions of galaxies with BEAGLE
• Unification of the Fundamental Plane and Super-Massive Black Holes Masses
• The MASSIVE Survey - I. A Volume-Limited Integral-Field Spectroscopic Study of the Most Massive Early-Type Galaxies within 108 Mpc
• Radial variations in the stellar initial mass function of early-type galaxies
• The Stellar Initial Mass Function in Early-Type Galaxies from Absorption Line Spectroscopy. III. Radial Gradients
• The Dawes Review 8: Measuring the Stellar Initial Mass Function
• SDSS-IV MaNGA: The Spatially Resolved Stellar Initial Mass Function in $\sim$400 Early-Type Galaxies
• The SINFONI Nearby Elliptical Lens Locator Survey: Discovery of two new low-redshift strong lenses and implications for the initial mass function in giant early-type galaxies
• The stellar initial mass function of early type galaxies from low to high stellar velocity dispersion: homogeneous analysis of ATLAS${}^{3D}$ and Sloan Lens ACS galaxies
• Radial constraints on the Initial Mass Function from TiO features and Wing-Ford band in Early-type Galaxies
• ALMA-IMF I -- Investigating the origin of stellar masses: Introduction to the Large Program and first results
• The Scaling of Stellar Mass and Central Stellar Velocity Dispersion for Quiescent galaxies at z < 0.7
• A calibration of the stellar mass fundamental plane at z ~ 0.5 using the micro-lensing induced flux ratio anomalies of macro-lensed quasars
• IMF shape constraints from stellar populations and dynamics from CALIFA
• The SLUGGS survey: Exploring the metallicity gradients of nearby early-type galaxies to large radii
• The Fornax3D project: overall goals, galaxy sample, MUSE data analysis and initial results
• The initial mass function of a massive relic galaxy
• Metallicity of stars formed throughout the cosmic history based on the observational properties of star forming galaxies
• The Stellar Initial Mass Function in Early-Type Galaxies From Absorption Line Spectroscopy. IV. A Super-Salpeter IMF in the center of NGC 1407 from Non-Parametric Models
• Variations of the initial mass function in semi-analytical models: implications for the mass assembly and the chemical enrichment of galaxies in the GAEA model
• Evidence of a non universal stellar Initial Mass Function. Insights from HST optical imaging of 6 Ultra Faint Dwarf Milky Way Satellites
• The Initial Mass Function in the Nearest Strong Lenses from SNELLS: Assessing the Consistency of Lensing, Dynamical, and Spectroscopic Constraints
• The Fornax 3D project: a two-dimensional view of the stellar initial mass function in the massive lenticular galaxy FCC 167
• On The History and Future of Cosmic Planet Formation
• Spatially resolved variations of the IMF mass normalisation in early-type galaxies as probed by molecular gas kinematics
• Further evidence for a time-dependent initial mass function in massive early-type galaxies
• Velocity Dispersion, Size, Sérsic Index and $D_{n}4000$: The Scaling of Stellar Mass with Dynamical Mass for Quiescent Galaxies
• Strong Gravitational Lensing and the Stellar IMF of Early-type Galaxies
• Connection between dynamically derived IMF normalisation and stellar population parameters
• Galaxy properties as revealed by MaNGA. I. Constraints on Initial Mass Function and M${}_{\ast }$/L gradients in ellipticals
• ALMA-IMF VI -- Investigating the origin of stellar masses: Core mass function evolution in the W43-MM2&MM3 mini-starburst
• The stellar population and initial mass function of NGC 1399 with MUSE
• The IMF-sensitive 1.14-micron Na I doublet in early-type galaxies
• The hELENa project - I. Stellar populations of early-type galaxies linked with local environment and galaxy mass
• The Initial Mass Function of Early-type Galaxies: no correlation with [Mg/Fe]
• The MASSIVE SURVEY XVI. The Stellar Initial Mass Function in the Center of MASSIVE Early-Type Galaxies
• The statistical challenge of constraining the low-mass IMF in Local Group dwarf galaxies
• The Spectroscopy and H-band Imaging of Virgo cluster galaxies (SHIVir) Survey: Scaling Relations and the Stellar-to-Total Mass Relation
• Calibrated, cosmological hydrodynamical simulations with variable IMFs I: Method and effect on global galaxy scaling relations
• Radial measurements of IMF-sensitive absorption features in two massive ETGs
• The initial mass function in the Coma Berenices dwarf galaxy from deep near-infrared HST observations
• Is it possible to reconcile extragalactic IMF variations with a universal Milky Way IMF?
• Revisiting the classics: Is [Mg/Fe] a good proxy for galaxy formation time-scales?
• Initial Mass Function Variability (or not) Among \\ Low-Velocity Dispersion, Compact Stellar Systems
• The initial mass functions of M31 and M32 through far red stellar absorption features
• ZFIRE: Using H$\alpha$ equivalent widths to investigate the in situ initial mass function at z~2
• Implications of a variable IMF for the interpretation of observations of galaxy populations
• Exploring the IMF of star clusters: a joint SLUG and LEGUS effort
• Multimass modelling of Milky Way globular clusters -- I. Implications on their stellar initial mass function above 1 M${}_{\odot }$
• The Initial Mass Function of Lens Galaxies from Quasar Microlensing
• Dark Matter and IMF normalization in Virgo dwarf early-type galaxies
• Disc cloaking: Establishing a lower limit to the number density of local compact massive spheroids/bulges and the potential fate of some high-z red nuggets
• ALMA-IMF X -- The core population in the evolved W33-Main (G012.80) protocluster
• Massive High-Redshift Quiescent Galaxies With JWST
• Stellar dynamics in the strong-lensing central galaxy of Abell 1201: A low stellar mass-to-light ratio, a large central compact mass, and a standard dark matter halo
• Evidence of a Bottom-heavy Initial Mass Function in Massive Early-type Galaxies from Near-infrared Metal Lines
• Environmental variation of the low-mass IMF
• A Precise Benchmark for Cluster Scaling Relations: Fundamental Plane, Mass Plane and IMF in the Coma Cluster from Dynamical Models
• Variations of the Initial Mass Function in Semi-Analytical models
• Calibrated, cosmological hydrodynamical simulations with variable IMFs II: Correlations between the IMF and global galaxy properties
• Testing the Universality of the Stellar IMF with Chandra and HST
• Variation in the stellar initial mass function from the chromospheric activity of M dwarfs in early-type galaxies
• An assessment of the evidence from ATLAS3D for a variable initial mass function
• The initial mass function of stars and the star-formation rates of galaxies
• Unravelling the Origin of the Counter-Rotating Core in IC 1459 with KMOS and MUSE
• Dynamical masses of brightest cluster galaxies II: constraints on the stellar IMF
• A modern view of galaxies and their stellar populations
• Recovery of the low- and high-mass end slopes of the IMF in massive early-type galaxies using detailed elemental abundances
• A counter-image to the gravitational arc in Abell 1201: Evidence for IMF variations, or a $10^{10}$M${}_{\odot }$ black hole?
• Understanding the Fundamental Plane and the Tully Fisher Relation
• Lower mass normalization of the stellar initial mass function for dense massive early-type galaxies at z ~ 1.4
• Initial Mass Function Variation in two Elliptical Galaxies using Near-Infrared Tracers
• Explaining the stellar initial mass function with the theory of spatial networks
• Simple Stellar Population Modeling of Low S/N Galaxy Spectra and Quasar Host Galaxy Applications
• Stellar initial mass function variation in massive early-type galaxies: the potential role of the deuterium abundance
• When did the initial mass function become bottom-heavy?
• Past, present and Future of the Scaling Relations of Galaxies and Active Galactic Nuclei
• Connection between dynamically derived IMF normalisation and stellar populations