How Long does a Burst Burst?

Abstract

Several gamma-ray bursts (GRBs) last much longer (~hours) in gamma-rays than typical long GRBs (~ minutes), and recently it was proposed that these "ultra-long GRBs" may form a distinct population, probably with a different (e.g. blue supergiant) progenitor than typical GRBs. However, Swift observations suggest that many GRBs have extended central engine activities manifested as flares and internal plateaus in X-rays. We perform a comprehensive study on a large sample of Swift GRBs with XRT observations to investigate GRB central engine activity duration and to determine whether ultra-long GRBs are unusual events. We define burst duration t_burst based on both gamma-ray and X-ray light curves rather than using gamma-ray observations alone. We find that t_burst can be reliably measured in 343 GRBs. Within this "good" sample, 21.9% GRBs have t_burst >=10^3 s and 11.5% GRBs have t_burst >=10^4 s. There is an apparent bimodal distribution of t_burst in this sample. However, when we consider an "undetermined" sample (304 GRBs) with t_burst possibly falling in the gap between GRB duration T_90 and the first X-ray observational time, as well as a selection effect against t_burst falling into the first Swift orbital "dead zone" due to observation constraints, the intrinsic underlying t_burst distribution is consistent with being a single component distribution. We found that the existing evidence for a separate ultra-long GRB population is inconclusive, and further multi-wavelength observations are needed to draw a firmer conclusion. We also discuss the theoretical implications of our results. In particular, the central engine activity duration of GRBs is generally much longer than the gamma-ray T90 duration and it does not even correlate with T90. It would be premature to make a direct connection between T90 and the size of the progenitor star.

ApJ accepted. 11 pages, 9 figures, 1 Table. emulateapj style. Data analysis expanded, Some clarifications, more references. Main conclusions unchanged

References in corpus (14)

• The Supernova -- Gamma-Ray Burst Connection
• Discerning the physical origins of cosmological Gamma-ray bursts based on multiple observational criteria: the cases of z=6.7 GRB 080913, z=8.3 GRB 090423, and some short/hard GRBs
• A Comprehensive Analysis of the Swift/XRT Data: II. Diverse Physical Origins of the Shallow Decay Segment
• A Complete Reference of the Analytical Synchrotron External Shock Models of Gamma-Ray Bursts
• The First Survey of X-ray Flares from Gamma Ray Bursts Observed by Swift: Temporal Properties and Morphology
• Mass Fall-back and Accretion in the Central Engine of Gamma-Ray Bursts
• A comprehensive analysis of Swift/XRT data: I. Apparent spectral evolution of GRB X-ray tails
• A Comprehensive Analysis of Fermi Gamma-ray Burst Data: II. $E_{\mathrm{p}}$-Evolution Patterns and Implications for the Observed Spectrum-Luminosity Relations
• "Late prompt" emission in Gamma Ray Bursts?
• Giant X-ray Bump in GRB 121027A: Evidence for Fall-back Disk Accretion
• GRB 091024A and the nature of ultra-long gamma-ray bursts
• Curvature Effect of a Non-Power-Law Spectrum and Spectral Evolution of GRB X-Ray Tails
• On the Implications of Late Internal Dissipation for Shallow-Decay Afterglow Emission and Associated High-Energy Gamma-Ray Signals
• Extremely long hard bursts observed by Konus-Wind

Cited by in corpus (84)

• The Physics of Gamma-Ray Bursts and Relativistic Jets
• A very luminous magnetar-powered supernova associated with an ultra-long gamma-ray burst
• The Diversity of Transients from Magnetar Birth
• Choked Jets and Low-Luminosity Gamma-Ray Bursts as Hidden Neutrino Sources
• How Bad/Good Are the External Forward Shock Afterglow Models of Gamma-Ray Bursts?
• Neutrino-dominated accretion flows as the central engine of gamma-ray bursts
• Physics of Gamma-Ray Bursts Prompt Emission
• The Volumetric Rate of Superluminous Supernovae at z~1
• Illuminating Massive Black Holes With White Dwarfs: Orbital Dynamics and High Energy Transients from Tidal Interactions
• The X-ray fundamental plane of the Platinum Sample, the Kilonovae and the SNe Ib/c associated with GRBs
• The Birth of a Relativistic Jet Following the Disruption of a Star by a Cosmological Black Hole
• GRB 130925A: an ultra-long Gamma Ray Burst with a dust-echo afterglow, and implications for the origin of the ultra-long GRBs
• An Analysis of Chandra Deep Follow-up GRBs: Implications for Off-Axis Jets
• Explaining the most energetic supernovae with an inefficient jet-feedback mechanism
• Internal Energy Dissipation of Gamma-Ray Bursts Observed with Swift: Precursors, Prompt Gamma-rays, Extended emission and Late X-ray Flares
• The GRB-SLSN Connection: mis-aligned magnetars, weak jet emergence, and observational signatures
• Short vs. Long Gamma-Ray Bursts: A Comprehensive Study of Energetics and Prompt Gamma-Ray Correlations
• A comprehensive power spectral density analysis of astronomical time series I: the Fermi-LAT gamma-ray light curves of selected blazars
• Gamma Ray Burst Prompt correlations
• Neutrinos from the Brightest Gamma-Ray Burst?
• Black hole hyperaccretion inflow-outflow model. I. long and ultra-long gamma-ray bursts
• Are Ultra-long Gamma-Ray Bursts different?
• Individual power density spectra of Swift gamma-ray bursts
• Ultra Long Gamma-Ray Bursts from the collapse of Blue Super Giant stars: an end-to-end simulation
• The shallow decay segment of GRB X-ray afterglow revisited
• The Optical/NIR afterglow of GRB 111209A: Complex yet not Unprecedented
• A comprehensive statistical study on gamma-ray bursts
• A self-consistent analytical magnetar model: The luminosity of $\gamma$-ray burst supernovae is powered by radioactivity
• Analysis of the duration--hardness ratio plane of gamma-ray bursts using skewed distributions
• Are Ultra-Long Gamma-Ray Bursts Caused by Blue Supergiant Collapsars, Newborn Magnetars, or White Dwarf Tidal Disruption Events?
• Super-solar metallicity at the position of the ultra-long GRB130925A
• On the Origin of High-Energy Cosmic Neutrinos
• Closure relations during the plateau emission of Swift GRBs and the fundamental plane
• Do the Fermi Gamma-Ray Burst Monitor and Swift Burst Alert Telescope see the Same Short Gamma-Ray Bursts?
• GROND coverage of the main peak of Gamma-Ray Burst 130925A
• Revealing the Production Mechanism of High-Energy Neutrinos from NGC 1068
• Black hole central engine for ultra-long gamma-ray burst 111209A and its associated supernova 2011kl
• Gamma-ray burst afterglow blast waves
• Statistical analyses on the energies of X-ray plateaus and flares in gamma-ray bursts
• Characteristics of Two-episode Emission Patterns in {\em Fermi} Long Gamma-Ray Bursts
• Outflows from black hole hyperaccretion systems: short and long-short gamma-ray bursts and "quasi-supernovae"
• Fall back accretion and energy injections in gamma-ray bursts
• X-ray light curve in GRB 170714A: evidence for quark star?
• The History of GRB Outflows: Ejection Lorentz Factor and Radiation Location of X-Ray Flares
• A Stochastic Approach To Reconstruct Gamma Ray Burst Lightcurves
• Black hole hyperaccretion inflow-outflow model. II. Long-duration gamma-ray bursts and supernova ${}^{56}\mathrm{Ni}$ bumps
• Distributions of Pseudo-Redshifts and Durations (Observed and Intrinsic) of Fermi GRBs
• A Statistical Study of GRB X-ray Flares: Evidence of Ubiquitous Bulk Acceleration in the Emission Region
• Catalog of Isolated Emission Episodes in Gamma-ray Bursts from Fermi, Swift and BATSE
• A Comparative Study of Long and Short GRBs. II. A Multi-wavelength Method to distinguish Type II (massive star) and Type I (compact star) GRBs
• Relation between the intrinsic and observed central engine activity time: implications for ultra-long GRBs
• GRB Observational Properties
• GRB 110715A: The peculiar multiwavelength evolution of the first afterglow detected by ALMA
• The Second Plateau in X-ray Afterglow Providing Additional Evidence for Rapidly Spinning Magnetars as the GRB Central Engine
• Multivariate analysis of BATSE gamma-ray burst properties using skewed distributions
• Magnetar as Central Engine of Gamma-Ray Bursts: Central Engine-Jet Connection, Wind-Jet Energy Partition, and Origin of Some Ultra-Long Bursts
• Can we quickly flag Ultra-long Gamma-Ray Bursts?
• Gamma-Ray Bursts with Extended Emission: Classifications, Energy Correlations and Radiation Properties
• Ultra-Long Gamma-Ray Bursts detection with SVOM/ECLAIRs
• The ultra-long GRB 220627A at z=3.08
• On the existence of a luminosity threshold of GRB jets in massive stars
• The rapid decay phase of the afterglow as the signature of the Blandford-Znajek mechanism
• Update on the GRB universal scaling E${}_{\mathrm{X},\mathrm{iso}}$-E${}_{\gamma ,\mathrm{iso}}$-E${}_{\mathrm{pk}}$ with ten years of $Swift$ data
• Liverpool Telescope 2: a new robotic facility for rapid transient follow-up
• Central Engine Memory of Gamma-Ray Bursts and Soft Gamma-Ray Repeaters
• GRB Redshift Estimation using Machine Learning and the Associated Web-App
• Detecting Radio Afterglows of Gamma-Ray Bursts with FAST
• High-energy neutrino emission from magnetised jets of rapidly rotating protomagnetars
• GRB Optical and X-ray Plateau Properties Classifier Using Unsupervised Machine Learning
• Electromagnetic transients and gravitational waves from white dwarf disruptions by stellar black holes in triple systems
• The Prompt Emission of Gamma-Ray Bursts from the Wind of Newborn Millisecond Magnetars: A Case Study of GRB 160804A
• Multiwavelength observations of GRB 140629A. A long burst with an achromatic jet break in the optical and X-ray afterglow
• A further study of $t_{\mathrm{burst}}$ of GRBs: rest frame properties, external plateau contributions and multiple parameter analysis
• Steep Decay Phase Shaped by the Curvature Effect. I. Flux Evolution
• Hard X-ray Spectral Investigations of Gamma-ray Bursts, 120521C and 130606A, at High-redshift z~6
• External Shock in a Multi-Bursting Gamma-ray Burst: Energy Injection Phase induced by the Later Launched Ejecta
• Deciphering the properties of the central engine in GRB collapsars
• Exploring GRBs and supernovae connection: does a superluminous hypernova population exist?
• Gamma-ray burst engines may have no memory
• Comparative Statistical Analysis of Prompt and Afterglow X-Ray Flares in Gamma-Ray Bursts: Insights into Extended Central Engine Activity
• Radio Afterglow Rebrightening: Evidence for Multiple Active Phases in Gamma-Ray Burst Central Engines
• Multi-Messenger Astrophysics with THESEUS in the 2030s
• Outliers in spectral time lag selected gamma-ray bursts
• Revisiting black hole hyperaccretion in the center of gamma-ray bursts for the lower mass gap