Analysis of the duration--hardness ratio plane of gamma-ray bursts using skewed distributions

Abstract

The two widely accepted classes of gamma-ray bursts (GRBs), short and long, are with confidence ascribed to mergers of compact objects and collapse of massive stars, respectively. A third, intermediate/soft class, remains putative. Its existence was claimed based on univariate and bivariate analyses of GRB observables modeled with Gaussian distributions. This, however, may not be the appropriate approach, as it has been already shown that the univariate distributions of durations are better described by mixtures of two skewed components rather than three Gaussian ones. This paper investigates whether data in the duration--hardness ratio plane is better modeled by mixtures of skewed bivariate distributions than by normal ones. The archival data set of the Compton Gamma-Ray Observatory/BATSE and Fermi/GBM data from the most recent catalogue release are examined. The preferred model is chosen based on two information criteria, Akaike ($AIC$) and Bayesian ($BIC$). It is found that the best description is given by a two-component mixture of skewed Student-$t$ distributions, which outperforms any other model considered. This implies that the distribution of the studied parameters is intrinsically skewed, introducing spurious Gaussian components, and hence the third class is unlikely to be a real phenomenon. Its existence, based on statistical inference, is therefore rejected as unnecessary to explain the observations.

15 pages; accepted in ApJ

References in corpus (40)

• Multi-messenger Observations of a Binary Neutron Star Merger
• Gravitational Waves and Gamma-rays from a Binary Neutron Star Merger: GW170817 and GRB 170817A
• The Supernova -- Gamma-Ray Burst Connection
• An Ordinary Short Gamma-Ray Burst with Extraordinary Implications: Fermi-GBM Detection of GRB 170817A
• Statistical applications of the multivariate skew-normal distribution
• Distributions generated by perturbation of symmetry with emphasis on a multivariate skew $t$ distribution
• INTEGRAL Detection of the First Prompt Gamma-Ray Signal Coincident with the Gravitational Wave Event GW170817
• No supernovae associated with two long-duration gamma ray bursts
• Discerning the physical origins of cosmological Gamma-ray bursts based on multiple observational criteria: the cases of z=6.7 GRB 080913, z=8.3 GRB 090423, and some short/hard GRBs
• The Observer's Guide to the Gamma-Ray Burst-Supernova Connection
• The 3rd Fermi GBM Gamma-Ray Burst Catalog: The First Six Years
• The ultra-long Gamma-Ray Burst 111209A: the collapse of a blue supergiant?
• Star Formation History up to z = 7.4: Implications for Gamma-Ray Bursts and the Cosmic Metallicity Evolution
• A new definition of the intermediate group of gamma-ray bursts
• Global Properties of X-Ray Flashes and X-Ray-Rich Gamma-Ray Bursts Observed by Swift
• A new type of long gamma--ray burst
• Further Study of the Gamma-Ray Bursts Duration Distribution
• The redshift distribution of gamma-ray bursts revisited
• The Gamma--Ray Burst catalog obtained with the Gamma Ray Burst Monitor aboard BeppoSAX
• Classification of Swift's gamma-ray bursts
• A Comparative Study of Long and Short GRBs. I. Overlapping Properties
• An analysis of the durations of Swift Gamma-Ray Bursts
• Statistical Study of Observed and Intrinsic Durations among BATSE and Swift/BAT GRBs
• Classification of Gamma-Ray Burst durations using robust model-comparison techniques
• Classification of BeppoSAX's Gamma-Ray Bursts
• Ultra Long Gamma-Ray Bursts from the collapse of Blue Super Giant stars: an end-to-end simulation
• Gaussian-Mixture-Model-based Cluster Analysis Finds Five Kinds of Gamma Ray Bursts in the BATSE Catalog
• Searching for differences in Swift's intermediate GRBs
• Clustering of gamma-ray burst types in the Fermi-GBM catalogue: indications of photosphere and synchrotron emissions during the prompt phase
• Distributions of Pseudo-Redshifts and Durations (Observed and Intrinsic) of Fermi GRBs
• Revisiting the Redshift Distribution of Gamma Ray Bursts in the Swift Era
• Classifying GRB170817A / GW170817 in a Fermi duration - hardness plane
• A Black Hole - White Dwarf Compact Binary Model for Long Gamma-ray Bursts without Supernova Association
• Redshift distribution of gamma-ray bursts and star formation rate
• Two Dimensional Classification of the Swift/BAT GRBs
• On the Connection of Gamma-Ray Bursts and X-Ray Flashes in the BATSE and RHESSI Databases
• Multivariate $t$-Mixtures-Model-based Cluster Analysis of BATSE Catalog Establishes Importance of All Observed Parameters, Confirms Five Distinct Ellipsoidal Sub-populations of Gamma Ray Bursts
• Statistical analysis of BATSE gamma-ray bursts: Self-similarity and the Amati-relation
• Factor analysis of the long gamma-ray bursts
• Classification of Fermi Gamma-RAY Bursts

Cited by in corpus (25)

• The Fourth Fermi-GBM Gamma-Ray Burst Catalog: A Decade of Data
• A Comprehensive Power Spectral Density Analysis of Astronomical Time Series. II. The Swift/BAT Long Gamma-Ray Bursts
• Temporal Properties of Precursors, Main peaks and Extended Emissions of Short GRBs in the Third Swift/BAT GRB Catalog
• Extreme Variability in a Long Duration Gamma-ray Burst Associated with a Kilonova
• Multivariate analysis of BATSE gamma-ray burst properties using skewed distributions
• On Spectral Peak Energy of Swift Gamma-Ray Bursts
• Two Dimensional Clustering of Gamma-Ray Bursts using durations and hardness
• Properties of Gamma-Ray Bursts Associated with Supernovae and Kilonovae
• Gamma-Ray Bursts with Extended Emission: Classifications, Energy Correlations and Radiation Properties
• Does the GRB Duration Depend on Redshift?
• GRB X-Ray Flare Properties among Different GRB Subclasses
• Graph-based clustering of gamma-ray bursts
• GRB Optical and X-ray Plateau Properties Classifier Using Unsupervised Machine Learning
• A new nonparametric interpoint distance-based measure for assessment of clustering
• A new interpoint distance-based clustering algorithm using kernel density estimation
• Classification of Pulsar Glitch Amplitudes using Extreme Deconvolution
• Evaluation of the number of clusters in a data set using $p$-values from Multiple Tests of Hypotheses
• A Tight Three-parameter Correlation and Related Classification on Gamma-Ray Bursts
• Can the Cosmological Dilation Explain the Skewness in the Gamma-Ray Burst Duration Distribution?
• Distribution of gamma-ray bursts on the t90-hardness ratio plane and their classification revisited
• Scanning the Universe for Large-Scale Structures using Gamma-Ray Bursts
• How does the shape of gamma-ray bursts' pulses affect the duration distribution?
• Confirmation of Binary Clustering in Gamma-Ray Bursts through an Integrated $p$-value from Multiple Nonparametric Tests of Hypotheses
• Gamma-ray burst taxonomy: looking for the third class on the spectral peak energy-duration plane in the rest frame
• Some statistical remarks on GRBs jointly detected by Fermi and Swift satellites