How realistic are solar model atmospheres?

Abstract

Recently, new solar model atmospheres have been developed to replace classical 1D LTE hydrostatic models and used to for example derive the solar chemical composition. We aim to test various models against key observational constraints. In particular, a 3D model used to derive the solar abundances, a 3D MHD model (with an imposed 10 mT vertical magnetic field), 1D models from the PHOENIX project, the 1D MARCS model, and the 1D semi-empirical model of Holweger & Müller. We confront the models with observational diagnostics of the temperature profile: continuum centre-to-limb variations (CLV), absolute continuum fluxes, and the wings of hydrogen lines. We also test the 3D models for the intensity distribution of the granulation and spectral line shapes. The predictions from the 3D model are in excellent agreement with the continuum CLV observations, performing even better than the Holweger & Müller model (constructed largely to fulfil such observations). The predictions of the 1D theoretical models are worse, given their steeper temperature gradients. For the continuum fluxes, predictions for most models agree well with the observations. No model fits all hydrogen lines perfectly, but again the 3D model comes ahead. The 3D model also reproduces the observed continuum intensity fluctuations and spectral line shapes very well. The excellent agreement of the 3D model with the observables reinforces the view that its temperature structure is realistic. It outperforms the MHD simulation in all diagnostics, implying that recent claims for revised abundances based on MHD modelling are premature. Several weaknesses in the 1D models are exposed. The differences between the PHOENIX LTE and NLTE models are small. We conclude that the 3D hydrodynamical model is superior to any of the tested 1D models, which gives further confidence in the solar abundance analyses based on it.

17 pages, 15 figures. Accepted for publication in A&A

References in corpus (9)

• A grid of MARCS model atmospheres for late-type stars I. Methods and general properties
• The Solar Optical Telescope for the Hinode Mission: An Overview
• Helioseismology and Solar Abundances
• The intensity contrast of solar granulation: comparing Hinode SP results with MHD simulations
• Solar Carbon Monoxide, Thermal Profiling, and the Abundances of C, O, and their Isotopes
• Center-to-Limb Variation of Solar 3-D Hydrodynamical Simulations
• Non-LTE Balmer line formation in late-type spectra: Effects of atomic processes involving hydrogen atoms
• The solar photospheric abundance of hafnium and thorium. Results from CO5BOLD 3D hydrodynamic model atmospheres
• The discrepancy in G-band contrast: Where is the quiet Sun?

Cited by in corpus (70)

• The chemical make-up of the Sun: A 2020 vision
• The elemental composition of the Sun II. The iron group elements Sc to Ni
• The elemental composition of the Sun I. The intermediate mass elements Na to Ca
• The elemental composition of the Sun III. The heavy elements Cu to Th
• The Solar Twin Planet Search. I. Fundamental parameters of the stellar sample
• Improvements to stellar structure models, based on a grid of 3D convection simulations. II. Calibrating the mixing-length formulation
• The Stagger-grid: A grid of 3D stellar atmosphere models - IV. Limb darkening coefficients
• Non-LTE oxygen line formation in 3D hydrodynamic model stellar atmospheres
• Towards stellar effective temperatures and diameters at one per cent accuracy for future surveys
• Solar structure and evolution
• Accurate abundance analysis of late-type stars: advances in atomic physics
• High-precision stellar abundances of the elements - methods and applications
• Isochrones for Old (> 5 Gyr) Stars and Stellar Populations. I. Models for $-2.4\le$ [Fe/H] $\le +0.6$, $0.25\le Y\le 0.33$, and $-0.4\le$ [$\alpha$\Fe] $\le +0.4$
• The solar silicon abundance based on 3D non-LTE calculations
• Atmospheres of Brown Dwarfs
• Empirical metallicity-dependent calibrations of effective temperature against colours for dwarfs and giants based on interferometric data
• Effective temperature determinations of late-type stars based on 3D non-LTE Balmer line formation
• The radii and limb darkenings of Alpha Centauri A and B - Interferometric measurements with VLTI/PIONIER
• Inelastic O+H collisions and the OI 777nm solar centre-to-limb variation
• Three-dimensional simulations of near-surface convection in main-sequence stars - I. Overall structure
• Improvements to Stellar Structure Models, Based on a Grid of 3D Convection Simulations. I. $T(\tau )$-Relations
• Testing the chemical tagging technique with open clusters
• The Stagger-grid: A Grid of 3D Stellar Atmosphere Models - II. Horizontal and Temporal Averaging and Spectral Line Formation
• Comparison of the power-2 limb-darkening law from the Stagger-grid to Kepler light curves of transiting exoplanets
• The Stagger-grid: A grid of 3D stellar atmosphere models V. Synthetic stellar spectra and broad-band photometry
• A photometric and spectroscopic survey of solar twin stars within 50 parsecs of the Sun: I. Atmospheric parameters and color similarity to the Sun
• Accurate effective temperatures of the metal-poor benchmark stars HD 140283, HD 122563 and HD 103095 from CHARA interferometry
• The age of 47Tuc from self-consistent isochrone fits to colour-magnitude diagrams and the eclipsing member V69
• Fundamental stellar parameters of benchmark stars from CHARA interferometry. I. Metal-poor stars
• The solar gravitational redshift from HARPS-LFC Moon spectra. A test of the General Theory of Relativity
• Convective blueshifts in the solar atmosphere, I. Absolute measurements with LARS of the spectral lines at 6302 Å
• Stellar limb darkening. A new MPS-ATLAS library for Kepler, TESS, CHEOPS, and PLATO passbands
• Radiation hydrodynamics in simulations of the solar atmosphere
• Time Dependent Non-Equilibrium Ionization of Transition Region Lines Observed with IRIS
• Spatially resolved spectroscopy across stellar surfaces. I. Using exoplanet transits to analyze 3-D stellar atmospheres
• Solar and Stellar Photospheric Abundances
• Comparison of physical properties of quiet and active regions through the analysis of MHD simulations of the solar photosphere
• How different are the Liège and Hamburg atlases of the solar spectrum?
• Continuum intensity and [O I] spectral line profiles in solar 3D photospheric models: the effect of magnetic fields
• Bayesian Investigation of Isochrone Consistency Using the Old Open Cluster NGC 188
• LARS - An Absolute Reference Spectrograph for solar observations, Upgrade from a prototype to a turn-key system
• Thermodynamic fluctuations in solar photospheric three-dimensional convection simulations and observations
• Does the radial-tangential macroturbulence model adequately describe the spectral line broadening of solar-type stars?
• The amplitude of solar p-mode oscillations from three-dimensional convection simulations
• 3D Stagger model atmospheres with FreeEOS I. Exploring the impact of microphysics on the Sun
• Spatially resolved spectroscopy across stellar surfaces. IV. F, G, & K-stars: Synthetic 3D spectra at hyper-high resolution
• An extended and refined grid of 3D STAGGER model atmospheres. Processed snapshots for stellar spectroscopy
• Accurate effective temperature from H$\alpha$ profiles
• Fundamental stellar parameters of benchmark stars from CHARA interferometry -- II. Dwarf stars
• The relationship between photometric and spectroscopic oscillation amplitudes from 3D stellar atmosphere simulations
• Doppler beaming factors for white dwarfs, main sequence stars, and giant stars Limb-darkening coefficients for 3D (DA and DB) white dwarf models
• Models of Metal-Poor Stars with Different Initial Abundances of C, N, O, Mg, and Si. I. Bolometric Corrections Derived from New MARCS Synthetic Spectra and Their Implications for Observed Colour-Magnitude Diagrams
• The dynamic chromosphere: pushing the boundaries of observations and models
• Extended MCDHF calculations of energy levels and transition data for N I
• Does the ${\nu }_{\max }$ scaling relation depend on metallicity? Insights from 3D convection simulations
• Spectro-polarimetric simulations of the solar limb: absorption-emission FeI $6301.5\mathring{\mathrm{A}}$ and $6302.5\mathring{\mathrm{A}}$ line profiles and torsional flows in the intergranular magnetic flux concentrations
• Probing Na in giant exoplanets with ESPRESSO and 3D NLTE stellar spectra
• A new view on exoplanet transits: Transit of Venus described using three-dimensional solar atmosphere Stagger-grid simulations
• Opacity for realistic 3D MHD simulations of cool stellar atmospheres
• The solar photospheric silicon abundance according to CO5BOLD: Investigating line broadening, magnetic fields, and model effects
• Chromosphere of the quiet sun -- I. Shock and current-sheet dynamics and heating
• On the visibility of stellar oscillations
• Photospheric Hot Spots at Solar Coronal Loop Footpoints Revealed by Hyperspectral Imaging Observations
• Revisiting the statistical equilibrium of H${}^{-}$ in stellar atmospheres
• Implications of time-dependent molecular chemistry in metal-poor dwarf stars
• Solar Flux Atlases: The new HARPS-N Quiet Sun Benchmark and Ca II H & K Lines Continuum Normalisation
• Response to "Stray-light correction in 2D spectroscopy" by R. Schlichenmaier and M. Franz
• The metal-poorest tail of the Galactic halo: hypothesis on its origin from precise spectral analysis
• Exploiting solar visible-range observations by inversion techniques: from flows in the solar subsurface to a flaring atmosphere
• The solar carbon, nitrogen, and oxygen abundances from a 3D LTE analysis of molecular lines