Response to "Stray-light correction in 2D spectroscopy" by R. Schlichenmaier and M. Franz
arXiv:1310.4630 · doi:10.1051/0004-6361/201322397
Abstract
We discuss a recent paper by Schlichenmaier & Franz (SF; 2013, A&A, 555, A84), in which the claim is made that the penumbral dark downflows detected for the first time with the Swedish 1-m Solar Telescope (SST) by Scharmer et al. and Joshi et al. could be produced by overcompensation for straylight. We show that the analysis of SF is fundamentally flawed, because it ignores the constraints on the strength of such straylight from 3D convection simulations and on the spatial extent of the straylight point spread function from the measured minimum intensity in the sunspot umbra. Furthermore, we show that the claim made by SF, that the spatial straylight of Hinode is less than 10%, is false. We conclude that the analysis of SF is of no relevance in relation to the straylight compensation method applied to the SST data.
arXiv commentPublished in A&A. Rewording of a few sentences, one sentence removed
References in corpus (20)
- Radiative MHD simulation of sunspot structure
- Penumbral structure and outflows in simulated sunspots
- Fine structure, magnetic field and heating of sunspot penumbrae
- The intensity contrast of solar granulation: comparing Hinode SP results with MHD simulations
- MHD simulations of penumbra fine structure
- Penumbral fine structure and driving mechanisms of large-scale flows in simulated sunspots
- How realistic are solar model atmospheres?
- Simulations of the solar near-surface layers with the CO5BOLD, MURaM, and Stagger codes
- Magnetostatic penumbra models with field-free gaps
- Structure of sunspot penumbral filaments: a remarkable uniformity of properties
- Properties of sunspots in cycle 23: I. Dependence of brightness on sunspot size and cycle phase
- Point spread functions for the Solar Optical Telescope onboard Hinode
- On the continuum intensity distribution of the solar photosphere
- Opposite polarity field with convective downflow and its relation to magnetic spines in a sunspot penumbra
- Stray light correction and contrast analysis of Hinode broad band images
- On the velocity field of sunspot penumbrae - I. A global view
- Convective Nature of Sunspot Penumbral Filaments: Discovery of Downflows in the Deep Photosphere
- The velocity field of sunspot penumbrae II. Return flow and magnetic fields of opposite polarity
- SST/CRISP Observations of Convective Flows in a Sunspot Penumbra
- Sources of straylight in the post-focus imaging instrumentation of the Swedish 1-m Solar Telescope