Thermodynamic fluctuations in solar photospheric three-dimensional convection simulations and observations
arXiv:1306.6093 · doi:10.1051/0004-6361/201321596
Abstract
Numerical 3D radiative (M)HD simulations of solar convection are used to understand the physical properties of the solar photosphere. To validate this approach, it is important to check that no excessive thermodynamic fluctuations arise as a consequence of the partially incomplete treatment of radiative transfer. We investigate the realism of 3D convection simulations carried out with the Stagger code. We compared the characteristic properties of several spectral lines in solar disc centre observations with spectra synthesized from the simulations. We degraded the synthetic spectra to the spatial resolution of the observations using the continuum intensity distribution. We estimated the necessary spectral degradation by comparing atlas spectra with averaged observed spectra. In addition to deriving a set of line parameters directly, we used the SIR code to invert the spectra. Most of the line parameters from the observational data are matched well by the degraded simulation spectra. The inversions predict a macroturbulent velocity below 10 m/s for the simulation at full spatial resolution, whereas they yield ~< 1000 m/s at a spatial resolution of 0.3". The temperature fluctuations in the inversion of the degraded simulation do not exceed those from the observational data (of the order of 100-200 K rms for -2<log tau<-0.5). The comparison of line parameters in spatially averaged profiles with the averaged values of line parameters in spatially resolved profiles indicates a significant change of (average) line properties at a spatial scale between 0.13" and 0.3". Up to a spatial resolution of 0.3", we find no indications of the presence of excessive thermodynamic fluctuations in the 3D HD simulation. To definitely confirm that simulations without spatial degradation contain fully realistic thermodynamic fluctuations requires observations at even better spatial resolution.
arXiv comment21 pages, 15 figures + 2 pages Appendix, accepted for publication in A&A; v2 version: corrected for an error in the calculation of stray-light estimates, for details see the Corrigendum to A&A, 2013, 557, 109 (DOI: 10.1051/0004-6361/201321596). Corrected text and numbers are in bold font. Apart from the stray-light estimates, nothing in the rest of the paper was affected by the error
References in corpus (64)
- The chemical composition of the Sun
- The Solar Optical Telescope for the Hinode Mission: An Overview
- Line formation in solar granulation: IV. [O I], OI and OH lines and the photospheric O abundance
- Numerical simulation of the three-dimensional structure and dynamics of the non-magnetic solar chromosphere
- The formation of the Halpha line in the solar chromosphere
- The photospheric solar oxygen project: I. Abundance analysis of atomic lines and influence of atmospheric models
- Convectively driven vortex flows in the Sun
- Approximations for radiative cooling and heating in the solar chromosphere
- Quiet Sun internetwork magnetic fields from the inversion of Hinode measurements
- Non-equilibrium hydrogen ionization in 2D simulations of the solar atmosphere
- Radiative transfer with scattering for domain-decomposed 3D MHD simulations of cool stellar atmospheres
- The intensity contrast of solar granulation: comparing Hinode SP results with MHD simulations
- Spatially coupled inversion of spectro-polarimetric image data I: Method and first results
- What Is The Neon Abundance Of The Sun?
- Comparing Numerical Methods for Isothermal Magnetized Supersonic Turbulence
- Fully resolved quiet-Sun magnetic flux tube observed with the Sunrise IMaX instrument
- Center-to-Limb Variation of Solar 3-D Hydrodynamical Simulations
- The C/O ratio at low metallicity: constraints on early chemical evolution from observations of Galactic halo stars
- Multi-level 3D non-LTE computations of lithium lines in the metal-poor halo stars HD140283 and HD84937
- Center-to-Limb Variation of Solar Line Profiles as a Test of NLTE Line Formation Calculations
- How realistic are solar model atmospheres?
- Simulations of the solar near-surface layers with the CO5BOLD, MURaM, and Stagger codes
- Three-dimensional non-LTE radiative transfer computation of the Ca 8542 infrared line from a radiation-MHD simulation
- Solar Flux Emergence Simulations
- Multi-layer study of wave propagation in sunspots
- Point spread functions for the Solar Optical Telescope onboard Hinode
- Neutral oxygen spectral line formation revisited with new collisional data: large departures from LTE at low metallicity
- Detection of vortex tubes in solar granulation from observations with Sunrise
- Oxygen lines in solar granulation. II. Centre-to-limb variation, NLTE line formation, blends and the solar oxygen abundance
- On the validity of the 630 nm Fe I nm lines for the magnetometry of the internetwork quiet Sun
- Vortices in simulations of solar surface convection
- On the continuum intensity distribution of the solar photosphere
- 'Ultimate' Information Content in Solar and Stellar Spectra: Photospheric line asymmetries and wavelength shifts
- Statistical equilibrium of silicon in the solar atmosphere
- Excitation of acoustic waves by vortices in the quiet Sun
- Resolving the internal magnetic structure of the solar network
- Internetwork magnetic field distribution from simultaneous 1.56 micron and 630 nm observations
- Stokes diagnostics of simulated solar magneto-convection
- Solar velocity references from 3D HD photospheric models
- A geometrical height scale for sunspot penumbrae
- Solar abundance corrections derived through 3D magnetoconvection simulations
- The GREGOR Fabry-Pérot Interferometer
- Another forbidden solar oxygen abundance: the [O I] 5577 A line
- The Chromospheric Telescope
- Non-equilibrium calcium ionisation in the solar atmosphere
- Oxygen lines in solar granulation. I. Testing 3D models against new observations with high spatial and spectral resolution
- Stray-light contamination and spatial deconvolution of slit-spectrograph observations
- Chemical Abundances from Inversions of Stellar Spectra: Analysis of Solar-Type Stars with Homogeneous and Static Model Atmospheres
- The magnetic flux of the quiet Sun internetwork as observed with the Tenerife Infrared Polarimeter
- Solar Fe abundance and magnetic fields - Towards a consistent reference metallicity
- Time series of high resolution photospheric spectra in a quiet region of the Sun. II. Analysis of the variation of physical quantities of granular structures
- The energy of waves in the photosphere and lower chromosphere: 1. Velocity statistics
- A High-Resolution Three-Dimensional Model of the Solar Photosphere Derived from Hinode Observations
- Temporal evolution of the Evershed flow in sunspots. I. Observational characterization of Evershed clouds
- Physical properties of the solar magnetic photosphere under the MISMA hypothesis III: sunspot at disk center
- Three-dimensional surface convection simulations of metal-poor stars -- The effect of scattering on the photospheric temperature stratification
- Intensity contrast from MHD simulations and from HINODE observations
- Zeeman-Tomography of the Solar Photosphere -- 3-Dimensional Surface Structures Retrieved from Hinode Observations
- Application of speckle and (multi-object) multi-frame blind deconvolution techniques on imaging and imaging spectropolarimetric data
- Siphon flow in a cool magnetic loop
- The energy of waves in the photosphere and lower chromosphere: IV. Inversion results of Ca II H spectra
- The energy of waves in the photosphere and lower chromosphere: III. Inversion setup for Ca II H spectra in local thermal equilibrium
- Time series of high resolution photospheric spectra in a quiet region of the Sun. I. Analysis of global and spatial variations of line parameters
- Sources of straylight in the post-focus imaging instrumentation of the Swedish 1-m Solar Telescope
Cited by in corpus (11)
- A new MHD-assisted Stokes inversion technique
- Interpretation of Solar Irradiance Monitor measurements through analysis of 3D MHD simulations
- Continuum intensity and [O I] spectral line profiles in solar 3D photospheric models: the effect of magnetic fields
- The statistical distribution of magnetic field strength in G-band bright points
- The power spectrum of solar convection flows from high-resolution observations and 3D simulations
- Using the infrared iron lines to probe solar subsurface convection
- Spectroscopy at the solar limb: II. Are spicules heated to coronal temperatures ?
- The polarization signature of photospheric magnetic fields in 3D MHD simulations and observations at disk center
- A Refined Model of Convectively-Driven Flicker in Kepler Light Curves
- A study of solar photospheric temperature gradient variation using limb darkening measurements
- Sustained heating of the chromosphere and transition region over a sunspot light bridge