Bayesian Investigation of Isochrone Consistency Using the Old Open Cluster NGC 188

Abstract

This paper provides a detailed comparison of the differences in parameters derived for a star cluster from its color-magnitude diagrams depending on the filters and models used. We examine the consistency and reliability of fitting three widely-used stellar evolution models to fifteen combinations of optical and near-IR photometry for the old open cluster NGC 188. The optical filter response curves match those of the theoretical systems and are thus not the source of fit inconsistencies. NGC 188 is ideally suited to the present study thanks to a wide variety of high-quality photometry and available proper motions and radial velocities which enable us to remove non-cluster members and many binaries. Our Bayesian fitting technique yields inferred values of age, metallicity, distance modulus, and absorption as a function of the photometric band combinations and stellar models. We show that the historically-favored three band combinations of UBV and VRI can be meaningfully inconsistent with each other and with longer baseline datasets such as UBVRIJHKs. Differences among model sets can also be substantial. For instance, fitting Yi et al. (2001) and Dotter et al. (2008) models to UBVRIJHKs photometry for NGC 188 yields the following cluster parameters: age={5.78+ 0.03, 6.45+-0.04} Gyr, [Fe/H]={+0.125+-0.003, -0.077+-0.003} dex, m-M={11.441+-0.007, 11.525+-0.005} mag, and Av={0.162+-0.003, 0.236+-0.003} mag, respectively. Within the formal fitting errors, these two fits are substantially and statistically different. Such differences amongst fits using different filters and models are a cautionary tale regarding our current ability to fit star cluster color-magnitude diagrams. Additional modeling of this kind, with more models and star clusters, and future GAIA parallaxes are critical for isolating and quantifying the most relevant uncertainties in stellar evolutionary models.

19 pages, 6 figures, AJ accepted

References in corpus (2)

• The Dartmouth Stellar Evolution Database
• Inverting Color-Magnitude Diagrams to Access Precise Star Cluster Parameters: A Bayesian Approach

Cited by in corpus (10)

• Ages and masses of million Galactic disk main sequence turn-off and sub-giant stars from the LAMOST Galactic spectroscopic surveys
• The ACS Survey of Galactic Globular Clusters XIV: Bayesian Single-Population Analysis of 69 Globular Clusters
• Contact Binaries as Viable Distance Indicators: New, Competitive (V)JHKs Period-Luminosity Relations
• WOCS 5379: Detailed Analysis of the Evolution of a Post-Mass-Transfer Blue Straggler
• Bayesian Analysis of Two Stellar Populations in Galactic Globular Clusters III: Analysis of 30 Clusters
• Physical parameter study of eight W Ursae Majoris-type contact binaries in NGC 188
• A Bayesian Analysis of the Ages of Four Open Clusters
• Bayesian Characterization of Main Sequence Binaries in the Old Open Cluster NGC 188
• WOCS 4540: Detailed Analysis of a Very Long Orbital Period Blue Straggler
• Variable stars detection in the field of open cluster NGC 188