Systematic differences in simple stellar population model results: Application to the M31 globular-like cluster system
arXiv:1205.4310 · doi:10.1111/j.1365-2966.2012.21346.x
Abstract
Simple stellar population (SSP) synthesis models are useful tools for studying the nature of unresolved star clusters in external galaxies. However, the plethora of currently available SSP models gives rise to significant and poorly documented systematic differences. Here we consider the outputs of the commonly used Bruzual & Charlot and GALEV models, as well as a recently updated SSP model suite which attempts to include the contributions of binary merger products in the form of blue straggler stars (BS-SSP). We rederive the ages, metallicities, extinction values and masses of 445 previously observed globular-like clusters in M31 based on chi-square minimisation of their spectral energy distributions with respect to these three different SSP models and adopting a Chabrier-like stellar initial mass function. A comparison between our new results and previous estimates of the same parameters shows that the Bruzual & Charlot models yield the youngest ages and lowest masses, while adoption of the BS-SSP models results in the oldest ages and highest mass estimates. Similarly, the GALEV SSP models produce the lowest metallicities, with the highest values resulting from the BS-SSP model suite. These trends are caused by intrinsic differences associated with the models, and are not significantly affected by the well-known age-metallicity degeneracy. Finally, we note that the mass function of the massive M31 star clusters is similar to that of the Milky Way's globular clusters, which implies that the two star cluster systems likely formed under similar environmental conditions.
arXiv comment15 pages, 12 figures, 2 tables, accepted for publication in MNRAS
References in corpus (75)
- First Year Wilkinson Microwave Anisotropy Probe (WMAP) Observations: Determination of Cosmological Parameters
- Stellar population synthesis at the resolution of 2003
- Galactic Stellar and Substellar Initial Mass Function
- On the variation of the Initial Mass Function
- A grid of MARCS model atmospheres for late-type stars I. Methods and general properties
- Evolutionary population synthesis: models, analysis of the ingredients and application to high-z galaxies
- The propagation of uncertainties in stellar population synthesis modeling I: The relevance of uncertain aspects of stellar evolution and the IMF to the derived physical properties of galaxies
- MILES: A Medium resolution INT Library of Empirical Spectra
- The propagation of uncertainties in stellar population synthesis modeling III: model calibration, comparison, and evaluation
- A standard stellar library for evolutionary synthesis: I. Calibration of theoretical spectra
- The remnants of galaxy formation from a panoramic survey of the region around M31
- A standard stellar library for evolutionary synthesis: II. The M dwarf extension
- STELIB: a library of stellar spectra at R~2000
- A database of high and medium-resolution stellar spectra
- A Survey of Local Group Galaxies Currently Forming Stars. I. UBVRI Photometry of Stars in M31 and M33
- Stellar population models at high spectral resolution
- Spectral and Photometric Evolution of Young Stellar Populations: the Impact of Gaseous Emission at Various Metallicities
- M31 Globular Clusters: Colors and Metallicities
- Distance to M31 With the HST and Hipparcos Red Clump Stars
- Near-Infrared Photometric Variability of Stars Toward the Orion A Molecular Cloud
- The Y^2 Stellar Evolutionary Tracks
- HST color-magnitude diagrams of 74 galactic globular clusters in the HST F439W and F555W bands
- The Milky Way: An Exceptionally Quiet Galaxy; Implications for the formation of spiral galaxies
- Galactic Globular Cluster Relative Ages. II
- GALEV evolutionary synthesis models - I. Code, input physics and web-interface
- 2MASS NIR photometry for 693 candidate globular clusters in M31 and the Revised Bologna Catalogue
- Deep Wide-Field Spectrophotometry of the Open Cluster M67
- The Star Cluster Population of M51: II. Age distribution and relations among the derived parameters
- Analysing observed star cluster SEDs with evolutionary synthesis models: Systematic uncertainties
- Spectral & Photometric Evolution of Simple Stellar Populations at Various Metallicities
- Hierarchical Star Formation in M51: Star/Cluster Complexes
- Star Clusters in M31: I. A Catalog and a Study of the Young Clusters
- Physical limits to the validity of synthesis models: The Lowest Luminosity Limit
- Optical and Near-Infrared Color Profiles in Nearby Early-Type Galaxies and The Implied Age and Metallicity Gradients
- Confidence levels of evolutionary synthesis models III: On sampling and Poissonian fluctuations
- How well do we know the age and mass distributions of the star cluster system in the Large Magellanic Cloud?
- The M31 globular cluster system: ugriz and K-band photometry and structural parameters
- Accounting for Stochastic Fluctuations when Analysing Integrated Light of Star Clusters. I: First Systematics
- The Star Cluster Population of M51: III. Cluster disruption and formation history
- Confidence limits of evolutionary synthesis models. IV Moving forward to a probabilistic formulation
- An updated survey of globular clusters in M31. II Newly discovered bright and remote clusters
- Star Cluster Formation and Evolution in the Dwarf Starburst Galaxy NGC 1569
- Better age estimations using UV-optical colours: breaking the age-metallicity degeneracy
- NICMOS Observations of Extragalactic Cepheids. I. Photometry Database and a Test of the Standard Extinction Law
- Star Cluster Formation and Evolution in Nearby Starburst Galaxies: I. Systematic Uncertainties
- An updated survey of globular clusters in M 31. I. Classification and radial velocity for 76 candidate clusters
- M31 Globular Clusters in the HST Archive: I. Cluster Detection and Completeness
- Reddening, Colour and Metallicity of the M31 Globular Cluster System
- Star Cluster Formation and Disruption Time-Scales - II. Evolution of the Star Cluster System in M82's Fossil Starburst
- The Origin of the Gaussian Initial Mass Function of Old Globular Cluster Systems
- Analysing star cluster populations with stochastic models: the HST/WFC3 sample of clusters in M83
- An updated survey of globular clusters in M 31. III. A spectroscopic metallicity scale for the Revised Bologna Catalog
- Age and Mass for 920 LMC Clusters Derived from 100 Million Monte Carlo Simulations
- STIS Spectroscopy of Young Star Clusters in "The Antennae" Galaxies (NGC 4038/4039)
- Systematic uncertainties in the analysis of star cluster parameters based on broad-band imaging observations
- MASSCLEANage -- Stellar Cluster Ages from Integrated Colors --
- Blue Stragglers in Galactic Open Clusters and the Integrated Spectral Energy Distributions
- Spectral Energy Distributions and Age Estimates of 172 Globular Clusters in M31
- Spectral energy distributions and age estimates of 104 M31 globular clusters
- The Young Cluster Population of M82 Region B
- An HST/WFPC2 Survey of Bright Young Clusters in M31 III. Structural Parameters
- Spectral Energy Distributions and Age Estimates of 39 Globular Clusters in M31
- New age estimates of M31 globular clusters from multi-colour photometry
- An updated catalog of M31 globular-like clusters: UBVRI photometry, ages, and masses
- Blue Straggler Stars in Galactic Open Clusters and the Simple Stellar Population Model
- CIRPASS near-infrared integral-field spectroscopy of massive star clusters in the starburst galaxy NGC 1140
- Age constraints for an M31 globular cluster from SEDs-fit
- Evidence for Blue Straggler Stars Rejuvenating the Integrated Spectra of Globular Clusters
- An HST Survey of the Disk Cluster Population of M31. I. WFPC2 Pointings
- The analysis of red giant branch photometry in galaxies
- Wavelength and Redshift Dependence of Bulge/Total Light Ratios in Galaxies
- A Photometric Catalog of 77 Newly-recognized Star Clusters in M31
- IMF biases created by binning and unresolved systems
- The Impact of Starbursts and Post-Starbursts on the Photometric Evolution of High Redshift Galaxies
- Simple stellar population models including blue stragglers
Cited by in corpus (10)
- Virgo Redux: The Masses and Stellar Content of Nuclei in Early-Type Galaxies from Multi-Band Photometry and Spectroscopy
- Full spectral fitting of Milky Way and M31 globular clusters: ages and metallicities
- Evidence for Two Distinct Stellar Initial Mass Functions
- Star clusters in M33: updated UBVRI photometry, ages, metallicities, and masses
- The Next Generation Virgo cluster Survey (NGVS). XXVI. The issues of photometric age and metallicity estimates for globular clusters
- The RR Lyrae Delay-Time Distribution: A Novel Perspective on Models of Old Stellar Populations
- On the origin of the metallicity dependence in dynamically formed extragalactic low-mass X-ray binaries
- Lick Indices and Spectral Energy Distribution Analysis based on an M31 Star Cluster Sample: Comparisons of Methods and Models
- The Ages of M31 Star Clusters: Spectral Energy Distribution Versus Color-Magnitude Diagram
- The Effects of the WISE/GALEX Photometry for the SED-Fitting with M31 Star Clusters and Candidates