The Ages of M31 Star Clusters: Spectral Energy Distribution Versus Color-Magnitude Diagram

Abstract

It is well-known that fitting the Color Magnitude Diagrams (CMDs) to the theoretical isochrones is the main method to determine star cluster ages. However, when the CMDs are not available, the Spectral Energy Distribution (SED)-fitting technique is the only other approach, although it suffers the age-metallicity-reddening degeneracy. In this work, we gather the ages, metallicities and masses of dozens of M31 star clusters from the CMD-fitting with HST images from the literatures for comparison. We check the reliability of the SED-fitting results with different models, i.e., Bruzual \& Charlot 2003 model (BC03), Galaxy Evolutionary Synthesis Models ({\sl GALEV}) and Advanced Stellar Population Synthesis (ASPS) for the simple stellar populations (SSPs) with single stars (ss)-SSP/binary star (bs)-SSPs models. The photometry bands includes the Galaxy Evolution Explorer {\sl GALEX} FUV/NUV bands, optical/near-infrared $UBVRIJHK$ bands, as well as the Wide-field Infrared Survey Explorer ({\sl WISE}) $W1$/$W2$ bands. The comparisons show that the SED-fitting ages agree well with the CMD-fitting ages, either with the fixed metallicity or with the free metallicity for both the BC03 and the {\sl GALEV} model. However, for the ASPS models, it seems that SED-fitting results are systematic older than the CMD ages, especially for the ages log t <9.0 (yr). The fitting also shows that the {\sl GALEX} FUV/NUV-band are more important than the {\sl WISE} $W1$/$W2$ for constraining the ages, which confirms the previous findings. We also derived the masses of our sample star clusters from the BC03 and {\sl GALEV} models and it is found that the values agree well with that in the literature.

33 pages, 8 figures. Accepted for publication in AJ

References in corpus (13)

• GALEV evolutionary synthesis models - I. Code, input physics and web-interface
• An updated survey of globular clusters in M 31. I. Classification and radial velocity for 76 candidate clusters
• GALEX Ultraviolet Photometry of Globular Clusters in M31: Three Year Results and a Catalog
• Spectral Energy Distributions and Age Estimates of 39 Globular Clusters in M31
• New age estimates of M31 globular clusters from multi-colour photometry
• A systematic study of effects of stellar rotation, age spread and binaries on color-magnitude diagrams with extended main-sequence turn-offs
• An Isochrone Database and a Rapid Model for Stellar Population Synthesis
• Powerful CMD: A Tool for Colour-Magnitude Diagram Studies
• The LAMOST spectroscopic survey of star clusters in M31. II. Metallicities, ages and masses
• Explanation of a special color-magnitude diagram of star cluster NGC 1651 from different models
• Analysing Globular Cluster observations - Models and Analysis Tools for Lick/IDS indices
• Lick Indices and Spectral Energy Distribution Analysis based on an M31 Star Cluster Sample: Comparisons of Methods and Models
• The Effects of the WISE/GALEX Photometry for the SED-Fitting with M31 Star Clusters and Candidates

Cited by in corpus (1)

• Estimating ages and metallicities of M31 star clusters from LAMOST DR6