Atmospheric circulation of tidally locked exoplanets: a suite of benchmark tests for dynamical solvers

Abstract

The complexity of atmospheric modelling and its inherent non-linearity, together with the limited amount of data of exoplanets available, motivate model intercomparisons and benchmark tests. In the geophysical community, the Held-Suarez test is a standard benchmark for comparing dynamical core simulations of the Earth's atmosphere with different solvers, based on statistically-averaged flow quantities. In the present study, we perform analogues of the Held-Suarez test for tidally-locked exoplanets with the GFDL-Princeton Flexible Modeling System (FMS) by subjecting both the spectral and finite difference dynamical cores to a suite of tests, including the standard benchmark for Earth, a hypothetical tidally-locked Earth, a "shallow" hot Jupiter model and a "deep" model of HD 209458b. We find qualitative and quantitative agreement between the solvers for the Earth, tidally-locked Earth and shallow hot Jupiter benchmarks, but the agreement is less than satisfactory for the deep model of HD 209458b. Further investigation reveals that closer agreement may be attained by arbitrarily adjusting the values of the horizontal dissipation parameters in the two solvers, but it remains the case that the magnitude of the horizontal dissipation is not easily specified from first principles. Irrespective of radiative transfer or chemical composition considerations, our study points to limitations in our ability to accurately model hot Jupiter atmospheres with meteorological solvers at the level of ten percent for the temperature field and several tens of percent for the velocity field. Direct wind measurements should thus be particularly constraining for the models. Our suite of benchmark tests also provides a reference point for researchers wishing to adapt their codes to study the atmospheric circulation regimes of tidally-locked Earths/Neptunes/Jupiters.

Accepted by MNRAS, 23 pages, 17 figures, 2 tables. No changes from previous version, except MNRAS wants no hyphen in the title. Sample movies of simulations are available at http://www.phys.ethz.ch/~kheng/fms/

References in corpus (4)

• Dynamics and Disequilibrium Carbon Chemistry in Hot Jupiter Atmospheres, With Application to HD 209458b
• Atmospheric dynamics of Earth-like tidally locked aquaplanets
• Atmospheric Circulation of Hot Jupiters: A Shallow Three-Dimensional Model
• Hydrodynamic Simulations of Unevenly Irradiated Jovian Planets

Cited by in corpus (147)

• The PLATO 2.0 Mission
• Equatorial superrotation on tidally locked exoplanets
• 3D mixing in hot Jupiter atmospheres. I. application to the day/night cold trap in HD 209458b
• Inference of Inhomogeneous Clouds in an Exoplanet Atmosphere
• Rotation and winds of exoplanet HD 189733 b measured with high-dispersion transmission spectroscopy
• Doppler Signatures of the Atmospheric Circulation on Hot Jupiters
• Atmospheric Circulation of Hot Jupiters: Dayside-Nightside Temperature Differences
• Changing Phases of Alien Worlds: Probing Atmospheres of Kepler Planets with High-Precision Photometry
• Atmospheric Heat Redistribution on Hot Jupiters
• The atmospheric circulation of a nine-hot Jupiter sample: Probing circulation and chemistry over a wide phase space
• Accuracy tests of radiation schemes used in hot Jupiter global circulation models
• Atmospheric Dynamics of Hot Exoplanets
• Three-Dimensional Atmospheric Circulation Models of HD 189733b and HD 209458b with Consistent Magnetic Drag and Ohmic Dissipation
• The Effects of Consistent Chemical Kinetics Calculations on the Pressure-Temperature Profiles and Emission Spectra of Hot Jupiters
• Dynamic mineral clouds on HD 189733b I. 3D RHD with kinetic, non-equilibrium cloud formation
• The 4.5 $\mu$m full-orbit phase curve of the hot Jupiter HD 209458b
• Understanding Trends Associated with Clouds in Irradiated Exoplanets
• Pseudo 2D chemical model of hot Jupiter atmospheres: application to HD 209458b and HD 189733b
• A non-grey analytical model for irradiated atmospheres. I: Derivation
• The Effects of Irradiation on Hot Jovian Atmospheres: Heat Redistribution and Energy Dissipation
• The Atmospheric Circulation of Ultra-hot Jupiters
• The theory of transmission spectra revisited: a semi-analytical method for interpreting WFC3 data and an unresolved challenge
• Evolution of Ohmically Heated Hot Jupiters
• Advection of potential temperature in the atmosphere of irradiated exoplanets: a robust mechanism to explain radius inflation
• 3.6 and 4.5 $\mu$m $Spitzer$ Phase Curves of the Highly-Irradiated Hot Jupiters WASP-19b and HAT-P-7b
• Magnetic Scaling Laws for the Atmospheres of Hot Giant Exoplanets
• Atmospheric Circulation of Hot Jupiters: Dayside-Nightside Temperature Differences. II. Comparison with Observations
• Constraining High Speed Winds in Exoplanet Atmospheres Through Observations of Anomalous Doppler Shifts During Transit
• Treatment of overlapping gaseous absorption with the correlated-k method in hot Jupiter and brown dwarf atmosphere models
• Exoplanet Biosignatures: Future Directions
• Probing the extreme planetary atmosphere of WASP-12b
• Resolving Orbital and Climate Keys of Earth and Extraterrestrial Environments with Dynamics 1.0: A General Circulation Model for Simulating the Climates of Rocky Planets
• Magnetic Effects in Hot Jupiter Atmospheres
• Atmospheric Dynamics of Hot Giant Planets and Brown Dwarfs
• Magnetohydrodynamic Simulations of the Atmosphere of HD 209458b
• Atmospheric circulation of tidally locked exoplanets: II. Dual-band radiative transfer and convective adjustment
• The impact of atmospheric circulation on the chemistry of the hot Jupiter HD 209458b
• Thermal phase curves of nontransiting terrestrial exoplanets 1. Characterizing atmospheres
• The UK Met Office GCM with a sophisticated radiation scheme applied to the hot Jupiter HD 209458b
• 3.6 and 4.5 $\mu$m Phase Curves of the Highly-Irradiated Eccentric Hot Jupiter WASP-14b
• Simulating the cloudy atmospheres of HD 209458 b and HD 189733 b with the 3D Met Office Unified Model
• Exploring the Habitable Zone for Kepler planetary candidates
• Climate of Earth-like planets with high obliquity and eccentric orbits: implications for habitability conditions
• Atmospheric Regimes and Trends on Exoplanets and Brown Dwarfs
• A Semi-Analytical Model of Visible-Wavelength Phase Curves of Exoplanets and Applications to Kepler-7 b and Kepler-10 b
• Effects of Bulk Composition on The Atmospheric Dynamics on Close-in Exoplanets
• Implications of three-dimensional chemical transport in hot Jupiter atmospheres: results from a consistently coupled chemistry-radiation-hydrodynamics model
• Vertical Tracer Mixing in Hot Jupiter Atmospheres
• Clouds in Three-Dimensional Models of Hot Jupiters Over a Wide Range of Temperatures I: Thermal Structures and Broadband Phase Curve Predictions
• Analytical Models of Exoplanetary Atmospheres. II. Radiative Transfer via the Two-stream Approximation
• The HARPS search for southern extra-solar planets XXXV. Super-Earths around the M-dwarf neighbors Gl433 and Gl667C
• Prospects for Characterizing the Atmosphere of Proxima Centauri b
• Three-Dimensional Circulation Driving Chemical Disequilibrium in WASP-43b
• Gliese 581g as a scaled-up version of Earth: atmospheric circulation simulations
• Magnetically Controlled Circulation on Hot Extrasolar Planets
• Temperature Structure and Atmospheric Circulation of Dry, Tidally Locked Rocky Exoplanets
• Revisiting the Phase Curves of WASP-43b: Confronting Reanalyzed Spitzer Data with Cloudy Atmospheres
• Water-Trapped Worlds
• Exploring the Effects of Active Magnetic Drag in a GCM of the Ultra-Hot Jupiter WASP-76b
• Thermal Processes Governing Hot-Jupiter Radii
• Equatorial anti-rotating day side wind flow in WASP-43b elicited by deep wind jets?
• On the effects of clouds and hazes in the atmospheres of hot Jupiters: semi-analytical temperature-pressure profiles
• Atmospheric circulation of hot Jupiters: insensitivity to initial conditions
• Modeled Temperature-Dependent Clouds with Radiative Feedback in Hot Jupiter Atmospheres
• ARES II: Characterising the Hot Jupiters WASP-127 b, WASP-79 b and WASP-62 b with HST
• Idealised simulations of the deep atmosphere of hot jupiters: Deep, hot, adiabats as a robust solution to the radius inflation problem
• Carbon Dioxide in Exoplanetary Atmospheres: Rarely Dominant Compared to Carbon Monoxide and Water in Hot, Hydrogen-dominated Atmospheres
• Results from a set of three-dimensional numerical experiments of a hot Jupiter atmosphere
• Global-mean Vertical Tracer Mixing in Planetary Atmospheres II: Tidally Locked Planets
• The Atmospheric Circulation and Observable Properties of Non-Synchronously Rotating Hot Jupiters
• On the Stability of Super-Earth Atmospheres
• Intercomparison of General Circulation Models for Hot Extrasolar Planets
• THOR: A New and Flexible Global Circulation Model to Explore Planetary Atmospheres
• The 3D thermal, dynamical and chemical structure of the atmosphere of HD 189733b: implications of wind-driven chemistry for the emission phase curve
• The effect of metallicity on the atmospheres of exoplanets with fully coupled 3D hydrodynamics, equilibrium chemistry, and radiative transfer
• Exonephology: Transmission spectra from a 3D simulated cloudy atmosphere of HD209458b
• Temporal Variability in Hot Jupiter Atmospheres
• On the Existence of Shocks in Irradiated Exoplanetary Atmospheres
• Modeling the effects of inhomogeneous aerosols on the hot Jupiter Kepler-7b's atmospheric circulation
• Simulating gas giant exoplanet atmospheres with Exo-FMS: Comparing semi-grey, picket fence and correlated-k radiative-transfer schemes
• Atmospheric Circulation of Eccentric Hot Jupiter HAT-P-2b
• Atmospheric Circulations of Hot Jupiters as Planetary Heat Engines
• Shear-driven instabilities and shocks in the atmospheres of hot Jupiters
• Grid of Pseudo-2D Chemistry Models for Tidally-Locked Exoplanets. I. The Role of Vertical and Horizontal Mixing
• A Scaling for Atmospheric Heat Redistribution on Tidally-Locked Rocky Planets
• Optical phase curves as diagnostics for aerosol composition in exoplanetary atmospheres
• Probing exoplanet clouds with optical phase curves
• High Resolution Transmission Spectroscopy as a Diagnostic for Jovian Exoplanet Atmospheres: Constraints from Theoretical Models
• Outstanding Challenges of Exoplanet Atmospheric Retrievals
• Exomoons in the habitable zones of M dwarfs
• Constraining Hot Jupiter Atmospheric Structure and Dynamics through Doppler Shifted Emission Spectra
• THOR 2.0: Major Improvements to the Open-Source General Circulation Model
• The hottest hot Jupiters may host Atmospheric Dynamos
• Extremely long convergence times in a 3D GCM simulation of the sub-Neptune Gliese 1214b
• The Influence of Atmospheric Scattering and Absorption on Ohmic Dissipation in Hot Jupiters
• Towards multi-dimensional analysis of transmission spectroscopy. Part II: Day-night induced biases in retrievals from hot to ultra-hot Jupiters
• Analytical Models of Exoplanetary Atmospheres. I. Atmospheric Dynamics via the Shallow Water System
• Habitability and Multistability in Earth-like Planets
• The Fundamental Connections Between the Solar System and Exoplanetary Science
• Benchmark experiments with global climate models applicable to extra-solar gas giant planets in the shallow atmosphere approximation
• Ionisation in atmospheres of brown dwarfs and extrasolar planets VI: Properties of large-scale discharge events
• Atmospheric circulation of tidally locked gas giants with increasing rotation and implications for white-dwarf-brown-dwarf systems
• Models of Warm Jupiter Atmospheres: Observable Signatures of Obliquity
• Numerical Convergence of Hot-Jupiter Atmospheric Flow Solutions
• Retrieval of the dayside atmosphere of WASP-43b with CRIRES+
• Ionization in Atmospheres of Brown Dwarfs and Extrasolar Planets V: Alfvén Ionization
• Baroclinic Instability on Hot Extrasolar Planets
• The Mantis Network II: Examining the 3D high-resolution observable properties of the UHJs WASP-121b and WASP-189b through GCM modelling
• Atmospheric Circulation and Thermal Phase-Curve Offset of Tidally and Non-Tidally Locked Terrestrial Exoplanets
• Thermo-Resistive Instability of Hot Planetary Atmospheres
• The stable climate of KELT-9b
• Modeling the high-resolution emission spectra of clear and cloudy non-transiting hot Jupiters
• Signatures of Clouds in Hot Jupiter Atmospheres: Modeled High Resolution Emission Spectra from 3D General Circulation Models
• No evidence for radius inflation in hot Jupiters from vertical advection of heat
• The Acceleration of Superrotation in Simulated Hot Jupiter Atmospheres
• Geothermal heating enhances atmospheric asymmetries on synchronously rotating planets
• The THOR+HELIOS general circulation model: multi-wavelength radiative transfer with accurate scattering by clouds/hazes
• Hot Jupiter Atmospheric Flows at High Resolution
• An investigation of a super-Earth exoplanet with a greenhouse-gas atmosphere using a general circulation model
• Nonequilibrium thermodynamics of circulation regimes in optically-thin, dry atmospheres
• A Direct Comparison between the use of Double Gray and Multiwavelength Radiative Transfer in a General Circulation Model with and without Radiatively Active Clouds
• Electrostatic activation of prebiotic chemistry in substellar atmospheres
• Shallowness of circulation in hot Jupiters -- Advancing the Ohmic dissipation model
• Atmospheric stability and collapse on tidally locked rocky planets
• Exploring deep and hot adiabats as a potential solution to the radius inflation problem in brown dwarfs: Long-timescale models of the deep atmospheres of KELT-1b, Kepler-13Ab, and SDSS1411B
• Observing exoplanets in the near-infrared from a high altitude balloon platform
• A Global Non-Hydrostatic Atmospheric Model with a Mass and Energy Conserving Vertically-Implicit-Correction (VIC) Scheme
• Turbulence-driven thermal and kinetic energy fluxes in the atmospheres of hot Jupiters
• Repeated Cyclogenesis on Hot-Exoplanet Atmospheres with Deep Heating
• A closer look at LTT 9779b: The ESPRESSO endeavour to pierce the atmospheric veil
• Non-Axisymmetric Flows on Hot Jupiters with Oblique Magnetic Fields
• Magnetic winding and turbulence in ultra-hot Jupiters
• Unveiling the atmospheres of giant exoplanets with an EChO-class mission
• Dark skies of the slightly eccentric WASP-18 b from its optical-to-infrared dayside emission
• Semi-Transparent Shear Turbulence in Hot Jupiter Atmospheres
• Examining NHD vs QHD in the GCM THOR with non-grey radiative transfer for the hot Jupiter regime
• Inflated hot Jupiters: Inferring average atmospheric velocity via Ohmic models coupled with internal dynamo evolution
• Westward hotspot offset explained by subcritical dynamo action in an ultra-hot Jupiter atmosphere
• Global flow regimes of hot Jupiters
• Inhomogeneous magnetic coupling in exoplanets: the stop & go of WASP-18 b's atmospheric flows
• Accelerating exoplanet climate modelling: A machine learning approach to complement 3D GCM grid simulations
• The Study of Climate on Alien Worlds
• The Magnetic Mechanism for Hotspot Reversals in Hot Jupiter Atmospheres
• General Circulation Model Errors are Variable across Exoclimate Parameter Spaces
• Effective drag in rotating, poorly conducting plasma turbulence
• Cloudy and Cloud-free Thermal Phase Curves with PICASO: Applications to WASP-43b
• GCM-Motivated Multidimensional Temperature Parametrization Scheme for Phasecurve Retrieval