Intercomparison of General Circulation Models for Hot Extrasolar Planets
arXiv:1311.5134 · doi:10.1016/j.icarus.2013.11.027
Abstract
We compare five general circulation models (GCMs) which have been recently used to study hot extrasolar planet atmospheres (BOB, CAM, IGCM, MITgcm, and PEQMOD), under three test cases useful for assessing model convergence and accuracy. Such a broad, detailed intercomparison has not been performed thus far for extrasolar planets study. The models considered all solve the traditional primitive equations, but employ different numerical algorithms or grids (e.g., pseudospectral and finite volume, with the latter separately in longitude-latitude and `cubed-sphere' grids). The test cases are chosen to cleanly address specific aspects of the behaviors typically reported in hot extrasolar planet simulations: 1) steady-state, 2) nonlinearly evolving baroclinic wave, and 3) response to fast timescale thermal relaxation. When initialized with a steady jet, all models maintain the steadiness, as they should -- except MITgcm in cubed-sphere grid. A very good agreement is obtained for a baroclinic wave evolving from an initial instability in pseudospectral models (only). However, exact numerical convergence is still not achieved across the pseudospectral models: amplitudes and phases are observably different. When subject to a typical `hot-Jupiter'-like forcing, all five models show quantitatively different behavior -- although qualitatively similar, time-variable, quadrupole-dominated flows are produced. Hence, as have been advocated in several past studies, specific quantitative predictions (such as the location of large vortices and hot regions) by GCMs should be viewed with caution. Overall, in the tests considered here, pseudospectral models in pressure coordinate (PEBOB and PEQMOD) perform the best and MITgcm in cubed-sphere grid performs the worst.
arXiv comment29 pages, 11 figures: Accepted for publication in Icarus
References in corpus (11)
- Atmospheric circulation of hot Jupiters: Coupled radiative-dynamical general circulation model simulations of HD 189733b and HD 209458b
- Atmospheric Circulation of Hot Jupiters: Three-dimensional circulation models of HD 209458b and HD 189733b with Simplified Forcing
- Atmospheric circulation of tidally locked exoplanets: a suite of benchmark tests for dynamical solvers
- Dynamic Meteorology at the Photosphere of HD 209458b
- Three Dimensional Modeling of Hot Jupiter Atmospheric Flows
- Atmospheric Circulation of Hot Jupiters: A Shallow Three-Dimensional Model
- Atmospheric Circulation of Eccentric Hot Neptune GJ436b
- Methane in the atmosphere of the transiting hot Neptune GJ436b?
- Effects of Initial Flow on Close-In Planet Atmospheric Circulation
- Benchmark experiments with global climate models applicable to extra-solar gas giant planets in the shallow atmosphere approximation
- Baroclinic Instability on Hot Extrasolar Planets
Cited by in corpus (21)
- Accuracy tests of radiation schemes used in hot Jupiter global circulation models
- The Effects of Consistent Chemical Kinetics Calculations on the Pressure-Temperature Profiles and Emission Spectra of Hot Jupiters
- Hot Jupiters: Origins, Structure, Atmospheres
- Revisiting the Phase Curves of WASP-43b: Confronting Reanalyzed Spitzer Data with Cloudy Atmospheres
- Equatorial anti-rotating day side wind flow in WASP-43b elicited by deep wind jets?
- Modeled Temperature-Dependent Clouds with Radiative Feedback in Hot Jupiter Atmospheres
- Idealised simulations of the deep atmosphere of hot jupiters: Deep, hot, adiabats as a robust solution to the radius inflation problem
- Simulating gas giant exoplanet atmospheres with Exo-FMS: Comparing semi-grey, picket fence and correlated-k radiative-transfer schemes
- Atmospheric Circulations of Hot Jupiters as Planetary Heat Engines
- Shear-driven instabilities and shocks in the atmospheres of hot Jupiters
- Global climate modeling of Saturn's atmosphere. Part II: multi-annual high-resolution dynamical simulations
- THOR 2.0: Major Improvements to the Open-Source General Circulation Model
- Is the atmosphere of the ultra-hot Jupiter WASP-121b variable?
- Modons on Tidally Synchronised Extrasolar Planets
- Numerical Convergence of Hot-Jupiter Atmospheric Flow Solutions
- No evidence for radius inflation in hot Jupiters from vertical advection of heat
- Repeated Cyclogenesis on Hot-Exoplanet Atmospheres with Deep Heating
- Inhomogeneous magnetic coupling in exoplanets: the stop & go of WASP-18 b's atmospheric flows
- Radiative Flux from a High-Resolution Atmospheric Dynamics Simulation of a Hot-Jupiter for JWST and Ariel
- Simulations of idealised 3D atmospheric flows on terrestrial planets using LFRic-Atmosphere
- General Circulation Model Errors are Variable across Exoclimate Parameter Spaces